Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found comparison of grief hard

216 replies

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:00

Mumsnet can be good at tough love/realistic expectations so I'm here for that. I've had a weird few weeks of fog so I need some directness.

My Nana and my friends brother were in the same hospital at the same time. We were able to help each other, meet for coffee and relate to one another. They passed away within one week of one another.

My Mum was a single Mum, my Nana took me each weekend, we spoke most days and she was 81. Im so grateful to have her until my 30s. My friends brother had a long illness over fifteen years. It's been dreadful for them and we've watched as friends through many years of heartbreak for them.

I rang my friend as soon as I heard the news. Sent a hamper of food. Called as often as she wished for me to call. I tried my best.

This is where I might be unreasonable.....
When Nana died my friend said it's not the same. Nana had a good life, was a good age and friends brothers death was 'tragic'. I never once tried to compare but I tried to relate via passing on funeral planning knowledge, what was helping me with sleeping, practical tips etc. I didn't expect my friend to call, send anything or help as she had her own grief but I found the dismissal of my bereavement hard. I hid it and am continuing support.

OP posts:
SemperIdem · 25/03/2024 00:50

Computercalendar · 25/03/2024 00:44

I'm sorry but she is right, it is not the same. My aunt lost her son, my cousin. It was sudden in his early thirties. I've never experienced grief like it. I've lost my grandmothers and other family members.

When someone very young dies, when a mother has lost her child the situation is not the same. You'll feel very different. You may not have been comparing the deaths, but she will automatically be thinking this. I know I did.

Now, I personally wouldn't have said this out loud to someone but whenever people talk about deaths of grandparents or parents I find it very upsetting and frustrating. They are supposed to die before you. My aunt lost her husband a couple of years after her son and her father also died when she was a little girl. I bet you know which one is more tragic.

When you were giving tips on how to deal with death she must've thought how can you be feeling as bad as me. She probably didn't think you'd ever understand how she's truly feeling.

Comparison grief is hard. You say your friend's brother had an illness for over 15 years. To me the death may have been expected. Whereas, my cousin was so sudden and unexpected. And so I would be comparing that. I don't think you can win. It's best not to say anything to your friend.

I know people who have had more significant losses than a cousin, who are more gracious and kind when faced with someone who has had a loss significant to them, than you.

Ella31 · 25/03/2024 00:49

I'm so sorry for your loss. I can relate. I lost my twin sons in November one stillborn and the other died 4 days later in NICU. I was so stricken with grief that when people tried to make comparisons I felt compelled to explain that my chiidren died, my beautiful babies. Taken from me so un naturally and cruelly.

I think your friend hurt you because she's feeling the loss of her brother who should grow old alongside her, and its hard to make sense of his death but that doesn't take away from your lovely granny and how much you miss her. I hope you can forgive her, it's grief talking here. You sound like a lovely friend.

ChimneySweepLiverpool · 25/03/2024 00:47

But YANBU about how she should not have said it but she probably meant no harm

ChimneySweepLiverpool · 25/03/2024 00:46

As PP has said, you cannot win. Little things probably feel big to you (I'm not saying this is little but it may be misplaced anguish). You may get more annoyed with her as time goes on so just step aside for now and pay attention to other supportive people. Sorry for your loss

Computercalendar · 25/03/2024 00:44

I'm sorry but she is right, it is not the same. My aunt lost her son, my cousin. It was sudden in his early thirties. I've never experienced grief like it. I've lost my grandmothers and other family members.

When someone very young dies, when a mother has lost her child the situation is not the same. You'll feel very different. You may not have been comparing the deaths, but she will automatically be thinking this. I know I did.

Now, I personally wouldn't have said this out loud to someone but whenever people talk about deaths of grandparents or parents I find it very upsetting and frustrating. They are supposed to die before you. My aunt lost her husband a couple of years after her son and her father also died when she was a little girl. I bet you know which one is more tragic.

When you were giving tips on how to deal with death she must've thought how can you be feeling as bad as me. She probably didn't think you'd ever understand how she's truly feeling.

Comparison grief is hard. You say your friend's brother had an illness for over 15 years. To me the death may have been expected. Whereas, my cousin was so sudden and unexpected. And so I would be comparing that. I don't think you can win. It's best not to say anything to your friend.

25smallstacey · 25/03/2024 00:20

Thank you @KreedKafer. I didn't speak about my grief to her but perhaps she was cutting me off before I did, as she was worried I'd compare. That would be absolutely fair enough of her

OP posts:
KreedKafer · 25/03/2024 00:14

If I was mourning my brother, who had just died in his 40s, I’d be fucking broken and probably wouldn’t really have the emotional capacity to deal with someone else’s grief on top of my own. I think if you wanted to talk about the death of your grandmother, you probably should have chosen to talk about it to someone who isn’t at the worst possible stage of grieving for a member of their immediate family.

I’m sorry you lost your grandmother and of course to you, it’s a devastating loss. But she didn’t die prematurely and she wasn’t a member of your own generation in the family and you can’t expect your friend to see the two situations as being the same. They aren’t the same. That doesn’t mean you’re any less sad about your loss than your friend is about hers, but I think your friend is right that the death of someone in their 80s is in the natural order of things, while the death of someone in their 40s feels like a cruel twist of fate.

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:45

Yeah, don't worry I won't be mentioning my feelings to her and over time I'm sure I will forget. Just hit a sensitive nerve. I would love her to ask after my family/me/send an acknowledgment but I know that is selfish (I'm writing that online because I didn't want to say it out-loud!)

OP posts:
Cottoncandyflavaflav · 24/03/2024 23:43

She has just lost her brother. I would cut her some slack. She has lost her brother in her 30s! Unimaginable. Some times people don't always say the best thing especially at times of trauma.

Rosestulips · 24/03/2024 23:42

There is no correct way to grieve and how to feel about your loss so i your friend is being unreasonable

although she may not be thinking clearly.

I lost my Gran aged 100 and my Dad aged 67 within 6 weeks of each other, my Gran was ready, my Dad wasn’t so it felt more acceptable for her.

I’m so sorry for your loss.

SemperIdem · 24/03/2024 23:40

I’m sorry for your loss.

Grief is hard for everyone and it isn’t fair to compare.

Your friends brothers death might be more tragic because he didn’t live to a good age, but his death is not more sad for you and your family than your Nana’s passing.

Some deaths are tragic, all deaths are sad.

neilyoungismyhero · 24/03/2024 23:37

I'm sorry for your loss OP. It sounds like she was a lovely person and you were so fortunate to have her.
I expect your friend feels your Nan's death was in the natural order of things, which it was, given her age.
Her young brother's death however was not. That was a tragedy- a young man's life lost and it sounds as if he was doomed from the beginning.
Concentrate on your grief and continue being there for each other in the future .

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:34

My friend knew Nana, just as I knew her brother. I won't ever be bringing this up with my friend about what she said, nor will I be punishing but today I felt a little burnt out so I took more me time. I just needed some clarity to know if it was normal that it hit a nerve

OP posts:
OffToBedforshire · 24/03/2024 23:33

Ignore me! I misread your post and thought you said 'friend' not 'friends'. Apologies - my comment doesn't stand anymore.

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:32

I didn't ban anyone from funeral, sorry I wrote that badly. I meant I told friends not to take time off work/travel etc as I didn't EXPECT anyone to come

OP posts:
OffToBedforshire · 24/03/2024 23:31

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:17

I have told friends to not come to funeral. Told them she was in her 80s, the world keeps spinning and i'll see everyone afterwards for a cup of tea/catch up. I know this is not huge but it hit a sore spot

Honestly? This is too harsh. You're grieving and so if your friend. You need to be kind to each other. She was insensitive but I would have let that go. To effectively ban her from the funeral is over the top.

Fortitudinal · 24/03/2024 23:31

Give her time but equally, don’t prostrate yourself at the alter of her grief. Maybe you need some space from her too, you need space for your own grief.

Sorry for your loss @25smallstacey 💐

pizzaHeart · 24/03/2024 23:30

I think she was very wrong to say this to you. Yes, in a way it’s true. Your Nana had a long life and you shared a lot of happy memories together. However you could say that her brother had long illness over fifteen years and how good that he wasn’t suffering anymore and her family was free of caring responsibilities. I bet you didn’t tell her this because it would be very cruel even if it might be true especially in terms of family’s caring responsibilities.
I agree with PPs that you should cut her some slack as she is grieving but maybe step down a bit from supporting her and focus on yourself. I don’t know if it’s worth mentioning this to her later but I wouldn’t do it now.

Im sorry for your loss. Your relationship with your Nana sounds amazing, you are so lucky that she was in your life .

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:29

Yes, I'm incredibly lucky. It's both of our first times dealing with immediate family grief in our 30s. I have lost great aunts/uncles/friends parents but this is the first time with someone close

OP posts:
ColleenDonaghy · 24/03/2024 23:27

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:21

This is my first time dealing with grief and I have known this would happen eventually (obviously!) but I know it's possible I'm overly sensitive at the moment and I can't even imagine what my friend is going through

I think that's really unusual OP, it's a privilege to get to your 30s without loss but it must make the first time harder. By the time I was in my 30s I'd lost all grandparents, a great aunt who was effectively a grandparent, my best friend and a couple of other more distant friends.

She's hurting, you're hurting. Give each other space and be generous, things will settle down.

NotTerfNorCis · 24/03/2024 23:24

All death is tragic. We're all human beings with our own thoughts and memories and narrative. Old age is cruel. Fading away and dying is cruel. It kind of makes a mockery of everything before. Everything you aimed for, everything you loved, everything you worried about, the whole purpose of you. All pointless, dwindling to nothing.

LightSpeeds · 24/03/2024 23:23

Surely, the main point here isn't about the tragedy of the situation/age of the person that has died.

It's about the FEELINGS of the people left behind.

Your nan has been a close and integral part of your whole life and, of course, you would be justifiably devastated by the loss of such an important person.

Malarandras · 24/03/2024 23:23

Soonenough · 24/03/2024 23:18

Sorry I sort of agree with her. The death of an elderly person I also wouldn't consider tragic. Sad , yes but not a tragedy just a normal part of the inevitability of life . But a young person, dying of an illness long before a normal age is a tragic event. That being said there was no need for her to say that. But please be kind to each other , grief and loss can make people do and say things out of character. I am sorry for your loss sounds like you lost a lovely person in your life .

Well my Grandad died in his 80s - he was a lovely man, caring and thoughtful and funny. A really joy. I was devastated.

My husband died in his 40s and he was an abusive prick.

No prizes for guessing whose death I consider more tragic.

Redcoatwonder · 24/03/2024 23:22

Drench · 24/03/2024 23:20

Death outside of the natural order is inherently traumatic. It is a traumatic grief. I vote for giving her space too. And those that say the friend is uncaring/unreasonable I don’t think have experienced traumatic grief.

I have. And it's still insensitive. It was an entirely unnecessary thing to say to the op, unprompted especially. The op seems to be trying to bend over backwards to be supportive and a good friend while also grieving. They weren't having a who has it worse competition, they could have said nothing

Op, I'd step back a bit from her and support at a distance and concentrate on processing your own grief x

FortofPud · 24/03/2024 23:22

She's not wrong that her brother's death involves tragedy that an elderly grandparents death doesn't. But that isn't what makes grief hard or the loved person missed. The feeling of loss and greif is entirely subjective and cannot be measured based on whether the death was at the 'right' sort of time. I suspect the more complicated circumstances surrounding the loss of her brother has left her struggling and I would try not to take it to heart. It was an insensitive comment though, you're not wrong to be left feeling upset by it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread