Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Caught on camera, who pays

81 replies

GoldHold · 25/03/2024 09:45

Person A asked person B for a lift to the station after work. Person B drove through a restricted zone at the station, was caught on camera and has been issued a fine. Person B wants person A to pay. Person A has refused. Who is BU?

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 25/03/2024 13:53

I don't agree. Drivers are responsible for driving according to laws, restrictions etc. I assume there was a way to make the journey without triggering a fine.

I didn't dispute that, of course that's the case.

DH and I have recently had to drive to a few stations we're unfamiliar with, some of the restrictions are very poorly signposted. We didn't fall foul of them but would have been quite easy to if there had been a lorry or bus in the wrong place. So maybe that's giving me more sympathy for the driver. Plus as I said my own ethical compass would make it impossible to land B with the bill if I was A.

Vistada · 25/03/2024 13:52

Person B should pay, but should also never do lifts again

iwafs · 25/03/2024 13:51

hopscotcher · 25/03/2024 13:40

B is responsible for the fine. Why would they think it was A?

Obviously person B might appreciate a contribution because they wouldn't have been in that location, had it not been for A requesting to take them there. These mistakes are very easy to make.

My DH was once on an unfamiliar road and a weird sign appeared meaning that if he drove straight on, he would be in breach of something or other. He stopped a car length after the sign, turned the car around and went back. Because he drove that car length past it, he got fined. We had it on dashcam so know exactly what happened. Often these fines are set up to punish people for almost nothing - and certainly not a dangerous act.

oprahwindsock · 25/03/2024 13:49

GoldHold · 25/03/2024 11:20

I'm neither, but this has confirmed my opinion. The driver should pay as they are responsible, however it would be a good gesture for the passenger to offer to pay half.

Why? They weren't the driver!

amiold · 25/03/2024 13:49

This reminds me of when I went to uni... three of us used to travel together (different companies) 130mile each way. My company provided a car , other two companies paid mileage. I got a ticket for parking in the wrong zone ... my fault but we all thought we could park there. Neither of the other two passengers offered a penny even though I drove them every week and they were receiving £100 expenses a week. I probably wouldn't have took it but would have been nice to offer. I stopped the lifts.

iwafs · 25/03/2024 13:48

No good deed goes unpunished.

If I was person B, I'd feel so gutted. The signage on some of these restricted zones can be difficult to quickly decipher. If person B was unfamiliar with the location, mistakes can easily be made.

Person A should offer to pay half. Or never expect any sort of favour from person B ever again.

I think in person B's position, I'd feel like I wouldn't bother helping anyone with anything again.

Cottoncandyflavaflav · 25/03/2024 13:45

If I was the driver I would pay and not mention it to the passenger.

If I was the passenger I would pay.

If there is an argument over who pays they should both be arguing they will.

hopscotcher · 25/03/2024 13:40

B is responsible for the fine. Why would they think it was A?

trumancummings · 25/03/2024 13:26

If I was B and A didn't offer to pay the full fine (assuming I'd made a special trip out to give the lift and wasn't out and about anyway) then I'd pay it (obviously) but they'd get no more lifts. If they offered to pay the full fine I'd go halves. If they offered half I'd accept and probably wouldn't offer another lift. I'm guessing no petrol money was offered beforehand?

TinkerTiger · 25/03/2024 13:23

OneTC · 25/03/2024 13:14

I've actually been in this exact position. A friend asked for a lift to a station I don't normally go to and I made a right turn that you used to be able to make. I got fined.

I didn't even mention it to my friend because it's my responsibility to drive properly.

If you were being given a lift and they stacked their car into a wall because they weren't alert enough to not go round it you'd not be offering to pay half the excess would you? Because it's entirely on the competence of the licensed driver.

Same applies for drivers that blindly listen to their non driving passengers. Non drivers don't know shit, if you choose to follow their directions then you're an idiot

Edited

I'm like you. If I was the driver I wouldn't say a thing and if I was the passenger and it was mentioned I'd want to pay so it's lose-lose for me 😂

WaltzingWaters · 25/03/2024 13:23

p1ppyL0ngstocking · 25/03/2024 09:52

It's for the driver to pay, although if I was A I'd be offering half minimum.

Equally as B, I would brush off every future request for a lift from A with a "no thanks, last time I gave you a lift it cost me £50".

A can't expect to be driven round by other for free, it takes time, energy and a lot of money to run a car. A should be prepared to get a taxi in future.

i agree with this. b’s responsibility to pay attention to road signs and therefore their responsibility to pay. But would be nice for A to offer to contribute towards it. And if they didn’t I’d be saying this at any future lift requests.

UltramarineViolet · 25/03/2024 13:22

Person B should pay

Person A has no obligation to pay anything but if I was Person A then I would probably offer to pay half expecially if the journey to the station was in an area the driver wasn't familiar with or the signposting was poor, or if indeed I had suggested "yes drive don't there I'm sure it will be fine" or similar (I would probably offer to pay the full fine in those circumstances!)

Marblessolveeverything · 25/03/2024 13:17

@ErrolTheDragon I don't agree. Drivers are responsible for driving according to laws, restrictions etc. I assume there was a way to make the journey without triggering a fine.

OneTC · 25/03/2024 13:14

I've actually been in this exact position. A friend asked for a lift to a station I don't normally go to and I made a right turn that you used to be able to make. I got fined.

I didn't even mention it to my friend because it's my responsibility to drive properly.

If you were being given a lift and they stacked their car into a wall because they weren't alert enough to not go round it you'd not be offering to pay half the excess would you? Because it's entirely on the competence of the licensed driver.

Same applies for drivers that blindly listen to their non driving passengers. Non drivers don't know shit, if you choose to follow their directions then you're an idiot

saraclara · 25/03/2024 13:13

If I asked for the lift rather that it being offered, I'd definitely offer to pay at least half.

lurchersforever · 25/03/2024 13:08

Any half decent person would offer at least a contribution in A's position. It would cause so much ill-feeling otherwise - doing someone a favour after work and then being fined for it? I'd be so pissed off and remember it every time I saw them.

B was the driver, but restricted areas can be very tricky and it can be easy to get caught out. I've been driving 20 years and commute plus drive a lot for holidays etc and I have got one such fine - bus lane infringement in an unfamiliar city. It doesn't make someone a shit driver as a very occasional mistake and if someone does that when doing you a favour and you don't think to at least offer something, well, it's not great, is it?

Trophyfoot · 25/03/2024 13:08

BobbyBiscuits · 25/03/2024 13:07

@Trophyfoot yeah I guess. But they would not know how to navigate roads legally necessarily in a car. If the person is struggling hard then I guess the decent thing might be to pay a contribution towards the fine. It all seems awfully awkward. I bet they wish they just walked.
Maybe the important point is, did the passenger request the lift, or did the driver offer it unprompted? If the latter as passenger id feel even less responsibility.

I bet the driver wishes they'd never done the favour either. OP says the driver was asked for the lift.

BoogieBoogieWoogie · 25/03/2024 13:07

If I were person A I would offer to pay the fine. If it wasnt for person A then there would be no fine

BobbyBiscuits · 25/03/2024 13:07

@Trophyfoot yeah I guess. But they would not know how to navigate roads legally necessarily in a car. If the person is struggling hard then I guess the decent thing might be to pay a contribution towards the fine. It all seems awfully awkward. I bet they wish they just walked.
Maybe the important point is, did the passenger request the lift, or did the driver offer it unprompted? If the latter as passenger id feel even less responsibility.

GasPanic · 25/03/2024 12:57

Well my guess is Person A stumps up at least something. Otherwise they can kiss goodbye to any future lifts.

If I were person A I would also be thinking about how great work is going to be with Person B pissed off with them for probably the next 6 months. If person B is the boss then I can see it getting awkward.

Throwyourkeysup · 25/03/2024 12:55

Person B is the “captain” of the vehicle and as such takes responsibility.

ErrolTheDragon · 25/03/2024 12:54

Surely the route to the station must be one they've done at least a few times before?

Not necessarily, surely a person without a car is likely to go to a station more often than someone who has one?

IDontLoveTheWayYouLie · 25/03/2024 12:54

If person B can't read signage/work out restrictions when driving then I'm sure this isn't going to be the first time they will get a fine.

taylou278 · 25/03/2024 12:53

Person B is the driver therefore they pay

Trophyfoot · 25/03/2024 12:52

BobbyBiscuits · 25/03/2024 12:51

The person who was driving should have gone a different way.
Unless the passenger insisted on going down the restricted road and reassured them it was fine, then it's not passenger's fault.
Just don't get lifts with them again. Surely the route to the station must be one they've done at least a few times before?

Surely the passenger is likely to be more familiar with the station layout than a regular driver?