Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let DD go away with Brownies/Girlguides on her birthday?

163 replies

BrowniesGoingAway · 25/03/2024 12:05

She’s 9, almost 10 and a Brownie.

We have a party planned for the weekend before and will do a day out during the summer holidays (her birthday is about 3 weeks before the big summer holiday so we always “delay” a day out until the summer).

Her birthdays the Friday and the entire district have a weekend away planned Friday to Sunday. It’s her dads weekend with her but as it’s her birthday it’d be a shorter weekend (as in I’d have her for her actual birthday overnight then she goes to her dads the next day and does birthday 2.0 with him rather than him having her Friday -Sunday as he usually would). ExH is happy for her to go away for her birthday if she wants to go away and is happy to pay for it as part of one of her birthday presents (as it’s expensive, usually pack holidays cost £40-60 for 2 nights, this is £120 for 2 nights due to the activities their doing).

DD wants to go, it’s all she’s talking about, her best friend who is a Brownie in another pack is going, her Brownies (in her pack) friends are all going, her cousin (on her dad’s side) is going who is a Guide. She literally cannot see a drawback. Brownies have said she can go later so I can do birthday cake/candles with her at home or I can stay for their evening meal and they’ll do cake/candles as pudding if I supply enough cake for her pack to all have some (this is what DD wants me to do) - if I do the latter option I'd just buy cupcakes and DD can have 1 candle on a cake.

The reason I’m asking if AIBU is my family keep saying I shouldn’t let her go and she should realise that it’s a clash and people want to see her on her birthday and the weekend around it. I’m also apparently spoiling her already with a party and a day out (usually it#s one or the other but it’s a big birthday so it’s both this year, next year it’ll be day out, year after party) as she also always gets a day out with Ex-PILs for her birthday. They said by letting her go and ExH paying for it I’m teaching her she can have everything.

She is aware that it’ll mean less presents from her dad, she actually says she doesn’t care about getting things and quote “Would love love love to do all the activities and have an extra special sleepover with all her friends”.

Obviously I want to spend time with her on her birthday but I also don’t want to hold her back or her to resent me for letting something like a date in a calander a big deal. She lives with me 95% of the time (EOWend with her dad) and I work Term Time Only, so I can always celebrate with her properly a few weeks later.

We'd have an hour or so in the car as I'd have to drive her to take her and ExH will pick her up on the Sunday and bring her home but obviously it's not a full blown birthday evening together due to it.

So AIBU to let her go?

OP posts:
MrsJellybee · 25/03/2024 15:26

Another one saying let her go. She doesn’t exist in order to provide birthday memories for her grandparents.

LenaLamont · 25/03/2024 15:24

Tell your extended family to get a grip and don’t indulge in this utter nonsense anymore.

Of course she should go to camp, she’ll have a wonderful time. And every subsequent birthday she should do whatever she wants, as well.

Timeforanotheraliasnow · 25/03/2024 15:20

Definitely let her go, send cakes for her to celebrate with the pack. She'll have a blast xx

morellamalessdrama · 25/03/2024 15:17

This is a total no brainer and a good lesson to your daughter to put her needs first, especially for something like a birthday.

5128gap · 25/03/2024 15:17

Of course she should go. Not only is it her choice, but practically, the birthday things your family want to do can be done another time. Their attitude is very odd and I wouldnt pander to it on principle.

Tigertigertigertiger · 25/03/2024 15:13

If course she should go

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 25/03/2024 15:05

The ONLY people that matter in this decision is your daughter you and your daughter;s father - if he is ok with it, and it appears he is, then she goes to camp.

It is no one else's business.

Elebag · 25/03/2024 15:04

Of course she should go. An adventure with friends is much more important than a family get together.
Insular families are so suffocating.

JFDIYOLO · 25/03/2024 15:00

Let her go!!! It's a personal milestone, part of her growth, her memories. You're her mum, say what is going to happen.

VickyEadieofThigh · 25/03/2024 14:03

Even if you gave in this year, you're just pushing the problem further up the road - the older she gets the less likely she's going to want/be around to devote her birthday to her extended family rather than her friends/school/work/dad etc. Which is completely normal. So your family may as well get used to it now.

Absolutely this.

easylikeasundaymorn · 25/03/2024 13:47

so she wants to go
her father (who is giving up his weekend with her) is fine for her to go
her friends want her there
her brownie leaders want her there and have planned a way for you to be there to
You seem fine with her going, will still have a 'birthday tea' with her and have lots of other stuff planned to celebrate
Her GP on dads side are happy and have their own thing sorted
the only people who don't want her to go are miscellaneous family members on your side for no real reason other than they think birthdays should be celebrated on the exact day with them.
So they'd actually prefer her to be miserable with them on her birthday, than happy with her friends. Not exactly loving family, is it?
Basically you'd be causing aggro and upsetting your Dd if you said no, all for the sake of 'pleasing' people who don't really seem to care about her as a person at all, just what they want. Why on earth would you even consider it?
Even if you gave in this year, you're just pushing the problem further up the road - the older she gets the less likely she's going to want/be around to devote her birthday to her extended family rather than her friends/school/work/dad etc. Which is completely normal. So your family may as well get used to it now.

DappledThings · 25/03/2024 13:21

Your family are incredibly weird about birthdays. Of course you let her go since that's what she wants to do.

And stand up your overbearing relatives on her behalf to make sure they don't try to guilt trip her about it.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 25/03/2024 13:16

BrowniesGoingAway · 25/03/2024 12:21

@MidnightPatrol They have a thing about birthdays being family occasions, and it being celebrated before or after being the "wrong" thing to do so they won't come to her birthday party (well her same age and slightly older cousins will) the week before as it's not her birthday.

Well they are choosing to miss out on her party then. The thought of some sour faced adults having a strop because a 10 year old gets to do something really cool for her birthday is bemusing.

GuidingSpirit · 25/03/2024 13:11

I'm a brownie leader and she'll have a brilliant time! Sounds like the leaders are on it already. She'll always remember being on brownie holiday on her birthday.

VickyEadieofThigh · 25/03/2024 13:10

BrowniesGoingAway · 25/03/2024 12:21

@MidnightPatrol They have a thing about birthdays being family occasions, and it being celebrated before or after being the "wrong" thing to do so they won't come to her birthday party (well her same age and slightly older cousins will) the week before as it's not her birthday.

Sounds like your DD will have an even nicer party if her hideously controlling other relatives refuse to come. RESULT!

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 25/03/2024 13:07

Let her go away - she'll have a great time and have lots of fuss made of her because it's her birthday.

BendingSpoons · 25/03/2024 13:06

It's HER birthday, so she is the only one who gets a say really. Sounds like a great way to celebrate her birthday and get loads of attention. She can celebrate with family another day.

We are about to celebrate my DDs birthday with family 3 weeks late due to illness on the day and then my parents being on holiday. It will still be a lovely day.

ARichtGoodDram · 25/03/2024 13:05

BrowniesGoingAway · 25/03/2024 12:21

@MidnightPatrol They have a thing about birthdays being family occasions, and it being celebrated before or after being the "wrong" thing to do so they won't come to her birthday party (well her same age and slightly older cousins will) the week before as it's not her birthday.

It’s her birthday and this is what she wants to do - let her go!

She’ll have amazing memories of this birthday going forward.

If adults can’t have a bit of flexibility for a child to have a blast on their birthday then that says a lot about their selfishness imo.

ErrolTheDragon · 25/03/2024 13:02

if she is obliged to spend a rather stilted time with them on the exact date, mild resentment may creep in.

Likely more than 'mild' I'd have thought!
If these relatives might want her to choose to spend time with them as she gets older, they need to grow up and stop being so self-centred and ridiculous.

twoshedsjackson · 25/03/2024 12:56

I have been on school journeys with pupils having a birthday, and the various residential centres have always gone out of their way to help the day go with a special swing. I was especially touched when they got wind of my birthday one year.......
As PP's have mentioned, she is coming to a time in her life when her peer group is becoming increasingly important to her, while the family, whilst still dear to her heart, are becoming a bit less significant - this is her "chosen tribe".
The chances are that, if she were at home, and a party were to be arranged, her choices would be more friends than family. It's being organised for you - result!
Your family are finding it hard to let go of an earlier phase, but their rigidity will not work for them in the long run; if she is obliged to spend a rather stilted time with them on the exact date, mild resentment may creep in.
She sounds like a sensible girl; she's been pragmatic about having fewer presents because of expense, so let her know that her opinion matters.

RichinVitaminR · 25/03/2024 12:45

Your family are talking total crap, sorry. YANBU. Let her go and have a wonderful time, this won't happen every year and she won't be a Brownie forever. This will be something totally lovely to remember when she's older. I think the only people who make the decisions on how to raise your child are you and ExH. She'll always be grateful to you and her dad for arranging these lovely things. Family can see her when she gets home.

FinallyHere · 25/03/2024 12:44

Ilovelurchers · 25/03/2024 12:42

Your family sound utterly insane I have to say. So they see a child's birthday as a sort of unpleasant obligation for that child where they HAVE to see wider family, rather than do what they want to do?

Is there some religious/cultural aspect going on here? Because I have never heard of this and it sounds weird.

Just what I was wondering.

Glad that your DD whose immediate parents have her best interests at heart. Just hope you hold the line against what seems to be monumental selfishness from your family.

ErrolTheDragon · 25/03/2024 12:43

Of course your DD should go and have fun!

Your family is being weird and a bit controlling - ffs her birthday isn't about and for them. Confused

Ilovelurchers · 25/03/2024 12:42

Your family sound utterly insane I have to say. So they see a child's birthday as a sort of unpleasant obligation for that child where they HAVE to see wider family, rather than do what they want to do?

Is there some religious/cultural aspect going on here? Because I have never heard of this and it sounds weird.

Mrsjayy · 25/03/2024 12:42

Chylka · 25/03/2024 12:35

I think it’s hilarious that they think she is spoilt when it’s them as adults who want to dictate how she spends her birthday to suit them…

Yes this. It's lovely to celebrate birthdays with family but this is her social life and camps are good fun Its unfair of them to get all huffy about it.