Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?

637 replies

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 12:36

I try my best to live heathily (although definitely not fanatical). I try and stay away from ultra processed foods, try and avoid saturated fat, too much meat etc., try and exercise every week. I’ll have the odd takeaway and definitely overindulge on wine, but always try and be mindful of living heathily because so much information is constantly battering me through the radio, media etc. about getting ill from various foods and not exercising.

I’ve recently lost my mother far too young too, so I suppose it’s particularly on my mind at the moment. But then you hear Kate’s diagnosis, who obviously exercises regularly, has the best instructors, best food, best ingredients, best preparation, and she still falls ill, and it all seems a bit pointless.

AIBU to feel this way? I just wonder whether I really should make an effort to watch what I eat and run when I don’t feel like it if really, what will be will be regardless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
SergeantDawkins · 23/03/2024 13:15

This reply has been withdrawn

Message withdrawn - duplicate post

SergeantDawkins · 23/03/2024 13:15

I think the lesson here isn't that it’s all pointless but that it’s worth reconsidering some motivations.
We should all eat well to nourish our bodies, treat our bodies with care and kindness, and exercise to feel good, not to be thin or “healthy” eg. protected from illness

SpaghettiWithaYeti · 23/03/2024 13:15

hattie43 · 23/03/2024 13:08

I haven't read other responses but all I will say is that every person I know with or had cancer was not leading an unhealthy lifestyle , slim , exercise , non smoking . Not who you might think would be higher risk .

I personally think your genes are more involved than they'd care us to believe

Genes and also the environment we can't control (eg air /water pollution etc)

Luddite26 · 23/03/2024 13:12

You don't know her diagnosis so can't say it's anything to do with lifestyle. Living healthier can help you fight illness better or it can just be your genes that give you longevity but the fitter you are the better quality of life you can have.

Phineyj · 23/03/2024 13:12

I did a course in health once.

A statistic that stuck with me is that health is 1/3 genes, 1/3 environment and 1/3 lifestyle.

So you may as well work on the 1/3 under your control.

WaltzingWaters · 23/03/2024 13:11

My mum who ate healthily, exercised, never smoked, and rarely drunk alcohol died at 56. My dad who drinks a fair amount, doesn’t exercise and doesn’t eat very healthily was distraught that she were the one of the two of them to get poorly and pass young.
But this doesn’t means it pointless. presumably being healthy just makes you feel much better in yourself day to day? And it does help reduce risk factors, but sadly can’t eliminate them altogether. I’m like you - eat well the majority of the time, exercise but not exclusively, and enjoy wine a bit too often. Find a balance to being healthy but enjoying things that make you happy.

Berlinlover · 23/03/2024 13:10

I understand what you’re saying but healthy living is never pointless. I don’t smoke or drink alcohol, walk everywhere and eat very healthily. The BRAC1 gene is in my family and although I tested negative for the gene I kept a very close eye on my health. Last September I was diagnosed with mestatic uterine sarcoma and am going through chemo.

hattie43 · 23/03/2024 13:08

I haven't read other responses but all I will say is that every person I know with or had cancer was not leading an unhealthy lifestyle , slim , exercise , non smoking . Not who you might think would be higher risk .

I personally think your genes are more involved than they'd care us to believe

Roselilly36 · 23/03/2024 13:04

I think it’s down to luck quite honestly, no one knows what the future will hold. So enjoy life and make the most of it while you are fit and well. I was dx with Multiple Sclerosis at 40, totally out of the blue, I have lost so many wonderful family members and good friends to cancer, I absolutely despise the devastation it causes.

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 23/03/2024 13:02

You have no idea how she lives behind closed doors or what her family history is. She could also just be one of the sadly unlucky ones.

Living well improves your odds. It doesn't guarantee you a long and healthy life but it improves your chances (your chances according to the hand you were dealt as an individual).

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 12:58

Of course I don’t ‘blame’ people for being ill, as some of the posters on this thread have suggested.

But I suppose in some ways it is something I’d like to think. My mother died of heart problems and it’s really worried me that now I have a strong family history of heart issues, which is something I never expected, and I suppose I’ve been trying to convince myself that the increased genetic risk can be balanced out by running, not eating fried foods, sausages, bacon, red meat, and so on. But Kate’s diagnosis just makes me think that if she can get cancer in her 40s how much can lifestyle choices really protect you.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 23/03/2024 12:57

Healthy lifestyle isn’t a get out of jail free card, particularly with respect to cancer.

There are specific correlations between some behaviour and a higher risk of cancer (smoking is the most obvious example). But other than those the link between cancer and lifestyle is probably overstated. A large number of cancers have a genetic component to them and there’s not much you can do to prevent them.

That doesn’t mean that there aren’t other sensible reasons for a healthy lifestyle either. Reducing your risk of cardiovascular and metabolic disease is a huge one as you are more likely to succumb to one if these diseases as you are to cancer.

The news of Kate’s illness is obviously shocking but it doesn’t mean your life needs to change.

OrchardDoor · 23/03/2024 12:49

Genes play an important part as well as lifestyle. My grandad smoked roll ups and lived til 91 (and didn't die of lung disease or heart issues.) He was fit and healthy until not long before he died. I still wouldn't take up smoking as I've got my own set of genes and it might see me off of lung disease earlier than I would have died.

Finosaurtea · 23/03/2024 12:49

WarriorN · 23/03/2024 12:48

Being physically fit, particularly physically strong, also helps you deal with side effects if you are unfortunate enough to need treatments.

Totally agree

CranfordScones · 23/03/2024 12:49

Doing all the right things reduces the chance of getting cancer and other diseases. There's no doubt about that. So it does work in the sense that you're less likely to get ill.

Less likely doesn't mean that the risk is entirely eliminated. And some diseases are less affected by lifestyle factors.

WarriorN · 23/03/2024 12:48

Being physically fit, particularly physically strong, also helps you deal with side effects if you are unfortunate enough to need treatments.

Citrusandginger · 23/03/2024 12:48

At a population level, people who live healthier lives, live longer than those who don't. There are outliers both ways, within my own family, I have had a sports mad relative who died of mesothelioma in her '50's and an overweight, alcoholic FIL who is going strong in his late eighties.

If a hundred people your age ate healthily, exercised and didn't smoke, as a group they would outlive a group who did the opposite.

LadyKenya · 23/03/2024 12:48

Eating well, with limited UPFs would give your body a better chance of dealing with something like that, if it was to happen, I think. I would never think that somebody would not get xyz, just because of how they present. I think that is a strange way to think, but it would seem that a lot of people are saying the same thing. Obviously genetics could be at play as well. I eat as well as I can, but I do not believe that makes me immune to illness.

RoseAndRose · 23/03/2024 12:47

YABU, meant in a nice sort of way.

Doing things that reduce the chances of getting XYZ isn't the same as there being a guaranteed protective effect.

So some people will come down with serious illnesses regardless of what they do (and remember that we do not know what sort of cancer either the King or he Princess have - they may be ones unlinked to lifestyle factors for all we know)

But others, for cancers and other conditions which do have lifestyle factors, then yes there is a protective effect. Reducing odds from (to pull some numbers at random) from 3% chance of getting XYZ to a 1% chance of getting it doesn't mean that you as an individual won't get it; but it does mean that in a national population of 68mil you can expect number affected to fall from a little over 2mil cases a year to 680,000. That's a lot of people to whom it does make a big difference.

5128gap · 23/03/2024 12:47

Well I look after my body and will continue to do so. As while I can't protect myself from every eventuality, I can dramatically reduce my chances of some, give myself the best chance of recovery from those I can't, and enjoy the benefits of feeling my personal healthiest. All of that matters more to me than eating and drinking what I like, so I press on. I don't expect it to make me invincible though.

Hotcuppatea · 23/03/2024 12:47

I'm really sorry to hear about your mum. 💐Losing a parent is very tough and its normal to be impacted by events around you in a disproportionate way when youre grieving.

in my mind, living a healthy lifestyle is about being able to enjoy the time you have to the fullest. Its not necessarily about getting more time.

Quality not quantity.

WarriorN · 23/03/2024 12:47

Quite a lot of cancer is pure chance. They don't know why it happens.

It's not pointless to be as healthy as possible as many of those things reduce the risk of other issues such as type two diabetes. Exercise and resistance training greatly reduces the risk of dementia.

Also, if you've not been exercising at all, and start after a cancer diagnosis, it can reduce the risk of reoccurrence by as much as 55% for some types of cancer. (Varies depending on the cancer obviously.) Bowel and breast in particular iirc. Which is sometimes a better percentage rate than many of the treatments.

SpaghettiWithaYeti · 23/03/2024 12:47

Have you been going around assuming everyone else is only ill because it's their fault?

That explains all the deranged advice from friends who try and suggest weird diets or yoga will cure my genetic condition.

TDIAP · 23/03/2024 12:46

Im my own life I know 3 people over the age of 90 in excellent health and 2 of them have never touched salad and hate vegetables. They all eat processed food, I also know more than one person who ate healthily and died between the ages of 40 and mid-60s.
So yes, I think it’s pointless. I believe Its more down to genes and stress than anything else.

mynameiscalypso · 23/03/2024 12:45

Being skinny/slim (depending on your perspective) does not always equate to a healthy lifestyle.