Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think this is inappropriate?

80 replies

Opinionsneededd · 25/03/2024 00:32

NC. Wanting some opinions on this.

Female friend of about 2 years. Has what I'd consider a habit of boundary pushing, and doing so in a clever, sometimes, manipulative way. Myself and partner have done a fair few favours for her over the time. We like to be nice and help where needed. I'm going to keep the following scenario as undetailed as possible, as it'll definitely be outing. I'm also going to leave out previous what I'd consider to be, 'form', as I'm really wanting opinions on this scenario, only.

My OH was approached by female friend to do a favour for her (one which either he, or I, could have done). She asked him to do this favour on the spot, there and then, and asked him to because she said that she had a minor, but painful injury which meant she could not. Think along the lines of a walk to the shops (not that - but very similar). He said yes, of course he'd do it for her as she's injured.

He took a few minutes to get changed, during which when he told me about it, I said 'Oh that's nice of you'. Then I thought on it for a second, and clarified - 'she's asked you to do this because she physically can't?'. He said, yes, that's what she's said. I had a gut feeling and told him, 'I'm willing to put money on this, that she's said this, yet is going to accompany you to do this task'. His response was 'How can she? (because of her injury) She can't'.

Female friend proceeded to accompany alongside my partner to do the task, as I'd suspected. My partner, surprised by this, told her, 'it's fine, I'll do it for you, it's no problem. You're injured, stay home'. She refused and absolutely insisted she accompany him. It meant that my partner doing this favour FOR her, seemed utterly pointless, as she was able to accompany him?

I just wondered what anyone would make of her, in particular, behaviour? My oh is very shy and not sociable, they only chat briefly in passing and aren't friends/don't hang out. He was rather annoyed and confused that he was asked to do a favour when it seems he didn't need to.

I'm sorry I can't give more specific details. Just wondered what you all would make of this friend.

OP posts:
pinkyredrose · 25/03/2024 09:59

Does she only ever contact you when she wants something?

PerfectTravelTote · 25/03/2024 09:56

She's lonely.

tara66 · 25/03/2024 09:39

She seems a bit strange but this is not the end of Western Civilisation as we know it - is it?

LAMPS1 · 25/03/2024 09:03

As a stand alone incident, which is the way you want to present it, It could well be inappropriate or it could easily be innocent.

I think you shouldn’t be afraid to ask her why she chose to go on the walk with him, after having told him that she couldn’t go herself.
Then you can judge her motive better. And call her out on it or adjust your own friendship with her in future, if necessary.

Interesting though, that your instinct was proved spot on and correct.
Don’t ever ignore your instinct.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 25/03/2024 08:17

Opinionsneededd · 25/03/2024 00:43

I believe the reason (or excuse in my book) was she was afraid she'd fall if she did it alone. Which is pretty much why he told her to stay home - he would do it for her, there was no point her being in pain (and his words to me, slowing him down!).

There was no reason for her to go - she just went alongside.

Appreciate your viewpoint, thank you.

Looking at this as an isolated incident:

being afraid of a fall but not wanting to be stuck in the house / alone is completely understandable.

if she wasn’t able to carry the bags (or transport them in some other manner) she was physically unable to get her own groceries.

but it would still be understandable for her to want to take this opportunity to get out of the house and walk (without having to worry about falling).

it doesn’t seem dishonest to me based on this incident alone, tbh.

but this seems to be a “bigger picture” issue. So you will have to decide whether this is a friendship worth keeping.

Beautiful3 · 25/03/2024 08:13

Perhaps you go instead of hubby, and see how she reacts.

Talipesmum · 25/03/2024 08:11

Saymyname28 · 25/03/2024 07:08

Is it usually things to do with your husband or your home?

MIL has a similar issue atm. Very dear friend who is csn be very lovely and is going through a break up.

Very much boundary crossing and taking advantage but all circling around "I want the life and man you have" kind of acts like DFIL is also her DH, that my DP is also her son and asks that level of favours. Overstays at their home and treats it as her own. Very much like she's trying to take MILs position in her home. In general she seems to view other people's things as also hers and I have had to be very firm myself holding boundaries like "this is yours, this is mine" "you're doing this important thing, but I'm doing this important thing and my thing is more important to me than yours"

This is insightful- could it be this sort of thing? Doesn’t necessarily feel like she’s coming on to your DH, but more like she feels she ought to have an allocated person to do what she considers to be “DH jobs” eg bug catching, accompanying her when she’s not feeling 100%, just having her back, supporting her etc. So not stuff she can’t do herself, just stuff she feels her imaginary DH would do for her.

Mnk711 · 25/03/2024 08:10

Without any further background to go on, I think you're overthinking this. She may have felt bad about him going, or wanted some company whilst going out and about which she's struggled to do. It could be deeply cynical or totally harmless, impossible to say without background. But either way if her behaviour around favours makes you uncomfortable just don't do them in future, make up excuses.

KarstRegion · 25/03/2024 08:01

KreedKafer · 25/03/2024 00:45

I wouldn’t think anything about a friend like this because I wouldn’t ever HAVE a friend like this.

You do know that friends are supposed to be people you actually like, right? If you think someone is a manipulative liar, don’t be their mate. It’s not complicated.

This. The single most mystifying discovery I’ve made via Mn is finding out that a significant number of people have friends they appear to dislike intensely.

Janehasamane · 25/03/2024 07:57

Blueink · 25/03/2024 07:40

I can get her point - depending on what it was, in your example of the shop, she may have wanted to get out despite physical challenges and do the bits she could eg choose shopping items than have to stay home.

If he was uncomfortable and wanted to go alone he could have said that.

I don’t see it as anything more in isolation.

Agree, I also thought she was able to go, simply not able to carry the bags, so needed someone to come with her. There is clearly a back story here where the op doesn’t like her, and feels she’s after her bloke. Which may or may not be true. In isolation though I don’t see an issue, I’ve a friend with a temp mobility issue and she’d do something like this. She could go with someone, but going alone would be difficult, as she’d not be able to do it carrying bags, plus a little scary for her in case she did fall or something.

determinedtomakethiswork · 25/03/2024 07:56

Does she like to pretend your boyfriend is her boyfriend

Hamburgerandchips · 25/03/2024 07:56

I had a manipulative'friend' who got worse as time went on, had to confront and dump her

Ponoka7 · 25/03/2024 07:49

I was wondering if this was my sister, until you said about her living with someone. In my sister's (68) case, she losing confidence as her fall rate increases and her health declines. She's also desperately lonely. The sad thing is that because she isn't honest and overstays her welcome, people are withdrawing from her. It's often more useful to take people than do it completely for them. Otherwise they stay stuck indoors. Is she on painkillers etc? That can change decision making and manipulation can be from fear/loneliness. Rather than just drop her, speak to her.

Blueink · 25/03/2024 07:40

I can get her point - depending on what it was, in your example of the shop, she may have wanted to get out despite physical challenges and do the bits she could eg choose shopping items than have to stay home.

If he was uncomfortable and wanted to go alone he could have said that.

I don’t see it as anything more in isolation.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 25/03/2024 07:40

It's difficult with the (understandable) scant info but it sounds like she is almost inserting herself into your relationship somehow.

Topsyturveymam · 25/03/2024 07:40

Hi,

id want to know more about the context with this. Is there a pattern? what do you think her motivations are?
If she’s not feeling confident on her legs it seems a reasonable request - maybe she was embarrassed to ask for accompanying support in that moment of the call …and felt less confident at that point. She may be anxious, lonely etc. it’s difficult to know without background.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 25/03/2024 07:37

I’d go with him every time she asks your DH for help. That’ll piss her off, Shes after your man, she asks you for favors occasionally to make it less obvious.

Janehasamane · 25/03/2024 07:36

I guess she was ok to go. But didn’t feel able to carry the bags back hence the request?

HoppingPavlova · 25/03/2024 07:32

I just don’t understand why he went. Surely, when she rocked up to go he would have said ‘oh, I was only going on the basis you couldn’t go, but as you are going then I don’t see the need for me to go’ and then take his shoes off.

Epidote · 25/03/2024 07:25

If both of your are feed up of doing her constant favours just stop them.
She is OTT no doubt of that.

No sure if she got interest in your husband or just approach him first because she know he is going to do it.

Saymyname28 · 25/03/2024 07:08

Is it usually things to do with your husband or your home?

MIL has a similar issue atm. Very dear friend who is csn be very lovely and is going through a break up.

Very much boundary crossing and taking advantage but all circling around "I want the life and man you have" kind of acts like DFIL is also her DH, that my DP is also her son and asks that level of favours. Overstays at their home and treats it as her own. Very much like she's trying to take MILs position in her home. In general she seems to view other people's things as also hers and I have had to be very firm myself holding boundaries like "this is yours, this is mine" "you're doing this important thing, but I'm doing this important thing and my thing is more important to me than yours"

Voucherwoes · 25/03/2024 06:55

In this case though, it’s your DH who needs to set the boundary. If it was “on the spot” this is something he needed to say no to - there’s not much you could have done about it really.

it sounds like it’s annoyed him - but this is his boundary to protect , not yours.

Polishedshoesalways · 25/03/2024 06:50

Just stop seeing her. She is not your friend.

vanillawaffle · 25/03/2024 06:33

KomodoOhno · 25/03/2024 04:08

I bet! I hadn't thought of that but it fits!

That was my guess too. In which case she's basically gone on a date with him!

ohdamnitjanet · 25/03/2024 06:29

I’d just have gone instead of my partner to witness a miraculous recovery.