Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asda not opening checkout tills

313 replies

Cramlington567 · 25/03/2024 21:50

About 8pm. Had a trolley full of stuff. There was a single checkout open when I entered. Went there to pay and it is closed with a sign saying in the evening there maybe be times when checkout is closed and you should use self scan. Two staff chatting ten meters away. I ask if they can open the till. They said 'sorry, no we don't have enough staff".

I go to self service. About 4 times the machine stopped and had to wait for the same staff to come over and unlock it. I was only a quarter of the way through my trolley. Justly left it there, walked out and said to the two staff, sorry I am leaving it, it's too much hassle.

Unreasonable? Plus, everyone saw this coming 10 years ago when it was 'we will always have at least one checkout open' then ' just ask and we will open one'.

Went to Aldi in the end but I can see them going the same way.

I am healthy by the way and middle aged. Would they have opened a till if I was elderly? Or obviously disabled but then not all disabilities are visible of course.

OP posts:
Noyesnoyes · 26/03/2024 08:16

TesticularHeft · 26/03/2024 08:15

If it's not the staffs fault, who decided not to open the till, then whose fault is it?

I actually think it's a good thing you left the trolley. Perhaps the shop, be it managers or staff will think about it. Customer service is failing massively at the minute because of excuses like "not enough staff". They're making record profits so... Hire. More. Staff!

I personally would have warned them I was going to abandon the trolley to reduce any extra work for them but it is a joke.

I should imagine it's higher management deciding on tills opening!

I really don't get the leaving the trolley thing, it's the OP inconvenienced more than anyone else!

TesticularHeft · 26/03/2024 08:15

If it's not the staffs fault, who decided not to open the till, then whose fault is it?

I actually think it's a good thing you left the trolley. Perhaps the shop, be it managers or staff will think about it. Customer service is failing massively at the minute because of excuses like "not enough staff". They're making record profits so... Hire. More. Staff!

I personally would have warned them I was going to abandon the trolley to reduce any extra work for them but it is a joke.

Imfreetofeelgood · 26/03/2024 08:09

BlackForestCake · 25/03/2024 22:11

Aren't you online shopping with the same supermarkets you're complaining about? How do they lose profit then?

They lose the impulse buys, which is quite a lot if profit.

BobnLen · 26/03/2024 08:02

Asda and Morrisons came out worse in the Which supermarket reviews this year for in store shopping, why am I not surprised.

minisoksmakehardwork · 26/03/2024 07:54

Our local Asda staff are going on strike this weekend - Good Friday and Saturday to protest about pay and conditions as well as management bullying, ongoing issues and cuts to hours.

Part of this is, I am sure, driven by the increase in self service at the store. They and Morrisons have hours where the main tills are not staffed so the idea of self service being quicker and to avoid queues just doesn't happen for the customer. Plus due to being an area of deprivation,
Many people still budget with cash so have to queue to for 2-3 cash and card machines. The change Has also resulted in a pay cut for staff as they don't need to roster as many till trained staff on.

For elderly and disabled, the 1 person manning self service and scan as you shop tends to put the persons shopping through on scan as you shop after the person has struggled to do it themselves. Meanwhile anyone with a problem at their self serve till has to wait until they're free.

I appreciate the convenience as an independent person but it does annoy me when I have a problem and, as we all knew, there's only one person to oversee maybe 10 tills.

Perhaps customers need to simply refuse to use self service. If that means abandoning trolleys full of shopping, I appreciate it's more work for the floor staff. But eventually that cost impact of wasted produce will hit the shareholders where it matters to them.

Somepeoplearesnippy · 26/03/2024 07:46

This is nothing new. It's always been the same. I worked in a supermarket in the 1970s and again in the 1990s. Management (and I was eventually one of them) always rostered in the minimum possible amount of staff to run a shift because profit is everything. If there is no profit the store will close.

You did the right thing in abandoning your shopping. It's a tangible loss to the shop and a very clear message that staffing levels are not right. IME it's the only thing that made us bring in more staff.

Skyisbluegrassisgreen · 26/03/2024 07:41

InterestedinEfteling · 25/03/2024 22:04

Diva behaviour. The self scans only don't work properly due to user error. Use them a bit more and practice perhaps.

lol you clearly don’t use them

Elebag · 26/03/2024 07:39

Yanbu. I'm starting to avoid shops that don't keep some staffed checkout tills open (Local Boots and Morrisons, I'm looking at you).

Self service is fine for a couple of items or when I've got loads of change to shovel in there. Mostly I prefer a human being to scan it so I can pack and pay.

TotalDramarama24 · 26/03/2024 07:35

I've never worked in a supermarket but assume that they close the tills earlier than closing time so they can cash out and reconcile the tills. It's not just a case that one or two staff who happen to be chatting can just hop on a till as there might be no change left in it, or they might not have the staff to cash up and witness it again and put the money in the safe (or whatever it is that happens). I assume this all happens in advance of the shop closing so the staff don't have to stay late for free. Maybe it's for security reasons too in the evening as they have a lot more cameras on the self checkouts.

They will still have to cash up the self checkouts when the shop is closed. Anyway I couldn't get worked up about using a self checkout occasionally, or have the time of inclination to go to another shop to make a point.

sparkellie · 26/03/2024 07:34

ButtockUp · 26/03/2024 05:24

But if it keeps happening then staff will complain to their line managers who then complain to store managers who then feed back the senior management.
That's often how changes come about.

🤣🤣🤣 nobody cares if the staff complain. Trust me. A customer complaint has a 100% better chance of change than multiple staff complaints.

Noyesnoyes · 26/03/2024 07:31

Westfacing · 26/03/2024 07:29

Supermarkets will do whatever brings in most profit.

In M&S the other day it was quite busy with the staff going from till to till approving wine, and sorting out problems, etc.

Overhearing a conversation between staff, they'd had a lot of non-payers - seems there's an increase in people scanning, packing and walking off without paying!

But who knows whether those losses will eventually cause M&S to follow Booths example or the losses are outweighed by staff savings.

If you use Ikea self service you need to scan your receipt at the gate to exit, I guess they'll introduce that to stop theft? Or a security guard to check receipts at a gate, minimum wage and only one needed.

DemBonesDemBones · 26/03/2024 07:31

@LittleWeed2 of course it does when there's not enough staff!

Mummame2222 · 26/03/2024 07:30

InterestedinEfteling · 25/03/2024 22:04

Diva behaviour. The self scans only don't work properly due to user error. Use them a bit more and practice perhaps.

Well that’s not true 😂😂

LittleWeed2 · 26/03/2024 07:30

veryawkwardohno · 25/03/2024 22:05

abandoning your trolly full of stuff isn't going to do anything other than be annoying for minimum wage workers who have entirely zero control over how the supermarket is run

So what - the staff will earn the same whether they are chucking stuff out or putting it on the shelves - it makes no odds to them.

Noyesnoyes · 26/03/2024 07:29

BobnLen · 26/03/2024 07:27

I think what the poster means about spending less online is that in store you may see something like nice cakes and buy them that you wouldn't buy anyway so an extra. Also it's easy to keep to a strict list online and not buy unnecessary 'bargains' as you are not sidetracked by stuff on the shelves.

And you know how much you're spending as you go along.

Westfacing · 26/03/2024 07:29

Supermarkets will do whatever brings in most profit.

In M&S the other day it was quite busy with the staff going from till to till approving wine, and sorting out problems, etc.

Overhearing a conversation between staff, they'd had a lot of non-payers - seems there's an increase in people scanning, packing and walking off without paying!

But who knows whether those losses will eventually cause M&S to follow Booths example or the losses are outweighed by staff savings.

Beautiful3 · 26/03/2024 07:29

I have only ever used a basket at self check out. I cannot imagine how annoying it was getting through a trolley!!! I bet it kept stopping every third item!!! What a big waste of your time, picking it and then scanning it! Have you tried online deliveries?

BobnLen · 26/03/2024 07:27

I think what the poster means about spending less online is that in store you may see something like nice cakes and buy them that you wouldn't buy anyway so an extra. Also it's easy to keep to a strict list online and not buy unnecessary 'bargains' as you are not sidetracked by stuff on the shelves.

concernedchild · 26/03/2024 07:25

ZsaZsaTheCat · 26/03/2024 07:06

EVERY time I go to Sainsbury’s now I politely ask to speak to the manager about the self serve tills and make my point calmly that customers are not being well served.
There is ONE staff member to about 6/7 tills and most often then also have to cover the smart shop tills as well, so that’s one staff member for another 10 tills.
It’s not the staff members fault, it is management. Greedy bosses.

We are now;
1/ Scanning our own shopping
2/ Weighing our own goods
3/ Packing our own bags

I’m ok with all of the above but to then be kept waiting at the tills because there aren’t enough staff is tight fisted.

Where will it end? Sometimes I feel like I am actually working at Sainsburys myself!

You need to complain regularly.

And the manager will laugh at you every time because this is ridiculous.

Cosycover · 26/03/2024 07:22

InterestedinEfteling · 25/03/2024 22:04

Diva behaviour. The self scans only don't work properly due to user error. Use them a bit more and practice perhaps.

Biggest load of shite I've ever read on here.

Kalevala · 26/03/2024 07:20

DrunkenElephant · 25/03/2024 22:38

I spend far less online shopping than I do I store.

I suppose it’s because I stick to my list and don’t get tempted by all the “offers”, or something nice looking.

Every single time I go into the store I spend a good £40 more than online. Maybe I’m just weak 😂

Then surely you don't need to buy those items next time so it balances out? Or if it's things you don't normally buy you eat less of something else?

Noyesnoyes · 26/03/2024 07:17

myheadisaterribleplace · 26/03/2024 07:16

Where i am, we aren't allowed to use the self checkouts unless we have a basket, but they still get arsey if customers ask for a checkout to be opened. They look at customers like we have just requested their wages for the next year or something similar. This is the same for asda, tesco, Morrison, and sainsburys but worse in asda. If we go anywhere near a self checkout, they refuse to let us join the queue, but they don't open a till either

So you can't trolley shop in any of the supermarkets? Or have I misunderstood?

myheadisaterribleplace · 26/03/2024 07:16

Where i am, we aren't allowed to use the self checkouts unless we have a basket, but they still get arsey if customers ask for a checkout to be opened. They look at customers like we have just requested their wages for the next year or something similar. This is the same for asda, tesco, Morrison, and sainsburys but worse in asda. If we go anywhere near a self checkout, they refuse to let us join the queue, but they don't open a till either

CandidHedgehog · 26/03/2024 07:14

InterestedinEfteling · 25/03/2024 22:04

Diva behaviour. The self scans only don't work properly due to user error. Use them a bit more and practice perhaps.

I wish.

The last three times I used a self scan, the first time it didn’t recognise a box of chocolates (assistant said known problem with that brand / bar code not being put on the system properly). The second time (a week later) the problem with the chocolates still existed and I couldn’t find the bakery item on the ‘look up’ screen.

The third time, the discount bar code had been put on wrinkled and I had to type it in.

Three (or four if you count the chocolates twice) separate problems of which only one (not finding the item) was possibly my fault (apparently M&S have separate ‘bakery’ and ‘sweet bakery’).

Luckily this was M&S and an assistant swooped in immediately all 4 times, plus I only had a few items but lying about self scans ‘only not working due to user error’ doesn’t help anyone.

BobnLen · 26/03/2024 07:14

I used scan and shop ages ago in Waitrose to try it, it wasn't really any quicker but Waitrose has checkouts open anyway.