Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask - would you donate a kidney as a live donor?

309 replies

TransplantRequired · 25/03/2024 10:38

I have name changed, but been around a while.

I have recently been told my kidneys are failing, and I need a transplant or dialysis. The consultant and nurse are strongly encouraging me to find a living donor, because for various reasons dialysis is not a long term prospect of success for me, and the deceased donor list could take 3 to 5 years on average.

I do not have any siblings, or close family. My parents and their siblings all dead, and I am not in contact with any cousins, nieces etc. So, the only thing would be to approach my friends. I’m not one for discussing my health, so none of my friends know I have anything wrong with me. Any request would come completely out of the blue.

I am not comfortable broaching this with them, and I wouldn’t expect any of them to do it. But the consultant and nurse were astonished by me saying this, and really don’t accept that I don’t know anyone I feel close enough to to approach.

So, if one of your friends (not family, I think that’s different) needed a kidney, and you were in good health, and a match, would you offer?

YABU - Of course I would, it’s what friends are for!
YANBU - No, that’s too much to ask a friend to do.

OP posts:
Escaperoom · 25/03/2024 15:48

How likely is it that a friend would be a match though? Surely the idea of asking family members is that being genetically similar makes a match more likely. And no I wouldn't do this for anyone other than close family.

Asiatoyork · 25/03/2024 15:44

I sincerely hope that you can receive the kidney you need @TransplantRequired

Justkeeepswimming · 25/03/2024 15:36

Only for my children.

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 25/03/2024 15:32

No. I would inky do it for my children, partner, siblings and mother. Not even nieces nephews etc

romdowa · 25/03/2024 15:30

I wouldn't give one to a friend but I also wouldn't ask a friend for their kidney either, I think it would put awful pressure on a person. I'd feel terrible having to say no to someone , it's very odd of the hospital to suggest that you ask friends for a kidney like you'd ask to borrow a pen.
I'm sorry you are in this position and I hope a solution is found for you op.

percypal · 25/03/2024 15:26

I have no friends to ask me for one and none to ask for one for myself.

I’d do it for an immediate family member but what if you give to one then someone else needs one? I have more than one family member who have conditions meaning kidneys could go downhill …

Asiatoyork · 25/03/2024 15:24

Cattenberg · 25/03/2024 11:10

I think this was the scheme I saw a programme about. I think you’d still need someone to donate a kidney to you, but they wouldn’t need to be a match.

https://www.odt.nhs.uk/living-donation/uk-living-kidney-sharing-scheme/

My first job after graduating worked on these and I saw one of the first ever ones performed in the UK, after the Human Tissue Act made it legal

TransplantRequired · 25/03/2024 15:19

@fungibletoken thank you. I’m very grateful for the honest and helpful replies I’ve received, AIBU can be a scary place, but I’ve had the good ones on this thread!

OP posts:
Daffodilsandtuplips · 25/03/2024 15:19

I wouldn’t be able to, I’ve had kidney problems on the past which led to scarring on one of them. I was pretty ill at the time. But I don’t think I would.

I know of a live donor, my friend donated a kidney to his daughter. He’s 80. She was so ill before it but the difference it made to her is amazing.
A cousin was an organ donor, someone is alive now because of her, someone can see because of her.
I also know some who has no kidneys, bladder or prostrate due to cancer, he has dialysis three times a week and up until a year ago lef as full a life as possible, holidays abroad, with pre arranged dialysis sessions in whichever country he was in. He’s slowed down a bit now due to other another medical condition but he’s doing well.

Kalevala · 25/03/2024 15:18

I'd only donate to a sibling, my child, niece, nephew, or future grandchild. Maybe my cousin who I am close to and who has older parents and no siblings. Not someone unrelated.

LaMariposa · 25/03/2024 15:16

Only for my children, and possibly my younger child-free sister.

pontipinemum · 25/03/2024 15:15

LobsterWeb · 25/03/2024 14:54

Typically someone who needs a transplanted kidney will keep their own kidneys and the extra one is added in. It isn't actually transplanted into where your current kidneys are, but much further down your body closer to the bladder. So most people are only put on the transplant list because their total kidney function has got so low, not just because one kidney is failing.

Cancer is one of the situations where they would actually remove the recipient's kidney(s), but if the remaining kidney has enough function then there is no need for them to receive another.

Thank you for the explanation, that's very interesting. I guess I always thought they took out the old ones and put in the donated one. Apparently my nephews remaining kidney will eventually be able to do 75% of the work of two. Which is amazing really

LobsterWeb · 25/03/2024 15:13

Poshjock · 25/03/2024 14:53

I can’t donate, I was screened for DH but my own function is below living donor standard, although not considered low or of concern in itself. DH already received from a sibling many years ago. His other sibling was recovering from heart attack so couldn’t. His child of child bearing age was screened out. We had 3 offers from friends. One discovered an underlying illness that required treatment whilst undergoing screening, one found out his own daughter had PKD and decided to wait incase she needed it. And the last one sadly committed suicide before the process was started to screen him.

DH was offered kidney otherwise unsuitable and he accepted this. Effectively kidney from Hep + person. He was offered one but it was found to be below standard once it was removed. His next offer was from someone who died unexpectedly at the same age DH is. A better match could not have been found. He spent 3 years waiting but 18 months of that he was off list recovering from various heart issues at different times. The transplant team were overwhelmingly positive that he would not wait more than a year and that the change of donation policy was making a difference. In the end he was active on the list for 8 months when he got the call.

What a time you all had! I hope he's OK now?

My transplant team included a surgeon who had recently worked in the UK, and he also said that the change of donation policy there has significantly shortened the length of the waiting list. I'm hopeful this means my relative there will receive a kidney soon.

TransplantRequired · 25/03/2024 15:12

@Poshjock thank you for sharing your (dh’s) story. Good luck to you both.

OP posts:
YankSplaining · 25/03/2024 15:10

My guess is I probably wouldn’t want to donate, but I wouldn’t fault anyone for asking.

fungibletoken · 25/03/2024 15:08

Glad that you have decided to try to open up about it to those around you, OP. And whatever you do, YANBU - I'm totally struck by how measured and reasonable your comments/replies have been on this thread. Wishing you all the best in reaching better health.

Outnumbered99 · 25/03/2024 15:02

I probably wouldn't as I am a carer and I just can't be out of action for a day let alone for potentially weeks, but I would absolutely expect, and respect, you for being open on your social medias which is so absolutely important.

If it weren't for my specific circumstances regarding my caring role, I would do this for close friends and some family in a heartbeat

Poshjock · 25/03/2024 15:00

DH was never told the outcome of those who started screening and did not complete. He only knows because those individuals told him themselves.

He received offers because he was honest and open about his situation to everyone from family to acquaintances. He never asked. All offers were willingly made. He carried cards with the living donor co-ordinator’s contact details and handed to anyone that expressed interest and told them “don’t tell me, contact this person and discuss. You don’t ever have to tell me”. Also I was not a match. If I hadn’t fallen at the final hurdle my kidney would have been part of a three way swap with someone else who’s living donor was not a match.

Astrabees · 25/03/2024 14:56

Yes for one of my 3 best female friends wh ohave stuck by me through thick and thin. I would not do it for the rest of my good friends as they have not always been 100 percent.

LobsterWeb · 25/03/2024 14:54

pontipinemum · 25/03/2024 12:52

Do both of your kidneys need to go? My nephew had kidney cancer when he was a teenager - really unusual. But he is doing fine with just 1.

Sorry I also wouldn't do it for a friend but I don't really have close friends right now

Typically someone who needs a transplanted kidney will keep their own kidneys and the extra one is added in. It isn't actually transplanted into where your current kidneys are, but much further down your body closer to the bladder. So most people are only put on the transplant list because their total kidney function has got so low, not just because one kidney is failing.

Cancer is one of the situations where they would actually remove the recipient's kidney(s), but if the remaining kidney has enough function then there is no need for them to receive another.

CatOnTheLap · 25/03/2024 14:53

TheKeatingFive · 25/03/2024 10:44

Family yes, not sure about friends

I’m the opposite - friends yes, family no.

Poshjock · 25/03/2024 14:53

I can’t donate, I was screened for DH but my own function is below living donor standard, although not considered low or of concern in itself. DH already received from a sibling many years ago. His other sibling was recovering from heart attack so couldn’t. His child of child bearing age was screened out. We had 3 offers from friends. One discovered an underlying illness that required treatment whilst undergoing screening, one found out his own daughter had PKD and decided to wait incase she needed it. And the last one sadly committed suicide before the process was started to screen him.

DH was offered kidney otherwise unsuitable and he accepted this. Effectively kidney from Hep + person. He was offered one but it was found to be below standard once it was removed. His next offer was from someone who died unexpectedly at the same age DH is. A better match could not have been found. He spent 3 years waiting but 18 months of that he was off list recovering from various heart issues at different times. The transplant team were overwhelmingly positive that he would not wait more than a year and that the change of donation policy was making a difference. In the end he was active on the list for 8 months when he got the call.

WettyBite · 25/03/2024 14:52

I sincerely wish you all the best OP and hope everything works out for you ❤️

TransplantRequired · 25/03/2024 14:50

Just to add, for information for anyone who might want it, the consultant and nurse answered some of the points which have come up on this thread, and which I, too, had raised:

Anyone who has donated a kidney, who subsequently becomes in need of a transplant themselves is given priority on the donor list.

Living donors are reimbursed all expenses associated with donating, including topping up sick pay, childcare expenses, etc.

A living donor has their own, completely separate medical team, overseeing their care pre and post donation to ensure there can be no conflict of interest.

Anyone who comes forward to find out more about donating has complete confidentiality, and can withdraw right up to the point of donation. The recipient would not be told anyone is undergoing tests, or would simply be told the organ is not suitable.

I hope this is helpful. Thanks for reading and responding to my thread. I’m steeling myself to “come out” to my friends.

OP posts:
PosyPrettyToes · 25/03/2024 14:48

I would for my best friend if I could, but as my DS is disabled and dependent on me it wouldn’t be an option.