Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found comparison of grief hard

216 replies

25smallstacey · 24/03/2024 23:00

Mumsnet can be good at tough love/realistic expectations so I'm here for that. I've had a weird few weeks of fog so I need some directness.

My Nana and my friends brother were in the same hospital at the same time. We were able to help each other, meet for coffee and relate to one another. They passed away within one week of one another.

My Mum was a single Mum, my Nana took me each weekend, we spoke most days and she was 81. Im so grateful to have her until my 30s. My friends brother had a long illness over fifteen years. It's been dreadful for them and we've watched as friends through many years of heartbreak for them.

I rang my friend as soon as I heard the news. Sent a hamper of food. Called as often as she wished for me to call. I tried my best.

This is where I might be unreasonable.....
When Nana died my friend said it's not the same. Nana had a good life, was a good age and friends brothers death was 'tragic'. I never once tried to compare but I tried to relate via passing on funeral planning knowledge, what was helping me with sleeping, practical tips etc. I didn't expect my friend to call, send anything or help as she had her own grief but I found the dismissal of my bereavement hard. I hid it and am continuing support.

OP posts:
MissYouForever · 25/03/2024 17:20

Having lost my brother to suicide 7 year ago in my 20s, I actually used to get an incredible feeling of rage at anyone else's grief when it was for an elderly relative. Inwardly of course, i never once would show it, but i would have to walk away or blank any conversation about it.

Obviously grief is grief, and very personal. But I fully understand where your friend is coming from.

I still have that feeling where i almost want to roll my eyes when i hear about grief of other's elderly relatives. Old people are supposed to die. Im clearly still deeply hurt from my loss and i think i always will be. Life is incredibly unfair. But this is my problem, and again i would refrain from showing these feelings to others as i understand grief is personal.

When my parents die (which will be in the next decade) it will be such a tiny drop in the ocean compared to what ive already been through.

Again, i honestly do not want to minimise anyone's grief. Just maybe trying to show you feelings from the other side . I know the thoughts are horrible but i still can't stop them. And especially after the loss has just happened and is raw, i can imagine your friend is definitely going to need distance and zero comparisons

ZoeCM · 25/03/2024 17:16

OP, you sound like a nice person and a good friend. I'm sorry for the loss of your grandmother. Death is sad at any age; even the death of a 100-year-old will be sad for their family.

However, I would cut your friend some slack. She must be going through hell at the moment. The death of a grandparent is extremely upsetting, but it's on a completely different level to a sibling dying in their thirties, as you acknowledge in your OP. I know you didn't outright make the comparison, but I wonder if she felt you were implying that you two were going through the same thing when you started talking about ways of coping with grief, and she overreacted.

You said in your last post that you both knew you were likely to lose your loved ones in the next few years, which is a bit crass (although I'm sure you didn't mean it that way) - a young person always has a chance (however remote) of overcoming their addiction and living for several more decades, whereas an 81-year-old has already passed the life expectancy of a woman in the UK. Plus, you can take comfort in the fact that your nana lived a long life, and that you were lucky to be part of a small percentage of people who still have a living grandparent in their thirties - your friend can't say that about her brother. Maybe she picked up on your attitude of "we both knew this was going to happen" and felt offended.

For all the MN likes to say "there's no grief top trumps"... there kind of is. If someone was diagnosed with cancer, and their friend said, "I know what you're going through, I've got toothache, I know it's not as bad as cancer but it's still horrendous, we need to support each other" - realistically, the first person would get quite annoyed. Toothache can be fucking agony, and people have the right to complain about it, but it would be completely inappropriate to put in the same league as cancer. People accept this when it comes to physical pain; the same should apply to grief.

I remember a thread where a woman had had a stillborn baby, and her colleague said she knew how she felt, because she had "gender disappointment" over her son and felt as though she was grieving for a daughter! I think I would ended up in prison for GBH if someone had said that to me after a stillbirth.

Justkeeepswimming · 25/03/2024 16:11

@25smallstacey

Please get all the help you can from Cruse bereavement care, reach out to your relatives who knew Nana, prioritise self care and take time off work if needed and I hope you are able to come to terms.

But don’t go looking to your friend for support, making out like there is commonality - there isn’t any.

She will be like a worn out rag depleted of energy after an experience like that, awful and she is right - tragic - for her and the whole family that he couldn’t be saved.

Justkeeepswimming · 25/03/2024 16:07

25smallstacey · 25/03/2024 14:36

Thank you. Both my friend and I knew we would be likely to lose these people in the next few years. My Nana was elderly, she wasn't going to be here forever and my friends brother had been very destructive with addiction, they had known for years this would happen one day. I, perhaps wrongly, expected we could help each other through this due to the coincidence of timing but she has almost entirely shut off from me so I need to give her as much space as she needs

@25smallstacey

No wonder she has shut herself off…. So her brother has an addiction problem, be that drugs or alcohol, for 15 years and she has tried to help him all that time to prevent him from dying…. And no doubt suffered enormously through it all. All her efforts have failed and he is dead.

Meanwhile you have a rosy relationship with Nana, who after a short illness and a few days pain dies at a good age.

Then you come along to your friend needling her with advice on how to sleep and deal with her grief because you think you’re both in the same boat….

You are not even in the same ocean on the same planet.

mitogoshi · 25/03/2024 15:21

Comparing grief isn't something that is possible but I do have sympathy for your friend, loosing a younger person just is very different.

I organise funerals, I rarely know them so it isn't a personal bereavement but even then young person funerals are the ones that I find incredibly tough, they haven't had a life yet.

I think it's best to not compare and in this situation acknowledge that your grandmother though much loved and sorely missed, had had a great life.

saraclara · 25/03/2024 15:15

I, perhaps wrongly, expected we could help each other through this due to the coincidence of timing

It's the timing that means you can't help each other @25smallstacey . You're each too vulnerable at the moment. And if I'm entirely honest, the fact that you felt able to support her, but she isn't able to support you, kind of illustrates that your loss is different from hers.

WingingItSince1973 · 25/03/2024 14:50

I lost my brother when he was 28 in terrible circumstances. I would say my grief was different to my parents. I still expect to see my brother after 18 years now. I don't think anyone should dictate grief to each other. I never would have said to someone who lost an elderly relative that my grief was worse. My dad is in his 70s and I don't even want to think about life without him just because he's old and lived a life. Everyone is different. She may even have forgotten what she said to you. It's a strange and individual place to be. Your Nanna was special to you as I hope I am to my dgs ❤️

JackieWeaverhasendedthemeeting · 25/03/2024 14:47

I'm really sorry for your loss and as other posters have said, grief is such an individual thing it feels churlish for either of you to compare it to the other's.
I lost my sister very suddenly six months ago and the hardest part of the grief for me is that I never got to say goodbye and I can't remember the last time I told her I loved her.
Your grief is just as valid as your friend's grief but you are both grieving different things: your friend is grieving the future she will never have with her brother; you are grieving the loss of a very very important figure in your life growing up, who is no longer there to support and offer advice.
I am sure her words were not meant to hurt and please have an un-Mumsnetty hug from me.
🤗💐☕

25smallstacey · 25/03/2024 14:36

Thank you. Both my friend and I knew we would be likely to lose these people in the next few years. My Nana was elderly, she wasn't going to be here forever and my friends brother had been very destructive with addiction, they had known for years this would happen one day. I, perhaps wrongly, expected we could help each other through this due to the coincidence of timing but she has almost entirely shut off from me so I need to give her as much space as she needs

OP posts:
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 25/03/2024 14:28

LightSpeeds · 24/03/2024 23:23

Surely, the main point here isn't about the tragedy of the situation/age of the person that has died.

It's about the FEELINGS of the people left behind.

Your nan has been a close and integral part of your whole life and, of course, you would be justifiably devastated by the loss of such an important person.

This ^

You were very close to your gran and she meant a lot to you and will leave a larger hole in your life than for eg, my gran who I met once as a child and was frankly a bit scared of.

Of course, it is tragic when a younger person dies, but it doesn't nullify the loss of someone who was particularly close to you, even if they were older. With younger people we mourn the loss of potential, the things they didn't get to do. With older people its the things they have done, and been that sometimes make the loss harder.

I don't think its fair to think in terms of awarding particular instances grief points, which imply that one death has more impact than another.

It's the impact that a death has had on you. I think your friend was insensitive and that you have been very understanding and kind towards her.

Sorry for your loss, your gran sounds like she was a wonderful influence on your life. That is important, whatever her age. Please take care of yourself Flowers

AntonFeckoff · 25/03/2024 13:46

fliptopbin · 25/03/2024 13:12

The thing is, having veen in your friend's situation, a friend's grandmother died around the same time as my sister died, and this was totally irrational, and I have never felt anything like this since, but I had to walk away when she even alluded to her grandmother (not comparing grief, just bringing up her name)before I punched her.
I can't explain the hatred I felt (and 3 months later still do). It wasn't just her, I fucking hate people who say good morning to me, I only speak to my OH and my son now.
Just to give another perspective-I know this isn't normal and I am withdrawing from people till this phase of grief is over, but sometimes you just get this horrible urge to hurt others as much as you are hurting (then fucking hate yourself for it).

That sounds so difficult, but relatable.

I sometimes get the rage (inside) when people talk to me about their dads, casually talking about their dad coming over to help them with this and that, going out for birthday meals, celebrating milestones, helping out if they’re ill etc etc. They say it like it’s nothing. And I guess it isn’t, to them. But I would give anything for that. I would give anything for my dad to see me become an adult and guide me through early adulthood. I want to scream at them, do you know how lucky you are. When my dad died, I felt orphaned because my mum was never a mum to me. She couldn’t even manage basic things like looking after me when I was unwell or taking me to the doctor. I lost the only person that really cared about me.

When people talk about how they’re stressed about stuff I want to tell them to get a fucking grip, that they’ve got so much family support around them, family who will bend over backwards for them at the drop of a hat. To imagine how hard it is to go through all that shit on your own.

I don’t, of course, or I’d have no friends. But it’s incredibly isolating.

ColleenDonaghy · 25/03/2024 13:23

Well said @ginasevern . I'm very sorry for your loss, you speak very eloquently about it. Flowers

Merrymouse · 25/03/2024 13:21

ChaoticBag · 25/03/2024 13:04

@PandaRose123
Totally agree. I lost a parent at 15 and the other at 51. The pain it caused me was comparable - by then my remaining parent had been my only parent for 30 odd years, it was awful when they died. I'm not going to compete in grief Olympics because I know that losing a child or a young relative is something else altogether.

But please let's not minimise the death of a parent - why do we need to do that?

The woman that a pp was describing who was losing her elderly mother - she may not have losing been her DP but her mother could well have been her best friend/closest companion/housemate for the last 60 years - how can you not comprehend her pain even a little?

Heck my best friend at uni, whose parents were divorcing, actually said to me that at least my dad was dead and not suffering like hers was - now that was heartless. I knew what she meant but god that was cold.

Have some compassion people. Allow others to have their feelings - they're not in competition with you.

I think the point was not that she didn’t understand her pain, but that it wasn’t comparable, and they were suggesting that it was.

Also, in this instance, they were literally displaying what she had lost.

It’s not as though she said ‘oh do shut up, your grief is nothing’. She stood and listened for 40 minutes.

I do agree that the OP shouldn’t feel she needs to minimise her funeral plans or experience her grief purely in the shade of her friends loss.

Apollo365 · 25/03/2024 13:19

Just to add another voice here, it’s not you, it’s her. Grief makes us crazy and unreasonable.
My dad passed young and the rage was unreal. Looking back now I realise people were trying to help me but I just couldn’t see it.
Im so sorry to hear about your Nana, it’s sad and awful whatever her age. You can be there for your friend but not at the risk of your own MH x x

saraclara · 25/03/2024 13:18

Oh @fliptopbin that sounds so difficult. Three months is a long time to be hurting so much and feeling so angry.
Please, if you're not already, get some bereavement counselling, primarily for your own sake of course, but also for the sake of your husband and child, who must be affected by your grief to a degree.

Lifedonttalktomeaboutlife · 25/03/2024 13:18

I’m sorry for the loss of your Nana.

When you lose a sibling young you also have to grieve the life you should have had with them in it. It’s unspeakably hard. Maybe cut her some slack.

25smallstacey · 25/03/2024 13:16

@fliptopbin That sounds incredibly tough for you and I hope it passes as quickly as it can

OP posts:
fliptopbin · 25/03/2024 13:12

The thing is, having veen in your friend's situation, a friend's grandmother died around the same time as my sister died, and this was totally irrational, and I have never felt anything like this since, but I had to walk away when she even alluded to her grandmother (not comparing grief, just bringing up her name)before I punched her.
I can't explain the hatred I felt (and 3 months later still do). It wasn't just her, I fucking hate people who say good morning to me, I only speak to my OH and my son now.
Just to give another perspective-I know this isn't normal and I am withdrawing from people till this phase of grief is over, but sometimes you just get this horrible urge to hurt others as much as you are hurting (then fucking hate yourself for it).

Everythinggreen · 25/03/2024 13:04

Grief isn't exclusive and people are allowed to grieve.
For context when my dad died of cancer we were all heartbroken even though we knew it was coming, and he was well into his 70s.

When my sisters died, the grief was different and I feel harder, much harder for me and my brother because we were all so close and more like best friends and they are the only other people who would be able to "get" the same family stuff, nostalgia, jokes etc beyond my parents. I don't think I'll ever fully recover from losing them both, and close together.

That said, my grief is nothing compared to my poor mum who died a little inside with each of their deaths and my sisters poor children. They all kept checking in with me for months after but it was them I was more concerned about and I expressed my grief away from them because I chose to be the strong one for them and chose my DP and friends to let mine out to.

So it's not comparable and it's good your not claiming otherwise, but you are allowed experience your own grief.

ChaoticBag · 25/03/2024 13:04

PandaRose123 · 25/03/2024 09:06

I find the minimisation of grief for older people on this thread very difficult to read. I lost my mother in her seventies when I was in my thirties. The circumstances were horrific and I actually ended up receiving treatment for PTSD. I wasn’t able to share this with anyone around me, as I was getting the whole “she had a long and happy life” and “just remember the good times” treatment. Irrespective of the person’s age, they are gone, never to be seen again and that can be utterly devastating. Not to mention the impact of the circumstances of the death. Everyone who experiences a loss has a right to their feelings and each person is an individual who brings their own prior experiences to the grief process and experiences the death and its surrounding circumstances in their own way. I’m just glad that my own experience has meant that I will always have compassion for other people’s grief, for whomever it may be.

Of course, when someone dies young, it adds a very different dimension to the grief, which is important to recognise. We can validate the unfairness, tragedy and everything else that that loss is without voicing what we feel another person’s loss isn’t. There has been an unimaginable loss of a young person in my own family. I would never compare it to my own loss, but I still have the right to my grief and all the feelings that come with it.

OP, I’m so sorry for the loss of your lovely nana. It sounds like she was a huge figure in your life, so her loss is very important. I can totally understand why your friend’s comment was upsetting to you. I would also find that hurtful. At this point, she’s very deep in her grief and likely to be feeling angry, extremely sensitive and may be lashing out, which may help you to find some grace for her if it’s an isolated incident. At the same time, your own bereavement and feelings are no less valid, so don’t be afraid to make space for your own grief and even take a bit of a step back for the sake of your own well-being if that’s what you need. You can also always contact the Cruse Bereavement charity if you feel you’re struggling with your loss and wanted to speak someone who will offer you compassionate and non-judgemental support. I’ve found them very helpful. All the very best x

@PandaRose123
Totally agree. I lost a parent at 15 and the other at 51. The pain it caused me was comparable - by then my remaining parent had been my only parent for 30 odd years, it was awful when they died. I'm not going to compete in grief Olympics because I know that losing a child or a young relative is something else altogether.

But please let's not minimise the death of a parent - why do we need to do that?

The woman that a pp was describing who was losing her elderly mother - she may not have losing been her DP but her mother could well have been her best friend/closest companion/housemate for the last 60 years - how can you not comprehend her pain even a little?

Heck my best friend at uni, whose parents were divorcing, actually said to me that at least my dad was dead and not suffering like hers was - now that was heartless. I knew what she meant but god that was cold.

Have some compassion people. Allow others to have their feelings - they're not in competition with you.

MikeRafone · 25/03/2024 12:53

DespairAgony · 25/03/2024 12:47

Your friend is right, sorry OP.

That’s your opinion, it doesn’t mean your opinion is correct

DespairAgony · 25/03/2024 12:47

Your friend is right, sorry OP.

WaltzingWaters · 25/03/2024 12:38

FrancisSeaton · 25/03/2024 11:10

She didn't say it unprompted though the op appeared to be giving her advice on how to deal with an entirely different type of grief

From what I’ve understood the OP said nothing about trying to tell her how to grieve, merely that she passed on what was helping her both personally and with funeral planning. She never told her how to grieve or compared her situation to her friends.

“I wasn't speaking about Nana beforehand. It was that she said it’s so tragic to lose her brother in his 40s, not like what I have been through”. Sounds as though her friend diminished OP’s grief altogether and brought this up unprompted.

ginasevern · 25/03/2024 12:38

Namechange666 · 25/03/2024 11:47

But how do you know it wasn't as hard for her as it was for you?

I am very sorry you lost your husband and at such a young age.

But she might have just been trying to empathise back, showing she understood and related, through her mother's death?

It might have been the worst thing she's been through.

I mean this kindly but who are we to judge?

By expressing empathy towards each other and not taking slight, when none probably meant, then the word would be a kinder place.

I also had a very tragic death with my brother. To the point I had ptsd for years after it so I completely understand you. I'm just saying let's put ourselves in other people's shoes.

Kindness goes a long way.

I'm so sorry to hear about your brother, I truly am.

I am not an unkind person but, in all honesty, I don't think her mother's death impacted her life in the same way. Firstly, my friend was nearly 70 when her 92 year old mother died. That's not a bad innings in anyone's book.

Secondly, she still had her fit, healthy and loving husband whom she'd been married to for 50 years to comfort and support her. The very person whose shoulder you most want to weep on was there with her, to help make funeral arrangements, to sort out the paperwork and, most importantly, to offer love.

She didn't have to come home to a silent empty house, knowing it would remain that way. She didn't go to bed on the night of her mother's death alone gazing in numbed disbelief at the cold, vacant space beside her or get up the following morning again to silence, with no-one to hold and comfort her.

Nor did she didn't have to worry herself sick about finances because she'd lost her husband and therefore part of a joint income. She didn't have to rethink and restructure her entire life either.

There is also the vast difference in ages. Her mother had lived 45 years longer than my husband. She was over twice his age when she died. She also died peacefully in a nursing home while my husband died quite suddenly, out of the blue of a massive brain haemorraghe which caused blood to poor from his mouth and eyes as he stood before me. He hadn't been ill at all, there were no underlying health issues and it was just a normal, average Friday morning.

You can't empathise back when the goal posts are so wildly different. You really, really can't.

Besides, I personally would not consider her approach remotely empathetic. She said 5 token words about my bereavement and then proceeded to talk for 40 odd minutes about her mother whilst her husband hugged her lovingly and I stood there alone. I have absolutely no qualms about her sharing her loss and I was sorry to hear about her Mum, but I wouldn't dream of being so insensitive and self absorbed in those circumstances.

forgivingfiggy · 25/03/2024 12:31

Loss is loss. It's hard and shitty. There are secondary factors to this loss that offer comfort or increase the devastation.

She shouldn't need to compare. People who are grieving even the same person will experience it differently. Sorry she lashed out. Her brothers death is compounded by his age, but it doesn't mean you aren't suffering because your nan was old, just the compounding factors are different.