Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think buying my own place would be a terrible idea?

110 replies

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 08:55

Dp and I have been together a few years and live together. He owns his house but I don't pay towards the mortgage but do pay a contribution to bills and pay for most of our food. We aren't married and won't be getting married.

Basically, due to a combination of horrible bad luck and less than stellar life choices I've ended up in the situation where I have no significant assets and no real savings of my own. I have no private pension and have accepted a long time ago that I will (barring a miracle or lottery win) never own my own property and will likely have to work until I drop. Whilst I'm not 'fine' with this I've accepted it is what it is. I was born into a poor family and have never had much, living in extreme poverty at times, and as such I've given up being frustrated at not being able to afford certain things, am very frugal, and just generally try not to stress out about financial things as I know I don't have much choice and I will just have to deal with things as and when they come up as I always have. I work full time but just above MW which is very standard for this area and I'm very lucky to have even found a full time contract. I'm very proud of myself for finally paying off all my debt so am now completely debt free and trying to build up my credit rating.

My contrast Dp has been very fortunate. From a middle class family, got family help with his house deposit and earns quite well. He works hard and is careful with money but I think is a little bit blind to the good luck and extra advantages he has had over many (including me) that's helped put him in this position.

He's been encouraging me to save a deposit for my own place which I can then rent out and is a potential source of income for retirement.

Whilst I agree this is a good plan in theory, in practise I think it would be a terrible idea.

I have max £200 a month of disposable income to put into savings for a deposit. If I did so, after 5 years I'd have a deposit for a very cheap place, but in those 5yrs I then could not do anything more than the basics. No holidays, no paying for any unexpected expenses, nothing. That's really not a sacrifice I'm prepared to make!

Also, I'd then have to worry about fees and the like which are thousands extra, and renting comes with huge additional expenses and risks like someone trashing your place, just general wear and tear that comes with being a landlord, tenants who refuse to leave and having to go through expensive court proceedings to get them out, etc. That's if a bank would even give me a mortgage in the first place as I'm in my 40's and don't earn much.

I don't disagree that investing in something for the future is a good idea but I don't think this is a viable option. Aibu and should seriously consider this, or am I right and DP is BU to think this is possible in my current circumstances?

OP posts:
Maryamlouise · 25/03/2024 09:53

I am a landlord and would not recommend it, and I haven't even had any major issues with tenants. It wasn't something I planned and it doesn't make money (am higher rate tax payer). In fact I pay towards the mortgage every month but obviously once the mortgage is paid off it will be good and I am sticking with it as I don't have much else in terms of a retirement plan.

Savings and sorting out a plan for your future sounds like a good idea but I don't think property is it.

ThisOldThang · 25/03/2024 09:46

Lifetime ISA?

You can put in a maximum of £4k per annum and the government matches whatever you put in with a 25% bonus.

So, you put in £200 p/m and end up with £250 p/m. That works out at £3k per year.

You could invest in something like a passive global stocks ETF such as L&G Global Equity code LGGG with a 0.1% management charge. Investment firms such as AJ Bell allow regular monthly investments for £1.50 per trade.

You can access the money as a first time buyer, otherwise it's locked away until you're 60.

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 09:45

Yes @Lifestooshort71 effectively that's what I'm doing so the 'rent' I'm paying him I would use to rent a place of my own. My bills I already pay and food would be less as I'd be paying for 1 not 2.

I've had to leave my home unexpectedly and at short notice before and I've made it work. I had no choice! Same if DP died or we split. I'd figure it out.

Dp has said he will make provision for me in his will but hasn't gotten around to doing it yet. We have only been together 3yrs so I don't think it's unreasonable for him to wait until he's comfortable to do that, it's a big deal for someone to leave their biggest assets to someone they aren't married to who isn't family. He does very much care about me, which I know is why he's concerned about me making provisions for my future.

OP posts:
Furrydogmum · 25/03/2024 09:44

Why do you have so little left each month? If you have no rights to your DP's house, you should only be paying your share of bills, food etc. He shouldn't be benefitting from you at cost to your financial security.

Lifestooshort71 · 25/03/2024 09:39

Putting the emotional relationship to one side, the OP is effectively paying rent for a house share and has said that that amount would be enough to rent her somewhere else if necessary. They keep their finances totally separate so I don't see that either should be financially responsible for the other if she moved out (for whatever reason). Putting the relationship back in the equation, would her partner be comfortable with this situation if he suddenly passed away or would he leave her a small nest egg to help her settle somewhere else? As he has suggested she becomes more financially savvy, it doesn't sound as though he'd be that bothered but I could well be wrong.

Kosenrufugirl · 25/03/2024 09:39

Firstly well done for getting yourself where you are now-financially stable and no debt! I come from the extreme poverty background myself, I know how difficult it is to beat the old demons and acquire good financial habits. I don't think buy to let is a good idea for your circumstances (for all sorts of reasons above). How about investing into a private pension? AJBell is an investment platform which is very easy to use. No brokers fees. They have a huge amount of investment advice for all levels of investing knowledge and their charges are very low. You can open a SIPP for £250, buy one of their own funds and watch your money grow. Stock market will always beat cash over long term, £250 today will be worth a minimum £500 in today's money in 15 years time. You can then add up as you please into your SIPP or set up a direct debit. If you pay any income tax at all, AJBell will claim it from HMRC on your behalf (i.e. if you paid £250 into your pension they will claim £50 tax providing you did earn enough to pay £50 tax in the first place). The deadline to open a SIPP (self investment pension) and claim tax for 2023-2024 financial year is 5th of April.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 25/03/2024 09:39

You're definitely not in a position to buy and rent out a property. Many private landlords are selling up as it's just not cost effective any more.

You do need to wise up and get some savings behind you though. You don't say how old you are but regardless of age you need to pay into a pension.

As you need access to savings, my advice would be to put £100 per month into the best high interest accessible account you can find and £100 into a pension.

I'd also be seriously thinking about whether I wanted to be with someone who cared so little about my financial security.

It doesn't matter whether you want kids or not. He could drop down dead next week and you'd be left high and dry with nowhere to live. Doesn't it bother you that he doesn't care?

You should both, at the very least, have Wills sorted so that if anything does happen to either of you, there is some element of security.

I know of an unmarried couple with no Wills... he died unexpectedly. Their home was his... it's been an almighty mess to sort out financially. And a lot of the money that was there has been lost to the Government in tax.

If your OP is so concerned about financial stability he needs to look a bit closer to home!

Singleandproud · 25/03/2024 09:38

At the moment it doesn't sound like you'd be able to rent if you broke up let alone have a buy to rent property. If you are in a holiday spot it might be worth the pair of you buying a caravan on a holiday site and renting it out for the season.

At the moment you are fully self sufficient but do you have any contingency plans should you break up, made redundant, have a serious injury or fall ill? I think there are lots of things you could put your money in right now rather than a buy to let.

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 09:38

@InterestedinEfteling I pay something equivalent to a cheap rent in a house share, plus most (but not all) food. Like I said I don't earn much over MW plus I have my own bills and stuff to pay for.

I realise I did misspeak earlier though, I said max £200 to save whereas actually sometimes I do save more it's just that £200 is what I can comfortably save every month, including winter when my wage is lower. Last month I saved £300 and over the summer when hours go up I will probably save more.

OP posts:
TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 25/03/2024 09:37

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 09:16

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist I don't rely on DP for anything financially, we have separate bank accounts and I spend what I earn myself and never get money from him.

The contribution I make at the moment in bills and food is roughly equivalent to a cheap rent so yes I'd be able to afford that if we split. I'm also finally able to save money at the moment which I wasn't before. I don't have much in there yet but I will keep adding to that and could use that if we split.

I'm not sure I follow. You contribute to bills and food, but how is it equivalent to a cheap rent? If that amount was instead spent on renting cheaply (if you split with your DP), then what would you use to pay for bills and food?

It does as though you are financially precarious. Regardless of whether you have separate bank accounts, you'd be left very badly off if you split. You talk about saving meaning that you couldn't afford holidays, but if you were to split you wouldn't be able to afford holidays either.

I don't think you should necessarily consider buying a property, but you do need to be saving that £200 a month if you want to have any financial security in future.

caringcarer · 25/03/2024 09:35

OP focus on paying off all your debts then saving up a little nest egg. To get a btl mortgage you'd need 25 percent deposit minimum so I think sounds out for you but you could build up money in ISA's as it's tax free. Also you could/should pay into your pension fund as much as you can afford or you will be so broken in retirement.

senua · 25/03/2024 09:34

It's a basic rule of saving to never put all your eggs in one basket. Properties are expensive (stating the obvious!) so, unless you have a huge savings pot, buying a property takes up pretty much the whole basket all on its own.

