Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Fawning/obsessing over people you don't know

142 replies

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 12:41

Why? Just why? I don't need to name names as it's bloody everywhere!

Of course it's sad when ANYONE is unwell or experiences something stressful, but why do strangers become so occupied with it?

Even as a teen I never understood the fan base that pop bands etc would get, sure I enjoyed the music, but would always look on with bemusement at the obsession. When I see people screaming, crying at people, they don't know, I just do not get it.

Especially when these same people are able to access resources the majority of us could only dream of! At the same time, millions of people suffer/die because of the same issue, but are simply born to the 'wrong' family. So to then adorn the people who have everything with more adoration/concern - is beyond crazy to me.

So, am I being a grumpy git? (Likely) or do you also think for god sakes get a grip!

OP posts:
VampireWeekday · 24/03/2024 19:00

I think the phenomenon of celebrity fawning is the same as celebrity crushes. I just watched a whole film that I have little interest in because I fancy the actor who plays the main character. What's that about? I have never met this man, and if I did, I don't think I'd like him (and he would obviously pay me no attention at all, rightly so). If I saw his photo in a magazine without any context, I doubt it would strike me at all. But I've had years of exposure to this man on camera in various films and now there is some 'attraction' component to my brain that responds to seeing him on a screen. It doesn't really make sense, it's not even like I found them attractive the first few times I saw him act, it's like a mixture of familiarity and being told they're attractive that eventually gets you on side. I think that royal family interest is like that. It's a slow trickle of exposure over time that makes them feel familiar, mixed with being told they're good and important people, and in the end people end up invested.

BlueThursday · 24/03/2024 18:51

I was made to feel like the odd ball amongst my friends when I wouldn’t camp outside the local hotel when Boyzone were staying during a tour.

i think some of the outpourings seen is almost a contagion and teenaged girls especially egg one another on.

I privately admit though I think I would cry if I met the Holy Father

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/03/2024 18:49

GoonieGang · 24/03/2024 18:29

Fair enough.
I think people who accept the monarchy for what it is generally don’t fawn over them. You get the die hards who camp out at all events but that’s their choosing. I wouldn’t, but do find it bizarre that they do.
I did cry the 1st time I saw Prince in concert and again when he died. I was more gutted he died of an accidental overdose as I honestly didn’t think he would be so silly 🙄🤦‍♀️
I don’t class myself as a stalker though

I wouldn't think you a stalker or a fawner, just a fan. Who wouldn't be sad to think that they won't ever again hear or see somebody they've admired? I think that's normal behaviour. I was sad about Alan Rickman, I've liked him in every film. Also Richard Griffiths and many other actors. It's more a poignancy than anything else when I see those films/programmes now.

I'm very sorry for Catherine and for Charles, cancer is a shitty disease. That said, as PP have mentioned, they will never have to worry about being seen, getting treatment in time, paying bills. Disliking the inequity of the RF's position doesn't mean that the people are disliked, just the system that allows it.

I have no views on any of the royal family but I think they have not served a purpose and still don't. I feel the same about most politicians and feel anger towards them as they have a mandate to serve yet fail abysmally.

I was thinking about the last time I would have felt so strongly and it was for Hugh Grant's portrayal of the prime minister in Love Actually. He was incredible (the character, not HG). I can't be on my own in that, the writer came up with this superhero politician, the complete antithesis of what we have to put up with the UK. If we actually had a PM like that, I would fawn.

and Cesarina, you're off the hook cos, Walker Brothers... Grin

Fecked · 24/03/2024 18:47

It seems to be on these types of issues everything has to be binary

thank you for putting this into words. That’s what I feel too. Similarly with world situations.

VampireWeekday · 24/03/2024 18:46

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 13:10

Interesting you should connect the two. I find any degree of parasocial behaviour fawning. You are giving attention to someone who knows nothing about you.

I agree with he general sentiment, but I think that this quoted point is too far. It's normal to feel some minimal care or give some attention to people who you know of through their work, even if they don't know you exist. For example, I felt genuinely sad when my favourite author died. I didn't cry or post gushing things on social media, but within myself I felt sad. I think that this is normal and measured attention to give a stranger.

The royal family are like that too, to some people. They remember Kate getting married and having children, and they feel sad for a diagnosis like this because they know her through her 'work'. I do agree that obsession and fawning is too much, but there is definitely a normal level of attention that one can pay famous people without crossing that line.

Fecked · 24/03/2024 18:43

clairelouwho · 24/03/2024 13:43

Because it's pointless referencing someone, making it blatantly obvious who it is but then making a vague attempt to dress it up instead of just naming the person.

It's tedious. It's not as if it's some secret is it?

But you’re missing the point. OP wasn’t trying to hide anything, just wanted to examine the strangeness of many people’s reactions.

Raspberrymoon49 · 24/03/2024 18:31

They’re all just people, not some species of super human

GoonieGang · 24/03/2024 18:29

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 18:19

This is an interesting question as my own position is one that many would say is privileged. So no - it's not this.

Fair enough.
I think people who accept the monarchy for what it is generally don’t fawn over them. You get the die hards who camp out at all events but that’s their choosing. I wouldn’t, but do find it bizarre that they do.
I did cry the 1st time I saw Prince in concert and again when he died. I was more gutted he died of an accidental overdose as I honestly didn’t think he would be so silly 🙄🤦‍♀️
I don’t class myself as a stalker though

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 18:19

GoonieGang · 24/03/2024 18:18

Are you jealous of their wealth and private health care?

This is an interesting question as my own position is one that many would say is privileged. So no - it's not this.

OP posts:
GoonieGang · 24/03/2024 18:18

Are you jealous of their wealth and private health care?

Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 18:10

SecretSoul · 24/03/2024 17:53

Mmm, I'm not sure of your motives here really OP.

Are you actually asking a genuine question about why people get upset when something happens to a celebrity that they like?

Or is this just another way to have a pop at an establishment that you object to?

Because with your references to privilege and money, plus your later comments on this post, it really does feel like the latter.

Also, I notice that lots of PP who are strongly agreeing with you are also voicing similar distaste for the monarchy.

I'm not someone who has ever, even as a teenager, been prone to outpourings of emotion. I was never fanatical about bands. I don't really follow entertainment news. I certainly am not slavishly devoted to anyone because they're in the public eye. And I mention all this just to underline the point that I'm not defending my own actions here.

I remember working with a woman when Diana died. She was genuinely distraught. She cried at work about it, and she went to lay flowers. A lot of people thought she was a bit OTT but she did genuinely experience those emotions. She had DC, young boys, and she had also lost her own mother when young, so I think the tragedy brought up very raw emotions in her.

If you are legitimately and honestly asking why people get so caught up, then it's not a straightforward answer. There are so many possible reasons.

Let's use Catherine and her announcement as an example. Reasons people might be upset:

Maybe they have young children of their own and can't imagine having to tell them that their mum has cancer.

Maybe they lost their own mum at a young age.

Maybe someone close to them has cancer right now/maybe they just lost someone to cancer

Maybe they're a royalist and are caught in the whole Catherine/William/Harry/Meghan shenanigans and feel protective of Catherine.

Maybe they've followed royal news for years and feel a sense of familiarity with Catherine and her family. I think it's called parasocial bonding. Particularly now in the age of social media when so much information is constantly sprayed around, it's not difficult to feel as if you "know" someone, even while at the same time on a rational level, you are aware that they are just a stranger. Humans naturally yearn for connections, and when you've seen someone for years, like Catherine, it's not unusual to feel some level of emotion - even though the intensity of that emotion may be very variable!

Some people are just really empathic and emotional. That might be annoying to you but it's genuine and just how they are.

And of course, for some people the outpouring might be performative. A way of inserting themselves into someone else's news for attention.

That's just off the top of my head. There are probably tons of other reasons.

I find the people mocking others for feeling emotional are a bit sneery and judgey, and typically there's another agenda such as being anti-royal, or (commonly on MN) pro-Meghan and anti-Catherine. It seems to be on these types of issues everything has to be binary - if you like/support one side you must use any opportunity to attack the other. It's just shit tbh.

I think it's fine to be a bit bewildered by why others feel such strong emotions, but some of the comments on this thread are just deliberately mean.

Bear in mind I'm autistic and spend most of my life trying to work out why the fuck people act the way they do 😅

'Bear in mind I'm autistic and spend most of my life trying to work out why the fuck people act the way they do 😅' 😂ditto

Certainly PoW prompted my post, but there is an underbelly that I'm referring too that could apply to any celebrity or alike.

So yes, PoW - I am anti-monarch but there's also the fact that she exists in a world that many many people would never experience and therefore the outpouring of love etc feels befuddling to me. She really doesn't need it and actually it only serves to further prop up there position. It feels misplaced and I just can't understand why people would waste energy on someone who frankly wouldn't give a rats ass if the situation was reversed.

Then the same applies to other celebrities etc, the fact we put so many people on a pedestal? Why? They are flesh and blood like you and I yet garner a position in society that renders them untouchable, accessing things that we never could.

My own mum died when I was 2. Her death occurred due to medical mismanagement. This would never happen with the likes of PoW. This makes me angry. It points to a 2 tier system which I find abhorrent.

OP posts:
Sparklybutold · 24/03/2024 18:01

Dylanesque · 24/03/2024 17:35

I have never understood it either. But I think it's a form of brainwashing and it started with Diana. When images are constantly pushed at you, some people start to feel a connection. There's also group think. If everybody on mumsnet is wishing the likes of Kate well, nobody want to swim against the tide and say 'I don't give a toss'. They want to belong to the group, hence group think

👍🏻

OP posts:
Beezknees · 24/03/2024 17:55

Yeah, I don't get it either but then I struggle with forming emotional attachments to people in general so I wouldn't care a jot about someone I don't know.

SecretSoul · 24/03/2024 17:53

Mmm, I'm not sure of your motives here really OP.

Are you actually asking a genuine question about why people get upset when something happens to a celebrity that they like?

Or is this just another way to have a pop at an establishment that you object to?

Because with your references to privilege and money, plus your later comments on this post, it really does feel like the latter.

Also, I notice that lots of PP who are strongly agreeing with you are also voicing similar distaste for the monarchy.

I'm not someone who has ever, even as a teenager, been prone to outpourings of emotion. I was never fanatical about bands. I don't really follow entertainment news. I certainly am not slavishly devoted to anyone because they're in the public eye. And I mention all this just to underline the point that I'm not defending my own actions here.

I remember working with a woman when Diana died. She was genuinely distraught. She cried at work about it, and she went to lay flowers. A lot of people thought she was a bit OTT but she did genuinely experience those emotions. She had DC, young boys, and she had also lost her own mother when young, so I think the tragedy brought up very raw emotions in her.

If you are legitimately and honestly asking why people get so caught up, then it's not a straightforward answer. There are so many possible reasons.

Let's use Catherine and her announcement as an example. Reasons people might be upset:

Maybe they have young children of their own and can't imagine having to tell them that their mum has cancer.

Maybe they lost their own mum at a young age.

Maybe someone close to them has cancer right now/maybe they just lost someone to cancer

Maybe they're a royalist and are caught in the whole Catherine/William/Harry/Meghan shenanigans and feel protective of Catherine.

Maybe they've followed royal news for years and feel a sense of familiarity with Catherine and her family. I think it's called parasocial bonding. Particularly now in the age of social media when so much information is constantly sprayed around, it's not difficult to feel as if you "know" someone, even while at the same time on a rational level, you are aware that they are just a stranger. Humans naturally yearn for connections, and when you've seen someone for years, like Catherine, it's not unusual to feel some level of emotion - even though the intensity of that emotion may be very variable!

Some people are just really empathic and emotional. That might be annoying to you but it's genuine and just how they are.

And of course, for some people the outpouring might be performative. A way of inserting themselves into someone else's news for attention.

That's just off the top of my head. There are probably tons of other reasons.

I find the people mocking others for feeling emotional are a bit sneery and judgey, and typically there's another agenda such as being anti-royal, or (commonly on MN) pro-Meghan and anti-Catherine. It seems to be on these types of issues everything has to be binary - if you like/support one side you must use any opportunity to attack the other. It's just shit tbh.

I think it's fine to be a bit bewildered by why others feel such strong emotions, but some of the comments on this thread are just deliberately mean.

Bear in mind I'm autistic and spend most of my life trying to work out why the fuck people act the way they do 😅

Dylanesque · 24/03/2024 17:35

I have never understood it either. But I think it's a form of brainwashing and it started with Diana. When images are constantly pushed at you, some people start to feel a connection. There's also group think. If everybody on mumsnet is wishing the likes of Kate well, nobody want to swim against the tide and say 'I don't give a toss'. They want to belong to the group, hence group think

Cesarina · 24/03/2024 17:26

NooNakedJacuzziness · 24/03/2024 13:01

Never understood the Beatles fans who screamed so loudly they couldn't even hear them play, what's the point in that?

@NooNakedJacuzziness
I have to 'fess up to doing exactly that when I used to go and see The Walker Brothers! 🤦‍♀️
Can I be let off the hook as I was only around 15?🙏

neverbeenskiing · 24/03/2024 17:02

I don't subscribe to the idea that a particular family are inherently superior to the rest us because of their ancestory so I've never really understand the worship of the RF. Of course it's sad when anyone is seriously unwell, but I feel no more emotion about Katherine's condition than I would on being told that any other stranger has cancer. The fact is that unlike the vast majority of people with cancer she will not be at the mercy of NHS waiting lists and staffing shortages and nor will she have to worry about the financial implications of long term ill health. It's still sad, but her chances of making a full recovery are significantly better than those in a less privileged position.

People who are falling over themselves to express how "devestated" they are about her diagnosis are really just making it about them. It's like when the Twin Towers fell and you had people going "oh my god, we were in New York just a few months ago" as if that means anything at all. People like to try to insert themselves into events of historic significance of national dramas that play out in the media, either by making links to their own experience or competing over who is the most "distraught".

HeddaGarbled · 24/03/2024 16:53

A lot of people are a bit thick too

And some are just unpleasant.

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 24/03/2024 16:51

I don’t want to risk this thread being taken down as a TAAT, but I’ve just read a comment on one of current RF threads saying POW’s diagnosis and her video response made her ‘feel like one of us’ and the poster added this very intriguing and thought-provoking phrase ‘It made me feel better about the state of the world … We’ve had such a leadership vacuum both on a macro and micro level.

It’s feels quite a scary response.

I have often wondered whether these major public emotional events are somehow a response to what is happening collectively in society at a point in time. Obviously the clapping for the NHS during Covid and the Captain Tom madness was a response to how people were feeling during the pandemic, responding to social isolation and some people’s inability to do something constructive to hold the Govt to account.

is this a purely British response to collective frustration? Does it happen in other countries to the same degree? Is it the main function of the Royal Family? Is it detrimental?

Noicant · 24/03/2024 16:46

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 24/03/2024 15:56

I suspect many are not so good at showing empathy towards someone they know. They’re much more likely to criticise Kelly behind her back because she didn’t go to her mammogram appointments and formula fed her 3 children.

Inclined to agree with you there.

AhNowTed · 24/03/2024 16:19

It's actively encouraged.

I counted 26 articles on the DM app this morning.

I will never understand it.

I can't imagine other rational European countries behaving this way about their own celebs or royals.

It's absolutely baffling.

Lateliein · 24/03/2024 16:10

A lot of people are a bit thick too.

breakingmews · 24/03/2024 16:09

They are insecure in themselves and project what they feel they lack onto those figures, then try to live vicariously through them.

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 24/03/2024 15:56

Noicant · 24/03/2024 15:47

Yeah I get it OP, it’s the parasocial bit or people who burst into tears about someone they don’t know. I’d feel momentary sadness for anyone suffering but I’m rarely emotionally invested in it. I do wonder sometimes if people are like that with people they know. Do they dissolve into tears when Kelly from the corner shop who they’ve seen every Saturday morning for ten years got breast cancer?

I suspect many are not so good at showing empathy towards someone they know. They’re much more likely to criticise Kelly behind her back because she didn’t go to her mammogram appointments and formula fed her 3 children.

Noicant · 24/03/2024 15:47

Yeah I get it OP, it’s the parasocial bit or people who burst into tears about someone they don’t know. I’d feel momentary sadness for anyone suffering but I’m rarely emotionally invested in it. I do wonder sometimes if people are like that with people they know. Do they dissolve into tears when Kelly from the corner shop who they’ve seen every Saturday morning for ten years got breast cancer?