Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think support from the Job Center should be for everyone?

158 replies

Frequency · 25/03/2024 13:43

I had my appointment for contributions-based JSA today. I had a list of questions about support/help that would assist me in getting back into work quicker.

I was pretty much told their services are not for me and other professionals or people who have been previously successful. Their services only cover people who lack basic skills.

None of what I asked about was available to me or anyone else using their services.

I asked for;

Assistance towards paying for driving lessons as we have a lack of jobs available locally and poor public transport. Even this was only a money-off voucher with certain providers or meant having to travel to a government-approved driving school I would have taken the support.

Local or remote training that would lead to a professional certification or government certificate to verify I had the skills covered by the course - I was thinking of things like Cisco/Juniper/Solar Winds etc. They only offer functional skills. They have the government-funded skills courses on top of this but these are not run by the JC and they have no information on them.

Professional CV writing services to make sure I am using the right keywords to get through the AI scanner/past HR. They offer support with CVs but it is basic such as support with SPAG and how to use a word processor.

I understand the budget is limited but surely spending towards some of these things for people on a low-income or looking for employment would reduce the benefits bill in the long-run?

OP posts:
enchantedsquirrelwood · 25/03/2024 18:41

OP were you made redundant? And if so, did they offer you outplacement? They won't pay for things, but they do give support.

They may well be "gap in the market" for other people like returners as well - though at a cost. Some industries offer returner schemes.

Totallymessed · 25/03/2024 18:27

MFF2010 · 25/03/2024 17:29

You want a decent recruiter who specialises in IT to look at work from home options. There's really no reason you should be out of work or unable to find yourself a job, you don't need the job centre they can't help you 🤷‍♀️

Exactly. @Frequency How on earth do you think some random person working at the job centre will know more than you about what to do to find work in your specific field?
I'm actually mind boggled that you would seriously expect this from them.

ACynicalDad · 25/03/2024 17:50

I was on JSA once, I took a gamble and paid for a course in an industry I wanted to work in, it was £2k I didn't have in about 2010. I built a career from it and frankly got me a job so quickly and was probably only a little over my first months' salary when otherwise I'd have been unemployed. Is there any way you can get a loan and do one of the one week intensive driving school programmes. If I thought it would make that much difference to my life I'd do it in a minute.
Also if you are in IT are any of the learn coding courses worth doing, a few have job placements at the end and can be remote.

Piffle11 · 25/03/2024 17:47

But OP, you will know an awful lot more about your industry than any JCP worker, and that goes for all the other industries, too. What skills are needed, where vacancies are advertised, likely salary, etc. There’s no way of training staff to be at a level that would be helpful to you. I worked in a JCP many years ago: the skilled people - rightly or wrongly- tended to find their own work.

Redcoatwonder · 25/03/2024 17:35

Frequency · 25/03/2024 17:26

But this is my point. That seems counterproductive to me. They could offer me support in finding a role similar to my previous one where I wouldn't be entitled to top-up benefits and would be paying tax which would cost them in the short-term but would mean in the long term I pay more tax or they could push me into NMW work, which is all it seems they are set up to do, which I means I would pay little to no tax and would be getting longterm financial support in the form of top-up benefits.

The latter is shortsighted and more costly in the long run.

You're still mistaking the purpose of the job centre despite plenty pp explaining.

If you want job support for the type you're after, it's a recruiter, other agency or self fund. It's not the taxpayers job to fund a job you like/want, that would be ideal, but not realistic. They can't 'support you in finding an equivalent role' as they don't have access to them as most skilled/technical jobs either recruit directly themselves or go through a recruitment agency and or headhunt

It's like going to aldi and asking to book a holiday... Its not what they do

CaterhamReconstituted · 25/03/2024 17:35

Job centres are fearful places. I was unemployed once and had to sign on for about three months. They treat you like scum. I once walked in with an umbrella (it had been heavily raining) and the security guard cornered me and took it off me, as if I was going to use it as a weapon. If you are one minute late they won’t see you. They talk to you like you are stupid.

It’s a punishment regime. They are not geared up to actually help anyone or provide good advice.

MFF2010 · 25/03/2024 17:29

You want a decent recruiter who specialises in IT to look at work from home options. There's really no reason you should be out of work or unable to find yourself a job, you don't need the job centre they can't help you 🤷‍♀️

Frequency · 25/03/2024 17:26

Piffle11 · 25/03/2024 17:20

‘I could get a job locally in care or retail but that seems a bit silly when I have experience as a network engineer and was previously earning a decent amount.’

This is the issue.

The employment part of JCP isn’t there to help you get the best job for you, they’re there to get you off benefits. They won’t give anyone taxpayer funding in order that they can pay for driving lessons/courses that will help them get a high paying job.

But this is my point. That seems counterproductive to me. They could offer me support in finding a role similar to my previous one where I wouldn't be entitled to top-up benefits and would be paying tax which would cost them in the short-term but would mean in the long term I pay more tax or they could push me into NMW work, which is all it seems they are set up to do, which I means I would pay little to no tax and would be getting longterm financial support in the form of top-up benefits.

The latter is shortsighted and more costly in the long run.

OP posts:
Halloweenrainbow · 25/03/2024 17:25

I think the goal of the JC is to identify and remove barriers to work in mostly low skilled low paid positions. If somebody can't get a job staking shelves they assume there is a straightforward reason. You just need to update your CV, improve interview skills, brush up on basic literacy and numerousy etc then your ready to go. Not that simple unfortunately as many people out of work are over skilled and educated for these positions but lack experience for anything else. They are unemployable but not for the reasons JC assume.

Piffle11 · 25/03/2024 17:20

‘I could get a job locally in care or retail but that seems a bit silly when I have experience as a network engineer and was previously earning a decent amount.’

This is the issue.

The employment part of JCP isn’t there to help you get the best job for you, they’re there to get you off benefits. They won’t give anyone taxpayer funding in order that they can pay for driving lessons/courses that will help them get a high paying job.

NotMeNoNo · 25/03/2024 17:13

Basically you are a smart/educated person and I suppose expected to be able to find resources yourself. Is there anything in the zillions of Linkedin courses/Ted talks/free webinars that help?

NotMeNoNo · 25/03/2024 17:11

Having seen the job centre up close with my DC, they are targeted at people who don't really know how to help themselves and they have some good resources on that like basic work experience or short courses targeted at entry level jobs. I don't think you are their target client sadly.

Do you have access to any professional associations who might do career/retraining advice in your relevant field?

Bluefell · 25/03/2024 17:09

I had the same experience with the job centre some time ago. I walked in with postgraduate qualifications and they basically said they couldn’t help me, because they only assist people to get unskilled jobs. They said they could send me for interviews to be a cleaner or a shop assistant etc, but they couldn’t help me get a job that actually used my qualifications. So it’s always been like that, the job centre is only there to get people into min wage unskilled work.

Boomer55 · 25/03/2024 17:07

A Learner Loan for driving lessons might work, but no reason why the taxpayer should have to fund it.🙄

HalfAVirgin · 25/03/2024 17:05

Driving lessons are £60 per hour where I live, cannot believe anyone would expect help with that.

dottydodah · 25/03/2024 17:03

I think that Driving lessons is pushing it a bit! If you apply for a job could you not afford an Uber for a while? Maybe move closer to work ? Lessons are very expensive here, about £40 for an hour x however many people want them and it would very soon add up!

Jovacknockowitch · 25/03/2024 17:00

ChurchOfSeitan · 25/03/2024 13:56

To be honest the name job centre is a bit of a misnomer. They are more of a benefits centre.

I have never known anyone on benefits get driving lessons paid for. I don’t think that has ever been a thing.

Indeed it's one of many rebrands over the years - like changing unemployment benefit to jobseekers allowance.

OooScotland · 25/03/2024 16:56

I was looking for extra support and was surprised it was not available to anyone needing the most basic of support. It seemed shortsighted to me to not have anything available for people needing a higher level of support such as courses/professional CV building etc.

Nope. The purpose of the job centre is to get people onto benefits and then get as many of them as possible into work, any work, to get them off benefits (I went there post graduation and was immediately sent for interviews for part time cleaning work and told I had to take it - so no benefits and Jobcentre had served it purpose). That’s it.

As a professional looking for work you need to help yourself, and the jobcentre won’t be any use to you. Asking for higher support is a waste of time. Have you seen the state of thise places already?

aodirjjd · 25/03/2024 16:52

If you consider that we have a limited pot don’t you think paying for people to get basic maths and English or write their first proper cvs is a good use of funds? If you are likely to find a job quickly without help then you are not who they are aiming to help.

Lost019 · 25/03/2024 16:49

I agree with those saying that the job centre is not about actually helping people to get a job that they want. They are there to try and ensure people are looking for work and sanction them for not. It’s about getting people off benefit. I know someone who works for them and they are targeted on how many people they’ve got off benefit and into work.

I welcome that they don’t pay for driving lessons and so on but we’re on the outskirts of a major city and there’s many people locally who aren’t interested in looking for work and come from generations of non workers.

Job centre would expect you to apply/take a job and look for a job that matches your skill set thereafter.

ButterflyTulips · 25/03/2024 16:47

I teach adult education courses. I earn15k a year (but do get most holidays off). I so need a new job but it makes me laugh that I might get recommended to go on my own courses...

Danikm151 · 25/03/2024 16:44

check what funding your local authority provides for courses.
eg WMCA pays for adult education courses if your salary is below £30k.
I’m currently doing a finance course alongside working full time.
The job centre is just for jobs it isn’t focused on careers.

GiveMyHeadPeaceffs · 25/03/2024 15:21

@Frequency actually Job Centres in Northern Ireland can help with all of these things including driving lessons through a scheme called Advisor Discretionary Fund or ADF. From reading all the threads on here, UC and JBOs are very different beasts here in NI compared to the rest of the UK.

HateMyselfToo · 25/03/2024 15:13

I think I've learnt something from this thread. Like you OP, I think if I needed a job, the Job Centre is ONE of the places I would go for help and advice. Never crossed my mind that they wouldn't help me as I wasn't claiming benefits.
Luckily, I live in an area of the country where it's fairly easy to find work.