Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have let my 11 yr old get a piercing at the top of her ear?

169 replies

thistooshallarse · 24/03/2024 05:17

11 yr old got her ears pierced for the first time at 10 yrs old - the standard 2 studs in her lobes

She recently asked if she could get a single extra stud at the top of her ear and
I didn't see why not.

I have since gathered from a few reactions that letting her do this was outrageous, and that absolutely none of her friends would be allowed this. I don't understand why.

OP posts:
Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 24/03/2024 12:08

I think 11 is way too young for this.

WitsEnd10 · 24/03/2024 12:03

unsync · 24/03/2024 11:34

If it is a cartilage piercing, you just need to keep an eye on it. They take forever to heal and are best with a threaded stud as less likely to catch. No twiddling and lots of cleaning with saline.

We don’t recommend external threads anymore. Internally threaded labret bars are best.

LaDamaDeElche · 24/03/2024 11:51

I wouldn't at 11, no. That's because I've had one of those piercings and it was pretty painful and uncomfortable to sleep on it for a very long time. You really have to look after it properly too after having it done. I'd wait a few years.

Grapewrath · 24/03/2024 11:51

Of course you’re not- how silly that people see the top of the ear as so different. As long as you are aware of the longer healing time and look after it, it’s really no drama. Especially in a child- blood circulation is better so it’s an easier heal.
I had mine done at 12 and I still wear it at 44. With a gun too! Which I definitely don’t recommend

HelloCiao · 24/03/2024 11:50

I got mine done at 11 back in the late 90s. As long as you got it pierced properly (with a needle, not a gun) and school are OK , no problem.

Glittertwins · 24/03/2024 11:49

DD was 14 and she was lucky in that it healed quite well and never had a problem sleeping on it. It did get quite the healing bump though and that was a bit painful until it went bang. But she knew what to do and was old enough to deal with it. She also thinks 11 is too young to have it done.

Doingmybest12 · 24/03/2024 11:48

Cartlidge piercing is usually for 14 plus. I'm not sure reputable piercers would do this on an 11 year old. Most parents don't let their children rush ahead of doing things more common in older teens. You can't therefore be surprised by other people's reactions. Hope it heals well.

ittakes2 · 24/03/2024 11:39

For whatever reason a helix piercing is considered an older teen thing - its a bit like you might not let a 11 year old have lash extensions or wear heels, or whatever, but no one would blink if they saw a 16 year old doing these things.

But of course some parents would be OK with an 11 year old doing what 16 year olds tend to do - its up to you.

For context I have encouraged my daughter to think carefully about her piercings - the key reason because she will have scarring if she would ever decide not to use them anymore. She has also needed doctor's visits due to infections requiring antibiotics - and not because she didn't look after them properly because she did. Some people just take a while to heal from piercings and the hellix piercing is well known for this problem.

unsync · 24/03/2024 11:34

If it is a cartilage piercing, you just need to keep an eye on it. They take forever to heal and are best with a threaded stud as less likely to catch. No twiddling and lots of cleaning with saline.

orangeleopard · 24/03/2024 11:30

At 11 I don’t think that’s a suitable age. Top of the ear gets stuck on everything, so kids being kids there’s a possibility that might get ripped out. I think it’s more of a 13/14 year old thing to consider getting. Basically as a teen. A lot can change in a few years, so maybe wait.

bradpittsbathwater · 24/03/2024 11:26

I got mine done around the same age. Back in the day when it was a gun. Ouch! Mine never healed as it kept getting caught in my hair, so if she does get it done please be vigilant on healing and care.

zingally · 24/03/2024 11:23

I personally wouldn't encourage it at 11. But each to their own. I'd be concerned about healing.

I've got two holes in each lobe, and the "newest" holes are almost 20 years old, yet still give me trouble sometimes! Even with "nice" metals in.

Famousinlove · 24/03/2024 11:06

I had mine done over 20 years ago when i was 9. I asked my dad so many times and he kept saying no.. then eventually said do what you want so my mum took me to get it done.
I've still got the piercing now and it didn't ruin my life in any way!

buswankerz · 24/03/2024 11:06

Has 2 piercings, not had.

buswankerz · 24/03/2024 11:05

Dd is 5 and had 2 piercings in each ear. I don't see the problem with an 11 year old having their upper ear done. I've no doubt dd will want that done when she's that age if not before.

ArcticOwl · 24/03/2024 10:49

The care of a cartilage piercing is a WHOLE other ballgame than lobe piercings.

They take a long time to heal, and she will not be allowed/able to sleep on that ear for at LEAST 12 months, or it can distort the piercing, cause pain, keloids, infections... etc.

I am 42 and have a double helix piercing up on the top of my ear, its currently 16months old, i still can't sleep on it comfortably without it being sore the next day. I had 3 to start with (Triple helix) but lost one due to it not healing properly.

I have a lot of piercings, and personally i would not recommend ANYONE under 18 getting a cartilage piercing because the after care is not simple and needs dedication.

Mumof2teens79 · 24/03/2024 10:44

Yr6 or yr7?
Helix piercing carries more risks, takes longer to heal, and more car than lobes.
It also looks edgier and more adult than I might prefer for a 11 Yr old.

Primary schools tend to be more relaxed about earnings than secondary in my experience.

Menora · 24/03/2024 10:38

I don’t think people who haven’t had cartridge piercings understand the torture of trying to sleep on them for months on end. I commented on page 1 and I still stand by I don’t think a 11yo is equipped to deal with the pain which can last months. It isn’t the same as a slightly sore soft lobe. Mine is 2 years old now and only just properly healed and no longer gives me hell

IsadoraQuagmire · 24/03/2024 10:19

ohdamnitjanet · 24/03/2024 06:02

I used to do this kind of piercing and if it gets infected and swollen, it can be a hospital visit to have it removed, terribly painful. Not the same as a lobe piercing at all. I wouldn’t advise it on an 11 yr old.

This happened to me when I first got my ears pierced (usual earlobe piercing) One ear got infected (and I had to go to A&E where they pulled the whole thing out through the back of my ear) even though I'd been cleaning them properly. And I was 17. I think 11 is too young for anything even more likely to cause problems.

Angrymum22 · 24/03/2024 10:18

As long as she understands the risks - worst case scenario she has to have part of her ear amputated if the cartridge becomes necrotic- no problem.
But do consider that at 11 she is still growing and if the cartridge becomes infected then growth of the ear may stop.
A good example of damaged cartridge are the ears of a rugby forward. Show her a few pictures of how her ears could end up if she has repeated infections.

But that’s worst case.

colouredball · 24/03/2024 09:54

@Bridgertonned

Needles arent meant to be used on under 18s without there being a medical reason,

You just made this up, right?

Loubelle70 · 24/03/2024 09:54

Personally, no. My DD had her lobes done at 14..i wasn't happy about that lol but you know. I wouldn't allow top ears. She could do that after 16. 11 far too young, even for lobes tbh...thats just me.

WaitingForMojo · 24/03/2024 09:51

My dd had it done at 12 and also her nose. I personally don’t see an issue.

Bananabreadandstrawberries · 24/03/2024 09:49

More extreme example, but I saw a little girl, maybe 7yo, with a navel piercing an a midriff too, walking in the city with her family. It did seem a bit inappropriate to me.

Wouldn’t say anything to anyone else but I would agree to it.

zeibesaffron · 24/03/2024 09:47

I am probably in the minority but I have never had an issue with piercing as long as school are ok with them and the young person does all the right aftercare - there are far more harmful young person/ teenager behaviours out there to be concerned about.

However the top of the ear is more tricky and can get sore/ infected so is there a compromise- second piercings in the lobe?