Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have let my 11 yr old get a piercing at the top of her ear?

169 replies

thistooshallarse · 24/03/2024 05:17

11 yr old got her ears pierced for the first time at 10 yrs old - the standard 2 studs in her lobes

She recently asked if she could get a single extra stud at the top of her ear and
I didn't see why not.

I have since gathered from a few reactions that letting her do this was outrageous, and that absolutely none of her friends would be allowed this. I don't understand why.

OP posts:
InTheRainOnATrain · 24/03/2024 15:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

When I lived in the US DD’s paediatrician did ear piercing, with a gun! It’s pretty common over there apparently. So I don’t know they’re as bad as people often make out on here?? Obviously a medical doctor knows a lot more about hygiene and infection than a piercer with a needle so if they’re happy to use a gun they surely can’t be that bad… They’d do it anytime after the first set of shots so happy to do tiny babies too.

Bridgertonned · 24/03/2024 14:55

Not sure if people are being deliberately obtuse about my point re piercers not using needles on young teens

@bleughgreen I haven't said a good piercer would choose a gun. I've said that in my experience proper piercers - who only use needles - won't do the piercings on u16s because they're not insured. NOT that they would go oh I'm not insured to use a needle so hang on let me grab a shitty Claire's accessories gun instead! They'd just say they wouldn't do it. Good piercers have plenty of business without risking their studio by piercing tweens.

iLovee · 24/03/2024 14:06

I like to think I'm relatively relaxed about things, but idk about this one. I think a cartilage piercing should be left until older - year 10 maybe? No idea why I think that though!!

I would be fine with getting another in the lobes though.

Glittertwins · 24/03/2024 14:06

@idontlikealdi - the plastic retainers can be used in cartilage piercings. Our school changed the rules on us 6 months after they were done (within rules at the time) and eventually grudgingly allowed her to have these instead of removing them.

idontlikealdi · 24/03/2024 14:03

Jifmicroliquid · 24/03/2024 06:47

If school are fine with it, i dont see why not.
Word of warning though- they are a nighmare to heal and pretty painful to sleep on. When you accidentally catch them, you feel your soul leave your body!
They take a good 12-18 months to stop going manky and infected. I want the other side doing but I’m not sure i can be bothered with the hassle.

Not my experience at all, they've all healed fine.

Won't let dds who are 12 though, because school will make them take it out.

They have double lobes which also aren't allowed but they and all the rest of them wear those little plastic things to get round it. Wouldn't work in cartlidge.

snackatack · 24/03/2024 14:02

My suspicion is a decent piercer would not do it.

My dd needed to be 16 to have her nose cartilage pierced,

ImWearingPantaloons · 24/03/2024 13:59

Mine took about two years to heal fully, and I had to do warm sea salt water soaks twice a day for the first three months.

I'm not 100% sure about an 11 year old getting one but if she's hell bent on it, then make sure it's done with a needle not a gun.

Glittertwins · 24/03/2024 13:57

@ArcticOwl - my first helix was done with a gun and yes, it damaged the cartilage and was taken out.
It was done again with a needle and have never had a problem in the 30+ years I've had it.

JanefromLondon1 · 24/03/2024 13:53

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

Pantaloons99 · 24/03/2024 13:50

popofyellow · 24/03/2024 13:33

@Pantaloons99 I don't understand why you are so worried about your son getting a perm but then say that piercings are no big deal? A perm grows out, you can cut it out of needed, but a cartilage piercing is a hole intentionally made on the body with a high chance of causing pain and infection. I know which I'd prefer my teen to have!

I had a perm and it wrecked my hair structure. I also have a multitude of autoimmune conditions and have hyper reactions to chemicals. My conditions are highly heritable ; my son reacts strongly like me. So my situation and decision is personal to my circumstances.

If I saw another 13 year old with a perm, I wouldn't have a view at all - I doubt their circumstances are similar to mine. Ref the ear piercing, I hear you on risk of infection. I think that risk could be well managed. The decision in my view most certainly doesn't warrant judgement based on level of risk to child's health.

Bridgertonned · 24/03/2024 13:46

@WitsEnd10 or @colouredball can you get insurance to do the procedure for u16s? Genuinely interested. It would be a lot easier if we could give permission to angry teenagers, I'm not trying to defend it (maybe not a cartilage piercing for an 11yr old but for older ones...)

ArcticOwl · 24/03/2024 13:45

no-one should be piercing with a gun, its traumatic and so much more likely to cause problems. Claires in particular are butchers and shouldn't be piercing anyone.

Guns and cartilage are a MASSIVE NO, they risk shattering the cartilage.

All piercings are safer done by a professional piercer with a needle.

YankSplaining · 24/03/2024 13:41

MariaVT65 · 24/03/2024 06:11

At 11 i was already in a significant bra size and started my period 2 months after turning 12, so i wouldn’t go as far as ‘feeling like a child’ by that point tbh.

I started my period three months before turning twelve. At the time I was convinced that when I grew up, I was going to be a famous Hollywood actress and get married to Leonardo DiCaprio. I also still played with dolls.

Breast size and menstruation don’t mean much of anything when it comes to mental maturity.

Tygertiger · 24/03/2024 13:34

Bridgertonned · 24/03/2024 12:14

@colouredball that was the advice we got from our legal dept (eng and Wales) If you know otherwise, or if it's changed, happy to hear it. What we were told is that if there isnt a medical need then using a needle on an 18 isn't something any practitioner would be assured to do. Same for tattoos.
We seek the advice due to caring for children where we hold PR and have to agree or decline these requests.

I also work in Children’s Services. Your Legal dept need to update their training and understanding of piercings. Tattoos are irrelevant as it is illegal for under-18s to get one, so if anyone is tattooing children they need to be urgently reported and investigated. From a piercing point of view, needles are safer (less tissue damage) and more hygienic (single use and thrown away - a gun cannot be properly sterilised in between clients).

Obviously children should only be taken to reputable studios. But any decent APP registered studio will not use guns.

popofyellow · 24/03/2024 13:33

@Pantaloons99 I don't understand why you are so worried about your son getting a perm but then say that piercings are no big deal? A perm grows out, you can cut it out of needed, but a cartilage piercing is a hole intentionally made on the body with a high chance of causing pain and infection. I know which I'd prefer my teen to have!

Pantaloons99 · 24/03/2024 13:27

Other parents are a pain in the ass! I wouldn't think a thing on it, good for you. I personally won't let 13 year old son get a perm as an example as I know it can mess up the hair and the chemical issues. He keeps asking. Again I wouldn't want a tattoo but the ear piercing is no big deal . I cringe when I see 2 year olds with piercings but maybe I should just chill out on that, I don't know 🤷‍♀️.

I let my son go off on main roads alone cycling and have done since 11. I know I'm the only one who allows certain things in his class like that - but he is so capable and responsible and other parents can just stick their own anxiety up their backside. I think it's a good idea to NEVER ask parents their opinion on your parenting in real life ( not here where we can be anonymous). If anyone makes negative comments then just own it with absolute confidence! It's really no big deal. I like the fact you went against the grain. I imagine other folk feel jealous of that confidence you have when you allow something like that tbh, hence the judgement. It's hurting no one at end of the day.

popofyellow · 24/03/2024 13:24

I don't think I'd trust a studio that would be willing to do a cartilage piercing on an 11yo. As others have said they are a completely different ball game to a lobe piercing.

FrenchMustard · 24/03/2024 13:21

Each to his own if you allow it, but as others have said, helix piercings can be an absolute pain to heal and hurt to sleep on.

id be amazed if you can find a piercer who will do it on an 11 year old. Oh and please, please, please don’t get it done with a gun!!

JWhipple · 24/03/2024 13:19

Blue Banana state age 13 so ask if she'll wait until then and get it done at one of their branches. You pay more but they pierce with needles (not a gun), use steel or titanium body jewellery and I've not had any issues with any of my piercings from them. Gun piercings into cartilage are not a good idea at all. Anyone who offers that really isn't someone you should trust to give you a decent piercing.
Yes she'll have to avoid sleeping on that side for a bit but she'll get used to that.

www.bluebanana.com/en_GB/body-piercing-information

WitsEnd10 · 24/03/2024 13:18

Bridgertonned · 24/03/2024 12:14

@colouredball that was the advice we got from our legal dept (eng and Wales) If you know otherwise, or if it's changed, happy to hear it. What we were told is that if there isnt a medical need then using a needle on an 18 isn't something any practitioner would be assured to do. Same for tattoos.
We seek the advice due to caring for children where we hold PR and have to agree or decline these requests.

I’ve no idea where ‘your legal department’ are getting their information but it’s complete rubbish.

Snugglemonkey · 24/03/2024 13:18

I have a lot of piercings, including 3 helix and a triple reverse helix. I have been quite lucky with all my piercings, but those helix piercings were buggers to heal. I wouldn't let my daughter to have one until they were a bit older. They take a lot of care.

LolaSmiles · 24/03/2024 13:08

Most parents don't let their children rush ahead of doing things more common in older teens. You can't therefore be surprised by other people's reactions
This sums it up.
It amazes me that when parents choose to allow their pre-teens do things typically associated with older teens they're surprised that other parents raise an eyebrow.

EauNeu · 24/03/2024 12:39

it's one of the trickier piercings to look after, painful to get and to heal, awkward for sleeping on. It really needs babying so as not to get infected or to reject. i think it's one for an older teenager who can look after it properly. I've had this piercing as an adult and had to remove as it was rejecting, now scarred.

Pickingmyselfup · 24/03/2024 12:30

I would proceed with caution because they can be an absolute nightmare to heal.

I had a double helix, one of them didn't heal and I had had enough of the pain (throbbing all the time requiring ibuprofen) so I took it out. The other one did heal eventually but it was painful whilst it did.

I'm currently battling with my rook and my tragus after 6+ months but by now I know what I'm dealing with and I'm refusing to give in.

I would be concerned that if her piercings went the same way as mine she wouldn't be able to deal with it so young but they could heal fine, you just never know. My first and second lobes got done as a child no problem but my helix as a 14 year old didn't heal, belly button at 18 then 3rd lobes and one helix. Sometimes they've been so painful that there is no way I would let anyone near me to take them out if there was an issue and when they are playing up I flinch when someone approaches my head, not ideal with 2 kids and a husband!

I also haven't slept on a normal pillow for years...

I'm in my 30s and stubborn so I'm willing to do these things but I think it's a bit much for a child but like I say, they might heal fine.

Just something to consider before doing it. As far as the idea in principle for that age, fine, can't see an issue, if you were thinking nipples then I could see why people were horrified. Incidentally I had mine done recently and they've been absolutely fine, my tattoos also fine so it's clearly just an ear thing with me (yet I never learn and still go back for more 🙄)

Bridgertonned · 24/03/2024 12:14

@colouredball that was the advice we got from our legal dept (eng and Wales) If you know otherwise, or if it's changed, happy to hear it. What we were told is that if there isnt a medical need then using a needle on an 18 isn't something any practitioner would be assured to do. Same for tattoos.
We seek the advice due to caring for children where we hold PR and have to agree or decline these requests.