Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found comparison of grief hard

216 replies

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:00

Mumsnet can be good at tough love/realistic expectations so I'm here for that. I've had a weird few weeks of fog so I need some directness.

My Nana and my friends brother were in the same hospital at the same time. We were able to help each other, meet for coffee and relate to one another. They passed away within one week of one another.

My Mum was a single Mum, my Nana took me each weekend, we spoke most days and she was 81. Im so grateful to have her until my 30s. My friends brother had a long illness over fifteen years. It's been dreadful for them and we've watched as friends through many years of heartbreak for them.

I rang my friend as soon as I heard the news. Sent a hamper of food. Called as often as she wished for me to call. I tried my best.

This is where I might be unreasonable.....
When Nana died my friend said it's not the same. Nana had a good life, was a good age and friends brothers death was 'tragic'. I never once tried to compare but I tried to relate via passing on funeral planning knowledge, what was helping me with sleeping, practical tips etc. I didn't expect my friend to call, send anything or help as she had her own grief but I found the dismissal of my bereavement hard. I hid it and am continuing support.

OP posts:
Throckmorton · 25/03/2024 09:05

ColleenDonaghy · 25/03/2024 08:57

IME their age makes a huge difference tbh.

My dad was my dad, I love him, I miss him. But he married, had children, saw us grow up, walked us down the aisle, cuddled his grandchildren, enjoyed a retirement with my mum. He wasn't that old, just shy of 70, they could have had longer together, but he lived a life.

My best friend didn't do any of that. So many of life's experiences that she never got to have because cancer came for her in her early 20s.

Losing someone at an older age can of course be devastating when it's someone we love, but I do think it's disingenuous and borderline insulting to say it's the same as losing someone we love at a young age.

You have missed my point. I am saying it is not the same for different people. I'm sorry for your losses. You have no idea who I have lost though, so please hold back on the "disingenuous" and "insulting"

pontipinemum · 25/03/2024 08:58

You didn't compare them, she did. You sound like you are both grieving but that it is different. She is in a lot of pain but should not have lashed out that her pain is worse than yours.

I have lost a sister young and tragically and I have lost older family members who I loved dearly. The incomprehension is not comparable. But the initial loss/ grieving/ missing that person is there regardless. I also found that after an illness was 'easier' to move on from compared to sudden death. And that a lot of comfort can be taken from knowing a person had a good life. It can be really hard to swallow with a younger person

ColleenDonaghy · 25/03/2024 08:58

Kelly51 · 25/03/2024 08:55

With grief comes a lot of anger, it is hard not to compare. My DH died at 55, around the same time a friends grandpa died at 95 and the endless weeping and wailing about how it wasn't fair and he could have got better did enrage me.
My DC lost their dad; they would have loved to have him another 40 years, some people are insensitive but you do need to weigh up everyone's grief and how their life is impacted by the loss.

Gosh. That would have been end of friendship for me, for sure. I'm so sorry.

RickyGervaislovesdogs · 25/03/2024 08:57

I’m sorry for your loss.🌷

Nobody has a monopoly on grief.

ColleenDonaghy · 25/03/2024 08:57

Throckmorton · 25/03/2024 08:53

There's a lot of people on here generalising from their own personal experience as though it was universal. Grief is personal and totally individual, and not the same for everyone experiencing it, nor everyone they experience it about. Also, people's relationships with relatives differ, so it's impossible to say that X-relationship is above/below Y-relationship. If you are really really close to someone and they die, it doesn't make a whole lot of difference what age they were - they are gone and you miss them. Anyone comparing grief really needs to take a step back and realise we all experience the world differently. OP - I am so sorry for your loss, and that your friend was so insensitive.

IME their age makes a huge difference tbh.

My dad was my dad, I love him, I miss him. But he married, had children, saw us grow up, walked us down the aisle, cuddled his grandchildren, enjoyed a retirement with my mum. He wasn't that old, just shy of 70, they could have had longer together, but he lived a life.

My best friend didn't do any of that. So many of life's experiences that she never got to have because cancer came for her in her early 20s.

Losing someone at an older age can of course be devastating when it's someone we love, but I do think it's disingenuous and borderline insulting to say it's the same as losing someone we love at a young age.

Kelly51 · 25/03/2024 08:55

With grief comes a lot of anger, it is hard not to compare. My DH died at 55, around the same time a friends grandpa died at 95 and the endless weeping and wailing about how it wasn't fair and he could have got better did enrage me.
My DC lost their dad; they would have loved to have him another 40 years, some people are insensitive but you do need to weigh up everyone's grief and how their life is impacted by the loss.

Throckmorton · 25/03/2024 08:53

There's a lot of people on here generalising from their own personal experience as though it was universal. Grief is personal and totally individual, and not the same for everyone experiencing it, nor everyone they experience it about. Also, people's relationships with relatives differ, so it's impossible to say that X-relationship is above/below Y-relationship. If you are really really close to someone and they die, it doesn't make a whole lot of difference what age they were - they are gone and you miss them. Anyone comparing grief really needs to take a step back and realise we all experience the world differently. OP - I am so sorry for your loss, and that your friend was so insensitive.

Abeona · 25/03/2024 08:52

You are both grieving, neither of you is at your best or can be expected to be completely reasonable or rational. Let this go.

Griefs aren't comparable. I can say from experience that when someone dies after a long life at least one can have some comfort in the knowldege they had a good innings. I think losing a sibling while you are both still young can bring up a lot of very difficult stuff because younger people aren't supposed to die. Siblings are supposed to grow old together. It was unfortunate your friend brought this up, but it's an indication of how devastated she's feeling.

One of the ways the people who are grieving deal with the pain is to get angry and lash out at those around them. It's easier than dealing with the loss and sadness. So cut your friend some slack and let this go.

Beautiful3 · 25/03/2024 08:50

You have both lost someone dear to you both. You both deserve to process your grief. I'd step back from the friends to deal with your own grief. Yes it is seen as more tragic when a younger person dies, before their natural time. As they didn't achieve their natural mile stones, e.g. getting a house, being married, having children etc. But age doesn't take away from their beloved role in family life. Focus on yourself right now and stop doing things for other people. It's fine that your friend isn't helping you, because she's grieving too. I'm sorry for your loss ❤️

mixedemotionsonmanythings · 25/03/2024 08:41

I'm sorry about the loss of your nana OP.

I thought about this comparison a lot after my mum died suddenly. She was 75 (not particularly old) but her death was so unexpected that it felt like a tornado had blown through our lives. Utterly overwhelming but at the same time, she had lived 7 decades, had seen her children and grandchildren and lived a great life. That doesn't diminish how we felt about losing her but it makes it a different experience to my friend who lost her dad when she was 10 and he was 40. He missed all the major milestones in her life and his death fractured her development in a very painful life-long way.

At the same time, comparisons help no one at all. You're both grieving and you should be allowed to go through that and feel what you feel. But because the impact of her loss is going to be much, much different, it's best for you to not speak to her about this (as much as your journeys might see similar at the moment).

Just keep supporting your friend from afar as best as you can. And at the same time don't be sad or ashamed to mourn the loss of your nana who was very special to you.

Shiningout · 25/03/2024 08:36

saraclara · 25/03/2024 08:21

Except you've just compared how you were in grief, with how OP 's friend is.

Your losses sound awful and clearly you did well if you managed not to say anything that risked others being hurt. We don't all manage to be rational in deep grief.

That's fair enough. What I was trying to say is although I would used to think that my losses hurt more, now I'm older in my 30s I've realised that's an issue with me and that grief isn't something that can be compared. I probably didn't word it very well.

Merrymouse · 25/03/2024 08:35

I don’t agree that there is no ‘hierarchy’ of grief.

When my mother died in her eighties, she had lived a full and complete life, and left so much behind in spirit that she will never truly leave me.

My fit healthy husband died less than a year later, from cancer, when my children were teenagers. We are still putting our lives back together, and our family will never be properly whole again. Some well meaning adults did try to compare my children’s loss to their loss of a parent in adulthood, and it felt like staring across a gulf of incomprehension.

In turn, I know that there are worse kinds of loss than ours. Sometimes there is no putting a life back together.

However what you can’t do is look at another person’s life and assume that you understand its shape and the place of everyone in it.

ObliviousCoalmine · 25/03/2024 08:29

My partner lost a sibling unexpectedly when they were both in their twenties. He's lost a grandparent recently after a fairly long period of decline and he has said himself it is incomparable in terms of immediate processing.

Nobody's grief is the same and she may be being unreasonable to have verbalised it, I think everyone gets a pass go in that situation and you've been great in that you've carried on supporting and have processed your upset away from her.

Your grief is huge, her upset and comparison doesn't diminish that.

MiddleParking · 25/03/2024 08:29

Namechange666 · 25/03/2024 08:16

You know I hate people who compare grief. It's not a bloody competition.

My nana recently died in January and took it harder than I thought I would. My friends were there for me.

My friend's pet died on Friday and she was overcome. She needed help and I was there.

I certainly didn't go, oh for goodness sake, it's a pet, it doesn't compare to my nana. Because for one, I know pets are like family. Mine are for certain.

We were both talking about grief and I said to her there is no wrong or right in how you're feeling. Just let yourself feel whatever you have to.

For what it's worth, my brother also died in a very tragic way. And I still wouldn't put my friend down or make comparisons.

I would tell her it's not a competition, that grief is still grief no matter how it comes about.

Sorry for your loss op.

Edited

You would tell your friend whose brother just died young after years of illness that “it’s not a competition”? Really? To what end, exactly?

DanielGault · 25/03/2024 08:28

Shiningout · 25/03/2024 08:14

Honestly I can think this sometimes in my head having lost both parents in their 40s when I was a teenager, however I would never ever say it to someone. Grief is personal and not comparative.

I'm so sorry to hear that 💐

MorningSunshineSparkles · 25/03/2024 08:25

I agree with your friend - she put it insensitively but she is correct. That does not in any way diminish the grief you feel though, I’m sorry for your loss Flowers

saraclara · 25/03/2024 08:21

Shiningout · 25/03/2024 08:14

Honestly I can think this sometimes in my head having lost both parents in their 40s when I was a teenager, however I would never ever say it to someone. Grief is personal and not comparative.

Except you've just compared how you were in grief, with how OP 's friend is.

Your losses sound awful and clearly you did well if you managed not to say anything that risked others being hurt. We don't all manage to be rational in deep grief.

Namechange666 · 25/03/2024 08:16

You know I hate people who compare grief. It's not a bloody competition.

My nana recently died in January and took it harder than I thought I would. My friends were there for me.

My friend's pet died on Friday and she was overcome. She needed help and I was there.

I certainly didn't go, oh for goodness sake, it's a pet, it doesn't compare to my nana. Because for one, I know pets are like family. Mine are for certain.

We were both talking about grief and I said to her there is no wrong or right in how you're feeling. Just let yourself feel whatever you have to.

For what it's worth, my brother also died in a very tragic way. And I still wouldn't put my friend down or make comparisons.

I would tell her it's not a competition, that grief is still grief no matter how it comes about.

Sorry for your loss op.

BusyMummy001 · 25/03/2024 08:15

I think the age of the person dying is irrelevant - it’s the quality of the life and the impact they and their passing has had on the bereaved person that matters. A person who dies in their forties who was selfish/abusive/absent, for example, can’t compare to an elderly person who was a defacto second parent who sacrificed a lot for you, was a daily part of your world for your whole life.

Both these individuals were deeply loved and, seemingly, wonderful and loving people. Yes it’s tragic when someone dies ‘before their time’ but a slow, death in one’s early 80’s can also seem ‘too soon’ when many of us have relatives living into their mid 90’s with no apparent physical or cognitive issues.

OP’s friend is experiencing a deep grief and this can make one insular and insensitive - but the posters here minimising the OPs loss should give their heads a wobble. OP, I would give your friend some space and focus on your own grief with friends who are better able to support you at this time.

Shiningout · 25/03/2024 08:14

Honestly I can think this sometimes in my head having lost both parents in their 40s when I was a teenager, however I would never ever say it to someone. Grief is personal and not comparative.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 25/03/2024 08:13

saraclara · 25/03/2024 08:07

give your friend some time and space too but I would have a conversation with her in the future about how insensitive she has been.

Good grief. Please don't do that, OP.

You are both grieving, and consequently in turn tactless and sensitive. Both are norma and understandable behaviours in grief, and this is not something that needs bringing up later on the hope of an apology.

Absolutely and I hope she doesn't come across this thread in her grief with all the bile and nastiness directed at her.

Scorchio84 · 25/03/2024 08:11

WhateverMate · 24/03/2024 23:10

I think when it comes to grief, you should both cut each other some slack.

It's hard for everyone but it's such an individual thing Flowers

Absolutely this

Riverlee · 25/03/2024 08:11

Probably didn’t mean to hurt you and people grieving say things they don’t mean to.

Humphhhh · 25/03/2024 08:10

SemperIdem · 25/03/2024 00:50

I know people who have had more significant losses than a cousin, who are more gracious and kind when faced with someone who has had a loss significant to them, than you.

That's a really unhelpful response. Anger and rage are a perfectly normal part of grief, particularly if it's traumatic or a younger person. Your friends almost certainly will feel similar but they're just better able to channel their emotions into a more productive outcome. Not everyone can do that, some will internalise it and that's not helpful either.

Whycantiwinmillionsandsquillions · 25/03/2024 08:09

Your ‘friend’ is completely out of order.
I remember a wise work college once saying, nobody can decide how death affects individuals. Absolutely nobody can say how upset an individual will be when someone dies.
Lets face it, sone people will not be upset when their spouse dies.
All relationships are unique.
I would pull back from her.
Sorry for your loss.

Swipe left for the next trending thread