Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think buying my own place would be a terrible idea?

110 replies

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 08:55

Dp and I have been together a few years and live together. He owns his house but I don't pay towards the mortgage but do pay a contribution to bills and pay for most of our food. We aren't married and won't be getting married.

Basically, due to a combination of horrible bad luck and less than stellar life choices I've ended up in the situation where I have no significant assets and no real savings of my own. I have no private pension and have accepted a long time ago that I will (barring a miracle or lottery win) never own my own property and will likely have to work until I drop. Whilst I'm not 'fine' with this I've accepted it is what it is. I was born into a poor family and have never had much, living in extreme poverty at times, and as such I've given up being frustrated at not being able to afford certain things, am very frugal, and just generally try not to stress out about financial things as I know I don't have much choice and I will just have to deal with things as and when they come up as I always have. I work full time but just above MW which is very standard for this area and I'm very lucky to have even found a full time contract. I'm very proud of myself for finally paying off all my debt so am now completely debt free and trying to build up my credit rating.

My contrast Dp has been very fortunate. From a middle class family, got family help with his house deposit and earns quite well. He works hard and is careful with money but I think is a little bit blind to the good luck and extra advantages he has had over many (including me) that's helped put him in this position.

He's been encouraging me to save a deposit for my own place which I can then rent out and is a potential source of income for retirement.

Whilst I agree this is a good plan in theory, in practise I think it would be a terrible idea.

I have max £200 a month of disposable income to put into savings for a deposit. If I did so, after 5 years I'd have a deposit for a very cheap place, but in those 5yrs I then could not do anything more than the basics. No holidays, no paying for any unexpected expenses, nothing. That's really not a sacrifice I'm prepared to make!

Also, I'd then have to worry about fees and the like which are thousands extra, and renting comes with huge additional expenses and risks like someone trashing your place, just general wear and tear that comes with being a landlord, tenants who refuse to leave and having to go through expensive court proceedings to get them out, etc. That's if a bank would even give me a mortgage in the first place as I'm in my 40's and don't earn much.

I don't disagree that investing in something for the future is a good idea but I don't think this is a viable option. Aibu and should seriously consider this, or am I right and DP is BU to think this is possible in my current circumstances?

OP posts:
ThisOldThang · 25/03/2024 14:27

I don't think it's reasonable to expect your partner to just give you half his house and assets.

I'm not sure why so many people seem to think you should get to live rent free, when your partner has to pay a mortgage.

I very much doubt anybody would be suggesting a home owning woman should allow a low earning man to live rent free in her mortgaged home and also expose herself to losing half her assets due to marriage/divorce.

It's not clear what your educational background is or what you currently do for a living (tourism related?), but I think the people advising you to upskill and earn more money are correct.

Perhaps some IT courses would allow you to earn more money - e.g. Microsoft Office for basic office/business skills?

SoupDragon · 25/03/2024 14:21

Sausage1989 · 25/03/2024 14:18

Why the hell are you paying for his food shop?!?!? He sounds selfish and tight. I bet he hasn't sorted his will out. I bet any money that he won't be doing that. Open your eyes. He's taking the piss.

i Was under the impression she pays for food rather than paying rent.

Sausage1989 · 25/03/2024 14:18

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 09:45

Yes @Lifestooshort71 effectively that's what I'm doing so the 'rent' I'm paying him I would use to rent a place of my own. My bills I already pay and food would be less as I'd be paying for 1 not 2.

I've had to leave my home unexpectedly and at short notice before and I've made it work. I had no choice! Same if DP died or we split. I'd figure it out.

Dp has said he will make provision for me in his will but hasn't gotten around to doing it yet. We have only been together 3yrs so I don't think it's unreasonable for him to wait until he's comfortable to do that, it's a big deal for someone to leave their biggest assets to someone they aren't married to who isn't family. He does very much care about me, which I know is why he's concerned about me making provisions for my future.

Why the hell are you paying for his food shop?!?!? He sounds selfish and tight. I bet he hasn't sorted his will out. I bet any money that he won't be doing that. Open your eyes. He's taking the piss.

Sausage1989 · 25/03/2024 14:15

You partner doesn't sound very nice.

slippedonabanana · 25/03/2024 13:49

You aren't in a position to buy at the moment. I think you need to find a balance between a low paying job that you like and one that pays more. Not all well paying jobs are torture. You need to consider something you could train to do that provides a better income. You aren't in your 20s and it's time to protect your future. Your boyfriend has said that he won't be helping you financially.

How much is it costing you to live with him?

MiddleClassProblem · 25/03/2024 13:47

I’m not sure how old you are but if you are under 40 I would open a lifetime isa. You can use it for buying a property or to boost your pension. You could just put in £2 a week a that would be £104 in a year which would have an interest rate plus the government would give you £25.

So even if it’s just a few pounds and you use it to take out when you are 60, it could still end up being a couple of hundred with interest and the government top up added on top. It could just come in handy for emergency money or a treat when you’re older.

This could be a little side savings set up and separate while you figure stuff out.

EasterBunnny · 25/03/2024 13:34

How much is it you are paying your boyfriend? Are you happy with this amount? It must be quite a bit if you can only save around £200 per month.

A Lisa or pension could be worth looking into.

Basically he’s telling you that you need a financial plan for your future as you can’t rely on him.

RawBloomers · 25/03/2024 13:26

I agree that property probably isn’t the thing to invest in. Buy to let is not so easy for single property owners any more. It requires more capital than it used to, there are a lot more hoops to jump through, and many people with just one or two properties are selling up. But the concern for your future Is very valid and your initial post sounded more like you wanted to spend the money now than invest in something else, which I can see why that would concern someone who worried about your future.

But, to be honest, it sounds like you should be looking at investing in your earning power at this stage. You’re in a shared household with no kids (?) and all you can save is 200 a month. That’s not much. Also, you sound like you have a fairly insecure income dependent on the hours available. Not all jobs with variable hours are insecure or low paying but the way you describe your financial situation, it sounds like yours is. This is what I would be looking to change. Save up a bit so you can retrain in a trade or profession that will pay significantly more than you currently earn.

ThisCosyPoster · 25/03/2024 13:10

You are contributing to your boyfriend's growing financial asset (the house) and his financial security by paying him 'rent'. You on the other hand end up with a load of old supermarket receipts. Appreciate it's only 3 years in but this isn't fair if this is serious relationship.

Bigpaintinglittlepainting · 25/03/2024 12:55

I would definitely not be paying towards his assets, do not pay him rent, if he won't marry you because of money why should you pay for his house ? Taking the piss, split bills and food but no way would I be paying towards his mortgage

areyoutheregod · 25/03/2024 12:50

Think they've only been together 3 years so its a bit much asking him to cover her so she can save more. As I understand the OP, you don't pay rent or mortgage, but share the bills and pay all the food? Is that right?

Fluffyhoglets · 25/03/2024 12:48

Why are you paying for most of the food? You should be sharing that cost equally then you'd have more to save each month in a pension or isa.
I'd sort that out with him ASAP!

But you are right BTL is not a great idea for you.

Hankunamatata · 25/03/2024 12:46

Talk to financial advisor. You may be better paying £200 a month into a private pension.

sarah419 · 25/03/2024 12:44

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 08:55

Dp and I have been together a few years and live together. He owns his house but I don't pay towards the mortgage but do pay a contribution to bills and pay for most of our food. We aren't married and won't be getting married.

Basically, due to a combination of horrible bad luck and less than stellar life choices I've ended up in the situation where I have no significant assets and no real savings of my own. I have no private pension and have accepted a long time ago that I will (barring a miracle or lottery win) never own my own property and will likely have to work until I drop. Whilst I'm not 'fine' with this I've accepted it is what it is. I was born into a poor family and have never had much, living in extreme poverty at times, and as such I've given up being frustrated at not being able to afford certain things, am very frugal, and just generally try not to stress out about financial things as I know I don't have much choice and I will just have to deal with things as and when they come up as I always have. I work full time but just above MW which is very standard for this area and I'm very lucky to have even found a full time contract. I'm very proud of myself for finally paying off all my debt so am now completely debt free and trying to build up my credit rating.

My contrast Dp has been very fortunate. From a middle class family, got family help with his house deposit and earns quite well. He works hard and is careful with money but I think is a little bit blind to the good luck and extra advantages he has had over many (including me) that's helped put him in this position.

He's been encouraging me to save a deposit for my own place which I can then rent out and is a potential source of income for retirement.

Whilst I agree this is a good plan in theory, in practise I think it would be a terrible idea.

I have max £200 a month of disposable income to put into savings for a deposit. If I did so, after 5 years I'd have a deposit for a very cheap place, but in those 5yrs I then could not do anything more than the basics. No holidays, no paying for any unexpected expenses, nothing. That's really not a sacrifice I'm prepared to make!

Also, I'd then have to worry about fees and the like which are thousands extra, and renting comes with huge additional expenses and risks like someone trashing your place, just general wear and tear that comes with being a landlord, tenants who refuse to leave and having to go through expensive court proceedings to get them out, etc. That's if a bank would even give me a mortgage in the first place as I'm in my 40's and don't earn much.

I don't disagree that investing in something for the future is a good idea but I don't think this is a viable option. Aibu and should seriously consider this, or am I right and DP is BU to think this is possible in my current circumstances?

what’s your line of work? have you thought about moving abroad? tax free salaries in the Gulf even for jobs like sales reps, with better living standards and opportunities to save while “living life”. you can’t continue this way, so start thinking outside the box x

PensionedCruiser · 25/03/2024 12:41

Putting aside the fact that he doesn't want to get married, I am assuming that you are in a loving committed relationship, so why isn't he making an effort to help provide for you in the future? It would be the loving, caring thing to do. For instance, if he is not struggling financially, he could have you paying less into your home and you could use the saved money to put in a pension pot or to buy property.

Of course, if your relationship is not all those things, I would wonder why you are together.

Notamum12345577 · 25/03/2024 12:37

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 08:55

Dp and I have been together a few years and live together. He owns his house but I don't pay towards the mortgage but do pay a contribution to bills and pay for most of our food. We aren't married and won't be getting married.

Basically, due to a combination of horrible bad luck and less than stellar life choices I've ended up in the situation where I have no significant assets and no real savings of my own. I have no private pension and have accepted a long time ago that I will (barring a miracle or lottery win) never own my own property and will likely have to work until I drop. Whilst I'm not 'fine' with this I've accepted it is what it is. I was born into a poor family and have never had much, living in extreme poverty at times, and as such I've given up being frustrated at not being able to afford certain things, am very frugal, and just generally try not to stress out about financial things as I know I don't have much choice and I will just have to deal with things as and when they come up as I always have. I work full time but just above MW which is very standard for this area and I'm very lucky to have even found a full time contract. I'm very proud of myself for finally paying off all my debt so am now completely debt free and trying to build up my credit rating.

My contrast Dp has been very fortunate. From a middle class family, got family help with his house deposit and earns quite well. He works hard and is careful with money but I think is a little bit blind to the good luck and extra advantages he has had over many (including me) that's helped put him in this position.

He's been encouraging me to save a deposit for my own place which I can then rent out and is a potential source of income for retirement.

Whilst I agree this is a good plan in theory, in practise I think it would be a terrible idea.

I have max £200 a month of disposable income to put into savings for a deposit. If I did so, after 5 years I'd have a deposit for a very cheap place, but in those 5yrs I then could not do anything more than the basics. No holidays, no paying for any unexpected expenses, nothing. That's really not a sacrifice I'm prepared to make!

Also, I'd then have to worry about fees and the like which are thousands extra, and renting comes with huge additional expenses and risks like someone trashing your place, just general wear and tear that comes with being a landlord, tenants who refuse to leave and having to go through expensive court proceedings to get them out, etc. That's if a bank would even give me a mortgage in the first place as I'm in my 40's and don't earn much.

I don't disagree that investing in something for the future is a good idea but I don't think this is a viable option. Aibu and should seriously consider this, or am I right and DP is BU to think this is possible in my current circumstances?

So you are having to live frugally, have not got a pension, and most likely will have work until you drop. You partner, who you live with, earns well and has a house that I assume will be mortgage free at some point. This is not a partnership.

TomatoWrap · 25/03/2024 11:23

At this stage OP, I think the best investment you could make is in yourself.

What are your interests? What is your dream job? What are you good at? What do you enjoy?

What courses or work experience is available to you in your free time? What can you do in the next 5 years that would lead to a better longer term financial position (job with a better pension, better pay). Or even a job you can do on the side of your current job.

For example...I'd like to write childrens books. I could do this in addition to my day job, but it is going to take me a number or years (and investment in myself) to complete some courses and write the material.

BeckiWithAnI · 25/03/2024 11:05

ThisOldThang · 25/03/2024 10:55

That's quite a crazy level of entitlement coupled with advice to use a partner for financial gain.

They've only been together for three years. OP brings no assets to the relationship. Why should her partner put his assets at risk, when they don't want children?

Would you give this advice if roles were reversed or call him a cocklodger?

Because the partner is quick to tell her exactly what she should do with her money.
If he’s happy to cohabite with someone to benefit himself (she clearly isn’t cocklodging if she’s paying her way) but not pool resources, get married, generally do anything after THREE YEARS to suggest he’s in it for the long run, then what’s the actual point?
He could be suggesting she saves as much as she can for five years and then they buy together, or a stake in his property. He’s mentioned a provision in his will that he never gets round to. But in reality he has no intention for her to be any more than a lodger.
I think it’s best OP saves her own money and puts a roof over her own head.

Bigcat25 · 25/03/2024 11:04

I think it's too much risk. If the house needed repairs or the place got trashed by renters you'd have no margin. Imo, being a landlord should be for those who can absorb the risk.

Is there anyway you could share the food costs equally, instead of you paying more? Have you talked to your partner about your concerns?

ThisOldThang · 25/03/2024 10:55

BeckiWithAnI · 25/03/2024 10:41

I’d suggest you DO save and buy yourself a little place… but to live in by yourself.

How can you have a future with a man like this? Won’t marry you to provide you both with the legal security that comes with that, and acts like he’s doing you a favour charging you mates rates rent, presumably that still benefits him financially with bills and his mortgage. Whether he says it goes directly into his mortgage or not, it still does in a roundabout way.

You mentioned your financial position being due to some poor choices. He sounds like another one. I’d see him for what he is, an opportunity to pay off your debts, save and get yourself a little money behind yourself for when it goes tits up.

That's quite a crazy level of entitlement coupled with advice to use a partner for financial gain.

They've only been together for three years. OP brings no assets to the relationship. Why should her partner put his assets at risk, when they don't want children?

Would you give this advice if roles were reversed or call him a cocklodger?

Lifestooshort71 · 25/03/2024 10:53

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 09:45

Yes @Lifestooshort71 effectively that's what I'm doing so the 'rent' I'm paying him I would use to rent a place of my own. My bills I already pay and food would be less as I'd be paying for 1 not 2.

I've had to leave my home unexpectedly and at short notice before and I've made it work. I had no choice! Same if DP died or we split. I'd figure it out.

Dp has said he will make provision for me in his will but hasn't gotten around to doing it yet. We have only been together 3yrs so I don't think it's unreasonable for him to wait until he's comfortable to do that, it's a big deal for someone to leave their biggest assets to someone they aren't married to who isn't family. He does very much care about me, which I know is why he's concerned about me making provisions for my future.

You sound very sensible and level headed. Good luck x

BeckiWithAnI · 25/03/2024 10:41

I’d suggest you DO save and buy yourself a little place… but to live in by yourself.

How can you have a future with a man like this? Won’t marry you to provide you both with the legal security that comes with that, and acts like he’s doing you a favour charging you mates rates rent, presumably that still benefits him financially with bills and his mortgage. Whether he says it goes directly into his mortgage or not, it still does in a roundabout way.

You mentioned your financial position being due to some poor choices. He sounds like another one. I’d see him for what he is, an opportunity to pay off your debts, save and get yourself a little money behind yourself for when it goes tits up.

ViciousCurrentBun · 25/03/2024 10:27

There was a time to be a BTL landlord, that time is not now, you get a bad tenant and that can wipe out profit for a few years. Plus changes in housing law means it’s much higher risk.

Does your company have a pension scheme and what age are you?

One of the best things currently is a LISA but you have to be under 40 and any savings made can only be used for a mortgage or retirement. It’s max 4k per annum but it’s 25% interest tax free. This product is far less available now but here is a link to the GOV website outlining this, https://www.gov.uk/lifetime-isaYou have a small pot to play with being a landlord or playing the stock market is risky. You need to go in with your eyes open and be prepared to lose and afford to lose it without if affecting you if you invest. My DH lost a lot of money trading one day many years ago, his only big loss, he did recoup it fortunately.

Lifetime ISA

Tax free saving for your first home and later life: what is a LISA, who can apply, 25% government bonus, withdrawal charges.

https://www.gov.uk/lifetime-isa

Octavia64 · 25/03/2024 10:16

A lot of people in the U.K. still think buy to let is a golden money train which it really isn't any more.

Sounds like he's not really up to date with the tax changes etc as well as to be honest as others have said it's just not a good idea if you don't have spare cash to cover new boiler/new roof etc.

Ragruggers · 25/03/2024 10:10

The most important detail is how old are you ? If you are 30 a lot different to 50. You earn NMW and have a contract but are you able to have a works pension.Life has many surprises and being old and cash strapped is not the same as young and well.Glad you are able to save now my advice would be to get a savings plan together and really save for a couple of years.Good luck