Diversify.

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 09:33

Oh I absolutely think I should invest in Something, I just do think property is a good idea in my circumstances.

Tbh I've always been so poor and/or in debt I've always just lived paycheck to paycheck trying desperately to keep my head above water, so things like savings, pensions and buying property was so wildly out of the realms of possibility I never really considered it. Now I'm in a much better financial position I can consider it but I need to look carefully at my options and be realistic about what is possible.

OP posts:
InterestedinEfteling · 25/03/2024 09:32

How do you only have £200 left each month? How much are you paying him.

DarrylPhilbin · 25/03/2024 09:31

In your position I would save say a couple of grand in a cash ISA just in case you ever do split up and you need to find somewhere to rent, and then put the rest away for a pension (however you do that-LISA, SIPP, extra contributions through your employer etc.) If buying your own property is out of your reach then at least you will have more money in your retirement and a nest egg.

Galliano · 25/03/2024 09:28

£200 pcm into a pension with the resultant tax benefit plus possibly a matched contribution from your employer would make much more sense.
Has he made provision for you in the event he dies? It would be extremely tough if you lost your partner and your home at same time.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 25/03/2024 09:26

I think a lot depends on your age. If you are 57 then you are right to think scrimping towards buying a place is a non-starter and would only cause problems if you split from your partner and needed to claim assistance. Same goes for pension to be honest.

If you are 32 then the situation is different and yes, I think it would make sense to plan to buy somewhere.

kiwiane · 25/03/2024 09:26

You’re right - you don’t have the money to be a successful landlord. The tax breaks come in for the rich with a dozen properties.
i would try to save something in case you need to rent your own place sometime.

areyoutheregod · 25/03/2024 09:25

Your concerns around buying property are valid but I think he’s right you need to do something for your future. You don’t have a pension so at some point you would likely rely more heavily on him. How about an ISA?

SeaAndCakes · 25/03/2024 09:22

I think it would take a long time to have enough to buy - and keep - a property by saving £200 a month. Also I agree with you about the overall stress and opportunity costs. I'd be tempted to split that money between a savings account and tracker fund instead to try to build up some money for the future.

Haydenn · 25/03/2024 09:21

I think he is very right in encouraging you to save and get into the habit of saving. He is also right that if you have a focus for the money (such as buying a house) you are then less likely to dip into those savings for treats and things. A goal for the savings will mean you are less likely to raid them.

I think you are in a financially precarious position. You may see your DP as lucky- others may see him as savvy. I’d take his advice. You might never be in the position to actually buy a property, but having a nest egg will do you no harm at all.

Notmyuser · 25/03/2024 09:20

Why don’t you suggest buying a place together and him renting the property you live in together out?

Mrsttcno1 · 25/03/2024 09:19

I think whether it’s a house or something else, your partner is right in that you need to be planning for your future.

Personally I probably wouldn’t do buy to let, on top of the fact that you would need 25% deposit minimum probably to get that at the moment, it also comes with quite a lot of financial responsibility once you have tenants in. Obviously everyone will have a different experience of being a landlord and it can be a great investment but the couple of friends I have who have done this have regretted it because the property ended up trashed, tenants had to be taken to court to evict etc, being a landlord is definitely not the easy passive income that a lot of people think it is (or should I say being a GOOD landlord isn’t) which is why I’d never think of doing it as I just think it’s too much hassle.

pandarific · 25/03/2024 09:18

I would say you’re right, houses are stressful and time consuming - but I would be putting anything spare into an ISA or your pension. Perhaps research what would be the best option for you - moneysavingexpert is great and you will get tailored advice on the message boards.

I would suggest to your DP that for a bit of joint savings/fun money perhaps both pay into a credit union or football pools or similar, where there is a chance of winning some extra or prizes etc to be shared by you both. That can be emergency/holiday fund etc.

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 09:16

@TarantinoIsAMisogynist I don't rely on DP for anything financially, we have separate bank accounts and I spend what I earn myself and never get money from him.

The contribution I make at the moment in bills and food is roughly equivalent to a cheap rent so yes I'd be able to afford that if we split. I'm also finally able to save money at the moment which I wasn't before. I don't have much in there yet but I will keep adding to that and could use that if we split.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread