Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?

637 replies

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 12:36

I try my best to live heathily (although definitely not fanatical). I try and stay away from ultra processed foods, try and avoid saturated fat, too much meat etc., try and exercise every week. I’ll have the odd takeaway and definitely overindulge on wine, but always try and be mindful of living heathily because so much information is constantly battering me through the radio, media etc. about getting ill from various foods and not exercising.

I’ve recently lost my mother far too young too, so I suppose it’s particularly on my mind at the moment. But then you hear Kate’s diagnosis, who obviously exercises regularly, has the best instructors, best food, best ingredients, best preparation, and she still falls ill, and it all seems a bit pointless.

AIBU to feel this way? I just wonder whether I really should make an effort to watch what I eat and run when I don’t feel like it if really, what will be will be regardless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:48

Delatron · 25/03/2024 19:43

For the second time ‘common side effects include - fatigue, headaches, digestive issues, muscle pain, nausea, to list a few.

So yes absolutely that needs to be weighed up with the risk of the individual to heart disease. That is my point. If the only symptom is high cholesterol then no I don’t think the risk is worth it in an otherwise healthy individual.

High cholesterol needs to be looked at along with other risk factors - such as age, BMI, exercise etc - which is in the QRISK questionaire and the NICE guidelines as posted

At no point did I say nothing concerned me or not about statin prescription.
At no point did I express an opinion on cholesterol levels and prescribing

You keep saying they are overprescribed - but you haven't posted any actual evidence.

But that's not unusual for people making claims on the internet.

Delatron · 25/03/2024 19:43

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:41

I am not claiming there are no side effects.

I am saying that the side effects have to be balanced against the benefits.

You said "big side effects" - really? Can you name them?

Again - you sound like someone who can't read a thread.

For the second time ‘common side effects include - fatigue, headaches, digestive issues, muscle pain, nausea, to list a few.

So yes absolutely that needs to be weighed up with the risk of the individual to heart disease. That is my point. If the only symptom is high cholesterol then no I don’t think the risk is worth it in an otherwise healthy individual.

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:42

Delatron · 25/03/2024 19:40

You don’t need data and research to read the side effects on the back of a packet.

You do need data and studies to understand the relative risks of the side effects versus the overall effect to you.

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:41

Delatron · 25/03/2024 19:39

There are side effects on the back of the packet. Are you actually claiming they have no side effects? How bizarre. I have listed them (can you not read?) you say I haven’t. Do you need a peer reviewed study or do you not trust what is written as side effects on the packet and on the NHS website as common side effects?

I am not claiming there are no side effects.

I am saying that the side effects have to be balanced against the benefits.

You said "big side effects" - really? Can you name them?

Again - you sound like someone who can't read a thread.

Delatron · 25/03/2024 19:40

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:40

It's not derailing - it's about data, absolute risks, relative risks and good quality research.

Also large studies - not personal anecdotes about "Well I had statins but they didn't do me any good / weren't needed " etc

I guess some people don't like scientific studies with lots of people.

You don’t need data and research to read the side effects on the back of a packet.

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:40

It's not derailing - it's about data, absolute risks, relative risks and good quality research.

Also large studies - not personal anecdotes about "Well I had statins but they didn't do me any good / weren't needed " etc

I guess some people don't like scientific studies with lots of people.

Delatron · 25/03/2024 19:39

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:37

Must be right?

What must I be right about?
What clients?

I have asked you to say what the big side effects are? You haven't posted any
I have said that if someone was possibly going to be prescribed statins, then there are a lot of factors to consider - specifically the risk of not being prescribed them (the QRISK data) versus the potential side effects - and it's not just cholesterol that's important.

I have asked you about what evidence you have for over prescription in people - you haven't posted anything.

You sound like my teenage son when he gets asked to back up his claim.

There are side effects on the back of the packet. Are you actually claiming they have no side effects? How bizarre. I have listed them (can you not read?) you say I haven’t. Do you need a peer reviewed study or do you not trust what is written as side effects on the packet and on the NHS website as common side effects?

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:37

Delatron · 25/03/2024 19:31

Yes and this is what I’m talking about. And this is common as I talk amongst my clients. But no I don’t have any research to show that. Therefore you must be right.

Must be right?

What must I be right about?
What clients?

I have asked you to say what the big side effects are? You haven't posted any
I have said that if someone was possibly going to be prescribed statins, then there are a lot of factors to consider - specifically the risk of not being prescribed them (the QRISK data) versus the potential side effects - and it's not just cholesterol that's important.

I have asked you about what evidence you have for over prescription in people - you haven't posted anything.

You sound like my teenage son when he gets asked to back up his claim.

Delatron · 25/03/2024 19:33

That was to @cakeorwine but anyway I feel that statin chat is derailing the thread.

Delatron · 25/03/2024 19:31

Quizine · 25/03/2024 19:13

I had high cholesterol for a long time and was advised statins. I didn't want them and tried the usual things we are told to do to reduce it. It did reduce a bit over time but not by that much. I'm now just at the recommended total level with a slightly higher LDL than HDL.

Anyway during a recent hospital stay for cardiac AFib I was given a cardiac CT scan and had a zero score of calcium (can block arteries - plaque) so having had high cholesterol for many years it didn't seem to cause any blocked arteries anyway. I dunno, it's all a bit mad if you ask me. Who do we listen to, ourselves I think!

Yes and this is what I’m talking about. And this is common as I talk amongst my clients. But no I don’t have any research to show that. Therefore you must be right.

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:28

High cholesterol is a symptom of something else in the body - of course.

What things in particular?

Diet?
Genetic issues?

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:25

Where is your evidence that they are over prescribed?
Especially to young people?

Or is that just another spurious claim without evidence?

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 19:24

Delatron · 25/03/2024 18:46

You’re working on the assumption that if someone has high cholesterol then that automatically means they are at risk of heart disease and this needs to be treated. Which may be the case for some people. I have no doubt many people need statins. I don’t need to see research on that.

I’m not claiming nobody should take statins. I’m suggesting that they are overprescribed- especially if one is young and otherwise healthy. I’d also argue that high cholesterol is a symptom of something else going on in the body and lifestyle changes should always be the first resort.

im not arguing we do away with statins or that they are ineffective. But if a doctor told me to take statins now for example I would question that. If my only symptom was high cholesterol and I was otherwise healthy.

No - I am working on the assumption that people look at the data, the relative risks associated with various variables including their cholesterol level as well as other factors and then works with the doctor and the NICE guidelines to see if it is worth it.

You seem to be reading things that people don't say.

It's about the data, the research, the variables etc

QRISK3

QRISK3

https://www.qrisk.org/

Moreorlessmentallystable · 25/03/2024 19:18

Tbh, just because she has access to all of that does not mean she is healthy. To me she looks like she might have an eating disorder that would mess with your health just the same as eating very unhealthily....

Quizine · 25/03/2024 19:13

I had high cholesterol for a long time and was advised statins. I didn't want them and tried the usual things we are told to do to reduce it. It did reduce a bit over time but not by that much. I'm now just at the recommended total level with a slightly higher LDL than HDL.

Anyway during a recent hospital stay for cardiac AFib I was given a cardiac CT scan and had a zero score of calcium (can block arteries - plaque) so having had high cholesterol for many years it didn't seem to cause any blocked arteries anyway. I dunno, it's all a bit mad if you ask me. Who do we listen to, ourselves I think!

Delatron · 25/03/2024 18:46

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 18:32

Wouldn't you want to know the benefits to you of taking the statins on reducing the risk of CHD versus the side effects?

You’re working on the assumption that if someone has high cholesterol then that automatically means they are at risk of heart disease and this needs to be treated. Which may be the case for some people. I have no doubt many people need statins. I don’t need to see research on that.

I’m not claiming nobody should take statins. I’m suggesting that they are overprescribed- especially if one is young and otherwise healthy. I’d also argue that high cholesterol is a symptom of something else going on in the body and lifestyle changes should always be the first resort.

im not arguing we do away with statins or that they are ineffective. But if a doctor told me to take statins now for example I would question that. If my only symptom was high cholesterol and I was otherwise healthy.

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 18:32

Delatron · 25/03/2024 18:30

Yes there is a long risk of common side effects which I think are big. Headaches, digestive issues, fatigue, nausea. If I was youngish and otherwise well, no I wouldn’t want to risk those ‘common’ side effects.

If I was a prediabetic male with a history of heart disease and did zero exercise then I’d take the bloody statins. It’s about risk versus benefit.

It does concern me that statins are handed out at the rate they are to younger, otherwise healthy people.

If that doesn’t concern you then fine.

Wouldn't you want to know the benefits to you of taking the statins on reducing the risk of CHD versus the side effects?

Delatron · 25/03/2024 18:30

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 18:26

That's not what I said.

You used the words Big Side Effects

"I’m highly suspicious of the amount of people supposedly who need statins (especially young, otherwise healthy people). Big side effects. Especially on gut health. Meanwhile lots of profits for those pharma companies."

If you can't discuss the big side effects or discuss the benefits versus side effects, then maybe you should do some research before using words like Big side effects

Yes there is a long risk of common side effects which I think are big. Headaches, digestive issues, fatigue, nausea. If I was youngish and otherwise well, no I wouldn’t want to risk those ‘common’ side effects.

If I was a prediabetic male with a history of heart disease and did zero exercise then I’d take the bloody statins. It’s about risk versus benefit.

It does concern me that statins are handed out at the rate they are to younger, otherwise healthy people.

If that doesn’t concern you then fine.

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 18:29

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 18:26

Delatron · 25/03/2024 18:13

Well all medications have side effects. So if you’re claiming statins have no side effects then go ahead? I said they have side effects. I said if I was youngish and in good health then I’d weight up those side effects like I would with any medication I had to take each day. You don’t need a study to tell you that. They are on the back of the packet….

That's not what I said.

You used the words Big Side Effects

"I’m highly suspicious of the amount of people supposedly who need statins (especially young, otherwise healthy people). Big side effects. Especially on gut health. Meanwhile lots of profits for those pharma companies."

If you can't discuss the big side effects or discuss the benefits versus side effects, then maybe you should do some research before using words like Big side effects

Delatron · 25/03/2024 18:15

Notsuretoputit · 25/03/2024 17:54

I agree that butter is better than ultra processed spreads. But that doesn’t mean butter is good for you.

Fat is fine. We do need fat. But we can get it from fatty fish, avocados, olive oil, nuts etc. as opposed to butter, cream, pork belly etc.

Whole foods are fine in moderation, but too much saturated fat isn’t good for you.

I literally said ‘butter is better than margarine’ I did not say ‘butter is good for you’. ‘Eat a shed load of butter’

Delatron · 25/03/2024 18:13

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 18:04

Go on then - what are the risk of statins and what does the data show?

(Are you going to reference absolute risk, relative risk and also the risk of CHD etc from people who don't take statins)

Well all medications have side effects. So if you’re claiming statins have no side effects then go ahead? I said they have side effects. I said if I was youngish and in good health then I’d weight up those side effects like I would with any medication I had to take each day. You don’t need a study to tell you that. They are on the back of the packet….

Grapewrath · 25/03/2024 18:10

I don’t buy into Kate looking ‘the picture of health’ to me she always looks thin, frail and anxious. Also, wasn’t she a smoker?
We don’t know what cancer she has or her family history so there’s no point speculating about healthy living being pointless. Personally I’d rather eat well and move my body.. even if I do get an illness I’d like to use my body to its full potential and not feel exhausted and shitty

cakeorwine · 25/03/2024 18:04

Delatron · 25/03/2024 14:21

Yep. I wouldn’t be looking to the NHS for diet advice and guidelines.

Butter is better than ultra processed margarine. Fat is fine, we need fat. It’s sugar we should be more concerned about. They focus on the wrong things.

In low fat foods they replace fat with sugar. They don’t fill you up and leave you hungry again (plus a sugar crash).

I’m highly suspicious of the amount of people supposedly who need statins (especially young, otherwise healthy people). Big side effects. Especially on gut health. Meanwhile lots of profits for those pharma companies.

Go on then - what are the risk of statins and what does the data show?

(Are you going to reference absolute risk, relative risk and also the risk of CHD etc from people who don't take statins)