Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I’m right that she has far more than most?

131 replies

jealoysgL · 23/03/2024 13:53

I know I’m being unfair. I guess my question is how to deal with this in the family environment. Me and DH are in ok jobs and bring in around 50k between us. I know this is a lot of money and we obviously share our home so we have bills halved too etc. We have one dc.

My sister is on 68k AND is given 1k a month from her ex. Her dc is only in nursery three and a half days a week and so the 1k she is paid basically covers this and all her DD’s expenses. Whenever we go out she doesn’t bat an eyelid at buying coffees or lunch, while we will be bringing sandwiches made at home for example.

What is getting to be is that she pleads poverty all the time. My parents always give her ‘a bit extra’ at Xmas or birthdays because she’s on her own… yet we are clearly struggling much more financially! It’s really hit a nerve recently as she’s been saying she has a savings pot for DD’s future and is aiming to reach 30k by the time dd is 3… she’s already 1.5!!!! We have no savings, always stretched yet at family occasions she is always always seen as the poor single parent. I don’t think she even sees how hard it is for me and dh as she just thinks it must be easier. I am finding it so hard not to say anything and know I will be shot down if I do!!! Would you start to explain actually even as a couple we have less?

OP posts:
woahboy · 23/03/2024 16:02

Snore2024 · 23/03/2024 14:54

Are those figures before or after tax? On 68k she will be paying a lot of tax. Your monthly take homes per household may not be that different, especially as the money from her ex is going on nursery fees so might as well be discounted from the equation.

The OP will have childcare fees also.
The OP has £50k total
Her sister has £68k plus £1-2k monthly. So that's £80-92k a year

She will pay higher rate tax on about £17k

The sister is clearly thousands better off
£50k vs £ 80-92k is massive.

MyOtherCarisAVauxhallZafira · 23/03/2024 16:00

You have twice the potential to earn more, but you've settled with a little more than NMW being decent?

woahboy · 23/03/2024 15:59

@spriots

Dsis will only he on higher rate take for around £17k. She will pay basic on the rest and probably nothing on the £2k per month given to her.

Sweetheart7 · 23/03/2024 15:58

@HesterRoon no it doesn't. It just different problems. Did you not read the poster has her child day in day out. That's besides the point though let's not be bitter. Money doesn't compensate for having no social life as a single parent does it? Being stressed because you need to work and have nobody as back up and your manager will be furious for ringing in sick because of a poorly child.

I don't get as much as 1k from my ex. I would defo take less money to have more of a break! The choice isn't mine though.

Hereyoume · 23/03/2024 15:56

alwaysbuffingnails · 23/03/2024 13:59

You're not in 'ok' jobs if you're only earning minimum wage! Which you must be if you're only earning 25k each.

I'm missing the point of the thread, I know, but I get sick of people on here saying they're on a good wage when they're just on the lowest wage that their employer can get away with paying them!

🙄

Tell that to all the junior doctors and nurses and police officers.

woahboy · 23/03/2024 15:56

OP sorry it's an extra £2k A MONTH. so it more like she's on between £80-92k a year compared to your £50

woahboy · 23/03/2024 15:55

OP id just start making comments on how much harder it is on £50k for you as a family of 3?/4?
And as ds is on £70k with the top ups for a family of 2? It must be so much easier.

Oh how you wish you could afford the things she does.

Speak up ffs

woahboy · 23/03/2024 15:53

@thaegumathteth

Honestly shocked you said that to your parents. There's no way I'd ever determine how my mum spends her money on my siblings or otherwise.
Why are you shocked.

Parents are fully entitled to spend their money as they like. If they choose to favour one dc that is completely their right.

Offspring and fully entitled to engage with or reduce contact with their parents in the basis of how they are treated. If they feel they are being treated poorly it is completely within their rights to go LC

One could just say nothing and then LC or they could do as the poster did and explain the situation and how is is perceived by them and why they feel it is unfair and how they will modify their relationship if this is how the parents are planning to treat them.

Everyone has the agency to communicate and the set their boundaries.

HesterRoon · 23/03/2024 15:42

Meadowfinch · 23/03/2024 14:17

Having it hard doesn't only cover money OP. I earn slightly less then your sil. My ex pays half costs except housing.

But I had ds 350 nights a year. I don't get to go out. I made every decision, did every night, managed every illness, no back up, no break. No easily available babysitter.

It can be relentless and having money in the bank made no difference when my ds was poorly or upset.

So imagine what it’s like being a single parent on a low income-that’s the reality for many women. Earning well cushions your problems significantly.

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 23/03/2024 15:04

I totally get it OP. My younger sister used to do this in her 20s, she lived this really lavish lifestyle, eating out 5 nights a week and takeaways on the other nights, taxis from one place to the next cos she couldn't be bothered walking or getting a bus etc. She then would say she was 'broke' and my parents were supplementing her income saying it was fine for me because I had a house but she was renting. Completely illogical, I had to save for years to get my house deposit then had a mortgage anyways which is why I didn't spend stupid money like she does.

I think OP the money is on some level compensation for her managing everything on her own. Maybe she looks at your life and sees you dividing duties and childminding with DH and feels really envious. Maybe the money is to help with babysitters so she can have some sort of social life but she choses to save it? I'd say there is little you can do, maybe mention your salary to your sister to stop her going on about it though, thats realliy annoying

Jennyjojo5 · 23/03/2024 15:03

I’d be pleased for your sister that she has a good life financially as a single parent. She has managed to break out of being the stereotypical single mum that the media portrays as the scum of the earth and has done well for herself. Be pleased for her

your parents probably recognise that life in general is tougher for her raising a kid alone, compared to you in a (assumption) happy secure relationship (which is true). They probably get pleasure from helping out their granddaughter by giving their mum some extra cash here and there. There is probably also a sense of guilt from the grandparents that the child is growing up in a lone household and therefore they are overcompensating by giving financial gifts.

TheSnowyOwl · 23/03/2024 14:55

Where I am £1k per month wouldn’t cover three days a week at nursery, let alone all of a child’s expenses.

I suspect she includes savings for her DD as part of her outgoing expenses and as a result her disposable income is less than you feel it should be.

Snore2024 · 23/03/2024 14:54

Are those figures before or after tax? On 68k she will be paying a lot of tax. Your monthly take homes per household may not be that different, especially as the money from her ex is going on nursery fees so might as well be discounted from the equation.

pootlin · 23/03/2024 14:53

thaegumathteth · 23/03/2024 14:51

@pootlin I am shocked and judgy about your brother actually. He should sort himself out and stop being dependent on your parents BUT that doesn't mean you get to decide how they spend their cash.

No, I don’t get to decide, but I do get to decide if I continue to do the drudgery of driving over with home cooked meals, driving them to appointments, taking them shopping, making time to give them the relentless demands for company and then see them lavish a £20k car on a feckless son merely because of his sex.

thaegumathteth · 23/03/2024 14:51

@pootlin I am shocked and judgy about your brother actually. He should sort himself out and stop being dependent on your parents BUT that doesn't mean you get to decide how they spend their cash.

pootlin · 23/03/2024 14:50

iamwhatiam23 · 23/03/2024 14:49

@pootlin i can read just fine thanks! If you attached " conditions" to the things you do for your parents then maybe you should just not bother doing them at all? I help out my dp all the time, i have no idea what help/money they give or receive from my brother because i don't care and its absolutely none of my business!

Well have a medal 🥇, because I do care.

I am not you and I don’t care what you do. You have no idea about my life and family so don’t stick your oar in.

KateMiskin · 23/03/2024 14:49

Floofydawg · 23/03/2024 14:47

AND is given 1k a month from her ex.

What you actually mean here is that her ex pays for his kid. He doesn't 'give' your sister money.

Exactly. Extreme envy here. If my sis were a single parent I wouldn't grudge her money. Its an incredibly hard job.

iamwhatiam23 · 23/03/2024 14:49

@pootlin i can read just fine thanks! If you attached " conditions" to the things you do for your parents then maybe you should just not bother doing them at all? I help out my dp all the time, i have no idea what help/money they give or receive from my brother because i don't care and its absolutely none of my business!

Floofydawg · 23/03/2024 14:47

AND is given 1k a month from her ex.

What you actually mean here is that her ex pays for his kid. He doesn't 'give' your sister money.

Lanawashington · 23/03/2024 14:46

Threads like this always baffle me. Dh and I earn £49k between us, I’m 29 and he’s 32. Live in the south west and we consider this a good income. We’re doing a lot better than most of our friends. I know it’s going to go up a bit soon as minimum wage goes up but it’s not like we’re poor or earning a shit wage

mrsdineen2 · 23/03/2024 14:45

thaegumathteth · 23/03/2024 14:08

Honestly shocked you said that to your parents. There's no way I'd ever determine how my mum spends her money on my siblings or otherwise.

OP just let it wash over you. Being pissed off wont do you any good.

My parents had no money to give to me or my sibling, so I don't have a horse in that race.

But I have kids who I love very much. The idea that I'd single one of them out to treat and overspend on at the expense of the others is disgusting.

pootlin · 23/03/2024 14:45

iamwhatiam23 · 23/03/2024 14:44

Wow! You sound like a spoilt brat! Its absolutely none of your business if your parents wish to buy your db a car!

Another one who clearly can’t read competently. Wow just wow 😱

spriots · 23/03/2024 14:44

FriendlyNeighbourhoodAccountant · 23/03/2024 14:41

The chances are as you and your husband each have a personal allowance you are probably, as a household, coming out with a higher net pay than she is each month. So, are you actually begrudging her the amount she receives in child maintenance?

She earns a good wage, instead of complaining maybe you or your husband could focus on increasing your own salaries.

I was going to make this point.

She will be paying higher rate tax and also won't have child benefit.

You have two personal allowances and only pay basic rate tax, will also get child benefit

I think you would be surprised by the results if you put it into a tax calculator.

Also I doubt the £1k maintenance covers all of her DD's costs, it might cover the nursery element

Wooloohooloo · 23/03/2024 14:44

Do you both work full time?

iamwhatiam23 · 23/03/2024 14:44

pootlin · 23/03/2024 14:01

YANBU. Have you told your parents they’re being unfair?

My dad and mum wanted to buy my brother a car recently. Brother lives at home and pays no rent or bills or does any housework.

When my dad mentioned the car I said how unfair it was and that they if they do buy him the car then they can kiss goodbye to me coming over with meals and all the other things I do for them. Which made them back down.

People will tell you it’s your parents money but I don’t accept that children should be treated differently because one child pleads poverty.

Speak to your parents so at least they know that you think they’re being unfair.

Wow! You sound like a spoilt brat! Its absolutely none of your business if your parents wish to buy your db a car!