Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found comparison of grief hard

216 replies

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:00

Mumsnet can be good at tough love/realistic expectations so I'm here for that. I've had a weird few weeks of fog so I need some directness.

My Nana and my friends brother were in the same hospital at the same time. We were able to help each other, meet for coffee and relate to one another. They passed away within one week of one another.

My Mum was a single Mum, my Nana took me each weekend, we spoke most days and she was 81. Im so grateful to have her until my 30s. My friends brother had a long illness over fifteen years. It's been dreadful for them and we've watched as friends through many years of heartbreak for them.

I rang my friend as soon as I heard the news. Sent a hamper of food. Called as often as she wished for me to call. I tried my best.

This is where I might be unreasonable.....
When Nana died my friend said it's not the same. Nana had a good life, was a good age and friends brothers death was 'tragic'. I never once tried to compare but I tried to relate via passing on funeral planning knowledge, what was helping me with sleeping, practical tips etc. I didn't expect my friend to call, send anything or help as she had her own grief but I found the dismissal of my bereavement hard. I hid it and am continuing support.

OP posts:
Dylanesque · 25/03/2024 12:19

OP, grief can only ever be personal. Yours is not your friends and vice versa. There is no timeline on the processing period either. I never married my partner, but we were together for 40 years. He died 4 years ago, in a hospice. I was so wrapped up in my own feelings, it took me weeks before I really understood that my daughter had also lost her father. I have never told her that it was a relief to let him go. The wasted man that pain and illness had turned him into was now a stranger to me. Some feelings only you alone can deal with.

Merrymouse · 25/03/2024 12:11

Namechange666 · 25/03/2024 11:47

But how do you know it wasn't as hard for her as it was for you?

I am very sorry you lost your husband and at such a young age.

But she might have just been trying to empathise back, showing she understood and related, through her mother's death?

It might have been the worst thing she's been through.

I mean this kindly but who are we to judge?

By expressing empathy towards each other and not taking slight, when none probably meant, then the word would be a kinder place.

I also had a very tragic death with my brother. To the point I had ptsd for years after it so I completely understand you. I'm just saying let's put ourselves in other people's shoes.

Kindness goes a long way.

To give them the benefit of the doubt, it’s likely that they were just shocked, didn’t know what to say and just blurted out what was on their minds.

It’s also possible that they were experiencing some additional trauma that the poster didn’t know about.

However, on the available facts, losing a mother at 92, (and having a supportive husband) is very obviously NOT comparable to losing a spouse at 47. People naturally try to empathise by making comparisons, but the reality is that if they completely miss the mark sometimes that can be more isolating.

I think it’s good to give grace to people trying to say something when they just don’t know what to say. However it’s just not true that all deaths are equally traumatic and tragic.

Missmariannedashwood · 25/03/2024 12:00

So sorry for your loss but your friend is right. For someone who is old and has lived a full life to die is not the same as a young person dying. It’s just not.

My mum died in her twenties, when I was two. I’m in my fifties now and have constantly missed a loving mother figure. My mother also missed out on being a mum to me and my sibling. When I see friends posting on Facebook about their world ending because their 80-odd year old mother has died, I want to tell them to get a grip. Yes of course it’s sad, it’s a loss and comparisons are difficult, but it’s not the same.

As upset as you are, you can celebrate your nana’s long life and all the lovely things that entailed. She has clearly left a precious legacy in her children and grandchildren. Your friend’s brother did not have chance to do that. It’s not the same.

DanielGault · 25/03/2024 11:59

25smallstacey · 25/03/2024 11:53

I was shocked when I logged back in and saw the responses. Thank you and also so many have shared their stories of grief, I'm sorry for all the losses 🌻

I'm quite a practical person. I was planning Nanas funeral and friend was planning brothers funeral so I thought it would be helpful to share tips from that. I can see now that could look like comparison. For me, planning the funeral was a helpful distraction but probably not for my friend.

I watched my Nana have a slow and painful last few days. She didn't seem to want to go and watching her in that pain is something I am probably still processing. My friend on the other hand is probably processing a long illness and life not able to be lived by brother.

God love you, you're going through it all right now. Mind yourself, it's a hard time x

Paintedhat · 25/03/2024 11:58

I don’t think your friend should have compared your grief in any way TO you, even if she was thinking it. That was something she needed to keep to herself, but grief does funny things to us and she obviously couldn’t keep it in.

My mum died when I was 6. My friends are starting to lose their parents now and it just doesn’t hit the same way. I guess it’s similar to the angle she is taking.

muggart · 25/03/2024 11:55

ginasevern · 25/03/2024 11:25

About 8 months after my 47 year old husband dropped down dead in front of me, I was shopping in a supermarket where I bumped into a friend I hadn't seen for a while. She was really pleased to see me and asked after my DH (she knew us both). I told her the news, but didn't make any sort of fuss because quite frankly I didn't even want to say the words "DH died". It didn't seem real and still doesn't.

She said something like "oh dear, sorry to hear that" and then promptly told me she knew just how I felt because her 92 year old mother had died recently in a nursing home. Her husband, who was standing right next to her, put his arm around her and told me how terribly hard it had been for his poor wife.

I didn't have a husband to put an arm around me because he had died in front of me at the age of 47 with blood coming out of his mouth. I didn't have a mother or father either because they died years ago (which this friend knew).

No-one should ever, ever compare grief but I do believe that whilst death is always sad, there is such a thing as tragic death and I can't believe the inability of some people to recognise the difference and speak accordingly.

Reading this I feel annoyed on your behalf. Those friends were tone deaf with a total lack of empathy. Bet you couldn't get out of there quick enough!

25smallstacey · 25/03/2024 11:53

I was shocked when I logged back in and saw the responses. Thank you and also so many have shared their stories of grief, I'm sorry for all the losses 🌻

I'm quite a practical person. I was planning Nanas funeral and friend was planning brothers funeral so I thought it would be helpful to share tips from that. I can see now that could look like comparison. For me, planning the funeral was a helpful distraction but probably not for my friend.

I watched my Nana have a slow and painful last few days. She didn't seem to want to go and watching her in that pain is something I am probably still processing. My friend on the other hand is probably processing a long illness and life not able to be lived by brother.

OP posts:
housethatbuiltme · 25/03/2024 11:52

aperolspritzbasicbitch · 25/03/2024 10:08

Grief can make you really jaded.

I lost one parent when I was 12, and the other when I was 32. Both in here one minute, gone the next situations.

I have never, ever, voiced these opinions out loud, but I do struggle to give too much of a shit when people who are my age lose their grandparent. I don't necessarily think I'm correct in those feelings, but they are there and as long as they are just in my head I don't feel the need to work through them.

On the other hand, I've also had people try and suggest that the out of the blue loss that I have experienced is in some way better than the loss of someone after an illness. It makes me want to punch them in the face, because it's not a competition. There are no winners here.

I would suggest giving her space to grieve, and allowing yourself the space to focus on your own grief.

On the other hand, I've also had people try and suggest that the out of the blue loss

I honestly don't think there is a winning way either way... It torture to sit and watch someone die (especially knowing its slow and they are scared/suffering) but I bet its devastating to your mental health not be with them when it happens or not have goodbyes either.

I said to my mam on monday 'see you on thursday' and wednesday she went into hospital and died a week later. I saw her and spent that week sat with her (although she was mostly unconscious she did wake a few times). I imagine it would suck the air away if I said 'see you on thursday' and then thursday had just never come at all and I had never saw her alive again.

I know people who where away when a parent died out of the blue and it must be a heart stopping phone call to come out of nowhere.

Lamelie · 25/03/2024 11:48

I think she was heading you off from comparisons. Cruel and crass though, but she’s not herself through grief and not emotionally available at the moment.

But what about you @25smallstacey ?
Who is looking after you? Who can you talk about your lovely Nana to? Flowers

Namechange666 · 25/03/2024 11:47

ginasevern · 25/03/2024 11:25

About 8 months after my 47 year old husband dropped down dead in front of me, I was shopping in a supermarket where I bumped into a friend I hadn't seen for a while. She was really pleased to see me and asked after my DH (she knew us both). I told her the news, but didn't make any sort of fuss because quite frankly I didn't even want to say the words "DH died". It didn't seem real and still doesn't.

She said something like "oh dear, sorry to hear that" and then promptly told me she knew just how I felt because her 92 year old mother had died recently in a nursing home. Her husband, who was standing right next to her, put his arm around her and told me how terribly hard it had been for his poor wife.

I didn't have a husband to put an arm around me because he had died in front of me at the age of 47 with blood coming out of his mouth. I didn't have a mother or father either because they died years ago (which this friend knew).

No-one should ever, ever compare grief but I do believe that whilst death is always sad, there is such a thing as tragic death and I can't believe the inability of some people to recognise the difference and speak accordingly.

But how do you know it wasn't as hard for her as it was for you?

I am very sorry you lost your husband and at such a young age.

But she might have just been trying to empathise back, showing she understood and related, through her mother's death?

It might have been the worst thing she's been through.

I mean this kindly but who are we to judge?

By expressing empathy towards each other and not taking slight, when none probably meant, then the word would be a kinder place.

I also had a very tragic death with my brother. To the point I had ptsd for years after it so I completely understand you. I'm just saying let's put ourselves in other people's shoes.

Kindness goes a long way.

Namechange666 · 25/03/2024 11:43

It doesn't matter the length someone has lived.

When you love someone, you love someone.

Whether it was for a long time or an hour.

Grief is grief and is incomparable.

My aunty's baby died when he was a few hours old.

My mum (her sister) lost her son in his early 20s to an awful tragedy.

They both lost their sons. It is better to have known someone or always wondered?

Neither is worse than the other. They share their grief and they share their love.

artfuldodgerjack · 25/03/2024 11:43

Sorry for your loss.

I can see the side for your friend though. My mum died young, she was early 60's, not even retired. I was mid thirties when she died. A relative lost her mother a couple of months after, she was mid nineties and had had a good life but was suffering from dementia. My relative kept trying to compare their loss to mine, I must admit that I snapped after a while. It was horrible to keep hearing about all her "suffering" at her loss and how I must be feeling the same way. In the end I blew up and said actually, no, her loss couldn't compare to mine, her mother was suffering and in the end in pain, but she'd seen her grandchildren grow and have their own kids, she had lived her life. My mum died suddenly, unexpectedly and my child has missed out on having a grandparent there.

Death is hard at any age, but when someone dies before their time, so to speak, it's much harder.

Namechange666 · 25/03/2024 11:40

@MiddleParking

The friend wasn't exactly kind to op in the moment was she?

I have empathy for all people however, I will never quite understand people who believe that their situation is worse than yours and will tell you so type.

It isn't a competition and the friend started the comparison first.

A true friend would have grieved together.

When I lost my brother when I was in late teens and him early 20s, I would never have spoken to my friend like that. To try and suggest their grief is not as much as mine. How dare would I or should I? It wouldn't be my place to.

housethatbuiltme · 25/03/2024 11:31

I'm sorry for your loss. You are allowed to feel your own grief and sadness but you cannot try and put it on your friend who had an entirely different experiance.

Unfortunately what they said is true, your nana had her whole life.

My mam also died young, in a horrible way after a really hard life (medically) that robbed her of most basic life enjoyment. She was basically bed bound from her early 20s and had severe illness after illness including several cancers and long chemo journeys, dozens and dozens of serious surgeries from the preventative treatments and organ failure.

Honestly I was left speechless in the aftermath of the amount of people who thought they where 'consolling' with me about it but turning it round to how 'they know the struggle' because they lost a relative who all died much older, in normal ways after living long healthy lives.

I don't doubt for a second they felt grief and loss when losing a loved one (of course you do) but it is in no way comparable to the tragic trauma of losing someone young after watching the struggle fight and fade away.

Its really a gut punch when people compare them. I've lost all my grandparents, I lived with my nana while my mam was in hospital through out my youth (so we where close) and my nana died of dementia (which sucks too, another case of watching someone fade away) but she was old and had had a long good life it was simply just not the same 'tragedy'.

ginasevern · 25/03/2024 11:25

About 8 months after my 47 year old husband dropped down dead in front of me, I was shopping in a supermarket where I bumped into a friend I hadn't seen for a while. She was really pleased to see me and asked after my DH (she knew us both). I told her the news, but didn't make any sort of fuss because quite frankly I didn't even want to say the words "DH died". It didn't seem real and still doesn't.

She said something like "oh dear, sorry to hear that" and then promptly told me she knew just how I felt because her 92 year old mother had died recently in a nursing home. Her husband, who was standing right next to her, put his arm around her and told me how terribly hard it had been for his poor wife.

I didn't have a husband to put an arm around me because he had died in front of me at the age of 47 with blood coming out of his mouth. I didn't have a mother or father either because they died years ago (which this friend knew).

No-one should ever, ever compare grief but I do believe that whilst death is always sad, there is such a thing as tragic death and I can't believe the inability of some people to recognise the difference and speak accordingly.

FrancisSeaton · 25/03/2024 11:10

WaltzingWaters · 25/03/2024 11:01

It was an awful thing for her to say to you. Death always comes with sadness for those close to the person, and of course it’s better knowing they’ve lived a long (and hopefully happy/fulfilled) life, rather than dying young.

My mum died from an unexpected (came on quick) illness at 56. Before she could be a nana to my kids or see me get married. Around the same time an older friends mum died at age 89. She used to compare the two. Whilst I did think to myself (whilst not minimising her grief in the slightest) it’s not the same thing, I would never have actually voiced that opinion. And I never thought that my grief was more than hers at losing our mums, just that I also grieved so many events and experiences that I should have been able to experience with her and I wished I had been able to grieve her death when she was 89 rather than 56.

It was very rude of her to say that (especially with no prompting of the subject). I wouldn’t necessarily bring it up as she’s obviously going through a very traumatic time, but yes, it was wrong of her to say.

Edited

She didn't say it unprompted though the op appeared to be giving her advice on how to deal with an entirely different type of grief

WaltzingWaters · 25/03/2024 11:01

It was an awful thing for her to say to you. Death always comes with sadness for those close to the person, and of course it’s better knowing they’ve lived a long (and hopefully happy/fulfilled) life, rather than dying young.

My mum died from an unexpected (came on quick) illness at 56. Before she could be a nana to my kids or see me get married. Around the same time an older friends mum died at age 89. She used to compare the two. Whilst I did think to myself (whilst not minimising her grief in the slightest) it’s not the same thing, I would never have actually voiced that opinion. And I never thought that my grief was more than hers at losing our mums, just that I also grieved so many events and experiences that I should have been able to experience with her and I wished I had been able to grieve her death when she was 89 rather than 56.

It was very rude of her to say that (especially with no prompting of the subject). I wouldn’t necessarily bring it up as she’s obviously going through a very traumatic time, but yes, it was wrong of her to say.

concernedchild · 25/03/2024 10:58

When my nan died my friend told me to get over it because she was old.

I no longer speak to her.

Workhardcryharder · 25/03/2024 10:57

Honestly I think it’s the “I tried to relate…” bit.

It’s like when my husband was trying to sympathise with me last month when we had a bug. He threw up once and felt nauseous. I threw up around 20 times and couldn’t move for 24 hours. He kept saying “aw I’m sorry, it’s been rough hasn’t it, looking after the kids and being sick” and all I kept thinking was WE ARENT IN THE SAME SITUATION HERE. It (unjustifiably) felt like he was downplaying the absolute horrendous time I had. Obviously I know this is not the same as your situation.

Maybe by trying to relate and giving here “grieving tips”, she feels like you are making it about you, and acting as if you are in the same boat. I can imagine it would be frustrating for someone who feels life has wronged her brother.

saraclara · 25/03/2024 10:43

The other day I bumped into someone I hadn't seen for years. I discovered that her husband had suddenly dropped dead in front of her and the children while they were on holiday abroad.

It made me really grateful for the 18 months I had with my husband after his terminal diagnosis. Those times were of course hard. But to my mind, much, preferable (from a grieving perspective) to losing someone so suddenly and traumatically.

So yes, when I compare other people's losses to mine (in my head) it's usually because I'm grateful to have been able to say goodbye.

DanielGault · 25/03/2024 10:43

Grief is so deeply personal. When my father died, I had been NC for a few years. He never got to see my daughter, his first grandchild. I hated him. But when he died, there was grief, for the relationship that might have been. It's all very difficult to navigate, and we should all allow ourselves to go through it it. There's no 'map'. It just sucks really, but it's an inevitable part of life.

Pelham678 · 25/03/2024 10:37

Merrymouse · 25/03/2024 09:22

The difference that age makes is the grief for lives that should have been lived had that person not died. It’s being flung into an alternate universe.

Absolutely. It's changed our family in a way that wouldn't have happened with an older person dying.

AntonFeckoff · 25/03/2024 10:10

I've also had people try and suggest that the out of the blue loss that I have experienced is in some way better than the loss of someone after an illness.

JFC. I'm really sorry.

aperolspritzbasicbitch · 25/03/2024 10:08

Grief can make you really jaded.

I lost one parent when I was 12, and the other when I was 32. Both in here one minute, gone the next situations.

I have never, ever, voiced these opinions out loud, but I do struggle to give too much of a shit when people who are my age lose their grandparent. I don't necessarily think I'm correct in those feelings, but they are there and as long as they are just in my head I don't feel the need to work through them.

On the other hand, I've also had people try and suggest that the out of the blue loss that I have experienced is in some way better than the loss of someone after an illness. It makes me want to punch them in the face, because it's not a competition. There are no winners here.

I would suggest giving her space to grieve, and allowing yourself the space to focus on your own grief.

Gettingonmygoat · 25/03/2024 09:54

I am so sorry you have lost your Nana. Grief is awful and affects everyone differently. You need to be gentle with yourself and concentrate on you. When we are wrapped up i our own grief it is often hard to feel for anyone else, i think your friend didn't mean to be unkind but she was a little clumsy when trying to say that it tragic when someone has short life full of illness.

Swipe left for the next trending thread