Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think relationships are more work than being single

80 replies

Greenhouse12 · 23/03/2024 20:55

I can admit that I'm slightly cynical being newly single after being in a rubbish relationship for too long.

But I feel as if almost every friend I have has a story about there partner being incompetent. Everytime I go on tiktok I see these videos of women joking about asking their husband to do something simple to help and them not being able to or not knowing basic information like their Childs birthday.

I seen one yesterday about a man who thought his child was vitamin deficient because her nails never grew… he had just never cut them

I know it's not all men and I work with some great ones but recently it just looks more hassle than its worth.

I have two friends who are single mums by choice via IVF and I actually envy them! The only negative is the lack of child support.

Please restore my faith in relationships or if you have any stories about the extra mental load from having a partner

OP posts:
WaltzingWaters · 24/03/2024 07:41

It really depends on the partner. My DP is amazing and does his equal share. I know of many like that, and of course many who are just awful, lazy man-children.

Greenhouse12 · 24/03/2024 07:33

@biscuitsnow actually I'm here so get other peoples opinions not confirm my belief it's been really nice to see the amount of people who've said their partner is their best friend.

I've not given up on dating so hopefully I meet someone like that. From the messages it seems to be just luck of the draw lol

OP posts:
Greenhouse12 · 24/03/2024 07:30

JordanPeterson · 24/03/2024 00:33

When men complain about women’s behaviour online they are labelled misogynists & spreading harmful rhetoric

When women complain about men’s behaviour online they are supported & it’s seen as evidence that men will drag us down in a relationship

Bad relationships are more work than being single, but in general being single is not easier than being in a relationship

Because when you are in a team both players help & complement each other

In the past we had more defined roles so each team member would play to their own strengths & roles were divided + conquered

But today men & women today are seen as needing to be good at the same roles in order to prove their worthiness as a partner

If a woman complains that a man hasn’t cut his daughter’s nails then is he automatically incompetent?

Or is it possible while she is inside cutting baby’s nails that he is busy with some other chore that isn’t her personal strength, like fixing the boiler or up on the roof cleaning the gutters ?

When someone complains about their partner’s ineptitude at a role or task, we only hear one side & may not see a full, realistic picture of the relationship as a whole

I really like that you replied with a different point of view and your point is valid however I think the reason the video I seen about the daughter nails had so many views and reactions is because it's relatable to so many women unfortunately.

Personally my ex has never cut my Childs nails even when asked it's a small task but parenting should be 50/50 he also isn't doing the guttering or climbing the roof.

For a lot most of the contribution is financial but personally I Dont think financially providing makes your partner your servant

OP posts:
BorderBelle · 24/03/2024 06:48

I've been happily with DH for 20 years. We're 40 and 42. No kids.

Yes he adds to my mental load. Nothing I've tried has totally fixed this and I have to say I've slightly given up at this point. As we've not got kids (never wanted them) the mental load isn't huge anyway.
And he's retrained and works away monday-friday now, so I figure with me working mainly from home, I do have more time these days than he does.
Don't get me wrong, it gets me down from time to time.

But he's my best friend, confidante, so supportive and encouraging of anything I want to do at work, he's good to my family and tolerates my difficult mum, he's loyal and trustworthy, and I like the companionship of always having someone there to do things with.

biscuitsnow · 24/03/2024 06:02

YANBU to suggest that relationships take work- when you've been with someone for years it's natural that you both piss each other off sometimes and there will be little bumps along the way. Both of you need to make an effort to work together to sort them out. Relationships do require compromise and effort on both sides.

YABVU by taking your "evidence" from TikTok or a few people you know. Its confirmation bias isnt it- if you look for something, you'll find it. Noone would go on TikTok to say "I have a great husband and all is well" because its boring and mundane and TikTok thrives on drama and people watching and most people wouldnt watch a video like that.

Its a bit like the news- people pay attention to sad and sensationalistic stories far more than stories saying "all is ok" so therefore you never hear about all the great relationships because noone makes a huge thing about them. That makes the crappy, dramatic scenarios seem more common/rife.

Its your reticular activating system- it looks for confirmation of your existing beliefs and ignores the outliers that suggest the opposite.

EcstaticMarmalade · 24/03/2024 05:50

I think all relationships are more work than being single. It’s just that some of them are worth that extra effort. The rewards exceed the costs, and/or they here is a transformative effect where the whole exceeds the sum of the parts.

It’s more and more difficult to achieve that though. Sometimes it because people have bad attitudes, sometimes it’s because they are too just busy and the rest of their lives are too hard. A lot of it is an increasingly transactional attitude to things.

DanielGault · 24/03/2024 03:50

The right relationship isn't hard work. It's different to being single obvs, you have to give and take where you didn't before. But if it's hard work, it's not right. (Imo anyway)

SeriouslyStressed · 24/03/2024 03:45

@CoatRack ok, maybe I should have said "the latest research" instead of "all the research"

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/may/25/women-happier-without-children-or-a-spouse-happiness-expert

(Big studies prior to this were affected by selection bias)

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 24/03/2024 01:26

Been with my husband 21 years. I can’t imagine anything different. He’s my best friend and fab

KattyBoomBoom95 · 24/03/2024 01:21

I don't live with my partner, though. We both like our freedom and it works for us both.

DreamTheMoors · 24/03/2024 01:20

One person = your own bullshit.

Two people = twice the bullshit.

And I can usually tolerate myself lol.

KattyBoomBoom95 · 24/03/2024 01:20

But these types of threads always bring out the disgruntled women so you'll not get a very balanced view.

KattyBoomBoom95 · 24/03/2024 01:18

Well, yes, it's 'easier' but kind of more depressing than being in a good relationship to me. A bit like how not working would probs be easier but also shitter.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 24/03/2024 01:16

I totally agree.. That's why I'm single and my devoted dog is the best male I've ever lived with( sons excepted)

alrightjackie · 24/03/2024 00:46

@JordanPeterson In your experience being in a relationship is easier than being single.

In my experience... it's really not. And as I get older, I'm leaning into my own experiences rather than trying to follow societal norms.

A lot of men complaining about women online are expecting women to change and do their bidding.

I might be complaining about men, but I'm not expecting them to change. I've finally accepted all their limitations and... I've opted out. I see what they have to offer and it doesn't make my life better, so no thank you.

I only think there is an issue in complaining if you expect the other person to magically fit your ideals.

I think men and women are wired very differently, and if you're straight (as I am), that's a problem, as you're going to have to make a lot of compromises to be in a relationship. The older I get, the less I want to compromise. I don't want to take up less space. I want to take up more.

Whether it's all men, or just the men I seem to attract, it doesn't really matter, because the only men in my orbit do not make my life better and I don't want my life to be worse. I need to make my own choices based on what's right for me as a woman with the time I have left on this planet, not based on what's right for all womankind.

Meadowfinch · 24/03/2024 00:40

I'm definitely of the 'relationships are hard work' view.

The men I meet seem to expect I should organise their social lives or cook MasterChef grade meals or be up for weekend travel to Europe.

Somehow they can't see what's right in front of their noses, that I have a career, work full time, and have full time care of my ds for at least another 18 months. I'm offering a warm friendly relationship where we go to the pub at the weekend or see friends locally. Share a companionable pot of chilli and a glass of wine. And a bed. Run ParkRun. Watch a film.

Don't people relax any more? I rush around all week. I just don't need the hassle or the criticism.

JordanPeterson · 24/03/2024 00:33

When men complain about women’s behaviour online they are labelled misogynists & spreading harmful rhetoric

When women complain about men’s behaviour online they are supported & it’s seen as evidence that men will drag us down in a relationship

Bad relationships are more work than being single, but in general being single is not easier than being in a relationship

Because when you are in a team both players help & complement each other

In the past we had more defined roles so each team member would play to their own strengths & roles were divided + conquered

But today men & women today are seen as needing to be good at the same roles in order to prove their worthiness as a partner

If a woman complains that a man hasn’t cut his daughter’s nails then is he automatically incompetent?

Or is it possible while she is inside cutting baby’s nails that he is busy with some other chore that isn’t her personal strength, like fixing the boiler or up on the roof cleaning the gutters ?

When someone complains about their partner’s ineptitude at a role or task, we only hear one side & may not see a full, realistic picture of the relationship as a whole

alrightjackie · 24/03/2024 00:30

I don't know if I'll ever be in a relationship again.

I had a couple of back-to-back serious long-term relationships when I was 18. I fell into them, it was socially normal... I dated for a bit after that, also normal... then I realised I hated it all and stopped looking.

I've been on my own for a long time now and I've done so much better in terms of the quality of my lifestyle and career. I honestly feel that being with a man was holding me back.

When in relationship, I felt pressurised to put him first, subsidise him, do what he wanted to do, look a certain way, adapt my working hours, do all the life admin...

I have complete freedom now.

People say life is cheaper in a relationship. It isn't. I'm only paying for my own choices and I'm now a homeowner with a good job. I haven't inherited a thing, or taken family money - I've got here on my own. The path I took here got quicker to run down when I was single.

I've survived some really horrific things in recent years, and the thing is, I am pretty sure being a relationship would have made it worse. There were a couple of men chasing me at the time and I know they saw my grief as an opportunity to 'win' me. It gave me the ick and they cannot understand why I don't want anything to do with them now.

I just don't think any man who has ever professed to love me really knows what love is. Love is not making myself smaller so a man can take up more space. Or if it is, I reject it. It's not something I want.

I feel like when I was little, I was conditioned to think that being a relationship was something to aim for. Now I'm older, I enjoy having the space to be selfish and put myself first. It's the little things like watching what I want on Netflix and eating what I want to.

I enjoy my own company. And I have an active social life.

Women generally live longer, so if I got married, chances are, I'd still be single on my deathbed.

My friends are between 20 years younger than me and 30 years older than me. I'm sure someone will be left to see me before I die.

StrawberryTwister · 24/03/2024 00:14

Candleabra · 23/03/2024 23:13

For women yes.
Men, no.

Isn't it interesting then that it's mostly women who want relationships / marriage/ babies but men are mostly happy to be single / play the field/ keep options open and not settle down? Seems from everyone I know irl and on here it's mostly women who want relationships funny that

StrawberryTwister · 24/03/2024 00:13

Depends on the partner, I'm a lone parent and I don't find it easier doing everything myself with no partner.

HateMyNewJobSoMuch · 24/03/2024 00:10

I genuinely can't imagine life without my husband. He is completely amazing. We work well as a team together to make each other lives easier.

Yourethebeerthief · 24/03/2024 00:07

I would be utterly lost without my husband. It would be awful to be alone without him.

CoatRack · 24/03/2024 00:04

SeriouslyStressed · 23/03/2024 23:00

All the research shows that (heterosexual) relationships benefit men's physical and mental health and extend their life expectancy but have a detrimental effect on women's physical and mental health and life expectancy.

There will of course be exceptions to this rule, and we are so socialised to want to be in a relationship that we often ignore the adverse impact of relationships on ourselves.

I don't think you've ever actually looked at any research. If you did, you'd know that although men gain the most, marriage increases life expectancy for both men and women.

NewName24 · 23/03/2024 23:28

WhatWhereWho · 23/03/2024 21:01

Depends on the relationship. Personally I would find being with someone who got their opinions on relationships from random people on TikTok too much effort.

This.

Candleabra · 23/03/2024 23:13

For women yes.
Men, no.