Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?

637 replies

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 12:36

I try my best to live heathily (although definitely not fanatical). I try and stay away from ultra processed foods, try and avoid saturated fat, too much meat etc., try and exercise every week. I’ll have the odd takeaway and definitely overindulge on wine, but always try and be mindful of living heathily because so much information is constantly battering me through the radio, media etc. about getting ill from various foods and not exercising.

I’ve recently lost my mother far too young too, so I suppose it’s particularly on my mind at the moment. But then you hear Kate’s diagnosis, who obviously exercises regularly, has the best instructors, best food, best ingredients, best preparation, and she still falls ill, and it all seems a bit pointless.

AIBU to feel this way? I just wonder whether I really should make an effort to watch what I eat and run when I don’t feel like it if really, what will be will be regardless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
Delatron · 24/03/2024 12:35

EasternStandard · 24/03/2024 12:29

I think it’s unfair to infer from a diagnosis

In some cases it will very sadly be a childhood diagnosis, in that case lifestyle may not have any impact at all

Although that does not negate population trends, so the op should still strive to be healthy

Edited

Yes that’s my point. It’s unfair to infer anything about her diagnosis so why are people?

Children get cancer, animals get cancer. It’s cells going wrong. It can happen to anyone.

EasternStandard · 24/03/2024 12:29

Delatron · 24/03/2024 12:07

Yes and we see it on here. People can’t accept that the P of W is healthy. Insisting she must have been a heavy smoker, a bad diet (as if - she’s hardly going to be living off takeaways).

We have far less control than we think. You can stack the odds in your favour but no guarantees . But I think it’s so odd that all the people I know who have had cancer have been super healthy. As many on here have said the same. There’s clearly something else going on.

I think it’s unfair to infer from a diagnosis

In some cases it will very sadly be a childhood diagnosis, in that case lifestyle may not have any impact at all

Although that does not negate population trends, so the op should still strive to be healthy

Delatron · 24/03/2024 12:07

Isthisit2 · 24/03/2024 10:19

Also I think there are some people who want to reassure themselves that there’s reasons that people got sick and that they can avoid it . It’s actually awful as it’s almost blaming the person . I mean a huge part of it is genetics and shit luck . I remember my friend who is obsessed with health being shocked over a friend of ours getting throat cancer (non smoker/never drank a drop of alcohol , healthy as you can get) and she kept saying but there must be something, maybe her diet wasn’t great……🙄 It was just a way to reassure themselves when knowing there was no controlling this.
Im not sure if stress plays a part like maybe there’s a link , when I’m stressed I lose weight (I’m already thin) , don’t sleep and maybe don’t put time into proper exercise so that probably does affect my health negatively.
Tbh though I just think it’s one of awful things that usually happens to good people. We are also living way longer .

Yes and we see it on here. People can’t accept that the P of W is healthy. Insisting she must have been a heavy smoker, a bad diet (as if - she’s hardly going to be living off takeaways).

We have far less control than we think. You can stack the odds in your favour but no guarantees . But I think it’s so odd that all the people I know who have had cancer have been super healthy. As many on here have said the same. There’s clearly something else going on.

Quizine · 24/03/2024 11:11

Most things that are enjoyable in life are advised to be BAD for us, but there is no proof of this (Smoking excepted). Those who eat reasonably well but occasionally use packaged ready meals and have take aways at the weekend along with a bottle of something alcoholic are often vilified.

All the nice things are bad therefore many feel guilty and remorseful for that bar of chocolate or bottle of wine. That adds to the stress of life. There are no guarantees and there is far too much lecturing going on with mixed messages about different food types, low carb, high protein, veggie, vegan and so on. None of the regimes is perfect and in fact high protein can affect kidney function for one thing.

So people become obsessed with doing it RIGHT. Or feeling guilty if they perceive they are doing it WRONG. Then they get up at 5 am to do a punishing gym routine, home for breakfast and kids, throw on the washing machine. race around and get to work for a stressful 8-10 hour day. Rinse and repeat at night. It is guilt, worry and wanting to be in control. It doesn't work that way I don't think. Life is a lottery for most of us.

I'm not saying that everyone hates eating well and doing hard exercise at all, that's great if you enjoy it. But for those who don't, why put yourself through that because someone said you should? Go for a walk instead.

The biggest thing we can do for our health long term is to stay within the average weight for height as far as possible. Add a little exercise, enjoy life and off you go. A contented person in the end.

Yazo · 24/03/2024 11:07

She's rich, that doesn't mean healthy. Of course she can ask her chef to make nutritious food, plenty of sleep, exercise, low stress and all the boxes ticked but she could also eat a lot of rubbish, smoke, drink, unhealthy habits. Just because she's rich and thin. But ultimately cancer is no-ones fault, all you can do is give yourself a better chance.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/03/2024 10:46

My mum lived a healthy outdoor life (vetinary nurse and farmers wife), ate home cooked food including plenty of fruit and veg, drank moderately and never smoked. She died from a brain tumor at 46.

I still think living a healthy life is worth it.

Lentilweaver · 24/03/2024 10:41

@CormorantStrikesBack I am not sure about that. I am veggie, DH is not. But even meat eating Indians often eat very little meat, maybe once or twice a week and he eats mostly fish or chicken. No red meat. I expect these habits arose because most people couldn't afford meat.

We don't eat much processed food because we weren't reared on it. Maybe crisps, chocolate and the occasional Coke. We like our veggies and lentils so it's no terrific hardship..What is a hardship is reducing the carbs: rice, parathas and all the other delicious stuff.

CormorantStrikesBack · 24/03/2024 10:36

@Lentilweaver are there higher rates of vegetarianism in British people of Indian descent?

Dh is vegetarian purely to combat cancer risk. He’s read studies saying meat consumption raises the risk.

Lentilweaver · 24/03/2024 10:29

I am of Indian origin, and the cancer rates for British Indians eating an Indian diet are much less than for a traditional British diet. There are studies to that effect. Not just anecdotes.

I think diet plays a huge part, but I also like my traditional foods ( modified to reduce carbs) , so that is a bonus. And now the Zoe diet and the Tulleken brothers have leapt on to that bandwagon of fermented foods and 30 veggies a week, which many of us from other cultures have been doing all our lives.🙄

Isthisit2 · 24/03/2024 10:19

Also I think there are some people who want to reassure themselves that there’s reasons that people got sick and that they can avoid it . It’s actually awful as it’s almost blaming the person . I mean a huge part of it is genetics and shit luck . I remember my friend who is obsessed with health being shocked over a friend of ours getting throat cancer (non smoker/never drank a drop of alcohol , healthy as you can get) and she kept saying but there must be something, maybe her diet wasn’t great……🙄 It was just a way to reassure themselves when knowing there was no controlling this.
Im not sure if stress plays a part like maybe there’s a link , when I’m stressed I lose weight (I’m already thin) , don’t sleep and maybe don’t put time into proper exercise so that probably does affect my health negatively.
Tbh though I just think it’s one of awful things that usually happens to good people. We are also living way longer .

colouredball · 24/03/2024 10:14

@cakeorwine

I do understand, it was just frustratingly pointless and the irony of prolonging one's life as long as possible only for it to turn out a horrific experience at the end isn't lost on me.

Isthisit2 · 24/03/2024 10:10

@Notsuretoputit I know what you mean tbh , I’ve only read your first point but I know everyone will have come back with the obviously true facts that being healthier reduces risks of cancer etc .
My fil smokes like a chimney, proper unfiltered black tobacco and drinks v heavily , he’s had a check up and is in amazing good health and is in his 70’s. Same for some of my family who were heavy smokers (now not ) but zero issues health wise thankfully . The people I know in real life who’ve have died or going through very serious cancer are my friend who is a vegan , non drinker, non smoker , two v v small children ☹️ I knew a guy growing up who was a professional athlete, died in his 30’s of aggressive form of cancer . Obviously this is antidotal so means absolutely nothing. I can’t remember the celebrity recently diagnosed with cancer but I read in the paper how she had gone through some v specific tests and had a mammogram the year before and all clear and now she has just been diagnosed with bc, also v fit and healthy.
I do think we have way way less control over our lives that we think we do tbh ….
The only thing I’ve ever seen any correlation with is it’s all the good people who get screwed over in this life…

cakeorwine · 24/03/2024 10:06

LoreleiG · 24/03/2024 09:56

The sun is a directly proven link for skin cancer but even so, getting it is bad luck. I agree that a healthy lifestyle is the best hope of cancer prevention but at the
same time it is often unknown what causes it and people who get cancer are not necessarily unhealthy.

Bad luck?
Not really - exposing yourself to the sun and developing skin cancer is not bad luck. It's more a case of shit happens, I knew the risks (maybe not when young) and I developed skin cancer.

Of course people who get cancer are not necessarily unhealthy. Genetics plays a part.

If you lead an unhealthy lifestyle and you develop a disease associated with that unhealthy lifestyle, then I wouldn't say that it's down to bad luck. I would say that you helped load the dice against yourself. It's unfair that some people can lead an unhealthy lifestyle but not get ill, and others can lead the same lifestyle but do get ill. It's unfair that people can lead a healthy lifestyle but get ill.

But a good way to load the dice in your favour is to lead a healthy lifestyle and the way to load the dice against yourself is to lead an unhealthy lifestyle.

At the same time, life is for living and there are pleasures to be had in life that sometimes you have to indulge in.

cakeorwine · 24/03/2024 10:00

colouredball · 24/03/2024 09:34

My nanna did everything she could to live a long and healthy life. She did. Except when she got into her 90s and got dementia we had months of hell trying to access care for her and even then it wasn't at all good enough. She deserved much better. I was secretly (joking) fuming at her for doing all she could to live so long. In the end it wasn't worth it. Dementia is degrading and dehumanising.

So yeah, I kind of get the point OP

If you knew that eating certain foods would reduce the chances of getting dementia, would you follow it?

Can a healthy diet reduce your dementia risk? - Heart Matters - BHF

Your nanna developed dementia even though she followed a healthy lifestyle. But there are going to be other people who could have developed dementia but they did follow the same healthy lifestyle and did not develop dementia. A healthy lifestyle can reduce the chances of developing dementia on a population scale.

If she had not followed a healthy lifestyle, she would have been more likely to have had other debilitating diseases when younger that could have ended her life sooner or made her 60s, 70s and 80s more difficult as she could have had health issues.

Can a healthy diet reduce your dementia risk?

Research suggests there’s a diet that may help to prevent dementia. Our Senior Dietitian Victoria Taylor explains.

https://www.bhf.org.uk/informationsupport/heart-matters-magazine/nutrition/dementia-diet

LoreleiG · 24/03/2024 09:56

cakeorwine · 24/03/2024 00:11

I got skin cancer. I think it's very likely I got it from sun exposure. I take measures now to reduce my exposure to sun.

Is there blame involved? Or was it me exposing myself to sun, which does increase DNA damage and can lead to skin cancer?

If someone has an unhealthy lifestyle and develops an illness associated with that lifestyle, is that bad luck? Just a role of the dice? Or did the lifestyle load the dice?

The sun is a directly proven link for skin cancer but even so, getting it is bad luck. I agree that a healthy lifestyle is the best hope of cancer prevention but at the
same time it is often unknown what causes it and people who get cancer are not necessarily unhealthy.

BMW6 · 24/03/2024 09:51

I think you need to balance having a healthy lifestyle and actually enjoying your life.

No point in doing all the "right" things 100% of the time but having a joyless existence.

So have a little crispy chicken skin now and then.
The pleasure may not add days to your life, but enjoyment of life can't be measured.

colouredball · 24/03/2024 09:34

WoodBurningStov · 24/03/2024 08:25

That's a bit like saying you might as well smoke because we all die anyway. Healthy living will increase your chances of having a longer life. Doesn't guarantee anything tho.

My nanna did everything she could to live a long and healthy life. She did. Except when she got into her 90s and got dementia we had months of hell trying to access care for her and even then it wasn't at all good enough. She deserved much better. I was secretly (joking) fuming at her for doing all she could to live so long. In the end it wasn't worth it. Dementia is degrading and dehumanising.

So yeah, I kind of get the point OP

WoodBurningStov · 24/03/2024 08:25

That's a bit like saying you might as well smoke because we all die anyway. Healthy living will increase your chances of having a longer life. Doesn't guarantee anything tho.

User14March · 24/03/2024 07:35

@ThePotholeHelpline true, although there is a lot of luxury, loving parents & second homes etc to mitigate. By that token many have to deal with debilitating stress.

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 24/03/2024 06:54

@crossingbridges - but we don’t actually know she’s eats healthily and exercises regularly, we know she’d thin, but nothing about the quality of food she’s eating, if she is eating a balance of foods and lots of veg, if she drinks heavily etc. she’s not particularly muscular, so exercise is a guess as well. We have no idea what drugs she’s taken over the years (legal or otherwise)

she may well do, but it’s guess work that thin equals healthy choices.

ThePotholeHelpline · 24/03/2024 00:27

who obviously exercises regularly, has the best instructors, best food, best ingredients

you don't know all of this for sure

Also, stress. Being a royal is (apparently) highly stressful due to the intense and constant scrutiny. Stress is a huge factor in disease.

DiscoBeat · 24/03/2024 00:26

That's not a good POV. Yes you can be extremely unlucky and get ill despite all the best care. But deliberately living an unhealthy lifestyle is adding more likely risk on top.

tothelefttotheleft · 24/03/2024 00:21

Thankyou @samarrange

cakeorwine · 24/03/2024 00:11

LoreleiG · 24/03/2024 00:07

I know what you mean OP. Cancer is bloody bad luck. I hate discussions about what causes it (beyond directly proven links) because it feels like blame.

I got skin cancer. I think it's very likely I got it from sun exposure. I take measures now to reduce my exposure to sun.

Is there blame involved? Or was it me exposing myself to sun, which does increase DNA damage and can lead to skin cancer?

If someone has an unhealthy lifestyle and develops an illness associated with that lifestyle, is that bad luck? Just a role of the dice? Or did the lifestyle load the dice?

LoreleiG · 24/03/2024 00:07

I know what you mean OP. Cancer is bloody bad luck. I hate discussions about what causes it (beyond directly proven links) because it feels like blame.

Swipe left for the next trending thread