Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hunt out of touch?

168 replies

BluebellsBluebell · 25/03/2024 09:39

£100k is 'not a huge salary'. Fair comment. Yanbu

Does this show Hunt and the tories are out of touch. Yabu

OP posts:
Havanananana · 25/03/2024 15:24

"Maybe there are arguments about Conservatives looking after the wealthy, but if they are, it certainly isn't people earning between £50k and £250k as they are been royally shafted in the lifetime of this parliament."

Those being royally shafted are the millions who have seen the vital services on which they rely - universal healthcare, public transport, utilities, education etc. - either chronically underfunded or monetarised, with the profits going to investors rather than back to the users in the form of investment, lower bills and fares or service improvements. The present government has spent 14 years dismantling the social contract that has been refined in the century from the end of WW1 to the detriment of millions of people in the UK.

If the 4% of the population earning £100k or more think they're being shafted, they can try living in a shitty HMO and working for a year on a zero-hour contract for £11.44 an hour, and hope to goodness that they don't get ill.

MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 15:21

Medschoolmum · 25/03/2024 15:06

Like I say, I think the cliff edges are ridiculous, as is the built in disadvantage for single parents who don't receive any maintenance from their child's other parent. So I agree that the system needs reform so that it's fairer for everyone and so that it doesn't actively disincentivise people from working full time. However, I do agree with the basic principle of redistributing wealth from those who have more to those who need more.

I disagree that £100k can be viewed as anything other than a high income, while acknowledging that disposable income will obviously beAnd I don't buy into the notion that high earners necessarily work harder than anyone else.

I haven't said £100k isn't a high income, nor have I said they work harder than anyone else. Nor do I disagree with the basic principles of a redistributive tax system.

But it is an absurdity to have cliff-edges in the tax system which are so extreme.

If any other group was spending 80% of their income on childcare it would be worth of attention (as we have seen from efforts to counter that), so why suddenly not at this threshold?

Why are we so desperate to particularly penalise higher-earning parents of toddlers? It makes no sense at all.

See the various threads of people cutting down their hours or stuffing money into their pensions - this is reducing tax take for the government, hardly a good policy if you'e looking to redistribute money.

MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 15:15

Havanananana · 25/03/2024 15:08

Two nursery places in the South East can easily be £4,000 a month, 80% of a £100k salary, and yet those people are being excluded from tax-free childcare and free hours.

So the problem is the cost of childcare, not the salary?

Why is childcare £4,000 a month in the South East? Why is there not government-funded pre-school provision? Because the Conservative government believes in low taxes and the Free Market, and this is the rate that the market will bear (despite locking out millions of families).

More civilised countries, where average earnings are higher than in the UK, have camparatively inexpensive childcare. Typical childcare costs in Germany are between €15-€400 a month for state daycare, averaging at around €169 per month. Childcare in Denmark costs around £450 a month for 0-3 year olds.

Yes, the issue Hunt is referring to (which was poorly phrased) is the issue of loss of childcare subsidies impacting higher earners.

I agree that universal state-backed childcare should be provided, as elsewhere in Europe.

There is government-funded preschool provision, and the value of that provision is increasing (additional 15 and 30 free hours). But on £100k you don't get that - hence the conversation.

Enterthewolves · 25/03/2024 15:15

Fuck me 30% of people who’ve responded think his statement was fair enough. I am lucky enough to earn that much and if I ever forget how privileged I am (yes I live in the South East, yes I have an enormous mortgage, yes childcare costs/uni is expensive) then I hope I lose it all and have to claim UC, I’ll deserve the karmic payback. There is NOTHING acceptable about Hunt’s glibness.

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 15:15

@MidnightPatrol I just see lazy old anti-tory lines dragged out time and time again on threads like this, without any hesitation to actually explain how they are the party of the high earner. Jeremy Hunt acknowledging that £100k hardly makes you the Wolf of Wall Street these days, in a 1-2-1 conversation who is affected by the £100k cliff edge, seems to offend people.

Havanananana · 25/03/2024 15:08

Two nursery places in the South East can easily be £4,000 a month, 80% of a £100k salary, and yet those people are being excluded from tax-free childcare and free hours.

So the problem is the cost of childcare, not the salary?

Why is childcare £4,000 a month in the South East? Why is there not government-funded pre-school provision? Because the Conservative government believes in low taxes and the Free Market, and this is the rate that the market will bear (despite locking out millions of families).

More civilised countries, where average earnings are higher than in the UK, have camparatively inexpensive childcare. Typical childcare costs in Germany are between €15-€400 a month for state daycare, averaging at around €169 per month. Childcare in Denmark costs around £450 a month for 0-3 year olds.

Medschoolmum · 25/03/2024 15:06

MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 14:42

My point is that someone on £100k isn't earning 3x the average wage, its more like 1.5x the average wage for a parent with two small children - as the previous poster was claiming.

Two nursery places in the South East can easily be £4,000 a month, 80% of a £100k salary, and yet those people are being excluded from tax-free childcare and free hours.

That is the critical context here.

Redistribution... specifically penalising high-earning working parents of under-5s? Seems an oddly specific group to target so severely.

This is a cliff-edge which incentivises the highest tax payers to work less. It's irrational.

Like I say, I think the cliff edges are ridiculous, as is the built in disadvantage for single parents who don't receive any maintenance from their child's other parent. So I agree that the system needs reform so that it's fairer for everyone and so that it doesn't actively disincentivise people from working full time. However, I do agree with the basic principle of redistributing wealth from those who have more to those who need more.

I disagree that £100k can be viewed as anything other than a high income, while acknowledging that disposable income will obviously beAnd I don't buy into the notion that high earners necessarily work harder than anyone else.

MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 15:04

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 14:45

If their raison d'etre is to look after people earning over £100k, they have a funny way of showing it!

  1. Childcare £100k cliff edge.
  2. >£100K effective 60% income tax rate with erosion of personal allowance
  3. Until recently, pension annual allowance at £40,000 with tapered annual allowance - only to stop doctors reducing workload or retiring.
  4. Pension lifetime allowance £1 million until recently abolished - only to stop doctors retiring
  5. Higher rate tax thresholds frozen
  6. Capital Gains Tax annual exemption reduced from £12,300 to £3,000 for 2024/25.
Maybe there are arguments about Conservatives looking after the wealthy, but if they are, it certainly isn't people earning between £50k and £250k as they are been royally shafted in the lifetime of this parliament.

It's a weird one isn't it.

No longer the 'party of the rich', they are now just the party of the old it seems.

Thing is - you can promote any policy for pensioners regardless of their wealth/income and no one really challenges it, but suggest increasing the thresholds for childcare support and it's 'giving money to the rich'.

Which is... odd...

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 14:50

Oh, and no changes to IHT threshold, despite being at £325,000 since 2009, residence nil rate band accepted.

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 14:45

Havanananana · 25/03/2024 14:31

Because the Conservative Party exists to protect the interests of the wealthy, and is funded by the wealthy.

The Conservatives are also extremely good at convincing people that issues that affect the wealthy are everyone's issues. 95% of the population earns nowhere near £100k a year.

Likewise, 95% of the Estates of people who die pay no Inheritance Tax, but reading the Daily Mail, Telegraph or Express you'd think that the government (and particularly a Labour government) is about to kick everyone's dependents out of house and home and steal their grandchildrens' inheritence. As usual, Hunt features in this nonsense, having previously mooted raising the threshold to £1m - i.e. almost three-times the current threshold. It must be the very rich company he keeps that keep giving him these ideas.

If their raison d'etre is to look after people earning over £100k, they have a funny way of showing it!

  1. Childcare £100k cliff edge.
  2. >£100K effective 60% income tax rate with erosion of personal allowance
  3. Until recently, pension annual allowance at £40,000 with tapered annual allowance - only to stop doctors reducing workload or retiring.
  4. Pension lifetime allowance £1 million until recently abolished - only to stop doctors retiring
  5. Higher rate tax thresholds frozen
  6. Capital Gains Tax annual exemption reduced from £12,300 to £3,000 for 2024/25.
Maybe there are arguments about Conservatives looking after the wealthy, but if they are, it certainly isn't people earning between £50k and £250k as they are been royally shafted in the lifetime of this parliament.
MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 14:42

Medschoolmum · 25/03/2024 14:34

That's what redistribution looks like though. More help for the people at the bottom who actually need it.

My point is that someone on £100k isn't earning 3x the average wage, its more like 1.5x the average wage for a parent with two small children - as the previous poster was claiming.

Two nursery places in the South East can easily be £4,000 a month, 80% of a £100k salary, and yet those people are being excluded from tax-free childcare and free hours.

That is the critical context here.

Redistribution... specifically penalising high-earning working parents of under-5s? Seems an oddly specific group to target so severely.

This is a cliff-edge which incentivises the highest tax payers to work less. It's irrational.

Nonewclothes2024 · 25/03/2024 14:40

He is very out of touch. He was crap in health , no idea.
Average is £35 k so yes £100k is huge.

Skippythebutterfly · 25/03/2024 14:37

Medschoolmum · 25/03/2024 14:34

That's what redistribution looks like though. More help for the people at the bottom who actually need it.

The people at the bottom don’t seem to understand that this is how it works though, and automatically think those on £100k must be totally loaded. When the simple fact is if they have 2 kids in nursery they truly aren’t.

Medschoolmum · 25/03/2024 14:34

MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 14:25

Ah but you see... it isn't. We have increasing tax levels, student loans, child benefit, childcare support etc.

So your £35k earner technically might get:

£27,320 basic salary

  • £2,074 child benefit
  • £2,000 tax free childcare
  • £7,200 free hours child 1 (30 hours)
  • £3,600 free hours child 2 (15 hours)

so... looks a but more like £42,194 or £3.5k a month take home.

Your £100k earner might get:
£59,014 base salary

  • £0 child benefit
  • £0 tax free childcare
  • £3,600 free hours child 1 (15 hours)
  • £0 free hours child 2

So in total £5.2k take home a month.

So while on the surface it looks like they earn 3x as much, it's more like 1.5x as much.

This isn't to say the lower earner shouldn't be supported (they should), but highlights why those on higher incomes are a bit 'WTF' about being excluded from various childcare initiatives.

That's what redistribution looks like though. More help for the people at the bottom who actually need it.

Bloom15 · 25/03/2024 14:33

@Skippythebutterfly thanks so much for being so patronising- there was me thinking only poor people paid tax. Silly me

Skippythebutterfly · 25/03/2024 14:31

Bloom15 · 25/03/2024 14:27

Exactly!

Care assistants, nurses etc. The vast majority of the essential workers from Covid days. But some posters seem to have forgotten that those were the people deemed essential. Bankers and the like were not

It many surprise you to know that those working in investment banks and retail banks all pay taxes on their - sometimes quite substantial - income. The financial service industry pays a huge amount of this nations taxes. ALL workers are essential.

Havanananana · 25/03/2024 14:31

Notonthestairs · 25/03/2024 14:15

"Economists! Researchers! They do know this. It’s their job to know this."

If this is correct why hasn't the Conservative government introduced it?

Because the Conservative Party exists to protect the interests of the wealthy, and is funded by the wealthy.

The Conservatives are also extremely good at convincing people that issues that affect the wealthy are everyone's issues. 95% of the population earns nowhere near £100k a year.

Likewise, 95% of the Estates of people who die pay no Inheritance Tax, but reading the Daily Mail, Telegraph or Express you'd think that the government (and particularly a Labour government) is about to kick everyone's dependents out of house and home and steal their grandchildrens' inheritence. As usual, Hunt features in this nonsense, having previously mooted raising the threshold to £1m - i.e. almost three-times the current threshold. It must be the very rich company he keeps that keep giving him these ideas.

Skippythebutterfly · 25/03/2024 14:28

Everyone is moving away from the Tories. Thank goodness. I do think we need universal benefits with increases in all tax bands across the board to pay for it. We need to celebrate the fact that we have high earners in this country, paying large taxes to the benefit of society.

There was a reason why new Labour were ‘intensely relaxed about people getting filthy rich - as long as they paid their taxes’. The reason was that these people funded public services.

Bloom15 · 25/03/2024 14:27

Macaroni46 · 25/03/2024 13:50

@Skippythebutterfly lots of people slog their guts out for far less than 100k per year and live in titchy tiny houses.
Of course people should have aspirations but I'm not going to a) agree that 100k isn't that much or b) feel sorry for someone earning that.

For five years I was a Headteacher. I worked 60+ hours per week and had huge responsibilities. Because it was 'only' a small infant school, my salary was nowhere near 100k. I slogged for those 5 years.

Exactly!

Care assistants, nurses etc. The vast majority of the essential workers from Covid days. But some posters seem to have forgotten that those were the people deemed essential. Bankers and the like were not

MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 14:25

randomchap · 25/03/2024 10:38

It's about 3 times the national average.

If people are struggling on it, then it does show how badly the Tories have managed the economy

Ah but you see... it isn't. We have increasing tax levels, student loans, child benefit, childcare support etc.

So your £35k earner technically might get:

£27,320 basic salary

  • £2,074 child benefit
  • £2,000 tax free childcare
  • £7,200 free hours child 1 (30 hours)
  • £3,600 free hours child 2 (15 hours)

so... looks a but more like £42,194 or £3.5k a month take home.

Your £100k earner might get:
£59,014 base salary

  • £0 child benefit
  • £0 tax free childcare
  • £3,600 free hours child 1 (15 hours)
  • £0 free hours child 2

So in total £5.2k take home a month.

So while on the surface it looks like they earn 3x as much, it's more like 1.5x as much.

This isn't to say the lower earner shouldn't be supported (they should), but highlights why those on higher incomes are a bit 'WTF' about being excluded from various childcare initiatives.

BIossomtoes · 25/03/2024 14:23

Skippythebutterfly · 25/03/2024 14:17

Because their core vote (boomer pensioners) would be against it, with their endless ‘in my day the mum stayed home and took care of the kids, and the kids were much better behaved’ and ‘why should we have to pay for your offspring’. I hate the word offspring!

Pensioners are moving away from the Tories now. Only a third of them intend voting Conservative now.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1379439/uk-election-polls-by-age/

UK election polls by age 2024 | Statista

In 2024, the political party that 18 to 24 year-old's in Great Britain would be most likely to vote for was the Labour Party, at 68 percent, while among those over 65, the Conservative Party was the most popular with 33 percent intending to vote for th...

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1379439/uk-election-polls-by-age/

Blackcats7 · 25/03/2024 14:22

It’s a huge salary to a nurse.

Skippythebutterfly · 25/03/2024 14:17

Notonthestairs · 25/03/2024 14:15

"Economists! Researchers! They do know this. It’s their job to know this."

If this is correct why hasn't the Conservative government introduced it?

Because their core vote (boomer pensioners) would be against it, with their endless ‘in my day the mum stayed home and took care of the kids, and the kids were much better behaved’ and ‘why should we have to pay for your offspring’. I hate the word offspring!

Medschoolmum · 25/03/2024 14:17

MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 14:08

Thing is, the country is fucked if even the top % of earners feel skint.

With two preschoolers, 80% of your income on a £100k salary could go on nursery in the South East.

That those people are then excluded from any childcare support is a bit grating - you would think their lifestyle would be rather better than it is.

The issue isn't people being out of touch IMO, it's tax threshold and benefit-removal thresholds being frozen for so long. Something like 3% of earners were affected by the 40% tax rate when it was introduced - by the end of this parliament it will be 15%. Ditto the removal of personal allowance and loss of childcare support at £100k which have been in place for more than a decade.

Oh, I agree that the whole system is fucked and that there needs to be better tapering of support so that there aren't these sudden cliff edges. However, I think that's a separate issue. It is still ridiculously out of touch and insensitive for a politician like Hunt to suggest that £100k is anything but a very good salary... even in Surrey.

And yes, lots of people do struggle in those early years with the cost of childcare/mat leave etc. That's why many people choose to space their kids out more or plan ahead with savings etc to carry them through. At least on an income of £100k you'll have had an opportunity to build up some savings before having kids, which a lot of people wouldn't have had the chance to do.

I'm a higher earner myself fwiw, so this isn't the politics of envy. I just think a lot of people have no idea at all about how others live!

TinkerTiger · 25/03/2024 14:17

CormorantStrikesBack · 25/03/2024 09:48

I’m on the fence. It’s a good salary but in Surrey it isn’t huge compared to others. Especially taking cost of housing in the south. If household income is 100k and you’ve got a mortgage and commuting costs and bringing up kids it probably feels stretched.

if you’re 23yo living In Middlesbrough with no commitments it’s a huge salary.

Honestly that's like saying £1 million isn't a large salary if you've got a huge mortgage and luxury cars and always travel first class and have 10 children in private school.

No shit.

'Everything is relative' goes only so far. Basic and comfortable housing are all we need. Anything more luxurious is a choice and of course will cost more.

But when even the 'cheapest' housing eats up half a monthly salary, yes of course that's a lot of money.