Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Sunday trading hours is silly

261 replies

iguano88 · 24/03/2024 11:39

Everyone waiting at the self service and normal checkouts from 10:45, with full baskets and trolleys (shop was open for browsing but Sunday hours 11-5). Staff then opened all the tills at exactly 11 but not a minute before.

Why do we still only open large shops for 6 hours on a Sunday? 11 seems really late to open. There’s a blend of religions in society and more people need hours at work, Sunday evenings would suit students or parents who need to work opposing hours to their other half for childcare reasons. The more I think about it the sillier it is. I also think it adds to the ‘Sunday scaries’ people experience.

AIBU to think it should just be abolished and business as usual?

OP posts:
Astariel · 25/03/2024 09:43

No, scientific reality is that social clubs benefits physical and mental health.

what exactly does that have to do with the price of fish? Unless you think working in ‘spoons is somehow attending a ‘social club’.

Vod · 25/03/2024 09:42

Worth pointing out that a lot of sectors where jobs are low paid and need to be done at fixed times in set places are struggling to recruit, even during the week when access to public transport and childcare is better. So I'm never convinced retail would be any different.

The UK is in a weird position where people increasingly expect services to be available outside the traditional standard working week, but this demand isn't necessarily creating sufficient supply of labour to provide it.

LameBorzoi · 25/03/2024 09:37

Astariel · 25/03/2024 09:02

Is working in Asda so much worse for young adults wellbeing than working in McDonald’s or Wetherspoons or vue cinemas or the Amazon warehouse packing shopping? What about the people working on Sunday till late in the Sainsbury’s local - is that different?

Again, moralised nonsense that ignores reality.

No, scientific reality is that social clubs benefits physical and mental health.

It's less about the individual jobs than the total numbers. If you open supermarkets for extended hours on Sunday, then you need a certain number of people to staff them. You also open the case for other businesses to be allowed to be open.

171513mum · 25/03/2024 09:32

Loads of people work Sundays and nights in other jobs including small shops and leisure outlets. Not sure why it's only workers in large supermarkets who need protecting from Sunday work. Also people still work in supermarkets on Sunday evenings etc just not on tills! Night shift/restocking shelves etc still happens.

People can choose a Monday to Friday job or a job involving weekends and lots of people would prefer to work more hours on a Sunday. So there's no logical reason for shops not being allowed to open normal hours on a Sunday. It's outdated.

Astariel · 25/03/2024 09:22

LlynTegid · 25/03/2024 09:10

How many of those people on this thread who have argued for longer shop hours on a Sunday ever work on one? Even just say four or five a year.

Service does not mean treating those who provide it as servants.

Some of us spent our student years working 4pm-11/12/1/2 shifts on Sunday nights in fast food restaurants. I also did a Christmas stint in toys r us (in Scotland, where it could open late on a Sunday) - both suited my needs at the time.

working at 11pm on a Sunday night doesn’t mean being treated like a servant. You can be treated like shit at 2pm on a Tuesday just as easily.

you also seem to be assuming that people with m-f office jobs don’t end up working on Sundays. Unpaid often.

If you don’t want to work weekends, I’d suggest that retail is possible not a great choice of industry for you. But many people actually want to work weekends.

Elphame · 25/03/2024 09:14

LlynTegid · 25/03/2024 09:10

How many of those people on this thread who have argued for longer shop hours on a Sunday ever work on one? Even just say four or five a year.

Service does not mean treating those who provide it as servants.

Yes. As a student I funded myself working in Sainsbury’s. I took all the Sunday overtime I could.

We had a changeover at the holiday cottage yesterday, one departure and an arrival. It didn’t clean itself.

Astariel · 25/03/2024 09:14

TheBeesBollox · 25/03/2024 09:10

... But only once a year. After all, who needs to spend time with family and friends the rest of the year?

Personally I think Sunday trading rules should go further, to allow as many people as possible to have the chance to socialise at a time when most people are off. Or possibly something like "weekend trading rules" with reduced hours on Saturday and Sunday, and strict rules about how much weekend work should be allowed/allocating weekend shifts fairly. (You'd need an opt-out clause or something where people could request weekend work, for those who actually want to do it.)

I say this as someone who had to work too many weekends and it destroyed my mental health and life. Single people without family need time to spend with others too.

do you want to mandate everyone has a SAHP too? Or do you just want to make it very difficult for people who work FT M-F?

And what about the people who want to work weekends and evenings - students, parents looking to minimise paid for childcare, etc, etc?

There are loads of M-F, 9-5 jobs in the world. Not everyone wants those kind of jobs. And if ever more people are restricted to those hours, then it will mean the few hours on a Saturday that you e designed acceptable for shopping are an absolute pinch point for people who are juggling a lot and cannot do it during the week.

LlynTegid · 25/03/2024 09:10

How many of those people on this thread who have argued for longer shop hours on a Sunday ever work on one? Even just say four or five a year.

Service does not mean treating those who provide it as servants.

Astariel · 25/03/2024 09:10

Eleganz · 25/03/2024 09:04

I think that defending unfettered hyper-consumerist capitalism by complaining that others are moralising is a hollow argument really. I do not want a 24/7 retail society regardless of my religious beliefs. It is bad for workers and bad for society at large. Personally I'm delighted that many supermarkets have rolled back from 24 hour opening during the week as well.

I agree that the legislation as it stands doesn't make much sense, but that's because it is not comprehensive enough, not because it exists at all.

I hate to break it to you - but the horse has bolted.

And moralising about ‘consumerism’ is pretty distasteful when you are talking about a set of activities that includes buying bread and milk at times you disapprove of. Meanwhile, the really frivolous purchases are easy to make 24/7 online.

TheBeesBollox · 25/03/2024 09:10

Floralnomad · 24/03/2024 13:10

@SocksAndTheCity I think it’s reasonable for shops to close on Christmas day so people who work in them have the opportunity to spend time with their family / friends .

... But only once a year. After all, who needs to spend time with family and friends the rest of the year?

Personally I think Sunday trading rules should go further, to allow as many people as possible to have the chance to socialise at a time when most people are off. Or possibly something like "weekend trading rules" with reduced hours on Saturday and Sunday, and strict rules about how much weekend work should be allowed/allocating weekend shifts fairly. (You'd need an opt-out clause or something where people could request weekend work, for those who actually want to do it.)

I say this as someone who had to work too many weekends and it destroyed my mental health and life. Single people without family need time to spend with others too.

Eleganz · 25/03/2024 09:04

Astariel · 25/03/2024 08:59

It’s usually only when people are disorganised that they absolutely have to get to the shops immediately on a particular day and “find it annoying” when they can’t.

The biggest problem with these debates is the moralising tone people adopt about shopping.

Of course they do, when the debate has been couched in religious moralising from the get go.

If you take the weird sneering about shopping as some kind of vice, then all you have is a set of legislative restrictions that apply in a largely unprincipled manner that was designed for another era.

I think that defending unfettered hyper-consumerist capitalism by complaining that others are moralising is a hollow argument really. I do not want a 24/7 retail society regardless of my religious beliefs. It is bad for workers and bad for society at large. Personally I'm delighted that many supermarkets have rolled back from 24 hour opening during the week as well.

I agree that the legislation as it stands doesn't make much sense, but that's because it is not comprehensive enough, not because it exists at all.

AstralSpace · 25/03/2024 09:04

My teens would happily take on a job that would mean working on a Sunday.
Forget family time. They spend a large amount of it in bed currently but would get up for a money making reason.

Astariel · 25/03/2024 09:02

LameBorzoi · 25/03/2024 08:48

Or we could ask, ad a modern society, whose wellbeing we are giving a higher priority - giant international corporations, or the health and wellbeing of our teens and young adults (who are often the people in these jobs).

Is working in Asda so much worse for young adults wellbeing than working in McDonald’s or Wetherspoons or vue cinemas or the Amazon warehouse packing shopping? What about the people working on Sunday till late in the Sainsbury’s local - is that different?

Again, moralised nonsense that ignores reality.

Astariel · 25/03/2024 08:59

It’s usually only when people are disorganised that they absolutely have to get to the shops immediately on a particular day and “find it annoying” when they can’t.

The biggest problem with these debates is the moralising tone people adopt about shopping.

Of course they do, when the debate has been couched in religious moralising from the get go.

If you take the weird sneering about shopping as some kind of vice, then all you have is a set of legislative restrictions that apply in a largely unprincipled manner that was designed for another era.

Mrsjayy · 25/03/2024 08:56

DoYouSmokePaul · 24/03/2024 11:46

That’s true! And also you can’t buy before 10am which has caught me out a few times trying to buy wine for cooking a lasagna. Having to hang around by the booze section until they lift the barriers makes me feel judged 😂

Oh yeah we are judging 😂

I've been caught in England on a Sunday
If we are on holiday I always forget the supermarket isn't open at 7pm.

LynetteScavo · 25/03/2024 08:52

I'm waiting for the surprised and disgruntled threads when people discover shops are closed on Easter Sunday. Like it's a new thing. Confused

LameBorzoi · 25/03/2024 08:48

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 25/03/2024 08:26

Once again for those in the cheap seats - this is NOT about organisation. It’s about whether, in the 21st century, the government should still be legally preventing businesses from setting their own opening hours.

Or we could ask, ad a modern society, whose wellbeing we are giving a higher priority - giant international corporations, or the health and wellbeing of our teens and young adults (who are often the people in these jobs).

Astariel · 25/03/2024 08:48

I really don’t understand any of the defence of the stupid English Sunday trading laws. A big Tesco is only allowed to open for 6 hours, but a small Tesco can open as long as the company likes. Hospitality is open (often every single day of the year, with far more ‘unsociable’ hours). You can shop online at any hour of the day - and you can have an Amazon food delivery arrive outside the hours large supermarkets are restricted to.

There really is no proper logic to it at all. It doesn’t protect retail workers - unless you don’t think people who work on smaller shops matter as much. Or you ignore the people who would actually prefer a Sunday evening shift - that would work better for their family life.

It’s ridiculous. Indefensible really. But people will insist on making the same arguments full of holes and comparing us to Germany.

Although they conveniently edit out the other things the Germans outlaw on Sundays.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/03/2024 08:42

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 25/03/2024 08:26

Once again for those in the cheap seats - this is NOT about organisation. It’s about whether, in the 21st century, the government should still be legally preventing businesses from setting their own opening hours.

I think it is about organisation to a large extent.

It’s usually only when people are disorganised that they absolutely have to get to the shops immediately on a particular day and “find it annoying” when they can’t.

There should be emergency pharmacies open on a Sunday though- weirdly the one shop that doesn’t even seem to be open on a Sunday - the one you might actually need and not through disorganisation.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/03/2024 08:40

WithACatLikeTread · 24/03/2024 11:51

I imagine this is easy to write if you don't work in retail. I am happy with it and rather it was shut completely.

I sort of agree with this. It means people are guaranteed that time off.

If shops were open I’m sure they’d find ways to lean on people to work that time when it doesn’t actually suit them. When they want to be with family. Just look at the “shift wars” that seem to go on whenever there’s a bank holiday or similar. I think best to let everyone have the day off tbh. I don’t think a National “day of rest” is a bad thing - albeit I know emergency workers have to work.

Very few other people only have Sunday off and have it as the only time they can shop - plus there’s delivery.

Eleganz · 25/03/2024 08:40

As a Christian obviously restricting working on Sunday is something I agree with on religious grounds. However, far more importantly for most people, it is good for retail workers' well-being by restricted anti-social hours on one day a week.

As others have said, find something to do on a Sunday rather than indulging your shopping habit. There are still shops open to get essentials and you can still go to a pub or restaurant.

Eleganz · 25/03/2024 08:38

Gottoloveatakeaway · 24/03/2024 22:36

We're a secular country

We aren't. We are a constitutional monarchy where our monarch is head of the state religion and senior members of that religion sit in our legislature.

LameBorzoi · 25/03/2024 08:34

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 24/03/2024 23:08

Why? What would people do?

See friends, see family, go for a walk, do a puzzle at home - there are so many things that don't require shops!

We would do a lot better as a society if people spent more time having fun and less time shopping. Sunday trading kills regular meet up groups. People don't join them even if they are only working one in 4 Sundays, because the y feel as if they can't commit.

Fizbosshoes · 25/03/2024 08:33

I think during covid supermarkets did employ extra staff for deliveries etc, but in a lot of jobs the extra duties needed (cleaning, managing queues etc ) were just absorbed by the staff already there.

If shops opened longer hours I very much doubt they'd be hiring students or whoever just from 5pm- 10pm on a Sunday or mums with young kids to do the 6am -11 Sunday shift....what would more likely happen would be that everyone's rota would include shifts that covered those hours and then the staff would be spread more thinly during the rest of the time.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 25/03/2024 08:26

IloveAslan · 25/03/2024 07:07

I agree. Funnily enough those wanting shops open for longer hours don't actually have to work in them. If people can't be organised enough to shop during the hours the shops are open then I fear for the world.

Once again for those in the cheap seats - this is NOT about organisation. It’s about whether, in the 21st century, the government should still be legally preventing businesses from setting their own opening hours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread