Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fawning/obsessing over people you don't know

142 replies

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 12:41

Why? Just why? I don't need to name names as it's bloody everywhere!

Of course it's sad when ANYONE is unwell or experiences something stressful, but why do strangers become so occupied with it?

Even as a teen I never understood the fan base that pop bands etc would get, sure I enjoyed the music, but would always look on with bemusement at the obsession. When I see people screaming, crying at people, they don't know, I just do not get it.

Especially when these same people are able to access resources the majority of us could only dream of! At the same time, millions of people suffer/die because of the same issue, but are simply born to the 'wrong' family. So to then adorn the people who have everything with more adoration/concern - is beyond crazy to me.

So, am I being a grumpy git? (Likely) or do you also think for god sakes get a grip!

OP posts:
Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 15:45

@SomethingUniqueThisTime

Yes!!! This with bells on it!

OP posts:
SomethingUniqueThisTime · 24/03/2024 15:43

Alargeoneplease89 · 24/03/2024 15:11

Honestly what a twatty thing to say. Do you despise everyone with more cash then you?

Do you not read stories in the paper about sad situations and feel sad? Or is it just people less successful than yourself?

Do you read a story about a child who has died and not feel sad? Or when you realise they have some privilege, you think fuck em?

I think its sad you can't have empathy

I think your post helps illustrate the problem. Empathy is an interesting emotion, and it’s an important part of human socialisation. However we often need to engage our brains beyond our immediate initial emotional response.

A young child dies in unfortunate circumstances, most of us feel sad and can relate to the suffering. For some reading about it, talking to others is all they do.
Wouldn’t it be better to use this empathy further? Think about what could be done to prevent such awful things happening, maybe what can I do to help young mothers locally in similar circumstances, could I volunteer at the food bank, write to my MP, vote differently in future?

Maybe rather than posting memes about a famous person with cancer, I could do some fund-raising for my local hospice, or donate some money to Cruse.

My main worry about all this public out-pouring of concern is people are focusing their energies in something that makes them feel better rather than doing something that makes a difference. I know people can do both, but do many really? Wouldn’t the money spent on all of the flowers left outside Buckingham Palace been better spent on a charity Diana supported or a campaign on seat-belt wearing.

Dontcallmescarface · 24/03/2024 15:26

YANBU, it's all very odd.

shenandoahvalley · 24/03/2024 15:26

I think fawning over people like QE2 and the PoW is a safe and socially acceptable way for emotionally constipated people to express their inner fantasies/thoughts/feelings about pretty much anything. It’s just a release of pent up emotion. For someone like QE2, there was a momentousness which amplified those feelings, and for Catherine it’s that she’s a “young mum”. But at the bottom of it all is people who don’t know what their feelings are, or who know but can’t or won’t express them, using a safe way to express fervent and deep emotion. It’s very childish.

SallyWD · 24/03/2024 15:25

I used to scream and sob over my favourite band as a teenager but I put that down to hormones and experiencing my first sexual feelings. It was all overwhelming.
Now I'm in my 40s I don't idolise anyone. I still admire certain people. Music has a profound effect on me so I admire certain musicians. Same goes for writers. I'm essentially admiring their talent. I also admire one or two politicians who I see as a force for good.
However, I see these people as flawed human beings like the rest of us. I don't fawn over them or idolise them.
It always amuses me when I read these threads on Mumsnet "Who's the nicest celebrity you've ever met?". The level of fawning!! People describe perfectly normal interactions between them and a celebrity in such a fawning way. Yes OK, the celebrity sounds like a pleasant person but why shouldn't they be? They're only human. It's like" I met Cat Deeley and she was soooo lovely. Genuinely interested in my life. Asked me how I was doing. Such a warm and kind person". The thing is if you had the same conversation with a cashier at the supermarket or with your dustman you wouldn't be raving about them in the same way. I think we all need to start appreciating the wonderful non-famous people we know and stop putting celebrities on a pedestal.

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 15:22

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 24/03/2024 15:16

@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe

“It's almost as if the worshipper believes that their devotion will cause the starry-dust to rub off on them.”

That is a very interesting point, it articulates something which is very apparent on the RF threads at the moment. Many of the regular posters are being very self-congratulatory about not being sucked into the weird conspiracy theories or ‘not being vile’. They want to feel they are in the ‘cool-girls’ gang.

Personally I find it all terribly concerning and posted about the existence of a 3-way toxic relationship between the RF, the media, and the followers of the RF. They RF needs to be adored by the public in order to exist, the media needs the clicks generated by its stories, and parts of the general public lap it all up and feed the relationship. It’s not how a healthy society should function.

Edited

Very well put. This is the toxicity of why it feels sinister. I do see it as unhealthy as it allows the rot to fester and continue.

OP posts:
ABitBright · 24/03/2024 15:22

I agree with you OP. I find the general adoration of the royal family bizarre and illogical. I sorry anyone has cancer and am as sorry that Charles and Kate have it as much as anyone else who I don't know has it.
I can't get my head around why people seem so obsessed with the royal family. Other than the fact they happen to be born into the family or married into it they seem very unremarkable.

I wish they would all abdicate. What particularly annoys me is when senior politicians and other people in the public eye fawn over them. They are not elected and don't do anything that's impressive. I bet the fact that they are hoping to receive some sort of honour has something to do with it.
The grief some people experienced when the Queen died was extreme. I can see she was a better leader than the current lot but even so. She was a stranger to 99.99% of the UK.

ShagratandGorbag4ever · 24/03/2024 15:21

RosesAndHellebores · 24/03/2024 13:05

You're a grumpy git. And if you want to bitch about the Princess of Wales do so openly rather than dressing it up on a thread about something else.

Poor woman, wife, mother and hopefully future Queen, is all I wish to say and I wish her a speedy and successful recovery.

What would an unsuccessful recovery look like, exactly?

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 15:17

Alargeoneplease89 · 24/03/2024 15:11

Honestly what a twatty thing to say. Do you despise everyone with more cash then you?

Do you not read stories in the paper about sad situations and feel sad? Or is it just people less successful than yourself?

Do you read a story about a child who has died and not feel sad? Or when you realise they have some privilege, you think fuck em?

I think its sad you can't have empathy

And fwiw - someone's cash flow is another topic altogether. This is about the over-the-top fawning.

OP posts:
Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 15:16

Alargeoneplease89 · 24/03/2024 15:11

Honestly what a twatty thing to say. Do you despise everyone with more cash then you?

Do you not read stories in the paper about sad situations and feel sad? Or is it just people less successful than yourself?

Do you read a story about a child who has died and not feel sad? Or when you realise they have some privilege, you think fuck em?

I think its sad you can't have empathy

I think this was aimed at me? I have empathy, of course I do. Of course it's sad. But it goes beyond this. That's what I find befuddling and that's what this thread is about.

OP posts:
SomethingUniqueThisTime · 24/03/2024 15:16

@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe

“It's almost as if the worshipper believes that their devotion will cause the starry-dust to rub off on them.”

That is a very interesting point, it articulates something which is very apparent on the RF threads at the moment. Many of the regular posters are being very self-congratulatory about not being sucked into the weird conspiracy theories or ‘not being vile’. They want to feel they are in the ‘cool-girls’ gang.

Personally I find it all terribly concerning and posted about the existence of a 3-way toxic relationship between the RF, the media, and the followers of the RF. They RF needs to be adored by the public in order to exist, the media needs the clicks generated by its stories, and parts of the general public lap it all up and feed the relationship. It’s not how a healthy society should function.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/03/2024 15:15

Yes, Westfacing, I think that was the turning point for mass hysteria to become the norm and society is worse for that.

Westfacing · 24/03/2024 15:14

YANBU - things have reached fever pitch over the past few days. Reminds me of the mass hysteria when Diana died.

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 15:12

Brawcolli · 24/03/2024 15:01

It’s very odd, aye. Of course it’s sad, but the people posting as if they know her personally makes me cringe. People idolising the royals in general is pathetic in my opinion, ridiculous that we still have them in what’s meant to be modern times!

👍🏻

OP posts:
Alargeoneplease89 · 24/03/2024 15:11

Honestly what a twatty thing to say. Do you despise everyone with more cash then you?

Do you not read stories in the paper about sad situations and feel sad? Or is it just people less successful than yourself?

Do you read a story about a child who has died and not feel sad? Or when you realise they have some privilege, you think fuck em?

I think its sad you can't have empathy

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 15:11

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/03/2024 14:59

It wasn't the clapping as such, most on our street did this. It was the censuring of people who didn't do it, didn't conform with the government dictat to clap. To be honest, seeing Boris do it should have been enough to make people stop and think, you would have thought?

It is the demand of social media that dictates what fawners will do next. I'm sorry for the term, I can't think of another one and 'over-invested members of the public' just isn't very snappy. The fawners take over and in the fact of anybody saying anything that isn't the party line, will declare that they are uncaring. It's become an epidemic, an insidious one that is doing serious damage.

Diana died in 97, social media hadn't really taken off by then, not to this degree, imagine the scene had that happened in current day?

I think that people like heroes, particularly ones that don't do anything very noteworthy. Social media says we must notice them and we do. Some take it too far and slavishly worship them as if they are some sort of idol. That's taking it beyond what is tolerable for those of us who don't. Hero worship is frightening to witness in current time as it's so intense. It's almost as if the worshipper believes that their devotion will cause the starry-dust to rub off on them.

There are no idols but there are everyday 'heroes' out there and nobody gets to know about them, but they quietly do their thing, new ones every day. Unheralded except by their families and friends. Good luck and thanks to all of them.

Oh yes - I remember the jump made when I refused to clap. That I didn't care. I felt quite the opposite. I was outraged at the lack of care and follow through. It was sinister and scary how everyone just went along because it 'looked' like the right thing to do. Even the woman who started it regretted it!

OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/03/2024 15:11

Totally get that, Spaghetti, I often have a bit of a cry when I hear about things that people have gone through/are going through. Either it's something I've gone through myself or somebody else I know has or I just imagine how awful it must be. I think that's normal empathy.

I felt very sad at Jade Goody's death, she was young, with young boys and had been so exploited. She did quite a lot to raise the profile of getting checked for ovarian cancer. If I'd been in charge of the honour's list, she would have got one for that - her horrendous circumstances gave rise to tremendous benefit to women.

I did not buy Marmite in her name, nor line the streets with it, nor stand in the road screeching at her coffin. I did make a donation to cancer research 'for her'.

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 15:08

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 24/03/2024 14:57

Perhaps it’s a type of escapism from the boredom of everyday life.

It’s also a bit voyeuristic, like watching a horror film or thriller. People can spend a couple of hours immersing themselves in a wealth of emotions and then move on without a backward glance to something else, thankful it’s not happening to them. Cathartic if you like.

Akin to watching a movie? Interesting viewpoint.

OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/03/2024 15:06

It's not 'superior' to just not behave like an incoherent nut about people you don't know, HeddaGarbled. Can we not just have a difference of opinion without you leaping to 'superior' as an insult?

It's not 'good taste' to not scream and cry about celebrities, it is normal behaviour, or should be.

SpaghettiWithaYeti · 24/03/2024 15:06

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/03/2024 14:16

I think it has a huge amount to do with the need to be involved in public adoration wherever it exists. Captain Tom is a good example. The mawkishness on here when he did his garden walks and was recognised for it. The charity run by his daughter was then rightly questioned in terms of financial probity leading up until current day.

The statue of Capt Tom was sold to a private collector as neither the council nor the foundation set up in his name, wanted anything to do with it.

Where are those posters now? Issue gone and forgotten but it was SUCH and important one when there was public outpouring and lauding to be done.

It's that kind of thing that leaves me cold. Fickle, stupid behaviour which just has to be played out in public.

Yes. It's often just performative empathy.

But I guess it might also be a way of playing through emotions that had been suppressed at the time.

I remember crying when Kate's hyperemesis was in the papers. And being shocked as I have never been one to get emotional about strangers. Then I realised that the tears were really for me and all the trauma I had been through with own own hyperemesis (physical trauma, isolation, incorrect medical care, judgement from people who thought it was the same as normal morning sickness). So maybe sometimes it's also a way for people to project their own pain and fears.

HeddaGarbled · 24/03/2024 15:04

I’m just reading a review (Caledonian Road by Andrew O’Hagan if anyone’s interested) in the Times and the reviewer describes the liberal protagonist thus: “blind to his prejudices and imagines his good taste automatically makes him a morally superior person”.

MrsDoylesDoily · 24/03/2024 15:02

I blame the internet.

It's not enough for some people to simply wish someone well.

Since they've got a keyboard to hide behind, they can pretend they're full on 'sobbing', 'howling', 'in floods' etc.

Bonus points for trying to out-sob and out-howl other posters.

Brawcolli · 24/03/2024 15:01

It’s very odd, aye. Of course it’s sad, but the people posting as if they know her personally makes me cringe. People idolising the royals in general is pathetic in my opinion, ridiculous that we still have them in what’s meant to be modern times!

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/03/2024 15:01

I think you have a good point there, SomethingUniqueThisTime, it's as if there's a great crashing of stardom... and then nothing. The public has moved on to the next great thing to worship.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/03/2024 14:59

It wasn't the clapping as such, most on our street did this. It was the censuring of people who didn't do it, didn't conform with the government dictat to clap. To be honest, seeing Boris do it should have been enough to make people stop and think, you would have thought?

It is the demand of social media that dictates what fawners will do next. I'm sorry for the term, I can't think of another one and 'over-invested members of the public' just isn't very snappy. The fawners take over and in the fact of anybody saying anything that isn't the party line, will declare that they are uncaring. It's become an epidemic, an insidious one that is doing serious damage.

Diana died in 97, social media hadn't really taken off by then, not to this degree, imagine the scene had that happened in current day?

I think that people like heroes, particularly ones that don't do anything very noteworthy. Social media says we must notice them and we do. Some take it too far and slavishly worship them as if they are some sort of idol. That's taking it beyond what is tolerable for those of us who don't. Hero worship is frightening to witness in current time as it's so intense. It's almost as if the worshipper believes that their devotion will cause the starry-dust to rub off on them.

There are no idols but there are everyday 'heroes' out there and nobody gets to know about them, but they quietly do their thing, new ones every day. Unheralded except by their families and friends. Good luck and thanks to all of them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread