Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go with this theory on parenthood / working mums ?

33 replies

Keepgoing88 · 24/03/2024 11:17

So this is random but please tell me if it’s a dumb theory…
i had children in my late twenties / early thirties. I was working in a professional role and a graduate. None of my friends had children for at least a good 3 years after me. What struck me is that many assumed being a parent would have a detrimental effect on their career and it suddenly occurred to me that I never thought like that. My mum had 3 kids in her early twenties and then thirties, was the main earner in a lucrative professional career throughout my childhood. What I’m getting at is … I never associated motherhood with lack or ending career, however the majority of the friends who have delayed being a parent had stay at home mums. I just wondered if there could be a correlation in mind set. I’m sure if my mum had given up a career to have me it might have made me think twice about having children in my twenties. Also in my NCT group in my late twenties one of the mums said ‘oh I can’t imagine having a baby before 30’ and everyone agreed (all mid to late thirties). Turns out they all had parents who had given up careers / not worked after having children.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OneMoreTime23 · 24/03/2024 13:20

the extra guilt that women have to carry if their work does take them away from home, which just isn't a thing for men where that expectation's not there.

DH hated being away from home every week when DD was tiny (and reliant on me for milk etc). I’m the one away 3 days a week now (she’s 13, been doing this since she started high school) and I don’t feel at all guilty. She has 2 equally competent parents providing for her and caring for her.

Pinkdelight3 · 24/03/2024 13:05

Halloweenrainbow · 24/03/2024 12:52

If only I could find a company willing to offer flexable training, a generous full-time wage for working 10am - 2pm, term-time only, and with unlimited parental leave the sky would be the limit!

Once again, I'm not criticising you. The fact that it sounds so pie in the sky put like that shows how much things are organised along a patriarchal model with the result that we're supposed to suck it up because of course anything better is impossible. This is just 'how it is'.

And extreme examples like your fantasy set-up vs long hours/working self to bone/not seeing kids are less of an issue than the side-effects of that thinking e.g. the extra guilt that women have to carry if their work does take them away from home, which just isn't a thing for men where that expectation's not there. Likewise the issues around part-time - so often women end up doing more work in less time, whilst also doing more at home because of their perceived 'time off' and expectation that they should be grateful for that privilege, when in fact they're juggling double responsibility and feel to be failing at both. This is the kind of thing I'm getting at, not what you've chosen to do given the options available. The OP talked about theory in a big picture way and that's what I'm responding to - the system and its disadvantages for woman overall, whether she was aware of them or not.

Halloweenrainbow · 24/03/2024 12:52

If only I could find a company willing to offer flexable training, a generous full-time wage for working 10am - 2pm, term-time only, and with unlimited parental leave the sky would be the limit!

Pinkdelight3 · 24/03/2024 12:41

My choice is to remain at a lower lever, on less pay but at home with DCs rather than travelling and training and working myself to the bone like my parents did.

No I understood completely, as most women do. I'm not faulting your 'choice'. I'm faulting the fact that the choices for women who want DC are thus limited.

Halloweenrainbow · 24/03/2024 12:37

I didn't make my point very clearly at all. It's true that if I did want to train and progress my career it would be difficult because of having DCs. Realistically it's not possible to be in two places at once. My choice is to remain at a lower lever, on less pay but at home with DCs rather than travelling and training and working myself to the bone like my parents did.

Taking maternity leave has not put me at a disadvantage compared to my colleagues at the same level who do not have children.

Itsonlymashadow · 24/03/2024 12:33

I think our own experiences definitely colour our view and expectations.

My mum always worked part time. She also got divorced twice and I saw what a detrimental impact that had on her. But in family finances. So for me, I was never going to be a sahp or a part time worker.

But I also had my first child quite young at 20. I hadn’t established a career. I actually fell into my career when my first was a toddler. I had another child at 28. My career continued to rise. I actually ended up divorced in my mid 30s and was very grateful I did have a steady, decent, income. And my career has grown massively since then.

Now the kids are older (early and late teens) a lot of people who have my experience in the job are all taking a bit of a step back as they have young kids. So there’s lot of opportunities. I don’t do it the ‘correct’ way. I didn’t establish a career first. I did it after my first. So can’t say it impacted me or not.

I have seen it impact alot of careers though. But I think the main impact is when people return PT. Or have husbands who don’t take equal responsibility for children.

But I am the first woman in my family to work full time in a career. So I didn’t have the example of it. But I did know what I didn’t want.

Superscientist · 24/03/2024 12:33

Caffeineislife · 24/03/2024 12:01

I think a bigger factor is childcare price, availability and hours in your area. Also how many employers are within a commutable distance within the child care hours available. For example, almost every child care provider around us (bar nannies) work 8-6 or 7.30-5.30. There is 1 day nursery that does 7.30-6.30. It is much more expensive than the others and has a huge waiting list, plus massive fines for late pickup. Pre children, I worked in a city nearly 1hr drive away, I needed to be at my desk by 8.30, I had to park at the park and ride and get the bus to my workplace. This meant I needed my child care to realistically start at 7.15. Bar hiring a nanny, there was not 1 child care provider with a 7am start. I finished at 4.30, but the park and ride bus came at around 4.45, then through the city stopping at almost every stop, I got to the park and ride usually about 5.15. I then had the drive home, which due to rush hour always took until 6.15. Bar a nanny, I could not get child care for 6.15. We could not afford to hire a nanny.

Our area has become a bit of a haven for Londoners moving for cheaper house prices. They have all come to the realisation that they cannot continue their London jobs if they need child care due to the train times and child care hours. So the train to London leaves our station at 6.50 and gets in at 8.30, there is not another one until 7.45 (but it requires a change so doesn't actually terminate in London until 9.30). Similarly the 4.30 train back gets in at 5.50, the next train back is at 5.45 but doesn't get in until 7.05. That is indeed if they are running and there are not rail replacement works/ signal issues/ cancellations in which case commuting by road is nearing 4 hours. Bar hiring a nanny, there is absolutely no child care cover for these commutes. Local jobs do not pay well, there are no equivalent employers unless you are willing to drive over an hour to the 2 nearest cities. Even then the wages are much lower than before. There are not many nanny's in our area, so they are a limited child care resource.

Transport is a big problem. If it wasn't for covid and my company finding a way to allow my role to be done from home I would have had to drop down to 7h days and stay on 5 days a week (35h total) instead of 8h days 4 days a week (32h). It would be too much of a drop to go down to 28h.
During the middle of the day there's one train and hour into Manchester. At rush hour there's a 2nd but they arrive and leave only a few minutes apart so don't change my working day. Our nursery is 7.30 -6 which means my working day is 8.45-4.30 due to train times and I go from a station one town over. If I went from my local station it would be 8.45 -4.15 as it's a slightly longer train and arrives at quarter past the hour so I can't make the full use of nursery hours. I do longer days on my WFH days so I average 8h per day over the week/month.

Before we moved we had 4 trains an hour and a 7.30-6.30 nursery which was living the dream but we wanted to be somewhere that was less "keeping up with the Jones'" and a bit greener! You don't have to move too far out of the suburbs to have a quite a drop on public transport.

Goddessonahighway · 24/03/2024 12:29

Depends what you mean by career and how 'big' a job qualifies as a career?

mindutopia · 24/03/2024 12:27

I think it’s probably down to the quality of life you saw in your mum. Mine was back to work when I was 3 months old and worked FT in a corporate/finance type role my whole childhood, at times with a good 1.5 hour commute to the office.

I had dc early to late 30s (only met Dh when I was 28) and I always saw them as a complement to my career. I had my first in the middle of a PhD and second in between postdocs. Dh started a new business when our first was 2 months old. We never saw career as taking a hit for either of us because of dc. We’ve built a life around work-life balance and careers and quality family time. We do actually both work part time to a degree but not to the detriment of our careers really.

I definitely think some of that came from knowing that it was absolutely possible, but that family was a priority too and that we’d find a way to do both and have the right balance. I definitely saw that with my mum. I suppose if she really struggled, I’d feel differently.

Pinkdelight3 · 24/03/2024 12:25

Halloweenrainbow · 24/03/2024 12:19

It must depend on the line of work. In my job it honestly makes no difference at all if you take 9 months maternity leave or go down to part time for a few years. I'm still at the same general grade and pay as my colleagues just pro rata. If I'd had 6 kids and took 6 years leave in a fast pace, ever changing industry, I may well have fallen behind. One issue is that I can't move up a level because training requires long hours and travel, so in that respect I am limited as a consequence of having a family. I don't mind, though. I always knew I wanted kids and that career would come second so my expectations are maybe lower.

Good example of someone starting out saying it makes no difference at all and then revealing there are many ways it makes a difference. From starting out with lower expectations because you want DC (a man doesn't need these lower expectations), to going part-time for years and therefore earning less (a man doesn't need to), to not moving up a level because of long hours/travel (plenty of DHs do this and DW picks up the slack at home), and so on to the conclusion that yep, women are limited as a consequence of having a family.

So I guess OP's theory needs to change to some women are just less aware for whatever reason, be it parents, conditioning to accept less, or whatever, but the system still sucks.

YankSplaining · 24/03/2024 12:22

I’m sure if my mum had given up a career to have me it might have made me think twice about having children in my twenties.

My parents had very complicated infertility problems, and they had been married for nearly ten years when I was born. My father, who worked harder in school and his career than anyone I know, is a very successful lawyer. My mother was a teacher until I was born. Because of my father’s career success, and because they had ten years with no kids to pay for, my mother was able to be a SAHM when I was born.

And she was completely thrilled. She wasn’t sure she would ever have a baby, and although she didn’t dislike teaching, she never really saw it as her calling in life. My parents tried for six years for a second baby, but that never happened. As a kid, I could always tell my mother was delighted to be home with me, and we had a lot of fun.

I went to law school, passed the bar, and keep my law license active, but all I’ve ever really wanted to do was write, get married, have kids, and stay home with them at least when they’re young. I was very clear about that with my now-husband. The narrative I grew up with was, “It’s wonderful to be able to stay home with your beloved children,” not, “It was so unfortunate when women have to leave careers to be home with their kids.”

After I left for college, my mother ran for local office and won. Her current term of office is ending soon and she’s retiring. I’m a SAHM to two daughters.

When women have kids, and why, and what they do about their careers is so individual - by person, by family, by financial situation. I don’t think it’s as easy to generalize about as you think.

Halloweenrainbow · 24/03/2024 12:19

It must depend on the line of work. In my job it honestly makes no difference at all if you take 9 months maternity leave or go down to part time for a few years. I'm still at the same general grade and pay as my colleagues just pro rata. If I'd had 6 kids and took 6 years leave in a fast pace, ever changing industry, I may well have fallen behind. One issue is that I can't move up a level because training requires long hours and travel, so in that respect I am limited as a consequence of having a family. I don't mind, though. I always knew I wanted kids and that career would come second so my expectations are maybe lower.

Lemoncokezero · 24/03/2024 12:14

Pinkdelight3 · 24/03/2024 12:12

I never associated motherhood with lack or ending career

Most people know that having DC affects a woman's career, whether or not their own DM worked. It's unfortunately evidenced time and time again and to not have considered that is a bit odd, but I wouldn't call it a theory. Sure people are influenced by what their parents do and can assume that's normal, but they also have wider world experience to draw on as they grow up, so I wouldn't say your theory prevails. Just that a lot more work is needed to make work fairer for women and parents overall.

I know like can you really be that hard of thinking op?

TheSnowyOwl · 24/03/2024 12:12

I think it depends. I knew I wanted three children and quite close together so it had to impact my career.

I spent my 20s at uni, travelling, saving, buying property and generally getting to a good position career-wise.

For me, the career impact wasn’t a concern as DH’s salary covers all our bills, but I wanted to feel I was in the right place in my life to have children and I knew I would only feel like that if I was a property owner, had decent savings, a good career to go back to, and felt I hadn’t missed out on travelling or going on holiday.

Pinkdelight3 · 24/03/2024 12:12

I never associated motherhood with lack or ending career

Most people know that having DC affects a woman's career, whether or not their own DM worked. It's unfortunately evidenced time and time again and to not have considered that is a bit odd, but I wouldn't call it a theory. Sure people are influenced by what their parents do and can assume that's normal, but they also have wider world experience to draw on as they grow up, so I wouldn't say your theory prevails. Just that a lot more work is needed to make work fairer for women and parents overall.

Lemoncokezero · 24/03/2024 12:10

I mean there's is loads of evidence that motherhood has a detrimental effect on women's careers and earning potential. So perhaps they were just looking at the reality of the situation?

You can do all the positive thinking you want. Doesn't chance the reality. Your theory feels a bit individualistic, bootstraps, blameful of women and unpleasant tbh.

Fairyliz · 24/03/2024 12:07

Surely it’s less about having a working mum and more about actually finding a decent man who will commit to having children and do a fair share of parenting?
My DD is nearly 30 with a decent career but finding a good man is near impossible, they all sound horrendous.

Caffeineislife · 24/03/2024 12:01

I think a bigger factor is childcare price, availability and hours in your area. Also how many employers are within a commutable distance within the child care hours available. For example, almost every child care provider around us (bar nannies) work 8-6 or 7.30-5.30. There is 1 day nursery that does 7.30-6.30. It is much more expensive than the others and has a huge waiting list, plus massive fines for late pickup. Pre children, I worked in a city nearly 1hr drive away, I needed to be at my desk by 8.30, I had to park at the park and ride and get the bus to my workplace. This meant I needed my child care to realistically start at 7.15. Bar hiring a nanny, there was not 1 child care provider with a 7am start. I finished at 4.30, but the park and ride bus came at around 4.45, then through the city stopping at almost every stop, I got to the park and ride usually about 5.15. I then had the drive home, which due to rush hour always took until 6.15. Bar a nanny, I could not get child care for 6.15. We could not afford to hire a nanny.

Our area has become a bit of a haven for Londoners moving for cheaper house prices. They have all come to the realisation that they cannot continue their London jobs if they need child care due to the train times and child care hours. So the train to London leaves our station at 6.50 and gets in at 8.30, there is not another one until 7.45 (but it requires a change so doesn't actually terminate in London until 9.30). Similarly the 4.30 train back gets in at 5.50, the next train back is at 5.45 but doesn't get in until 7.05. That is indeed if they are running and there are not rail replacement works/ signal issues/ cancellations in which case commuting by road is nearing 4 hours. Bar hiring a nanny, there is absolutely no child care cover for these commutes. Local jobs do not pay well, there are no equivalent employers unless you are willing to drive over an hour to the 2 nearest cities. Even then the wages are much lower than before. There are not many nanny's in our area, so they are a limited child care resource.

thatsnotmycateither · 24/03/2024 11:56

I had my children early (I was 27 having my third) and in the early low paid stages of my career. I carried on working and was senior in my profession by 35.

I think it was enabled by some flexibility in my role eg I could pick up from childcare at 4 pm and finish work in the evening.

It was also helped by a Labour government and higher tax credits at the time meaning I could afford the childcare.

But I think having them before I got into the senior leadership stages helped. I can’t imagine having babies now in my early 40s and now things are really picking up they’re teens so fairly independent. I also got a clear run through my 30s. It was much easier doing all the baby / sleepless nights / constant illnesses when I didn’t have so much responsibility for others.

I also became a single parent at 30 and had little family help but in a way that meant I had no choice but to crack on. Probably exhausted myself in the process though.

Purplevioletsherbert · 24/03/2024 11:54

I can see where you’re coming from. My mum was a SAHM pretty much straight out of school, but when we were all late primary age she went to college and by the time I was a teenager she was working in a graduate professional role and her career has continued to soar since then. She’s mid 50s and very much a career woman now. When I adopted my son, I was 27 and a HEO in the civil service. I got promoted to SEO about two years after I returned to work after a year of adoption leave, so was on about £45k by the time I was 30. I’m now 33, just did a lateral move but am looking to move up to G7 in two years. I don’t think I’d have the ambition if it wasn’t for my mum role modelling it for me.

Superscientist · 24/03/2024 11:48

I didn't qualify until 29. I had my daughter at 32. My mum worked as a nurse throughout out my childhood. My older sister had her daughter at 30. If I had my daughter before I qualified I would have had nearly 2years out of work as I wouldn't have been able to do my job whilst pregnant due to risks to the unborn during my PhD which would have had an impact on my career plus I would have only been entitled to statutory maternity pay as I was on a stipend.

My auntie only 5 years older than me as my nan was in her 40s when she had her with a 21y age gap to my dad had her kids at 19 and 20. Her and her husband wanted different experiences to their childhood. He was brought by his gran and my auntie was bullied for having a "granny as a mum". So I do think there is a connection between your childhood experiences and when you have children but there are hundreds of factors that contribute to when is the right time for a couple

OneMoreTime23 · 24/03/2024 11:47

My Nan worked. My mum went back to work (evenings) 2 weeks after I was born (she was 23). There was no question that my career would take a back seat if when/I became a parent.

I put in the legwork during my 20s. Had DD at 32. Became a contractor for a couple of years (DH worked away all week) then got back on the ladder at a higher point than I left it.

My best friend had her son at 19. She did a degree when he started comp and has built her career rapidly in her late 30s and 40s.

There isn’t one perfect route, but I do wish more men would step up and care for their children equally so that it isn’t always expected that the mum will stop working and take the career/pension hit when children come along.

Gillyyy · 24/03/2024 11:43

I would say in my experience becoming a mother has been detrimental to my career, at least in the short term. Companies can be so awkward about flexibility/letting you work part time and with childcare costs it isn’t always viable to work.

There are definitely more SAHMs now because of childcare costs and practicalities, rather than necessarily wanting to give up your career.

MissTrip82 · 24/03/2024 11:41

All the women in my family have worked, as is usual for working class women.

Didn’t occur to me to have children in my twenties as I was at medical school then training. I don’t know anyone who had a child before 30; most were after 35. That’s how it is for most women who do long degrees with significant time spent in further training or career-building afterwards.

Rosestulips · 24/03/2024 11:39

My Mum stayed at home until my youngest sibling was 5.

she now has grandchildren in the double figures and none of my siblings (all sisters) have had to forego a career.