Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?

637 replies

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 12:36

I try my best to live heathily (although definitely not fanatical). I try and stay away from ultra processed foods, try and avoid saturated fat, too much meat etc., try and exercise every week. I’ll have the odd takeaway and definitely overindulge on wine, but always try and be mindful of living heathily because so much information is constantly battering me through the radio, media etc. about getting ill from various foods and not exercising.

I’ve recently lost my mother far too young too, so I suppose it’s particularly on my mind at the moment. But then you hear Kate’s diagnosis, who obviously exercises regularly, has the best instructors, best food, best ingredients, best preparation, and she still falls ill, and it all seems a bit pointless.

AIBU to feel this way? I just wonder whether I really should make an effort to watch what I eat and run when I don’t feel like it if really, what will be will be regardless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
Polishedshoesalways · 24/03/2024 14:49

The link to stress is possible but I wonder if they are the same people too busy to see the doctor.

Meat is a known carcinogen. It’s normalised in our society but probably wouldn’t pass any current safety test.

cakeorwine · 24/03/2024 14:49

Delatron · 24/03/2024 14:38

I think there’s a difference between saying that she is healthy and has a healthy lifestyle versus implying that she is a chain smoker, eats crap, is too thin etc.

People don’t seem to understand that anyone can get cancer. Being healthy doesn’t protect you. But then that leads to people insisting she isn’t healthy (because they need to believe it can’t happen to them)- that her Dukan diet is to blame. That is wrong.

Saying it’s a worry that you can do everything right and still get cancer is a discussion point. And like someone pointed out - cancers in the under 50s have increased by 80%. I bet you still have people insisting that’s all down to crap diets and smoking.

Interesting statistic

Always good to look at the source

Study points to big surge in under-50 cancer cases - BBC News

"The number of cancer cases among the under-50s around the world appears to have risen sharply in the past 30 years, a study suggests.
Research published in BMJ Oncology found there had been 3.26 million cases in 2019 - 79% more than in 1990.
But experts cautioned against reading too much into the findings
The research did not take into account a 40% rise in the total population, while factors such as better reporting may also have played a role
The team, of experts from around the world, including the US, China and the UK, agreed no firm conclusions could be drawn.
But they were concerned lifestyle factors - including excess weight, diets high in red meat and salt and physical inactivity - could be pushing cancer cases up among 14- to 49-year-olds."

And

Cancer cases in under-50s worldwide up nearly 80% in three decades, study finds | Cancer | The Guardian

Genetic factors are likely to have a role, the researchers said. But diets high in red meat and salt and low in fruit and milk, along with alcohol and tobacco use, are the main risk factors underlying the most common cancers among under-50s, with physical inactivity, excess weight and high blood sugar contributory factors, the data indicates.
Dr Claire Knight, a senior health information manager at Cancer Research UK, which was not involved in the study, said it was not yet clear what was driving the trend and urged caution.
“However alarming this might seem, cancer is primarily a disease of older age, with the majority of new cancer cases worldwide being diagnosed in those aged 50 and above,” she said. “We need more research to examine the causes of early onset cancer for specific cancer types, like our BCAN-RAY study that is looking at new ways to identify younger women at higher risk of breast cancer.

“If people are concerned about their cancer risk, there are lots of ways to help reduce this such as not smoking, maintaining a balanced diet, getting plenty of exercise and staying safe in the sun.”

It would have been more useful to use the word rate / cancers per 100,000 population instead of arbitrary figures - the population in 1990 is very different to that in 2023

Nurse with patient making mammogram

Study points to big surge in under-50 cancer cases

Cases in under-50s jump 79% since 1990 but population rise and better reporting are likely factors.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66721566

Polishedshoesalways · 24/03/2024 14:48

Cancer can happen and most likely will happen to most of us. The variation will be age.

Delatron · 24/03/2024 14:38

I think there’s a difference between saying that she is healthy and has a healthy lifestyle versus implying that she is a chain smoker, eats crap, is too thin etc.

People don’t seem to understand that anyone can get cancer. Being healthy doesn’t protect you. But then that leads to people insisting she isn’t healthy (because they need to believe it can’t happen to them)- that her Dukan diet is to blame. That is wrong.

Saying it’s a worry that you can do everything right and still get cancer is a discussion point. And like someone pointed out - cancers in the under 50s have increased by 80%. I bet you still have people insisting that’s all down to crap diets and smoking.

Polishedshoesalways · 24/03/2024 14:35

I immediately assumed it was the high level of stress she has been living with for decades. The pressure must be unbearable at times. My healthy slim BIL died of cancer - also high stress lifestyle. Further study and research is needed, but that’s the most likely to cause serious illness. High levels of cortisol and the central nervous system running continuously at maximum capacity.

