Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask - would you donate a kidney as a live donor?

309 replies

TransplantRequired · 25/03/2024 10:38

I have name changed, but been around a while.

I have recently been told my kidneys are failing, and I need a transplant or dialysis. The consultant and nurse are strongly encouraging me to find a living donor, because for various reasons dialysis is not a long term prospect of success for me, and the deceased donor list could take 3 to 5 years on average.

I do not have any siblings, or close family. My parents and their siblings all dead, and I am not in contact with any cousins, nieces etc. So, the only thing would be to approach my friends. I’m not one for discussing my health, so none of my friends know I have anything wrong with me. Any request would come completely out of the blue.

I am not comfortable broaching this with them, and I wouldn’t expect any of them to do it. But the consultant and nurse were astonished by me saying this, and really don’t accept that I don’t know anyone I feel close enough to to approach.

So, if one of your friends (not family, I think that’s different) needed a kidney, and you were in good health, and a match, would you offer?

YABU - Of course I would, it’s what friends are for!
YANBU - No, that’s too much to ask a friend to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
nothingcomestonothing · 26/03/2024 17:17

To be clear, I'm not 'saving my kidney for my children' - that's silly, they are thankfully extremely unlikely to need it. I wouldn't donate to anyone other than them, because I wouldn't do anything to risk their only parent being unwell or dead and unable to care for them or work to support them. If my DC had another parent, or were fully independent, I might consider making a different decision.

Lavender14 · 26/03/2024 12:08

I'm honestly not sure op, I think it would depend on the friend an how close we were but I'd think nothing of someone asking me. I'd ask the question if I were you and let them make the decision for themselves. Its a big ask and a big deal for both of you but by not asking you're making the decision for them without giving them the chance to decide. There's a lot of factors that go into it, like their prior health. I'm not as healthy as I could be and have some issues which is partly why I'm cautious and I'd probably have cared slightly less about my longevity before I had ds. So I think it really depends on the individual and their circumstances.

Justkeeepswimming · 26/03/2024 10:51

Also somebody asked, if I wasn’t a match for my children would I donate to anyone else - no, because my health is crap, I need to be around for my kids and I wouldn’t do anything to jeopardise my overall health unless it was to save my own child’s life/or to save them from pain…

Would I take a kidney from someone else - never my children, possibly someone else if I was still at the age when kids under 25 and needed me…

All motivated by need to protect kids health and being around for them really.

bradpittsbathwater · 26/03/2024 10:45

Cattenberg · 26/03/2024 09:31

I’m surprised by those who would turn down their ill parent because they’re saving their kidney for their children.

What if you were a match for your parent but not for your children? Would you still say no?

Surely it depends on the age of the parent too? a 40 something giving their 80 something parent a kidney for a couple extra years life and risk of long term health issues for themselves might not be a good idea. I'm 39 my mum is 60 so I'd most likely be willing.

Justkeeepswimming · 26/03/2024 10:40

Cattenberg · 26/03/2024 09:31

I’m surprised by those who would turn down their ill parent because they’re saving their kidney for their children.

What if you were a match for your parent but not for your children? Would you still say no?

@Cattenberg the chances of a successful transplant lessen with age. I know this because we were told my parent (late 50s) would not be eligible to receive liver or kidney due to age/pre-existing conditions. Thought likely they wouldn’t make it off the operating table.

With a child/young adult they have a better chance.

Elphame · 26/03/2024 10:38

Cattenberg · 26/03/2024 09:31

I’m surprised by those who would turn down their ill parent because they’re saving their kidney for their children.

What if you were a match for your parent but not for your children? Would you still say no?

My parents would absolutely 100% refuse to accept a kidney from me.

I would also refuse a donation from my own children. In fact I would refuse from anyone.

TransplantRequired · 26/03/2024 09:54

Thank you to everyone who has commented here since my last message. I am reading all your replies with interest. I hope at least that my thread has got you thinking about something which is so important, but can get lost in the day to day busyness of life. Maybe have a discussion with your family about it if you’re comfortable with that. You never know when it might affect you or a loved one, and so much better to have thought it through calmly, than when emotions are high. Best wishes to you all, and thanks for a very reasoned and kind thread by AIBU standards!

OP posts:
Cattenberg · 26/03/2024 09:31

I’m surprised by those who would turn down their ill parent because they’re saving their kidney for their children.

What if you were a match for your parent but not for your children? Would you still say no?

Growlybear83 · 26/03/2024 08:30

Of course I would donate a kidney to my husband, daughter, or my Mum when she was younger. I would probably donate one to my two closest friends but it would have to depend on the state of my health at the time.

110APiccadilly · 26/03/2024 08:23

Oddly enough although I've already said I would for a close friend, and I definitely would for my husband or children, I don't know if I would for a parent. I suspect they wouldn't accept it (and I don't think I'd accept one from my kids). But that's coloured by seeing one of my grandparents have a very lingering, very ill old age. The two who died fairly suddenly had a much better deal. I'd think about it for a parent, but it would certainly be a less clear cut decision.

DianaTaverner · 26/03/2024 08:09

I do think that saying that you'd donate to your children but not your spouse is a bit odd. Assuming your spouse is your children's parent, then surely even if you only care about your children's wellbeing, saving them from very probable bereavement is more important than the tiny probability that they'd need the kidney that you're "saving for them".

Last year in the UK 430 people died on the transplant waiting list.

SENlife · 26/03/2024 08:07

I would be more inclined to donate to a stranger, definitely a child than I would any family or friends (excluding my own children - I would give them anything and everything)
For family and friends though i think it would change the dynamic too much, and could cause a bitter outcome or resentment

mrlistersgelfbride · 26/03/2024 07:39

I'd feel very awkward saying no if a friend asked me, but I'd have to save it for my daughter.
I don't feel close enough to any friends to do for them. Obviously that goes both ways.
Sorry you are going through this x

DragonGypsyDoris · 26/03/2024 07:34

Children or grandchildren, yes. Nobody else - not parents, spouse or friends. No way.

nothingcomestonothing · 26/03/2024 07:31

Galaga · 26/03/2024 00:28

Yes, I would. I've just had someone very dear to me die of end-stage kidney failure. It was awful to witness. If I could have helped him, I would have.

I may need to donate bone marrow to a relative soon. I have absolutely no qualms about that although it could make me ill.

Donating bone marrow won't make you ill. If you donate stem cells it'll mean a few days of GCSF injections and 1 or possibly 2 days with a cannula in each arm. If you donate marrow it'll be a short surgery - not even surgery really just a really big needle under anaesthetic- and feeling like you've been kicked really hard in the hip for a few days afterwards. It's extremely safe, children donate for their siblings, please don't worry it'll make you unwell.

OP I hope you get the treatment you need.

Edited for autocarrot.

PlumbersWifey · 26/03/2024 00:40

Nope nope nope. Not even my number 1 all time best friend. Would only do that for my sibling or my child.

Galaga · 26/03/2024 00:28

Yes, I would. I've just had someone very dear to me die of end-stage kidney failure. It was awful to witness. If I could have helped him, I would have.

I may need to donate bone marrow to a relative soon. I have absolutely no qualms about that although it could make me ill.

Panicatthegarden · 25/03/2024 23:39

Pre having a child I would have definitely said yes for a friend, now I've got a little boy to think about I'm not sure what I would do, he's only a baby so needs me in good health for quite some time.

Blanketpolicy · 25/03/2024 23:29

my mum was on dialysis for years and wouldn't even entertain a conversation about a kidney donation from my siblings or me. So we never had to think about it seriously, guess I'll never really know what I would have done.

I was tested for bone marrow for a sibling as that was a no brainer.

unnumber · 25/03/2024 23:16

There are 100 non-directed altruistic donations a year in the UK these days, i.e. people donating to complete strangers. Their donations often mean more transplants can go ahead. So Joe donates without knowing anyone in need, his kidney goes to Colin, Colin's daughter who didn't match Colin donates to Jane, Jane's husband donated to Peter.

So about 1 in 50 people on the waiting list get a kidney donated from a stranger, and more get kidneys with donations triggered by this first donation.

There's a really interesting set of case studies of these altruistic donors as they are called, here: https://www.giveakidney.org/category/personal-stories/donating/

Obviously more people again give to friends and acquaintances. So it's not that unusual to donate outside family.

Donating A Kidney Archives | Give a Kidney

When the Human Tissue Act 2004 became law in September 2006, this offered people the opportunity of becoming a kidney donor for the benefit of someone unknown to them on the NHS waiting list. Here are some of their stories.

https://www.giveakidney.org/category/personal-stories/donating

Daisy12Maisie · 25/03/2024 23:02

I would only definitely do this for my children or their children if they have them in the future so my grandchildren. Possibly if absolutely desperate and no one else willing then I would do it for my sisters.

I wouldn't consider it for any of my friends or anyone else.

therealcookiemonster · 25/03/2024 23:00

@TransplantRequired Hi OP I am someone with kidney failure.

I am really sorry you are going through this.
transplant is not the only option although it is the best. you can have diyalysis and patients live for many years on dialysis. you will also go on the transplant list. and depending on the rarity of your blood/tissue type you will probably get a transplant in a few years.
depending on why your kidneys are failing, steps could potentially be taken to slow down the deterioration of kidney function. are you in a low clearance clinic?

whenemmafallsinlove · 25/03/2024 22:37

I'm sorry for your situation. I have worked with renal patients and it's a hard, hard road. I would never donate however except to my kids. It's a huge ask.
I hope you match quickly on the deceased donor list, it may happen for you.

teacheroffsick · 25/03/2024 22:33

I would consider it but would obviously need to research the health implications thoroughly.

ladygindiva · 25/03/2024 22:29

It would depend who it was. My brother's only child, she's six, yes. My brother himself, no. Because my children need me healthy and he has a wife to look after his child. If I didn't have young kids I might do it for my brother though .