Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to have let my 11 yr old get a piercing at the top of her ear?

169 replies

thistooshallarse · 24/03/2024 05:17

11 yr old got her ears pierced for the first time at 10 yrs old - the standard 2 studs in her lobes

She recently asked if she could get a single extra stud at the top of her ear and
I didn't see why not.

I have since gathered from a few reactions that letting her do this was outrageous, and that absolutely none of her friends would be allowed this. I don't understand why.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Vulcanodon · 25/03/2024 21:02

I’m glad she healed well but, echoing others, I’m surprised a piercer would agree to do this to such a young child. Most would say 16+ as a minimum.

Mrssheepskin · 25/03/2024 16:39

SiriAlexa · 25/03/2024 11:04

Leaving aside the risks, I honestly think it’s too grown up for an 11 year old child. It will make her look older and less innocent than she is. Maybe that isn’t logical but it would be a firm no from me until my child was older. Yep, now prepared to be flamed for that!

I agree tbh.

popofyellow · 25/03/2024 12:04

@KreedKafer I'm also surprised that a piercer was willing to do it. It seems incredibly irresponsible.

KreedKafer · 25/03/2024 11:05

I've got nine ear piercings including three at the top of my ear and one in my daith, so clearly I love pierced ears. But piercing any part of the ear that isn't the lobe isn't a great idea for a child.

The ear lobe is very easy to pierce because it's just soft flesh and heals quickly. The top of the ear is cartilage and piercing it is a bigger deal physically. Most proper piercing studios will not pierce cartilage on children, even with parental consent - the place I go to won't pierce anything other than earlobes on under-16s, and requires parental consent for 16-18s.

It takes a lot longer to heal and infection can be more of a problem - if the cartilage gets damaged or badly infected, there's a risk of getting a cauliflower ear, and obviously a child's ears are smaller and more delicate than an adults. If they used a gun rather than a needle, the cartilage can shatter and leave permanent damage. Just because Claire's Accessories will do it, that doesn't mean it's a good idea.

It's also very likely that she'll have to take it out as soon as she starts secondary school. Not many schools allow more than one piercing.

While I don't care what your kid's ears look like, on a practical level I think it was a pretty poor decision on your part.

SiriAlexa · 25/03/2024 11:04

Leaving aside the risks, I honestly think it’s too grown up for an 11 year old child. It will make her look older and less innocent than she is. Maybe that isn’t logical but it would be a firm no from me until my child was older. Yep, now prepared to be flamed for that!

PracticallyPerfectedIt · 25/03/2024 10:56

Glad it's worked out well. I think for me it just seems like something really grown up, so I wouldn't let my child do it. It's not overly logical as you say, but it just feels like a studenty/adult kind of look rather than a little girl.

InTheRainOnATrain · 25/03/2024 10:53

Glad it healed well! Maybe there is something in getting it done younger? I know studies have shown that the chance of keloids are reduced when 11 or younger, maybe healing is often quicker too?

whyismysoupcold · 25/03/2024 10:50

I had my helix pierced when I was 17 and I couldn't sleep on my left hand side for 1 1/2 years. I eventually admitted defeat and took it out.

Would not recommend.

ArcticOwl · 25/03/2024 10:34

stripes92 · 25/03/2024 10:04

Glad it healed well! I've tried to get that piercing 3 times now and each time had to give up because it wouldn't heal, I guess my ears just don't like it!

i had it done once before and it failed, had to take it out.

First time it was done by gun, with a butterfly back, and i was not told how to properly care for it, so slept on it..etc.

This time it was done by a piercer, with a needle, i was taught the proper after care (spray with sterilised water twice daily and no touchy), with the proper flat back labret piercings, not sleeping on it...etc I still go an infection that needed antibiotics after an absent minded dirty washing machine water incident, and still lost one of the 3 i had done after it refused to heal, so i took it out (was a triple helix piercing and was the very bottom of the 3 so i think was getting irritated) but 18 months on the remaining two are healed and fine.

The key for me was the proper care, and switching out the post labret piercings for rings soon as it was safe (about 9 months post piercing)

stripes92 · 25/03/2024 10:04

thistooshallarse · 25/03/2024 04:47

Thank you to the poster who pointed out that the reason other parents are raising an eyebrow is because it is a thing usually reserved for older teens, like eyelash extensions or high heels. That explains it to me.

I still think it's illogical, but I get it now.

And for all those advising against and saying how long it will take to heal - it is already done - months ago - and it healed very quickly. I have a lot of piercings myself and I never found the top of the ear was slow to heal. I guess we're all different.

Glad it healed well! I've tried to get that piercing 3 times now and each time had to give up because it wouldn't heal, I guess my ears just don't like it!

Menora · 25/03/2024 09:28

I’m glad it worked out ok, I think she was lucky, it’s more common for it to be slow to heal and apparently absolutely not one issue with it so I am not sure why you asked this in the first place? She already has it, you already don’t mind. You already took the risk with your own child to be a cool mom. You don’t care what other people think about it. What was the point in this 😂😂

The one positive is that hopefully it’s spread some education on what is commonly found with cartilage piercings being challenging and maybe others won’t rush into it assuming it’s the same as a soft lobe piercing. As parents we are responsible for what risks we take with our children and this isn’t risk free.

Lemoncokezero · 25/03/2024 07:54

It's interesting 100s of people siad it can be slow to heal. I agree with this. In my experience it can heal then can go back to square one with healing if knocked etc.

This is no big deal suppose. I just think I'd have done a bit of research first before letting my child have this. Not just base it in my own experience. But it seems to have worked out OK.

thistooshallarse · 25/03/2024 04:47

Thank you to the poster who pointed out that the reason other parents are raising an eyebrow is because it is a thing usually reserved for older teens, like eyelash extensions or high heels. That explains it to me.

I still think it's illogical, but I get it now.

And for all those advising against and saying how long it will take to heal - it is already done - months ago - and it healed very quickly. I have a lot of piercings myself and I never found the top of the ear was slow to heal. I guess we're all different.

OP posts:
Wooloohooloo · 24/03/2024 19:48

I wouldn't (and I say this as someone who's had many piercings)- they are harder to heal and more prone to infection than lobe piercings.

Kat2328 · 24/03/2024 18:19

Be aware that cartilage piercings take a LOT longer to heal than lobe piercings (6-12 months vs 6-12 weeks for a regular lobe), and are more likely to get infected, or knocked / pulled. They can be painful when sleeping as you can't avoid laying on them. Plus there is more likelihood of problems (look up keloids).

While I don't have any issue with ear piercings in general; I don't think I'd allow it for that reason; I don't think an 11 year old is old enough to understand what they are consenting to.

pipsas · 24/03/2024 18:11

Oh Jesus 😂 I read a handful of these replies and they’re way OTT.

I had my first helix piercing at 10. Before that I had my lobes at 4 and nose pierced at 9. All with a good old gun, a plaster stuck over them at school and I lived to tell the story! I now have a total of 13 piercings, in a very successful career and not had a problem really with any of them.

Relax, it’s fine!

BuyingTheHills · 24/03/2024 18:00

MariaVT65 · 24/03/2024 06:11

At 11 i was already in a significant bra size and started my period 2 months after turning 12, so i wouldn’t go as far as ‘feeling like a child’ by that point tbh.

The fact remains that you were very much a child at 11/12. Some girls start puberty even younger and have periods from age 9, they are children. It’s immaturity, not maturity, often combined with crap parenting, that results in children wanting to do things that are more appropriate for older kids/teens.

hangingonfordearlife1 · 24/03/2024 17:38

yep i would, don't care about ears at all. they easily close up and can't be seen in future

WhamBamThankU · 24/03/2024 16:44

I had my helix pierced at 11, nose at 14. As long as they're old enough to keep the piercings clean I don't see the issue.

LazyDoll · 24/03/2024 16:41

As someone with multiple ear piercings I’d hold off her getting this one for a while. As pp have said healing takes upwards of 6 months for cartilage piercings and sleeping/knocking/hair getting twisted in it all delay healing. I’d wait until she is at a more responsible age to manage her own healing of it.

WitsEnd10 · 24/03/2024 16:37

InTheRainOnATrain · 24/03/2024 15:13

When I lived in the US DD’s paediatrician did ear piercing, with a gun! It’s pretty common over there apparently. So I don’t know they’re as bad as people often make out on here?? Obviously a medical doctor knows a lot more about hygiene and infection than a piercer with a needle so if they’re happy to use a gun they surely can’t be that bad… They’d do it anytime after the first set of shots so happy to do tiny babies too.

They’re awful, they cause tissue damage which needles don’t and they’re unsanitary as they can’t be sterilised (even the single use ones haven’t been sterilised prior to use). Any doctor using a piercing gin should be struck off.

WitsEnd10 · 24/03/2024 16:35

Bridgertonned · 24/03/2024 13:46

@WitsEnd10 or @colouredball can you get insurance to do the procedure for u16s? Genuinely interested. It would be a lot easier if we could give permission to angry teenagers, I'm not trying to defend it (maybe not a cartilage piercing for an 11yr old but for older ones...)

Absolutely, I’ve always had insurance that covers needle piercings for all ages until I changed career direction two years ago. I personally did lobes 8+, all other ear piercings/nostril/lip 13+ with parent present (also required ID from the child and parent to confirm they’re actually a parent) all other piercings 16+, apart from nipples and genitals 18+.

TempleOfBloom · 24/03/2024 15:32

I would have said no.

If’s a different piercing: through cartilage.

Piercings like that and the look is an adult look. A more advanced body modification for the purpose of your looks, not what I choose to enable in my children.

I didn’t know piercing places did these sort of piercings on children.

Bridgertonned · 24/03/2024 15:28

@Tygertiger that takes me back, had my nose done by them years ago when I was at uni!
I know lobes are low risk so less of an issue for kids, it's similar to how most hairdressers won't use permanent hair dyes on children (untested/uninsured) but many will be ok with doing a balayage or highlights that don't start from the root because there's little chance of a skin reaction then.

Tygertiger · 24/03/2024 15:21

Bridgertonned · 24/03/2024 14:55

Not sure if people are being deliberately obtuse about my point re piercers not using needles on young teens

@bleughgreen I haven't said a good piercer would choose a gun. I've said that in my experience proper piercers - who only use needles - won't do the piercings on u16s because they're not insured. NOT that they would go oh I'm not insured to use a needle so hang on let me grab a shitty Claire's accessories gun instead! They'd just say they wouldn't do it. Good piercers have plenty of business without risking their studio by piercing tweens.

Decent piercers will typically pierce lobes for children from the age of 8 and use needles for those, not a gun. I agree they won’t do any cartilage piercings under 16, but it’s not true they won’t use needles as this is how they will do lobe piercings.

I use Holier Than Thou in Manchester. They will do children’s lobes with a needle from age of 8 and they are very strict on ID. Cartilage piercings are for 16+ and intimate piercings 18+.

Swipe left for the next trending thread