Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think buying my own place would be a terrible idea?

110 replies

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 08:55

Dp and I have been together a few years and live together. He owns his house but I don't pay towards the mortgage but do pay a contribution to bills and pay for most of our food. We aren't married and won't be getting married.

Basically, due to a combination of horrible bad luck and less than stellar life choices I've ended up in the situation where I have no significant assets and no real savings of my own. I have no private pension and have accepted a long time ago that I will (barring a miracle or lottery win) never own my own property and will likely have to work until I drop. Whilst I'm not 'fine' with this I've accepted it is what it is. I was born into a poor family and have never had much, living in extreme poverty at times, and as such I've given up being frustrated at not being able to afford certain things, am very frugal, and just generally try not to stress out about financial things as I know I don't have much choice and I will just have to deal with things as and when they come up as I always have. I work full time but just above MW which is very standard for this area and I'm very lucky to have even found a full time contract. I'm very proud of myself for finally paying off all my debt so am now completely debt free and trying to build up my credit rating.

My contrast Dp has been very fortunate. From a middle class family, got family help with his house deposit and earns quite well. He works hard and is careful with money but I think is a little bit blind to the good luck and extra advantages he has had over many (including me) that's helped put him in this position.

He's been encouraging me to save a deposit for my own place which I can then rent out and is a potential source of income for retirement.

Whilst I agree this is a good plan in theory, in practise I think it would be a terrible idea.

I have max £200 a month of disposable income to put into savings for a deposit. If I did so, after 5 years I'd have a deposit for a very cheap place, but in those 5yrs I then could not do anything more than the basics. No holidays, no paying for any unexpected expenses, nothing. That's really not a sacrifice I'm prepared to make!

Also, I'd then have to worry about fees and the like which are thousands extra, and renting comes with huge additional expenses and risks like someone trashing your place, just general wear and tear that comes with being a landlord, tenants who refuse to leave and having to go through expensive court proceedings to get them out, etc. That's if a bank would even give me a mortgage in the first place as I'm in my 40's and don't earn much.

I don't disagree that investing in something for the future is a good idea but I don't think this is a viable option. Aibu and should seriously consider this, or am I right and DP is BU to think this is possible in my current circumstances?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
imansre · 26/03/2024 21:03

areyoutheregod · 26/03/2024 11:57

I don't understand why other posters are saying he is making himself more financially secure living with the OP? She doesn't pay half mortgage or a proper rental amount, so it looks like the OP benefits more financially by living in his house for free, and sharing bills and food- much smaller expenses. They've only been together 3 years and have no children. He doesn't owe her anything in terms of housing or bills. Unless he is expecting her to pay for expensive food items she normally wouldn't, then it seems like the OP benefits more from this situation at the moment. Nothing wrong with the arrangement if you ask me, but all the advice about savings and ISA's is worth following while you're in this position.

Lots of respect to you OP, not only for turning your life around but also for not being a grabby despite all that you have been through. Although strangers on the internet have been egging you on.

@areyoutheregod Because MN is biased towards women. One in this position is always advised to get rent to avoid cocklodging and protect everything she can. No mention of her making herself financially secure at his expense.

It's perfectly fine for a woman post-divorce to decide that she doesn't want a live-in partner. On here, her relationship isn't considered 'less' serious and she isn't expected to be responsible for the man's financial wellbeing.

But turn the tables and it's ooooh he should make provision. And as you said, OP is actually already better off living with this man, than on her own! Why should he take responsibility for her financial future?

I agree with the reasoning that a true partnership will warrant sharing, but it's only been 3 years. Nothing life changing. If it was 10 years, maybe.

QuizNight · 26/03/2024 13:20

I know OP is over 40 so can’t get one anyway, but I didn’t see anyone mention the risk of a LISA, which in my opinion would make the OP very unsuitable for one.

A LISA can only be used towards buying a home (OP has no plans to do this) or taken at pensionable age without losing money. Not just losing the bonus, but actually losing some of the money you originally paid in. As OP is not very financially stable and seems quite reliant on her partner, it is not unreasonable to think that she may need to access the LISA before she reaches her pensions if things don’t go exactly to plan. In that case, she would get less money back than she put in originally.

The regular saver someone mentioned above is the best idea. There is no risk, it’s decent interest rates and is perfect for people who can also save a relatively small amount but can do so regularly which the OP can.

areyoutheregod · 26/03/2024 11:57

I don't understand why other posters are saying he is making himself more financially secure living with the OP? She doesn't pay half mortgage or a proper rental amount, so it looks like the OP benefits more financially by living in his house for free, and sharing bills and food- much smaller expenses. They've only been together 3 years and have no children. He doesn't owe her anything in terms of housing or bills. Unless he is expecting her to pay for expensive food items she normally wouldn't, then it seems like the OP benefits more from this situation at the moment. Nothing wrong with the arrangement if you ask me, but all the advice about savings and ISA's is worth following while you're in this position.

RegretMisery · 26/03/2024 10:45

Buy to Let. Easy. If he leaves you for his secretary you will then have a place to go. I always encouraged my partner to save for his own place because I thought it would be good for him to own his own property.

WonderfulSkye · 26/03/2024 10:39

I have 2 properties that I rent out and it is not for the feint hearted! You need to be in a position to pay the mortgage if the tenant is late with their rent payment (this has happened to us multiple times)
We've also had to do a lot of repairs to properties where tenants haven't cared for them as you would hope for. I've also had to renovate where they've made changes without permission and we've had to put back to normal when they have left.
You also have to have funds to replace anything that breaks, and that needs to be fairly swift.
Insurance isn't cheap. It can all be EXTREMELY stressful!

I would highly recommend you don't go down that route unless you have far more money saved.

ViewP0intSelfie · 26/03/2024 03:33

If you buy a BTL
You will need spare money for
Deposit, mortgage
Self assessment tax every year
Agency fees, unless you manage it yourself
Repairs
If empty, you will need to pay utility bills & council tax
Gas & electric safety certificates
Emergency money
It is not an easy option !

If you work for an employer, it would be better to join their pension plan. Most employees also add some free money each month, us free life insurance.

Alternatively, you could put your savings into a tax free ISA. You can add up to a maximum of 20K per year. Some ISAs are currently paying g 5%

If you are under 40, you can save into a LISA & Government will add some free money

Saving into Nationwide regular saver will not pay 8% at the end of the year, it will pay half which is 4%.
So an ISA at 5% would be better & tax free

MeaRunte · 26/03/2024 03:07

Maybe you could have a chat and tell him you are planning to build up a cash buffer, so whilst you don't need him to subsidise you're going be living fairly leanly for a year or so?

So if he wants steak and alcohol and not thinking about the cost of food he can do his own thing. Or if he wants pricey holidays and going out then he needs to cover it all.

I do get what you're saying about wanting to live Ok/feeling life is short.

However, there's loads of fun stuff to do that's a lot cheaper.

Don't cripple yourself to live up to what he can afford.

No debts and NMW and no children means you can have a fine lifestyle, but if he's quite affluent you shouldn't be trying to keep up with him.

If he's been in good financial position always, he's probably used to doing all the things like takeaway coffee and eating out and taxis and buying things new (especially if his friends and colleagues can).

You may not be able to match this spending pattern.

Abitofalark · 26/03/2024 02:23

You've done so well, to survive every difficulty, get out of debt and be in a secure job. It's quite something. Yet it's concerning that you are paying towards bills to the point where you have only £200 a month left to save. That means that if you split you wouldn't even have enough to rent a place, while the man has the secure home and everything. It's such a disparity in your situations.

Does he even realise how little you have left over? Have you told him you couldn't save enough quickly enough for a deposit even if you wanted to buy to let? And you are right that it is not a good proposition for you. It's for people who are well set up and have some security, usually a house of their own and good income or spare cash. He wants you to be self sufficient - protecting his own assets - so I think you should see if he would be amenable to paying more towards the food / bills so that you can save to put yourself on a better footing for future self sufficiency.

A couple of things that I see as a priority and are straightforward:

Do you contribute to a pension with your employer? If not, you should enrol in that because the employer pays a generous contribution and it's providing for your future.

At the same time open a savings account with a bank or building society. Check out the savings interest rates on Money Saving Expert best buy tables.

Recently, Nationwide had a regular savings account paying 8%. You can pay in up to £200 a month but don't have to pay in every month. That high rate is limited to one year only. You'd need to check if it is still open for new applications and whether you need to be an existing customer with them to qualify.

Kickstartplease · 26/03/2024 00:07

My issue with this situation is you are supposed to be a partnership. He is making himself more financially secure by the fact that you living with him but you are not - even if you say you don't pay the mortgage you do really, as you pay towards the bills & the running of the house & make a payment to him even if you don't make the actual payment to the mortgage company.
Would he consider a restructure of finances - value the house, ring fence his capital then take out a new mortgage jointly but also make separate investments to pensions, ISA etc.
You could become a landlord but it isn't easy &/or isn't something to do without alot of research

MeaRunte · 25/03/2024 23:10

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 09:38

@InterestedinEfteling I pay something equivalent to a cheap rent in a house share, plus most (but not all) food. Like I said I don't earn much over MW plus I have my own bills and stuff to pay for.

I realise I did misspeak earlier though, I said max £200 to save whereas actually sometimes I do save more it's just that £200 is what I can comfortably save every month, including winter when my wage is lower. Last month I saved £300 and over the summer when hours go up I will probably save more.

What are the numbers? Agree with pps min wage full time should leave you with a lot more than £200-300 a month (you don't now have debt payments I assume).

How much are you spending in a month towards the food bill and this bills contribution

It sounds like your bills contribution is too high.

Are you paying for expensive food shops at his level? Or paying for social stuff just to keep up with him.

If you lived solo you could cut right down on outgoings, live off basic food.

skmissty · 25/03/2024 22:46

I literally wrote a post exactly like this 5 years ago. I had to dramatically increase my earnings and get myself in the position to contribute to a new mortgage. He was happy to move to a place though where it was a joint mortgage. I found it difficult as I have a kid though but I retrained and absolutely burst my gut.

I grew up pretty poor too and it was a difficult cycle to break but you can do it. Would he consider remortgaging or entering into a mortgage with you?

xxx

Notmyuser · 25/03/2024 22:39

ThisOldThang · 25/03/2024 22:19

That would be good, but might not be feasible.

There is no proven rental value on their current home, so I think lenders would simply look at income vs (outstanding mortgage + additional mortgage). Unless the OP's partner is a very high earner, I doubt they could borrow enough to buy another home. Switching from a 'normal' mortgage to a 'let to buy' would also result in higher rates and reduce affordability further.

Edited

Oh I know it might not be feasible, but it would certainly be worth exploring (over OP buying a property solo on a low income)

It also depends where they live. If they are somewhere that homes cost less (like where I am in Scotland) they might be able to pick up something half decent for under £100k. They are also allowing you to take longer terms on mortgages which helps with affordability (we took ours over 33 years) - it would depend on the value of the house they are living in, the outstanding mortgage amount, and their local market.

ThisOldThang · 25/03/2024 22:19

Notmyuser · 25/03/2024 21:45

A more sensible situation would be for them to buy another property as a joint asset and live in the new property, and rent out the property that her partner solely owns. Then, OP has the jointly owned property in event of his death (providing she can pay the mortgage alone) and he can leave the home he owned previously to whoever he likes.

That way, OP is gaining more financial security and isn’t purely funding her partners future.

That would be good, but might not be feasible.

There is no proven rental value on their current home, so I think lenders would simply look at income vs (outstanding mortgage + additional mortgage). Unless the OP's partner is a very high earner, I doubt they could borrow enough to buy another home. Switching from a 'normal' mortgage to a 'let to buy' would also result in higher rates and reduce affordability further.

KidsandKindness · 25/03/2024 22:07

ElizaMulvil · 25/03/2024 16:15

You need to give serious thought to your future.
Plan for yourself as there is no certainty that your partner will ever step up. Men are notoriously unreliable.

Save as if your life depended on it. It does.

1.Buy a 2 preferably 3 bed in a cheap area ie £100k or less after saving for 5 years or less if you are able ( £12k deposit) and Iive in it. Then you can rent out 2 rooms and earn £7,500 pa tax free ( rent a room scheme) This can help pay your mortgage and give you some security for when you retire. This does not stop you staying over at your partner's from time to time or him staying over at yours.

2.Search out a course / train on the job to boost your earnings as a matter of urgency. It is not an option to just tread water in case you get a job you don't like etc.

At the moment you are in a very vulnerable situation with no security of tenure in your partner's house and very low earnings. Your retirement or even your present could be a total disaster if you don't do something now.

Holidays / treats 'living life now' are not options you can afford. Burying your head in the sand is not a viable plan for the future.

I agree with this OP. Lots of people are probably talking about savings plans that you have no clue about if you've never had money to save before. So my advice on top of the quote above, would be open an account with a bank that has a 'Regular Saver Account', such as First Direct. You can save anything you want from £25 a month to £300 a month, and it doesn't have to be the same amount each month, unless you want it to be, so if an unexpected expense comes up, that you really can't avoid paying, as long as you can afford to keep paying the minimum £25 a month, the account will stay open. This sort of account pays the best possible interest at the moment of 7%. Most other 'Easy Access' accounts pay 5% or less. Please ignore anyone recommending a normal 'CASH ISA', as while you don't pay tax on the income, they do tend to pay less interest, and you are entitled to earn up to £1,000 in interest each year, on ANY savings account WITHOUT having to pay tax anyway, and you're very unlikely to fall into that bracket. So start simple, with a REGULAR saving account, and stash as much as you possibly can in that account, for as long as you possibly can.

OR

If you don't feel that you're likely to need the money you can afford to save, then do put it into a pension, as the younger you are, and the longer the money is in a pension, the more it will earn for your old age.

mdinbc · 25/03/2024 21:49

Congratulations for being in a situation now to think about the future, and saving towards it!

I would go to a financial advisor and start investing in some funds with a good growth rate, and then after 5 years see what position you are in.

I know it sounds a bit crazy, but are you in an area with beach huts? They can be a good investment, and you can rent them out in season. Short term rentals can be a job in themselves, with cleaning and meeting people to let them in.

Notmyuser · 25/03/2024 21:45

ThisOldThang · 25/03/2024 14:27

I don't think it's reasonable to expect your partner to just give you half his house and assets.

I'm not sure why so many people seem to think you should get to live rent free, when your partner has to pay a mortgage.

I very much doubt anybody would be suggesting a home owning woman should allow a low earning man to live rent free in her mortgaged home and also expose herself to losing half her assets due to marriage/divorce.

It's not clear what your educational background is or what you currently do for a living (tourism related?), but I think the people advising you to upskill and earn more money are correct.

Perhaps some IT courses would allow you to earn more money - e.g. Microsoft Office for basic office/business skills?

Edited

A more sensible situation would be for them to buy another property as a joint asset and live in the new property, and rent out the property that her partner solely owns. Then, OP has the jointly owned property in event of his death (providing she can pay the mortgage alone) and he can leave the home he owned previously to whoever he likes.

That way, OP is gaining more financial security and isn’t purely funding her partners future.

DarrylPhilbin · 25/03/2024 21:39

OP I think at the very least you should be splitting the bills and the food shop proportionally according to income. It's good that you're not contributing to the mortgage or upkeep of the house, but just make sure you're not then paying for that in other ways.

GinForBreakfast · 25/03/2024 21:31

Well you should definitely save for the future. A buy to let property is probably not a great idea for many reasons but saving is good.

What about better qualifications towards a better paying job in the future?

PurplGirl · 25/03/2024 21:30

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 21:03

Yes we are both early 40's. My debt is now paid off so I am in a position to start making more substantial savings.

It's not sensible NOT to plan for the future, I will keep looking into options for long term savings and investments and start putting more into my pension.

I don't mind that I have no financial interest in Dp's house. I put none of the effort in the get it in the first place and took none of the risk, nor do I pay towards any of the ongoing maintenance for it. I also don't expect to live for free which is why I'm happy to contribute in the form of bills and food. I do think it's a fair split.

Honestly if the situation was reversed I think I'd feel the same as Dp, it requires an immense amount of trust to share such a massive asset with another person. It's not that he doesn't care about me, he very much does and is a wonderful partner. He is just an extremely cautious person by nature. @PurplGirl I actually prefer to have separate finances.

My job may fluctuate a bit in terms of earnings over the year but it allows me a lot of flexibility which I really need at the moment, my mum isn't well so I take semi frequent trips across country to help care for her.

I am getting a promotion at work towards the end of the year so that will help too. There's lots that can change and probably will in years to come.

Why do you buy all of the food? You can still have separate finances, ie. Your wages going into your own account. And then a joint account for household expenditure that you each pay an amount into. It just seems daft you buying all the food, enabling him to build up equity in his home. Surely you should share the benefit in some way? I’d find it a bit patronising if my partner was telling me I should be putting money away for my future but not wishing to be fair with the current household finances. I don’t mean any harm, it is of course your relationship and you know him best. But since you came her for advice, I just felt I should really impress the importance of equity.

StarDolphins · 25/03/2024 21:29

At the very least in your situation, I would be saving as much as possible in an ISA or good rate savings account. I would feel very vulnerable & unsettled not having savings.

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 21:24

JLou08 · 25/03/2024 21:00

Well done on getting debt free.
You said you have lived in poverty, so if I was you I would be making sure I enjoyed having some disposable income. Do some of the things you enjoy, take nice holidays. There is no way I would be saving or investing all of my disposable income and buying a home does seem unrealistic for you.
I watched my grandads health deteriorate really quickly once he retired. My nan passed away in her early 60s from cancer. It puts thing in perspective for me as to how short life is. It needs to be enjoyed now. I do have a good workplace pension and have some savings for an emergency but I am definitely more focused on enjoying life now than trying to save for retirement.

Thank you for saying this. I hope it doesn't sound arrogant to say but I am really proud of how I've managed to turn my life around. I've escaped more than one abusive relationship and been through a lot of trauma that, at point time played absolute havoc with my mental health. 5 years ago I was on antidepressants and sleeping pills, I couldn't eat or sleep and lost 2 stone in 3 months.

I also don't think I realised just how traumatic living in poverty was until I was out of it. The humiliation of being in the supermarket and emptying every penny I had into the self checkout and still being a few pence short. Living in a place so dilapidated that the electric would cut out if I put the lights and kettle on at the same time. Not being able to afford heating and having to sleep in 2 sets of pjs and a dressing gown and waking up with bedsheets wet from condensation and ice on the inside of the windows. It was tough.

I'm also very aware of the fragility of life. Like I said, my mum isn't well and sadly I don't think she will make retirement age. It makes me want to live while I can but I'm also don't want to be so concerned with the present I forget about the future. It's a tough balancing act!

OP posts:
Spectre8 · 25/03/2024 21:16

You could always buy some NS&I bonds if you decide to save, ties your money up but u can get it all back when you need to, you might win some money though. Never know.

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 21:10

Yes we do @Autumn1990, it's not a 50/50 split.

So far there hasn't been much as far as white goods/furniture but Dp has paid for anything we've needed up to this point.

OP posts:
Autumn1990 · 25/03/2024 21:04

Do you pay towards the bills proportionally? Because you should if he earns more and the food bill should be split as well. Then you can save more
LISA is a good option.
There should also be a plan if he dies. So for every year you’ve been together you can stay in the house for two months for example and as you’d be looking to rent else where he should leave you enough for a deposit and first months rent. He could also leave you some furniture and white goods.
How do you split furniture and white goood purchases?

nohouseforme · 25/03/2024 21:03

Yes we are both early 40's. My debt is now paid off so I am in a position to start making more substantial savings.

It's not sensible NOT to plan for the future, I will keep looking into options for long term savings and investments and start putting more into my pension.

I don't mind that I have no financial interest in Dp's house. I put none of the effort in the get it in the first place and took none of the risk, nor do I pay towards any of the ongoing maintenance for it. I also don't expect to live for free which is why I'm happy to contribute in the form of bills and food. I do think it's a fair split.

Honestly if the situation was reversed I think I'd feel the same as Dp, it requires an immense amount of trust to share such a massive asset with another person. It's not that he doesn't care about me, he very much does and is a wonderful partner. He is just an extremely cautious person by nature. @PurplGirl I actually prefer to have separate finances.

My job may fluctuate a bit in terms of earnings over the year but it allows me a lot of flexibility which I really need at the moment, my mum isn't well so I take semi frequent trips across country to help care for her.

I am getting a promotion at work towards the end of the year so that will help too. There's lots that can change and probably will in years to come.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread