Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hunt out of touch?

168 replies

BluebellsBluebell · 25/03/2024 09:39

£100k is 'not a huge salary'. Fair comment. Yanbu

Does this show Hunt and the tories are out of touch. Yabu

OP posts:
Skippythebutterfly · 25/03/2024 22:22

TedMullins · 25/03/2024 17:03

of course it’s high. The fact that Surrey and childcare are expensive doesn’t negate the fact it is high! We need subsidised/free childcare and a house price cap, but somehow I can’t see 6-figure earners voting for such policies because they’d mean higher tax and property ceasing to be a profit-making asset. Because they don’t really care about the cost of living or the people on minimum wage getting the really shitty end of the stick, they only care about what affects them. Look at Scandinavia - affordable childcare for all, higher salaries, and a generally better standard of living, and high taxes to support all that - and consistently rated one of the happiest regions in the world.

Scandinavia has far higher tax rates on the lower bands than we do. Lower waged earners pay a far higher rate than they do here. That’s while they have better public services. Because EVERYBODY pays higher tax, not just those you might seem ‘wealthy’. That’s how you properly fund public services. Still up for it?

newnamethanks · 25/03/2024 21:52

£5k is very nearly half my annual income. I'm one of those wealthy boomer pensioners (give me my bloody money back you thieving buggers. I don't want compensation, I want the money I paid into my state pension that you stole from us) you hear so much about. People like me find Mr Hunt and his ilk more than tiresome.

Macaroni46 · 25/03/2024 21:11

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 16:44

@Havanananana to be fair to him, he would be slaughtered if he was seen to be giving "hand outs to the rich". I think you definition of huge is different to mine. A huge salary is Christiano Ronaldo, £500k a week or whatever. £5k a month with house prices, interest rates, inflation and childcare where they are doesn't meet my definition of huge.

As someone who has until very recently lived off less than 2k per month, 5k is huge.

PuttingDownRoots · 25/03/2024 17:23

Maybe the focus shouldn't be on giving childcare subsidies to high earners... but examining why nursery costs have got so high.

Is it staffing? Utilities? Food? Rent/mortgages? Extra activities?

Or profits?

Havanananana · 25/03/2024 17:17

@Everanewbie

£100k might not be "huge" but as I've already pointed out, only 4%-5% of the population earn this. For 95% of earners, it is far more than they currently earn, and is many times the earnings of the millions of people who make up 25% of the working population.

The discussion is not about what you or I regard as "huge" but what Hunt regards as "not huge." He's the Chancellor, and the decisions that he makes impact on the lives of millions. If he's making these decisions based on a view of the world that is completely out of touch with the lives of millions of people, or if like the PM, he knows no "poor" people and cannot envisage how the vast majority of the population lives, how can he make decisions that benefit the population at large, and not just those who pay to have their voices heard.

His mis-management of healthcare and social care has proven to have been an unmitigated disaster. He shows no signs of being any better at being Chancellor - something that for different reasons we both seem to agree on.

Vod · 25/03/2024 17:10

Havanananana · 25/03/2024 16:39

Hunt might well be mismanaging the technical situation regarding child care for those earning over £100k, but he's wrong to say that it is "not a huge salary."

Given his record as a Minister he seems perfectly capable of being incompetent and wrong about more than one thing at a time.

Very true!

TedMullins · 25/03/2024 17:03

of course it’s high. The fact that Surrey and childcare are expensive doesn’t negate the fact it is high! We need subsidised/free childcare and a house price cap, but somehow I can’t see 6-figure earners voting for such policies because they’d mean higher tax and property ceasing to be a profit-making asset. Because they don’t really care about the cost of living or the people on minimum wage getting the really shitty end of the stick, they only care about what affects them. Look at Scandinavia - affordable childcare for all, higher salaries, and a generally better standard of living, and high taxes to support all that - and consistently rated one of the happiest regions in the world.

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 16:44

@Havanananana to be fair to him, he would be slaughtered if he was seen to be giving "hand outs to the rich". I think you definition of huge is different to mine. A huge salary is Christiano Ronaldo, £500k a week or whatever. £5k a month with house prices, interest rates, inflation and childcare where they are doesn't meet my definition of huge.

missmollygreen · 25/03/2024 16:43

A politician who doesnt live in the real or understand the struggles of real people?! What a shock

Havanananana · 25/03/2024 16:39

Hunt might well be mismanaging the technical situation regarding child care for those earning over £100k, but he's wrong to say that it is "not a huge salary."

Given his record as a Minister he seems perfectly capable of being incompetent and wrong about more than one thing at a time.

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 16:37

Eleganz · 25/03/2024 16:31

Yes Hunt and the Tories are out of touch as it has taken things to get so bad that £100k a year is not that great for them to pick up that we are a low pay economy taxed to high hell for nothing when median earnings are about 1/3 of that and plenty of people earn even less than that.

The Tories are staring down the barrel of a very big gun created by over a decade of their own economic incompetence and wishful thinking and they know the trigger is going to have to be pulled before the year is out.

I think they're staring down the barrel due to partygate with BJ and the centre of it, then he was removed and its been nothing but factional infighting since.

I think Rishi is an extremely competent man, but he is Prime Minister at a time of turmoil and infighting, to the point where his party are just unelectable.

neverbeenskiing · 25/03/2024 16:35

Of course Hunt is sympathetic to the childcare woes of those earning £100k. Meanwhile, Nurses and Junior Doctors who are struggling with the cost of living should just suck it up and be grateful.

I'm quite surprised to see so many defending Hunt on the basis that "100k doesn't go far if you're in the SE and have two children in Nursery". I always thought Tories were big on telling people not to have more children than they can comfortably afford? Or is it only working class people who should stop at one child, or wait until their first child goes to school before they have a second child? I've also seen plenty of right-leaning posters on MN over the years claiming that it's entitled to expect to live in the SE and if you can't afford your accommodation costs you should just up sticks and "move to a cheaper area"? Again, I'm guessing that advice is just for the plebs.

Eleganz · 25/03/2024 16:31

Yes Hunt and the Tories are out of touch as it has taken things to get so bad that £100k a year is not that great for them to pick up that we are a low pay economy taxed to high hell for nothing when median earnings are about 1/3 of that and plenty of people earn even less than that.

The Tories are staring down the barrel of a very big gun created by over a decade of their own economic incompetence and wishful thinking and they know the trigger is going to have to be pulled before the year is out.

Calmdown14 · 25/03/2024 16:25

I would be a huge salary for me but then I can buy a three bed house for £160k.

The same house in Surrey would be about £700k and I'd need to be earning that kind of wage to buy there.

Relatively, my disposable income is probably better on a third of that salary, and certainly if it's the only salary in the household.

As MN tells us all the time, two medium earners are often better off than one higher earner..

Vod · 25/03/2024 16:06

One of many examples of fiscal drag, which have largely managed to go under the radar while the Tories claim to be reducing taxes.

Yep! And as we have a shortage of skills and workers generally, anything in the tax system that potentially disincentivises work is a problem for all of us. It's all very well saying this particular bottleneck or cliff edge only affects a small number of people, but there are a loooooot of them.

MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 16:01

BIossomtoes · 25/03/2024 15:52

It’s not even 4% of earners. It’s a sub section of that 4% who have children under school age. I saw somewhere it’s about 300,000 people - about the same number as WASPI women who the government ignored for years. And the same applies in that their situation is temporary and as soon as it comes to an end they stop caring.

3.6 million women are 'WASPI women'.

78,000 parents of preschoolers are currently impacted by this threshold - likely to increase to 127,000 by 2027 (Institute for economic affairs stat) due to frozen thresholds.

So it's an issue that is impacting more and more parents:

  • Because of the freezing of tax thresholds
  • Because of the freezing of benefit removal thresholds
  • Because the cost of childcare is increasing above inflation making it a bigger household expenditure for families

It impacting a comparatively small number of people isn't a reason to ignore it. If anything, it's a reason to allow them to have the benefit, as the cost of providing it might be less than the loss of tax as a result of them trying to avoid earning more than the threshold.

One of many examples of fiscal drag, which have largely managed to go under the radar while the Tories claim to be reducing taxes.

Vod · 25/03/2024 15:58

He sounds a tit saying 100k isn't that much. It's much more than most people have. Should've kept to the point he was actually making, which is that some of them face marginal tax rates in the five figures and that's not a good thing for anyone.

Though the obvious response to that is, you're the fucking Chancellor, do something about it.

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 15:58

BIossomtoes · 25/03/2024 15:52

It’s not even 4% of earners. It’s a sub section of that 4% who have children under school age. I saw somewhere it’s about 300,000 people - about the same number as WASPI women who the government ignored for years. And the same applies in that their situation is temporary and as soon as it comes to an end they stop caring.

Even without the childcare issue, someone earning more than 100k will still suffer the 60% effective tax rate, and be disqualified from child benefit. They are still being taxed disproportionately to their living standards. The child care issue just further illustrates how the 100k mark doesn't make you as wealthy as people think.

Spendonsend · 25/03/2024 15:56

I bet people agree that people on 100k should be allowed to send thier child to a state school and not pay for it.

I dont understand why having universal free childcare hours is considered a step too far.

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 15:54

Well no, sorry if this hurts, but those on minimum wage have not studied, grafted and worked for free for years. Unless they are directing their energies extremely badly.

And the people on 100k are nowhere near the wealthiest in the country. Your ire needs to be directed and the ultra-wealthy, generational wealth, Lord Sainsbury types. Not the person who works hard for their family as a doctor or a solicitor, a bank manager or architect. In all of those jobs you've mentioned, there are routes to £100k. Not easily, granted. But there are. Plenty of skilled tradespeople take out loans secured on their home, set up a business as bring in in excess of £100k following years of sacrifice and personal risk. Teachers can go on to be heads of large schools, or go into upper echelons of the educational system. Chefs would earn a shed load if they reached the top of their profession.

They won't do it by just rocking up day after day, doing their jobs, taking no risk and expecting it to fall in their laps. Those on £100k haven't.

BIossomtoes · 25/03/2024 15:52

It’s not even 4% of earners. It’s a sub section of that 4% who have children under school age. I saw somewhere it’s about 300,000 people - about the same number as WASPI women who the government ignored for years. And the same applies in that their situation is temporary and as soon as it comes to an end they stop caring.

Havanananana · 25/03/2024 15:45

"Why should they try living like that? They've grafted, studied, worked for free for years to get to that point. They deserve what they get, and given their contribution to the country's coffers, I think they deserve their voice to be heard."

Really? The wealthiest people in the country have "grafted, studied, worked for free for years to get to that point" have they? Is the implication that those who are not as wealthy have not "grafted, studied, worked for free for years to get to that point" - in which case you should go talk to some nurses, teachers, engineers, chefs, skilled tradespersons and others who would love to earn even half of £100k a year.

Why 4% of earners deserve to have their voices heard any more than the millions of people whose jobs have disappeared, whose educational opportunities have been diminished, who can barely afford to eat or heat, who are living in slum housing and whose prospects and ambitions have been dashed by the idiotic policies and incompetence of Cameron, May, Hunt, Truss and Johnson? The government is supposed to work in the best interests of all of the population, not just the 4% who have the Conservatives ear and who can send a helicopter to summons the PM whenever they want to tell him something.

MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 15:32

Havanananana · 25/03/2024 15:24

"Maybe there are arguments about Conservatives looking after the wealthy, but if they are, it certainly isn't people earning between £50k and £250k as they are been royally shafted in the lifetime of this parliament."

Those being royally shafted are the millions who have seen the vital services on which they rely - universal healthcare, public transport, utilities, education etc. - either chronically underfunded or monetarised, with the profits going to investors rather than back to the users in the form of investment, lower bills and fares or service improvements. The present government has spent 14 years dismantling the social contract that has been refined in the century from the end of WW1 to the detriment of millions of people in the UK.

If the 4% of the population earning £100k or more think they're being shafted, they can try living in a shitty HMO and working for a year on a zero-hour contract for £11.44 an hour, and hope to goodness that they don't get ill.

Most people earning these salaries will have spent time living in a shitty HMO and working for low wages. I spent about ten years living in one (as do most in London).

It's not a competition about helping one group vs another - we can care about improving housing for those on minimum wage while also agreeing it's not right to remove childcare support from higher earning working families.

MidnightPatrol · 25/03/2024 15:28

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 15:15

@MidnightPatrol I just see lazy old anti-tory lines dragged out time and time again on threads like this, without any hesitation to actually explain how they are the party of the high earner. Jeremy Hunt acknowledging that £100k hardly makes you the Wolf of Wall Street these days, in a 1-2-1 conversation who is affected by the £100k cliff edge, seems to offend people.

The thing is - it is ridiculous. It is £100k and need childcare support? On the surface that sounds mad. I would have thought the same.

Firstly people forget about the impact of tax thresholds - as I outline above a parent on £100k might have 1.5x the take home pay of a parent on £35k. No one would assume that without doing some maths - it's surprising.

And then I think people have their head in the sand about the cost of childcare. The cost has risen above inflation every year for 15 years or something - mine has increased by 20% since I signed up two years ago. No doubt it will go up again this year. £4,000 a month for two is normal here.

I still can't quite wrap my head around it myself tbh.

IMO the Tories have backed themselves into a corner with freezing these thresholds, and now cannot increase them without bad press. So they don't. God know what it will look like in 5 years time, when even more people are caught.

Everanewbie · 25/03/2024 15:27

Havanananana · 25/03/2024 15:24

"Maybe there are arguments about Conservatives looking after the wealthy, but if they are, it certainly isn't people earning between £50k and £250k as they are been royally shafted in the lifetime of this parliament."

Those being royally shafted are the millions who have seen the vital services on which they rely - universal healthcare, public transport, utilities, education etc. - either chronically underfunded or monetarised, with the profits going to investors rather than back to the users in the form of investment, lower bills and fares or service improvements. The present government has spent 14 years dismantling the social contract that has been refined in the century from the end of WW1 to the detriment of millions of people in the UK.

If the 4% of the population earning £100k or more think they're being shafted, they can try living in a shitty HMO and working for a year on a zero-hour contract for £11.44 an hour, and hope to goodness that they don't get ill.

Why should they try living like that? They've grafted, studied, worked for free for years to get to that point. They deserve what they get, and given their contribution to the country's coffers, I think they deserve their voice to be heard.

But. Taxing higher earners til the pips squeak is a reality that doesn't change the situation on the ground for those that need those vital services. Like I said earlier, its possible to hold two thoughts in your head at once.