Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?

637 replies

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 12:36

I try my best to live heathily (although definitely not fanatical). I try and stay away from ultra processed foods, try and avoid saturated fat, too much meat etc., try and exercise every week. I’ll have the odd takeaway and definitely overindulge on wine, but always try and be mindful of living heathily because so much information is constantly battering me through the radio, media etc. about getting ill from various foods and not exercising.

I’ve recently lost my mother far too young too, so I suppose it’s particularly on my mind at the moment. But then you hear Kate’s diagnosis, who obviously exercises regularly, has the best instructors, best food, best ingredients, best preparation, and she still falls ill, and it all seems a bit pointless.

AIBU to feel this way? I just wonder whether I really should make an effort to watch what I eat and run when I don’t feel like it if really, what will be will be regardless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
Notsuretoputit · 25/03/2024 17:55

OldMam · 25/03/2024 12:37

Yes, that’s the myth, still being perpetuated, still lingering in the mainstream, still causing harm, but based on faulty, interest-driven bad science. Saturated fat is perfectly healthy, ‘high cholesterol’ is not life-threatening. They want you to take statins. They want you to eat ultra processed petrochemical by-products instead of butter . Course they do. Be sceptical. Read more widely. https://books.google.co.uk/books?hl=en&lr=&id=l6sEEAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=cholesterol+misinformation&ots=FQxwcozOsY&sig=7ML_em7Y0QbFVO6UlyxnsJXE_0o&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=cholesterol%20misinformation&f=false

But why does it have to be ultra processed spreads or butter? Butter is better than ultra processed spreads, yes, but it is not a health food and too much of it, too much of any saturated fat, isn’t good for your health.

OP posts:
Notsuretoputit · 25/03/2024 17:54

Delatron · 25/03/2024 14:21

Yep. I wouldn’t be looking to the NHS for diet advice and guidelines.

Butter is better than ultra processed margarine. Fat is fine, we need fat. It’s sugar we should be more concerned about. They focus on the wrong things.

In low fat foods they replace fat with sugar. They don’t fill you up and leave you hungry again (plus a sugar crash).

I’m highly suspicious of the amount of people supposedly who need statins (especially young, otherwise healthy people). Big side effects. Especially on gut health. Meanwhile lots of profits for those pharma companies.

I agree that butter is better than ultra processed spreads. But that doesn’t mean butter is good for you.

Fat is fine. We do need fat. But we can get it from fatty fish, avocados, olive oil, nuts etc. as opposed to butter, cream, pork belly etc.

Whole foods are fine in moderation, but too much saturated fat isn’t good for you.

OP posts:
Delatron · 25/03/2024 17:51

Nextdoor55 · 25/03/2024 17:28

It's definitely precautionary, not minor but not many I mean. Widely reported.

I don’t think you understand what precautionary means with chemo. It means a tumour was found and surgery removed the tumour and further tests will have shown no spread. So the chemo is mopping up any cells that you might not see circulating.

Rather than using chemo to shrink the tumour.

Nextdoor55 · 25/03/2024 17:28

DillDanding · 24/03/2024 22:40

Where are you getting this info from? She didn’t say ‘minor cells’ were found?

It's definitely precautionary, not minor but not many I mean. Widely reported.

Quizine · 25/03/2024 15:43

There's a lot of stress involved in trying to figure out what's good for me today, because tomorrow it's usually the opposite!

HesterRoon · 25/03/2024 15:21

If you’re trying to be healthy, I wouldn’t eat too much butter. High sat fat is linked to CAD. You don’t have to eat margarine all the time-you can have nut butters and olive/fruit oils. So it doesn’t have to be butter or margarine. Bit of butter plus oil is the way to go.

Delatron · 25/03/2024 14:21

OldMam · 25/03/2024 12:37

Yes, that’s the myth, still being perpetuated, still lingering in the mainstream, still causing harm, but based on faulty, interest-driven bad science. Saturated fat is perfectly healthy, ‘high cholesterol’ is not life-threatening. They want you to take statins. They want you to eat ultra processed petrochemical by-products instead of butter . Course they do. Be sceptical. Read more widely. https://books.google.co.uk/books?hl=en&lr=&id=l6sEEAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=cholesterol+misinformation&ots=FQxwcozOsY&sig=7ML_em7Y0QbFVO6UlyxnsJXE_0o&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=cholesterol%20misinformation&f=false

Yep. I wouldn’t be looking to the NHS for diet advice and guidelines.

Butter is better than ultra processed margarine. Fat is fine, we need fat. It’s sugar we should be more concerned about. They focus on the wrong things.

In low fat foods they replace fat with sugar. They don’t fill you up and leave you hungry again (plus a sugar crash).

I’m highly suspicious of the amount of people supposedly who need statins (especially young, otherwise healthy people). Big side effects. Especially on gut health. Meanwhile lots of profits for those pharma companies.

Debaura55 · 25/03/2024 14:13

Meat fat water and salt

Debaura55 · 25/03/2024 14:12

Jordan Peterson carnivore diet

OldMam · 25/03/2024 12:37

Justpontificating · 25/03/2024 11:51

NHS guidelines on fats
‘ as part of a healthy diet you should cut down on saturated fats and trans fats and replace with unsaturated fats ‘

Yes, that’s the myth, still being perpetuated, still lingering in the mainstream, still causing harm, but based on faulty, interest-driven bad science. Saturated fat is perfectly healthy, ‘high cholesterol’ is not life-threatening. They want you to take statins. They want you to eat ultra processed petrochemical by-products instead of butter . Course they do. Be sceptical. Read more widely. https://books.google.co.uk/books?hl=en&lr=&id=l6sEEAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=cholesterol+misinformation&ots=FQxwcozOsY&sig=7ML_em7Y0QbFVO6UlyxnsJXE_0o&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=cholesterol%20misinformation&f=false

The Great Cholesterol Myth, Revised and Expanded

The best-selling book on heart disease, updated with the latest research and clinical findings on high-fat/ketogenic diets, sugar, genetics, and other factors. Heart disease is the #1 killer. However, traditional heart disease protocols—with their emph...

https://books.google.co.uk/books?hl=en&lr=&id=l6sEEAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP1&dq=cholesterol+misinformation&ots=FQxwcozOsY&sig=7ML_em7Y0QbFVO6UlyxnsJXE_0o&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=cholesterol%20misinformation&f=false

TorroFerney · 25/03/2024 12:32

User35352662 · 23/03/2024 14:10

I don't think any mother of three young children can truly be healthy on all fronts. People love to underplay the colossal impact having children has on woman's mental and physical health. Just think of the stress and sleep deprivation that nearly 10 years of being pregnant and juggling babies/toddlers brings. It's absolutely not comparable to a person without any children who has every single day to themselves and can sleep for as long as they want or schedule downtime whenever they feel like they need a break.

She also has immense pressure to appear immaculate and perfect during all work engagements so any time away from the kids is spent on grooming, makeup, hair etc. In the real world, most mums are willing to look a bit slobby in public if it means skipping hair and makeup so you can enjoy a few more minutes to yourself.

You can eat healthy all you want but it doesn't compensate for much if you're chronically sleep-deprived or under stress. Certain phases of life (eg being a mum) are fundamentally not compatible with being in a perfect state of mental and physical rest.

Agree - and some dickheads on this site have contributed / and carry on contributing to that stress with all the awful questions and conjecture as they pay their tenner a year in tax or whatever and think they have a right to her medical details . I bet her cortisol was off the scale when she was recording that tv message which i can't imagine is conducive to recovery.

Sunshineandrainbows23 · 25/03/2024 12:30

mindutopia · 25/03/2024 12:04

I wouldn't necessarily consider her to have a healthy lifestyle though. Yes, she is slender, but what does she eat? You can have all the private chefs you want, but if someone is existing on celery and diet shakes and herbal teas, that's not a healthy diet. Not saying that's what the PoW eats, but thin doesn't mean healthy.

Also do not discount the huge implications of stress on the development of chronic illness. The stress of constantly being watched, followed, your every move analysed, having to have nannies and protection officers trained to shield your children from a targeted attack just so they can safely get to school every day and back. Money can't undo the stress of living a life in a fishbowl. Just look at her being off due to illness and treatment, the world press had her being in a coma and abducted by aliens. The mind-body connection in development of chronic illness, including cancer, is no joke. It doesn't surprise me at all that she's ill.

Yes, exactly@mindutopia ... Of course the PoW doesn't have to worry about putting food on her table or keeping a roof over her head, but I can't imagine the stress of living in that kind of goldfish bowl. Every smile or wave dissected for public consumption. I wouldn't be able to cope with it. I've often heard people with cancer, when they've discovered it probably started at a particular time in their life, have then realised it correlated with something awful happening to them - the loss of a business, a job, bullying or whatever. The stressor might be different but it affects us all.

I hope that something that comes from this sad experience is that with the PoW's knowledge and interest in mental health, the mind body connection will be appreciated more - for all our sakes ...

And yes, thin doesn't necessarily mean healthy. Dr Goldner, who I talked about in my previous post, often says she has people who look like they have the perfect bodies come and see her - a six pack or whatever, but their dreadful diet that they thought was healthy, to enable them to look like that was actually killing them. Typically kidney issues with body builders as they usually eat so much meat ... I get really frustrated when people just assume thin equals a healthy diet ...

mindutopia · 25/03/2024 12:04

I wouldn't necessarily consider her to have a healthy lifestyle though. Yes, she is slender, but what does she eat? You can have all the private chefs you want, but if someone is existing on celery and diet shakes and herbal teas, that's not a healthy diet. Not saying that's what the PoW eats, but thin doesn't mean healthy.

Also do not discount the huge implications of stress on the development of chronic illness. The stress of constantly being watched, followed, your every move analysed, having to have nannies and protection officers trained to shield your children from a targeted attack just so they can safely get to school every day and back. Money can't undo the stress of living a life in a fishbowl. Just look at her being off due to illness and treatment, the world press had her being in a coma and abducted by aliens. The mind-body connection in development of chronic illness, including cancer, is no joke. It doesn't surprise me at all that she's ill.

Sunshineandrainbows23 · 25/03/2024 11:55

Although I'm a big believer in lifestyle medicine, it's because I was once so very ill that I am passionate about it. When people say "You gotta live" as I'm eating my salad, it's like "Well, yes, that's what I'm trying to do!"

Few of us have been lucky enough to have been fed "perfectly" from birth - things that our mothers were taught to feed us up on such as milk to make us grow, is now known to contribute towards hormonal cancers in both men and women. Meat is a carcinogen but we were all fed the we need meat protein to be big and strong. Parents just doing their best . Few of us have never experienced pollution, stress, even if we are doing our very best now, and even those who eat badly often have reasons for it. Some people think they are eating healthily when they are eating cancer causing foods. So we should never judge sickness. Just feel grateful it's not us.

One amazing Dr who reversed herself from Lupus, Dr Brooke Goldner, and now helps others reverse various chronic illnesses using a strict nutritional protocol (needed to get results) and teaching stress management techniques, always says just do it while getting on and enjoying the rest of your life. She attributes a "cheese addiction" Mac Cheese and Pizza :) as a child to triggering a genetic disposition, but she's been Lupus free for about 17 years after changing her diet. She is especially remarkable as she just lost a child in a terrible car accident but says this has given her the impetus to save others lives as she wasn't given a chance to save her son. She has helped transform thousands of peoples lives who were told there was nothing more that could be done by mainstream medicine.

I just see it as if you are given an opportunity to live a better life if not necessarily a longer one through life style choices, then that's a gift. Some of us were blessed with better genes, but we can all do what we can. Empowerment not judgment or victim blaming. Any person who is seriously ill has enough to contend with already. It's up to everyone to find our and make their own choices though. No judgement.

Justpontificating · 25/03/2024 11:51

OldMam · 25/03/2024 10:41

There is NOTHING wrong with saturated fat! That was a myth put about by the food industry to make their ultra processed junk sound ‘healthy’. Just saying.

NHS guidelines on fats
‘ as part of a healthy diet you should cut down on saturated fats and trans fats and replace with unsaturated fats ‘

To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?
To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?
To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?
Quatty · 25/03/2024 10:47

She could be downing 6 double gins every night, for all you know. God knows I would if I had to lead that life…

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 25/03/2024 10:45

Agreed. Butter is a hell of a lot better for you than the ultra-processed spreads that are marketed as healthy.

OldMam · 25/03/2024 10:41

There is NOTHING wrong with saturated fat! That was a myth put about by the food industry to make their ultra processed junk sound ‘healthy’. Just saying.

Quizine · 25/03/2024 10:37

I well remember a couple of years ago being whipped into A+E with cardiac symptoms. I was diagnosed eventually with Afib which in itself is not life threatening, but unless blood thinners are taken it can lead to stroke.

Anyway I got the fright of my life, had all the tests etc. and asked the doc if I was in danger of any cardiac issues like heart attack etc. He turned around and said "no, but something else will get you in the end!"

willWillSmithsmith · 25/03/2024 08:15

x2boys · 24/03/2024 20:24

It's sadly the luck of the draw my cousin died of cancer at 24 she had malignant melanoma when she was 17 no reason she was a typical.17 year old ,it was removed and she was apparently cured 7 years later she started d getting migranes and an mri scan found the cancer had returned and had metastised to her brain there was no cure
She did smoke but so do a lot of young people but she was otherwise young and healthy she was given 12 months and died 13 months later
Children die of cancer it's very sad but it's indiscriminate.

I know, that’s what makes it so scary, there’s no guarantee how you live will guard you against it. I’ve had cancer myself (when I was in my thirties) and it turned out I have a cancer gene which puts my risk at 80% higher than the average person 😕 So I’ve already had it, plus preventive surgery to remove future high risks. I know it’ll probably get me in the end I just hope it won’t be for very many more years.

SpaghettiWithaYeti · 25/03/2024 07:25

anon666 · 24/03/2024 22:57

So much blame is apportioned to people for lifestyle risks to health.

It's just not like that. Whilst statistically certain behavioural factors may influence risk, for any one human they aren't a guarantee of longer life.

Longevity isn't a moral issue, nor are behavioural factors in healthcare. Many people preserve their bodies, then sadly fall victim to alzheimers and end up dependent on long term social care.

Live your life how you see fit, them accept that you're rolling the dice with death to an extent anyway.

Yiu can see it on here, people desperately clutching for reason Kate might have actually been unhealthy behind the scenes so it's "her fault" rather than misfortune.

People don't seem to be able to accept the role chance plays in our lives

pineapplesundae · 25/03/2024 04:38

I hear you! I’ve wondered myself sometimes but I don’t give in to the feeling. I exercise six days a week, eat organic fruits and vegetables, you get it. You never know what people are doing behind the scenes. For example, I read, a long time ago, that Cate and her mother did the Dukan diet to shed weight quickly. So I tried it myself! And guess what? It worked! But, I came to my senses and realized that is not a healthy diet and switched to whole foods and healthy living. I believe it helps fend off disease and all any of us can do is the best that we can.

Firethehorse · 25/03/2024 02:06

Sorry about your mum OP 💐It’s a sobering moment when someone you love passes away.
I think your post is interesting and very pertinent for the times we live in. We are bombarded with conflicting information on what is ‘healthy’ (think keto v vegetarian v paelo etc) on what constitutes healthy exercise. Health is big business and we are inundated with supplements and regimes we should swallow and follow.
For me I’ve made peace with making as much food as I’m able from the best ingredients I can, ensuring we eat fruit, veggies, nuts, reducing alcohol, increasing water. I use the science ‘hacks’ so for instance add lemon juice to bbq food to negate carcinogens, will swap one drink for a green tea, add a shower and drinking water filter etc etc.
Your Pilates is fantastic and if you’re not enjoying running try something else, like a high energy fitness or dance class.
Think about all the good things you are doing to help yourself, be grateful for what you have, keep in contact with those you love and smile every day.
I guess what I’m saying is try to remove this stress and be grateful to yourself for the positive things you are doing.

0sm0nthus · 24/03/2024 23:45

AfterTheWatershed · 24/03/2024 20:20

I almost wonder if lifestyle is relevant in this debate. If we were living a ‘natural’ lifestyle us women would mostly be either pregnant/breastfeeding from teens to early 40s. It isn’t desirable or preferable to be living a natural lifestyle nowadays.

I guess by natural you mean something akin to a hunter gatherer lifestyle? I dont think any of us would fancy that!
Although my understanding is that late teens early 20's is the optimal age for childbearing- optimal for mother & child health that is!

anon666 · 24/03/2024 22:57

So much blame is apportioned to people for lifestyle risks to health.

It's just not like that. Whilst statistically certain behavioural factors may influence risk, for any one human they aren't a guarantee of longer life.

Longevity isn't a moral issue, nor are behavioural factors in healthcare. Many people preserve their bodies, then sadly fall victim to alzheimers and end up dependent on long term social care.

Live your life how you see fit, them accept that you're rolling the dice with death to an extent anyway.