Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found comparison of grief hard

216 replies

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:00

Mumsnet can be good at tough love/realistic expectations so I'm here for that. I've had a weird few weeks of fog so I need some directness.

My Nana and my friends brother were in the same hospital at the same time. We were able to help each other, meet for coffee and relate to one another. They passed away within one week of one another.

My Mum was a single Mum, my Nana took me each weekend, we spoke most days and she was 81. Im so grateful to have her until my 30s. My friends brother had a long illness over fifteen years. It's been dreadful for them and we've watched as friends through many years of heartbreak for them.

I rang my friend as soon as I heard the news. Sent a hamper of food. Called as often as she wished for me to call. I tried my best.

This is where I might be unreasonable.....
When Nana died my friend said it's not the same. Nana had a good life, was a good age and friends brothers death was 'tragic'. I never once tried to compare but I tried to relate via passing on funeral planning knowledge, what was helping me with sleeping, practical tips etc. I didn't expect my friend to call, send anything or help as she had her own grief but I found the dismissal of my bereavement hard. I hid it and am continuing support.

OP posts:
glittereyelash · 25/03/2024 06:43

A work collegue and I lost our mothers in the same week. Technically we suffered the same loss. However my collegue is eight years older than my mam was and her mother lived 28 years longer than mine. Her loss, pain and suffering is obviously horrendous but in my selfish thoughts I am jealous she had so much more time with her mum. On the flip side my collegue thinks as she had her mother for so much longer and built so many memories that her pain is greater. Neither of us is wrong grief just makes you feel like nobody could be hurting as much as you are. I'm very sorry for your loss and you are a wonderful and supportive friend.

RoseMarigoldViolet · 25/03/2024 06:39

I don’t think that comparison is helpful when it comes to bereavement and grief.

Maybe take a slight step back from this friend while you get through the next little while.

Sorry for your loss. 🌷

ColleenDonaghy · 25/03/2024 06:38

In many ways the impact is greater the longer you had the person in your life.

Tbh I think writing this on a thread where posters have discussed the loss of their children is awful.

HalebiHabibti · 25/03/2024 06:36

People have a terrible tendency to say their situation is worse OP. My mother died, and my father sincerely informed me that it was worse for him than us because we'd lost a mother but he'd lost a wife 😳

I asked him to think back and consider whether the death of his own mother (my beloved grandmother who he had adored) had felt worse than the loss of his wife (who frankly he never seemed especially keen on). He went quiet after that.

I'm sorry for your loss xxxx

HalebiHabibti · 25/03/2024 06:32

computercalendar - "My aunt lost her husband a couple of years after her son and her father also died when she was a little girl. I bet you know which one is more tragic."

I'm sorry but I honestly don't know which of those events is meant to be worse, based on your 'They're older than you so meant to die before you' metric. Please could you clarify.

Isthismyforever · 25/03/2024 06:28

I'm so sorry for your loss.

There is no comparison. The death of any person is a huge loss no matter their age or the circumstances. You are entitled to feel as you do & fwiw I think your friend is being unfair.

I'm currently dealing with the loss of my beloved Mum. If one more person says to me 'she was a good age' or ' she had a great innings' I think i will bite their heads off. Grief is about the life that was lived & its impact on those left behind. In many ways the impact is greater the longer you had the person in your life. You have more years of experiences with them & more years of love for them & more years of memories with them.

Take care of yourself OP 💐

PoochiesPinkEars · 25/03/2024 06:18

Was she dismissive your grief or just saying that there is another quality of regret to get brothers untimely death which is not present in the death of your nana.
So your loss can be powerful and strong, a significant loss... But you aren't wrestling thoughts of the life she didn't get.

I think she was clumsy in her phrasing, but think she was trying to express something she's particularly struggling with.
Do you think your attention and solidarity, lovely support from a friend though it is, might be the wrong thing for her at the moment? Maybe the content was connected to the way you have both gone through a mutual experience, but she feels it's not entirely mutual. The way you pushed friends away from the funeral because life shouldn't stop for this ladies funeral does rather minimise the event.

kiwiane · 25/03/2024 06:18

It is hard for you that your friend is unable to support you especially as you’d been so close to your nana and it’s your first bereavement.
You will need to grieve without her support; it will lead to you reevaluating your friendship.
If you have other people to talk to them do so or consider counselling. You’re not wrong for wanting your nana to still be here and many people live beyond 81.
Love and grief are intertwined and it can be so difficult first time round but you will gradually recover so that you’re not so heartbroken.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 25/03/2024 06:03

SemperIdem · 25/03/2024 02:25

@Willyoujustbequiet

People experience grief on their own terms. I know people who have lost their children who are kinder than you.

So in order to show how kind you are you're being horrible and superior?

FloydWasACat · 25/03/2024 05:51

I lost my brother when he was 34, it was tragic, it was horrible but I will say I think your friend is out of order. You can't and shouldn't compare grief, it's not a competition. Hope you are ok.

Pepsimaxedout · 25/03/2024 05:23

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:21

This is my first time dealing with grief and I have known this would happen eventually (obviously!) but I know it's possible I'm overly sensitive at the moment and I can't even imagine what my friend is going through

I think you are right here. I don't think you can understand what your friend is going through. You are both in different places. I know you're trying to be helpful by offering support but I think your friend needs space and to be left alone right now.

My sister died at 37. I wanted the world to burn at the time and had a nervous breakdown because of it. I didn't want any help or support from anyone.

coodawoodashooda · 25/03/2024 05:06

Fortitudinal · 24/03/2024 23:31

Give her time but equally, don’t prostrate yourself at the alter of her grief. Maybe you need some space from her too, you need space for your own grief.

Sorry for your loss @25smallstacey 💐

So sorry too @2525smallstacey

Autienotnaughtie · 25/03/2024 05:03

If she's normally a good friend I'd assume due to her grief she's not thinking .

But yes it's not a nice thing to say.

GoonieGang · 25/03/2024 03:48

Grief is a very personal thing. It can’t be compared to anyone else’s.
She is hurting as are you. For her to say it isn’t the same is correct but also way off the mark.
Don’t engage or minimise your own grief as it can hinder your ability to recover.
Losing someone you love is so bloody hard, doesn’t matter how old you are 💐

Delawear · 25/03/2024 03:05

Your friend is being insensitive to make comparisons. I would let it go but withdraw for your own mental well-being if you need to. Sorry for your loss 💐

SemperIdem · 25/03/2024 02:25

@Willyoujustbequiet

People experience grief on their own terms. I know people who have lost their children who are kinder than you.

DanielGault · 25/03/2024 02:06

MamaWillYouBuyMeAWillYouBuyMeABanana · 24/03/2024 23:12

To be honest I snapped a quite a few people when my children died.

Anything that sounded like a comparison, or solidarity just pissed me off.

It was totally about me, and not them.

I'm so sorry about your lovely Nana, it's absolutely fine for you to take a step back and deal with your own grief too 💐

I'm so sorry for your losses 💐

Cornishpasty342 · 25/03/2024 02:02

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:00

Mumsnet can be good at tough love/realistic expectations so I'm here for that. I've had a weird few weeks of fog so I need some directness.

My Nana and my friends brother were in the same hospital at the same time. We were able to help each other, meet for coffee and relate to one another. They passed away within one week of one another.

My Mum was a single Mum, my Nana took me each weekend, we spoke most days and she was 81. Im so grateful to have her until my 30s. My friends brother had a long illness over fifteen years. It's been dreadful for them and we've watched as friends through many years of heartbreak for them.

I rang my friend as soon as I heard the news. Sent a hamper of food. Called as often as she wished for me to call. I tried my best.

This is where I might be unreasonable.....
When Nana died my friend said it's not the same. Nana had a good life, was a good age and friends brothers death was 'tragic'. I never once tried to compare but I tried to relate via passing on funeral planning knowledge, what was helping me with sleeping, practical tips etc. I didn't expect my friend to call, send anything or help as she had her own grief but I found the dismissal of my bereavement hard. I hid it and am continuing support.

I’m sorry for your loss OP. Grief is a very difficult emotion to navigate, especially when it is your first time experiencing it. I don’t think it was particularly kind or considerate of your friend to make that comment but I also completely understand her perspective. The loss of a young person is unlike any other type of grief you can imagine, unfortunately I say this through experience. She was perhaps acting preemptively and wrongly assumed you would compare - this is probably due to her emotions. Grief sucks.

Runnerinthenight · 25/03/2024 01:59

@25smallstacey there is no hierarchy of loss! Everyone experiences their own grief in their own way. Yes there are deaths that are more tragic than others. I never knew three out of my four grandparents because they had all died before I was born, my paternal granny from breast cancer in her 50s.

I was devastated when my maternal granny died aged 81 totally unexpectedly. I was 31. She was like a second mother as she had lived with us all my life. My dad also died suddenly at 81, days after my mum was diagnosed with cancer. She died an untimely death at just 62.

My parents had a baby son who died when he was 9 days old. I was just 7, so it didn't hit me like it might have had I been older. I never saw him.

Just don't compare your losses. There are deaths that are truly tragic and deaths that are really just sad. Take care, and mourn in the way you want to x

Willyoujustbequiet · 25/03/2024 01:48

Drench · 24/03/2024 23:14

I’d have been insulted if a friends grandma died and they felt the grief was as large and as black and as awful as loosing my only brother when he was 16 (I was 14). And as for support for sibling grief - it was non existent.

Having lost my only sibling tragically at a young age I agree.

It's a whole other level of pain OP. One that I hope you never experience. I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy.

I've lost grandparents and parents. Nothing comes close to the pain of my sibling. It's not the way of things and the grief is relentless.

I'm sorry for your loss but I understand where your friend is coming from.

echt · 25/03/2024 01:41

I'm so sorry for your loss @25smallstacey .

People come out with the weirdest stuff at times of bereavement. You've behaved in an exemplary manner to your friend and have been handed back an utterly pointless and hurtful comparison. Unfortunately, as I've found, the bereaved, in this case you, are so often called on to be more forbearing, the bigger person at a time when their feelings are so raw.

At the same time, stepping back a bit on the support might give you time and emotional space to look after yourself.

Many Flowers

JadeandGreen · 25/03/2024 01:39

In theory, your friend was probably right, BUT, you can't rationalise one persons grief against another's. I lost my Nana in 2011, she was in her 80's, and I still think about her everyday, occasionally have a cry. She was like a mother to me (and I have a mum), and I'll never stop missing her. It took me a long time to accept she was gone. I still dream about her. So, while I understand where your friend was coming from, it was insensitive of her to voice it.

I'm sorry for your loss, be kind to yourself Flowers

Frangipanyoul8r · 25/03/2024 01:38

Sorry for your loss. It sounds like neither of you are in the best place to support each other and need to give each other a bit of space. Grief can be isolating and difficult and not everyone gets it right. Try not to dwell too much now on what she’s said whilst she’s also grieving.

FiveShelties · 25/03/2024 01:19

I am so sorry for your loss OP.

Grief is a weird emotion, comes and goes and affects everyone differently. There are no comparisons to be made - it is just a tough and difficult time.

Lavender14 · 25/03/2024 01:03

Ah op I'm so sorry for your loss. You've both had an incredibly difficult time and let's be honest, there is no one right way to grieve and sometimes it can get a little ugly without people even meaning for it to.

I think your friend is being a bit tactless absolutely, but she's in her own pain and I think if anything, that this is really a sign that right now you can't be the support you want to be for her and you maybe need to take a step back and focus on yourself and your own healing for right now. I think it might be the best way to protect your friendship actually. You could tell her that you love her very dearly and you want to be there but you are just finding it too hard with your own loss at the moment to talk about things with her and you hope she understands that it's not a reflection on your friendship, just that you're both going through something heartbreaking at the same time and it's too much. You're allowed to prioritise your own needs here op and if she's not helpful to your journey with grief then it's perfectly OK to step back. It doesn't need to be forever, just until you've both had space to process a bit more.

It sounds like you've both really been going through it together so the instinct to reach out to her at this painful moment makes complete sense and I think it's lovely that you have. I think she has shown that she can't appropriately accept the support you're trying to give or to match it at least right now. I hope you can forgive her, she's speaking from real pain and she's not handling things as graciously as you are. It's not right, but its where she's at and it's no reflection at all on the love and relationship you've had with your nana.