Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think support from the Job Center should be for everyone?

158 replies

Frequency · 25/03/2024 13:43

I had my appointment for contributions-based JSA today. I had a list of questions about support/help that would assist me in getting back into work quicker.

I was pretty much told their services are not for me and other professionals or people who have been previously successful. Their services only cover people who lack basic skills.

None of what I asked about was available to me or anyone else using their services.

I asked for;

Assistance towards paying for driving lessons as we have a lack of jobs available locally and poor public transport. Even this was only a money-off voucher with certain providers or meant having to travel to a government-approved driving school I would have taken the support.

Local or remote training that would lead to a professional certification or government certificate to verify I had the skills covered by the course - I was thinking of things like Cisco/Juniper/Solar Winds etc. They only offer functional skills. They have the government-funded skills courses on top of this but these are not run by the JC and they have no information on them.

Professional CV writing services to make sure I am using the right keywords to get through the AI scanner/past HR. They offer support with CVs but it is basic such as support with SPAG and how to use a word processor.

I understand the budget is limited but surely spending towards some of these things for people on a low-income or looking for employment would reduce the benefits bill in the long-run?

OP posts:
usernother · 25/03/2024 15:12

I don't think you should have driving lessons paid for just because you didn't want to pay for your own lessons while you were working. As others have said, take a local job as a means to an end and pay for your own lessons.

Meadowfinch · 25/03/2024 15:06

OP, what specific courses have you done? What IT skills do you have?

If they are recent, there will be opportunities. Have you contacted all your old colleagues and let them know you are looking? Have you flagged yourself as available for work on LinkedIn and updated your profile to cover all your skills?

Have you searched onLinkedIn for your specific skills?

ohtowinthelottery · 25/03/2024 15:04

I think you're possibly overestimating the level of 'professional ' help with CV writing that the job centre offer.
My DS did a job which involved helping people on UC find employment (referrals came via the job centre). Part of his job was helping people put together/improve their CVs. His only experience of CV writing was preparing one for his own job applications! And from what I know of his colleagues, they only had a similar level of experience. Average age of the people doing his job was around 25!

SpringBunnies · 25/03/2024 15:03

If you were made redundant, there is usually a retraining budget and that's where most of us go and sit a bunch of qualifications.

I'm surprised you don't have a drivers license. Have you been working as a network engineer long? Were you always remote? I always think of it as very in-demand skills. I know of the names you dropped. We have network engineers at my work and I'm not sure if they are remote or on-site.

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 25/03/2024 15:03

OldTinHat · 25/03/2024 14:23

Foe those saying/laughing about free driving lessons, yes, you can get them. People on certain benefits are entitled to 40 hours free lessons. A simple Google search will give you plenty of links.

Yes for those on high rate mobility on pip.

The job centre isn't going to pay for someone on contribution based benefits.

Pinkdelight3 · 25/03/2024 14:57

I understand the budget is limited

Apparently not. Driving lessons?? Gimme a break.

As for CVs, there's a zillion online resources. It's never been easier for someone with a modicum of intellect to do the research themselves and craft a decent CV, you don't need your hand holding.

Courses, well, if you want to retrain, you have to get a loan to pay for it. There are jobs available, it's not on the JC to help you achieve your career goals.

I'm sorry your DC situation sounds very distressing, but having a job that can be flexible to something that happens a handful of times a year is v limiting. Not impossible of course, but it's your own limitation you're imposing and not something like a disability that the JC would have to take into account.

As you've discovered, the JC is not there for these things, but there is help for a reasonable level of support on other services online, and plenty of help for those who can pay for it. I once worked for a firm where big execs paid a small fortune to get people to manage their careers, job applications and all of that. It's not that there isn't a need, but it's very much about who'll pay for it.

Meadowfinch · 25/03/2024 14:55

Ex-network consultant here.

Yabu. If you've had years working as a network engineer, why haven't you already learned to drive. It's a pretty fundamental skill.

And Cisco courses are very expensive, far more than the job centre can afford. It is up to your employer to pay for those.

I was out of work for six months after my dc was born. They did eventually offer me help with my cv but the advisor looked it over and said I'd done a good job, and I just needed to be patient.

In the end I gave up looking in the Midlands, moved back to the Thames Valley and got the 2nd job I applied for. Where are you applying from? Have you considered moving in to London where the lack of a car would be less of an issue?

5128gap · 25/03/2024 14:49

If you've been permitted to claim JSA then you will only just be out of employment, meaning you are a person amongst the most able to find another job, given your recent work experience. Government support to find work doesn't exist to help people because its the right thing to do, it exists to get them off benefits and save money from the public purse. Realistically as an evidenced employable person, you could find paid work very quickly, albeit not necessarily of the type you'd prefer, and you will be expected to do so. So any measures to get you off benefits will be more likely to involve a stick than a carrot, and be limited to requiring you to justify any failure to apply for any and every job you'd be capable of.

redalex261 · 25/03/2024 14:48

The JC are there to support those who are not “work ready” for whatever reason. As a professional with skills and qualifications in a desirable field you are not it. As you have been employed (and presumably paid reasonably well) recently it is unreasonable to expect the state to pay for extra certificates in your field or driving lessons. Surely you considered driving lessons while you were working? As you were WFH you must’ve known your inability to drive would limit your job prospects if you were paid off, especially if not on public transport route? Who would have paid for certificates if applying for a new post while employed? It would’ve been down to you. Obviously you don’t have to do this. But you can’t complain about JC not shelling out the minute you rock up as unemployed.

Alternatively you could consider a shot term job outwith your field and pay for the necessary yourself.

imansre · 25/03/2024 14:43

Frequency · 25/03/2024 14:37

I'm already on LinkedIn/Indeed/signed up with recruitment agencies/doing Udemy courses etc.

I was looking for extra support and was surprised it was not available to anyone needing the most basic of support. It seemed shortsighted to me to not have anything available for people needing a higher level of support such as courses/professional CV building etc.

For the driving lessons, I asked about them because the last time I had to claim benefits (which was admittedly over 21 years ago) they did offer loans towards the cost of driving lessons. They also offered funding for night courses at the local FE. That is what I was hoping for.

We didn't have so much for free/cheap on the internet 20 years ago,
FWIW OP, I sort of understand. As a PP said there should be loans available for learners. These things do exist, the jobcentre just isn';t a 'one-stop shop' unlike the national careers service.

However, like I said certifications are not a big deal in our industry. What feedback have you been getting from recruiters, former colleagues, etc? Are you perhaps fixating on the wrong thing? How long have you worked in IT, leaving for an emergency of course is possible with a supportive employer but not always guaranteed especially if you're on tight deadlines/the only person on site etc. With budgets being cut to the bone that's looking more and more likely.

Even this 'support' doesn't guarantee that you'll get a job.
~
What about remote IT support roles?

MartinaMorningstar · 25/03/2024 14:42

Frequency · 25/03/2024 14:00

I am on benefits atm. It was an appointment to claim a benefit as I said in the OP.

I could get a job locally in care or retail but that seems a bit silly when I have experience as a network engineer and was previously earning a decent amount. There are no jobs in my area that match my skill set that I can get to by public transport. I worked on a 24/7 NOC desk and public transport, unfortunately, is not 24/7 in my area. To get to the closest business park where there are jobs by 7 am when the shifts typically start using public transport I would need to set off the night before.

Plus, I'm pretty sure giving me 10% off driving lessons or whatever so I can get to a job suited to my experience would cost less in the long run than if I took a NMW care job and they had to top-up income long-term. That was my thinking behind it.

If you were earning so much before, why didn't you pay for your lessons while you were earning?

DojaPhat · 25/03/2024 14:42

I was looking for extra support and was surprised it was not available to anyone needing the most basic of support. It seemed shortsighted to me to not have anything available for people needing a higher level of support such as courses/professional CV building etc.

I think many people misunderstand the role of the Job Centre - they're basically there to make life on benefits as miserable as they can through seeking an opportunity to sanction people thus save the gov money. They wouldn't give a toss if you could fluently speak 5 languages, had experience of managing the entire finance department of John Lewis and degree in Chemistry from Cambridge. If you opted not to apply for a night job stacking shelves in a shop 10 miles away from your home - that would be the perfect opportunity for them to usefully sanction you.

Once you understand the apparent flaws in the system are actually intrinsic to its goal - you'll understand why they couldn't 'help' you.

Frequency · 25/03/2024 14:41

@imansre I need to be able to get to DD quickly if she has a mental health crisis or overdoses so it is a consideration to me. It happens approximately 4/5 times a year.

The last time I was in care I was not able to leave to go to her when she was at risk of having a mental health crisis which is why it now plays on my mind when applying for jobs. By the time I left work 18 hours later, she had already overdosed and we spent the day in A&E waiting to find out if she'd caused any permanent damage to herself. It was also horrific being at work knowing what she was likely to do and being unable to help her.

That is why I left that role for an IT role. I've never had any issues leaving to attend to emergencies while working in IT.

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 25/03/2024 14:41

OldTinHat · 25/03/2024 14:23

Foe those saying/laughing about free driving lessons, yes, you can get them. People on certain benefits are entitled to 40 hours free lessons. A simple Google search will give you plenty of links.

The Driving Lessons Grant Programme is specifically aimed at people receiving higher level disability benefits and PIP, who are often unable to use public transport or walk and cycle etc. It isn’t generally available to people just on out of work benefits as it’s funded by Motability.

User478 · 25/03/2024 14:40

GoingOutInABit · 25/03/2024 14:01

You fundamentally misunderstand the role of the job centre. It is to get people of benefits into any job at all. They are not there to help people get a good job or be happy in their job.

To that end the training provided is very basic. So if you do not know how to use a computer, word, etc then you can get access to a course that teach you basic computer skills. If you do not know how to write a CV they will help you put together a basic CV.

The support you want is to get a decent paid job. They are not there for that.

Yes, to a point, the main function of the job centre is to make the lives of the unemployed so uncomfortable that it's easier to get a job.

I got a jobcentre grant that paid for me to learn to drive a forklift truck, it doesn't seem so off the wall to put money towards a driving license, which would allow you to apply for many more positions (even more than being able to drive a forklift -which I've never had to do since I learnt!)

Redcoatwonder · 25/03/2024 14:40

Frequency · 25/03/2024 14:37

I'm already on LinkedIn/Indeed/signed up with recruitment agencies/doing Udemy courses etc.

I was looking for extra support and was surprised it was not available to anyone needing the most basic of support. It seemed shortsighted to me to not have anything available for people needing a higher level of support such as courses/professional CV building etc.

For the driving lessons, I asked about them because the last time I had to claim benefits (which was admittedly over 21 years ago) they did offer loans towards the cost of driving lessons. They also offered funding for night courses at the local FE. That is what I was hoping for.

I think the pp who said its misunderstanding what the job centres purpose is nailed it. What you're asking for is basic to you, but it isn't basic to most people or the government allocation of money to support people into work. The purpose is to get people into work, not work of their choosing

Frequency · 25/03/2024 14:37

I'm already on LinkedIn/Indeed/signed up with recruitment agencies/doing Udemy courses etc.

I was looking for extra support and was surprised it was not available to anyone needing the most basic of support. It seemed shortsighted to me to not have anything available for people needing a higher level of support such as courses/professional CV building etc.

For the driving lessons, I asked about them because the last time I had to claim benefits (which was admittedly over 21 years ago) they did offer loans towards the cost of driving lessons. They also offered funding for night courses at the local FE. That is what I was hoping for.

OP posts:
imansre · 25/03/2024 14:34

Frequency · 25/03/2024 14:31

Furthermore, you've also drip-fed that you need a role where you can leave at a 'moment's notice'.. but previously, you spoke about doing shift on-site at a business park. Surely these are contradictory?

When you're on-site you're generally working with other engineers and whilst leaving would be an inconvenience it is not impossible in emergencies. It is impossible in care roles where they need a minimum number of staff in the building by law.

I have seen the managers in this case. Also, how many emergencies do you have that this is even a consideration?
I'd consider an 'emergency' something that happens twice a year, max. Most people don't even think about it but if you do, then it looks like you require more flexibility.

Again not trying to put you down but what you want/need is unclear. When I worked on site we couldn't 'just' up and leave.

imansre · 25/03/2024 14:31

SauronsArsehole · 25/03/2024 14:26

No I actually think there should be learner loans available for skills like this that are a necessity these days.

ridiculous for wanting it paid for but there should be a way to get an affordable learner loan for it if you meet certain criteria/can prove it would be beneficial for you and a portion can be clawed back from UC immediately in small amounts.

connecting the learner loans with approved centres so the money could only go to lessons would be tricky. It feasible.

we really are shortsighted here that we can take out £30k for degrees but there’s limited learner loans for anything non academic.

I agree with this in principle but a lot of courses accept payment in instalments. Also, what would happen if the learner failed to see the benefits?
Would it just be written off?

Frequency · 25/03/2024 14:31

Furthermore, you've also drip-fed that you need a role where you can leave at a 'moment's notice'.. but previously, you spoke about doing shift on-site at a business park. Surely these are contradictory?

When you're on-site you're generally working with other engineers and whilst leaving would be an inconvenience it is not impossible in emergencies. It is impossible in care roles where they need a minimum number of staff in the building by law.

OP posts:
SquashPenguin · 25/03/2024 14:31

SauronsArsehole · 25/03/2024 14:26

No I actually think there should be learner loans available for skills like this that are a necessity these days.

ridiculous for wanting it paid for but there should be a way to get an affordable learner loan for it if you meet certain criteria/can prove it would be beneficial for you and a portion can be clawed back from UC immediately in small amounts.

connecting the learner loans with approved centres so the money could only go to lessons would be tricky. It feasible.

we really are shortsighted here that we can take out £30k for degrees but there’s limited learner loans for anything non academic.

Learner loans would be a great idea. Expecting money for free towards driving is just mental.

imansre · 25/03/2024 14:29

Frequency · 25/03/2024 14:24

If I took a job in care I would not be able to afford driving lessons once my rent and bills were paid. I love care work. I have worked previously in care. If it was a financially and practically available option to me I would go back to care in a heartbeat but it's not.

I need a role where I can leave at a moment's notice if I need to take DD to A&E and in care, you cannot do that. Retail might work but I've not seen much come up in retail. Maybe I am looking in the wrong place for retail work.

My previous job did pay for certifications for me but they were certifications in what they needed which was quite a new, niche hardware/software combination. Other certifications are more in demand or not vendor-specific, unlike the ones I have. I have done Udemy courses in the more in-demand certs out of interest but I don't have anything to prove I have the skill beyond me saying I do. That's what I was looking for.

Edited

The thing is OP I work in tech, close to infrastructure and the UK isn't a country obsessed with certifications. So they're not necessarily going to make you more competitive.
Furthermore, you've also drip-fed that you need a role where you can leave at a 'moment's notice'.. but previously, you spoke about doing shift on-site at a business park. Surely these are contradictory?

To @TokyoSushi 's point, there are so many different types of careers etc available these days it would be impossible for anybody to give the kind of step by step advise you are looking for. There are isolated charities/programs that connect people with industry mentors. But really. 30+ years ago it was easy to say 'take a typing course and become a secretary', but the job market is too complex.
I also have no idea how someone whose full-time job was being a 'career advisor' would keep abreast of all this.

There are forums etc online where people will review your CV for free, technology mentorship, AWS for example has a free 'AWS for women' mentoring program. There are also remote tech meetups,you can connect with people on your old job from LinkedIn.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 25/03/2024 14:27

If you are skilled and have previously had a god job you should be talking to recruitment agencies not the job centre. Get yourself onto LinkedIn and you'll have recruiters coming to you if you state that you're available for work.

There are still plenty of remote opportunities if you look on Indeed and LinkedIn.

Your expectations are way too high for the job centre. Asking for help to pay for driving lessons is laughable I'm afraid! Why didn't you take driving lessons when you were working? It's a life skill that as you've now discovered will help you in the long run.

And why didn't you ask your employer for professional development while you were working? You could have done all kinds of courses as part of your job surely?

SauronsArsehole · 25/03/2024 14:26

SquashPenguin · 25/03/2024 14:22

The driving lesson thing is ludicrous. I’d be embarrassed to even suggest that.

No I actually think there should be learner loans available for skills like this that are a necessity these days.

ridiculous for wanting it paid for but there should be a way to get an affordable learner loan for it if you meet certain criteria/can prove it would be beneficial for you and a portion can be clawed back from UC immediately in small amounts.

connecting the learner loans with approved centres so the money could only go to lessons would be tricky. It feasible.

we really are shortsighted here that we can take out £30k for degrees but there’s limited learner loans for anything non academic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread