Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let DD go away with Brownies/Girlguides on her birthday?

163 replies

BrowniesGoingAway · 25/03/2024 12:05

She’s 9, almost 10 and a Brownie.

We have a party planned for the weekend before and will do a day out during the summer holidays (her birthday is about 3 weeks before the big summer holiday so we always “delay” a day out until the summer).

Her birthdays the Friday and the entire district have a weekend away planned Friday to Sunday. It’s her dads weekend with her but as it’s her birthday it’d be a shorter weekend (as in I’d have her for her actual birthday overnight then she goes to her dads the next day and does birthday 2.0 with him rather than him having her Friday -Sunday as he usually would). ExH is happy for her to go away for her birthday if she wants to go away and is happy to pay for it as part of one of her birthday presents (as it’s expensive, usually pack holidays cost £40-60 for 2 nights, this is £120 for 2 nights due to the activities their doing).

DD wants to go, it’s all she’s talking about, her best friend who is a Brownie in another pack is going, her Brownies (in her pack) friends are all going, her cousin (on her dad’s side) is going who is a Guide. She literally cannot see a drawback. Brownies have said she can go later so I can do birthday cake/candles with her at home or I can stay for their evening meal and they’ll do cake/candles as pudding if I supply enough cake for her pack to all have some (this is what DD wants me to do) - if I do the latter option I'd just buy cupcakes and DD can have 1 candle on a cake.

The reason I’m asking if AIBU is my family keep saying I shouldn’t let her go and she should realise that it’s a clash and people want to see her on her birthday and the weekend around it. I’m also apparently spoiling her already with a party and a day out (usually it#s one or the other but it’s a big birthday so it’s both this year, next year it’ll be day out, year after party) as she also always gets a day out with Ex-PILs for her birthday. They said by letting her go and ExH paying for it I’m teaching her she can have everything.

She is aware that it’ll mean less presents from her dad, she actually says she doesn’t care about getting things and quote “Would love love love to do all the activities and have an extra special sleepover with all her friends”.

Obviously I want to spend time with her on her birthday but I also don’t want to hold her back or her to resent me for letting something like a date in a calander a big deal. She lives with me 95% of the time (EOWend with her dad) and I work Term Time Only, so I can always celebrate with her properly a few weeks later.

We'd have an hour or so in the car as I'd have to drive her to take her and ExH will pick her up on the Sunday and bring her home but obviously it's not a full blown birthday evening together due to it.

So AIBU to let her go?

OP posts:
Emmerald · 26/03/2024 09:27

I went away with the school at Easter when I was 10 and my 11th birthday was slap bang in the middle of the time we were away. I had a whale of a time! Let her go, the memories for her will mean far more than having to stop home to see relatives while your friends are away having a good time.

She can always have Birthday part 2 later!

Insidelaurashead · 26/03/2024 09:12

If you let her go to the camp she wants to go on, you're showing her that her wants and needs, where reasonable, should be priority. That's a big life lesson IMO. As an adult I still people please 99% of the time and I wish I'd been brought up knowing that I'm important too. Her wants, on her birthday, where it's not harming anyone else, come first. I hope she has a great time on her camp

PensionedCruiser · 26/03/2024 09:05

Birthdays happen. I suppose for some people growing up, a birthday was the only day they were made to feel special and want to perpetuate that specialness as adults (we've all met them) and foist that feeling on the children they come in contact with.

I think it's a healthy concept to teach children (and adults) that birthdays can be celebrated at other times too. Sometimes life gets in the way and we can't celebrate the way we want to on the day itself. That shouldn't diminish the celebration. December birthdays have often been passed over hurriedly because of Christmas. Surely it's better to make a fuss another time than have a half hearted attempt.

Let the birthday girl choose what to do and ignore the miserable family that want to decide how she should spend her day. They obviously have issues surrounding birthdays - don't pass them on to DD.

GreyCarpet · 26/03/2024 09:01

Follow your instincts, OP. Let her go and well done on being the one who breaks the cycle 😉

Her role is not to appease others. Show her this now or she'll be denying her own wishes and people pleasing for the rest of her life.

Thefutureisourownpath · 26/03/2024 08:57

Honestly she will have a total ball and give the leader a cake and card etc for her - presents when she gets back - honestly having your birthday on a camp is amazing / all day my son was going first etc 😂😂never ever happens to him at home

Whatwouldnanado · 26/03/2024 08:54

Family can bugger off. Organise a gathering when suits you, it will make her birthday last longer! Send her with a cake for the pack. She’ll have a ball.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 26/03/2024 08:50

Throwawayme · 25/03/2024 12:10

Yes absolutely she should go. Her birthday is about her and not about the other people who want to see her. Sounds like she'd be gutted to miss out

I agree with this.

also why on earth are your extended family getting so involved in your parenting and budgeting decisions - I don’t have the best boundaries, but even I wouldn’t accept input or opinions on that!

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 26/03/2024 08:49

I'm surprised there's even a debate here. She goes.

strawberry2017 · 26/03/2024 08:49

I can't believe family think they have a right to overrule what she wants to do on her birthday. If she's happy and the parents are happy then That's all that counts. I'm so happy you are letting her go. X

Teapot1980 · 26/03/2024 08:49

Let her go without question. Ignore all the BS from your family about spoiling her and teaching her she can have everything. This is your family coming up with spurious reasons why your daughter shouldn’t go, so that their needs will be met instead of your daughter’s. Selfish. Show them this thread!

Pottedpalm · 26/03/2024 08:49

I don’t understand why you are even giving this headspace. There is a ridiculous fuss over birthdays in my opinion which only leads to young women feeling neglected if they don’t have a week long celebration.
Of course she goes to camp. Have a family tea another day and if they choose not to come then so be it.

DigitalDust · 26/03/2024 08:48

Are the family this controlling about everything?

Glad your DD is getting to go on the camp. If she wants to go, the only people who should be having a say in the matter are her parents. No one else gets to have their opinion listened to!

WandaWonder · 26/03/2024 08:44

This would come before everything else in our house, sounds great fun

Abbyant · 26/03/2024 08:42

its her birthday let her celebrate it how she wants and extended family can butt the hell out. You would have one very disappointed dd if you give into other peoples demands over what your child has told you she wants to do.

Lifebeganat50 · 26/03/2024 08:42

She should realise that it’s a clash and people want to see her on her birthday and the weekend around it.

WHOSE birthday is it😂😂? I had my 11th birthday at guide camp, in the olden days when we used to go away to camp for a week, and it was the best EVER-sleepover for 30 with a day off camp “chores”

LinaLouLa · 26/03/2024 08:37

Ah let her go. She'll have a great time with her friends. Your family are being selfish wanting her to miss out on making loads of fun memories.

Mumandthemermaids · 26/03/2024 08:36

I’m a teacher and we’ve had children come away on residential when it’s been their birthday. They’ve loved it. We’ve done what we can to make it special for them. Parents have supplied cake in the past and we’ve sung and distributed it. She will have a wonderful time.
It’s her birthday. She wants to go. You and your ex-partner are supportive of her choice. I don’t see how you are being unreasonable in any way. Other family members have no right to be putting the pressure on you like that, especially in a way that could potentially make your daughter unhappy on her birthday. Stick to your guns OP.

budgiegirl · 25/03/2024 23:49

DD wants to go

This is all you need to know.

If you, your ex, and your DD are all happy with it, it's nobody else's business how your DD spends her birthday. Your family sound very selfish.

Rewis · 25/03/2024 16:25

Seems a lot of drama for something that's not a big deal. She wants to go to brownies. She should go to brownies.

SallyWD · 25/03/2024 16:21

Everyone's being very selfish! They can just celebrate with her a few days later. Let her go. She'll have a wonderful time and will remember it forever.

Heronwatcher · 25/03/2024 16:20

Your family are mad. And controlling. And selfish.

Yeah a real birthday treat being stopped from going away with her friends.

She can celebrate with them at a number of other times but this is a one off. Are any of them thinking of her rather than themselves?

I’m also a bit 😳 that you are doubting yourself, you are so far away from unreasonable. I don’t think I’d even entertain a member of my family questioning me like this.

Crumpleton · 25/03/2024 16:18

IMO the opinions of the one's your DD birthday concerns are the ones that count.

You, her DF and more importantly your DD herself are all ok with her going away with Brownies, she's looking forward to doing these activities on her birthday and with her friends and with some family members there it'll be like her having a big party anyway, she'll love it....
plus it's one you won't have to worry about arranging bar the cake. Win win..

BrowniesGoingAway · 25/03/2024 16:17

Have filled in the forms and emailed them back and double checked ExH still has the correct bank details to pay.

She will be going. Will tell her when I get her back from Holiday Club shortly

OP posts:
Coconutter24 · 25/03/2024 16:15

Your family need to realise someone else’s birthday isn’t about them and when they want or is convenient to see her. I’d suggest they come see her Thursday tea time then DD can go off with brownies for the weekend as her birthday present from her dad.

TheCatterall · 25/03/2024 15:46

@BrowniesGoingAway frankly this is a ‘them’ problem. You and your daughter and her DF are all happy with the arrangement and that’s all that matters.

if they want to be birthday martyrs that’s on them. Just decide on a phrase or two and roll it out in repeat until they get fed up of discussing it. “As her parents and with her agreement we decided that the weekend socialising with her peers as she wishes is the best way for her to spend this time and she will appreciate the memories and friendships built as she grows up, rather than being forced to miss out on a opportunity due to the unwillingness of others to celebrate her birthday on a different day due to their inflexible mindset…” but then in peri-menopausal and just grumpy with everyone.