OutsideLookingOut · 24/03/2024 14:09

Delatron · 24/03/2024 13:11

You shouldn’t be speculating how healthy someone is after a cancer diagnosis. There really is nothing more to it than that.

Then this whole thread is wrong and everyone replying to it is speculating because it is called "To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?" i.e. implying she was healthy in the first place.

Furthermore the fact is that many people do judge people especially the overweight/obese but slimmer people don't face the same judgement. In truth we should not be judging people but not allowing people to pint out slim =/ healthy is just trying to silence people.

Mirabai · 24/03/2024 13:52

Furtling · 24/03/2024 13:23

I’ve never had Covid (to my knowledge!). I have had the vaccine though and have speculated as to whether this was a contributing factor.

Interesting. Research indicates it’s the spike protein specifically triggering the cardiovascular damage in Covid. I guess the spike protein in either form - viral or mrna coded - could potentially cause similar issues. But that would take an awful lot of research to evaluate.

Anyway, I’m sorry to hear your experience, I hope you’re ok.

Mirabai · 24/03/2024 13:48

13luckyforsomeone · 24/03/2024 13:25

Absolutely missing the point we were making about randoms putting forward the cause of an illness. To the point where I wasn’t sure whether you were being satirical with your response.

You know what you can do with your ‘hth’.

Covid is a known risk factor for cardiovascular sequelae. Saying a link is “possible” is not determining it as a cause. And everyone is random on here.

Babyroobs · 24/03/2024 13:41

Fireangels · 24/03/2024 12:45

That’s really interesting. Statistically, people of South Asian descent are more likely to develop type 2 diabetes. When I asked during a work training course if this was as a result of their genetics, I was told possibly, but more likely to be because their traditional diets are high in fat - particularly ghee.

I have two asian colleagues in my office, both diabetic, both very slim, one does snack on sugary foods and samosas and things a lot of the time. I live in an area where half the population are origin and the rates of diabetes and cardiovascular disease are huge.

0sm0nthus · 24/03/2024 13:27

Furtling · 24/03/2024 13:23

I’ve never had Covid (to my knowledge!). I have had the vaccine though and have speculated as to whether this was a contributing factor.

I know of a woman who died of a heart attack very shortly after having the vaccine. She was extremely overweight, presumably that was part of the reason she didn't survive the heart attack.

13luckyforsomeone · 24/03/2024 13:25

Absolutely missing the point we were making about randoms putting forward the cause of an illness. To the point where I wasn’t sure whether you were being satirical with your response.

You know what you can do with your ‘hth’.

Furtling · 24/03/2024 13:23

Mirabai · 24/03/2024 13:12

Covid is a vascular disease as well as a respiratory one. It’s possible that it was a longer term consequence of Covid.

I’ve never had Covid (to my knowledge!). I have had the vaccine though and have speculated as to whether this was a contributing factor.

Mirabai · 24/03/2024 13:21

13luckyforsomeone · 24/03/2024 13:14

Covid is a vascular disease as well as a respiratory one. It’s possible that it was a longer term consequence of Covid.

😂😂 Quick @Furtling , call your cardiologist!

https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.2147/VHRM.S355410

hth

13luckyforsomeone · 24/03/2024 13:14

Covid is a vascular disease as well as a respiratory one. It’s possible that it was a longer term consequence of Covid.

😂😂 Quick @Furtling , call your cardiologist!

Mirabai · 24/03/2024 13:12

Furtling · 24/03/2024 13:00

I had a heart attack last year at 47. According to the cardiologist I’m just the unlucky one person in one million who had one for no reason at all. I’ve always eaten healthily, cooked from scratch almost all the time, watched my saturated fat intake, never smoked, exercised a lot and kept my BMI between 18-19. I still had a massive heart attack known as a widow-maker due to its severity. I hope that my previous good health helped me bounce back quickly and kept my heart undamaged.

I had to listen to people (who didn’t necessarily even know me!) telling me that it ‘must have been’ my high cholesterol that caused it (I didn’t have high cholesterol) or that my diet/stress levels must have been responsible. If the cardiologist couldn’t pinpoint the cause, I can’t imagine a random stranger would have much luck either!

I am even more careful now, in the hope that should anything else happen in the future I am in the best position to deal with it. Unfortunately crappy things happen to anybody and you can’t always mitigate against them - you just have to ensure you are in a good position to fight off whatever happens to you.

Edited

Covid is a vascular disease as well as a respiratory one. It’s possible that it was a longer term consequence of Covid.

Delatron · 24/03/2024 13:11

OutsideLookingOut · 24/03/2024 12:41

No two things can be true at once. We can admit that we don’t really know how healthy she is and that even if you are healthy you can get cancer.

You shouldn’t be speculating how healthy someone is after a cancer diagnosis. There really is nothing more to it than that.

13luckyforsomeone · 24/03/2024 13:05

Oh @Furtling I’m so with you there - some people think they know so much about (my) cancer, I feel like telling them to get in touch with an oncologist because medical science really needs to hear their input!

To your very good health!

Furtling · 24/03/2024 13:00

I had a heart attack last year at 47. According to the cardiologist I’m just the unlucky one person in one million who had one for no reason at all. I’ve always eaten healthily, cooked from scratch almost all the time, watched my saturated fat intake, never smoked, exercised a lot and kept my BMI between 18-19. I still had a massive heart attack known as a widow-maker due to its severity. I hope that my previous good health helped me bounce back quickly and kept my heart undamaged.

I had to listen to people (who didn’t necessarily even know me!) telling me that it ‘must have been’ my high cholesterol that caused it (I didn’t have high cholesterol) or that my diet/stress levels must have been responsible. If the cardiologist couldn’t pinpoint the cause, I can’t imagine a random stranger would have much luck either!

I am even more careful now, in the hope that should anything else happen in the future I am in the best position to deal with it. Unfortunately crappy things happen to anybody and you can’t always mitigate against them - you just have to ensure you are in a good position to fight off whatever happens to you.

CurlewKate · 24/03/2024 12:56

A lot of cancers are genetic-you can't protect yourself from them. But there are many you can reduce your risk of.

Also, we have no idea about the POW's life style.

Lentilweaver · 24/03/2024 12:53

I dont cook with ghee any more either @Fireangels. Also cut out all the fried snacks like samosas. Just kept the veggies and lentils part of my trad diet😀
I think most people cook with vegetable oil these days. Genetics does play a huge part in Type 2 diabetes, I think.

All that said, I think the PoW has just been unlucky, as millions are.

0sm0nthus · 24/03/2024 12:52

I knew a guy growing up who was a professional athlete, died in his 30’s of aggressive form of cancer
I think it's likely that being professional athlete can have a negative effect on your health compared to being someone who exercises in a more moderate way.

And there is this
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2021/jun/11/scientists-link-intense-exercise-with-mnd-risk-in-some-people-motor-neurone-disease
scientists described how they analysed data from the UK Biobank project, which holds detailed genetic and lifestyle information on half a million people. They found that people with a genetic makeup that made them more likely to do strenuous exercise were also more likely to have developed MND.
With vigorous exercise, activity levels changed for many of the genes linked to the condition, while individuals with a mutation that accounts for 10% of MND developed the disease earlier if they took part in regular, high-intensity exercise.

More is not always better!

Scientists link intense exercise with MND risk in some people

Those with a certain genetic makeup more likely to develop motor neurone disease, study confirms

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2021/jun/11/scientists-link-intense-exercise-with-mnd-risk-in-some-people-motor-neurone-disease

Fireangels · 24/03/2024 12:45

Lentilweaver · 24/03/2024 10:29

I am of Indian origin, and the cancer rates for British Indians eating an Indian diet are much less than for a traditional British diet. There are studies to that effect. Not just anecdotes.

I think diet plays a huge part, but I also like my traditional foods ( modified to reduce carbs) , so that is a bonus. And now the Zoe diet and the Tulleken brothers have leapt on to that bandwagon of fermented foods and 30 veggies a week, which many of us from other cultures have been doing all our lives.🙄

That’s really interesting. Statistically, people of South Asian descent are more likely to develop type 2 diabetes. When I asked during a work training course if this was as a result of their genetics, I was told possibly, but more likely to be because their traditional diets are high in fat - particularly ghee.

OutsideLookingOut · 24/03/2024 12:41

Delatron · 24/03/2024 12:07

Yes and we see it on here. People can’t accept that the P of W is healthy. Insisting she must have been a heavy smoker, a bad diet (as if - she’s hardly going to be living off takeaways).

We have far less control than we think. You can stack the odds in your favour but no guarantees . But I think it’s so odd that all the people I know who have had cancer have been super healthy. As many on here have said the same. There’s clearly something else going on.

No two things can be true at once. We can admit that we don’t really know how healthy she is and that even if you are healthy you can get cancer.

Delatron · 24/03/2024 12:40

EasternStandard · 24/03/2024 12:38

Yes completely agree with you, I should have said that

I also find it not very nice if someone is suffering to have the unhealthy accusation a further stress on top

Yes it’s not very nice at all. I can’t believe what I am reading on here.

EasternStandard · 24/03/2024 12:38

Delatron · 24/03/2024 12:35

Yes that’s my point. It’s unfair to infer anything about her diagnosis so why are people?

Children get cancer, animals get cancer. It’s cells going wrong. It can happen to anyone.

Yes completely agree with you, I should have said that

I also find it not very nice if someone is suffering to have the unhealthy accusation a further stress on top