Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?

637 replies

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 12:36

I try my best to live heathily (although definitely not fanatical). I try and stay away from ultra processed foods, try and avoid saturated fat, too much meat etc., try and exercise every week. I’ll have the odd takeaway and definitely overindulge on wine, but always try and be mindful of living heathily because so much information is constantly battering me through the radio, media etc. about getting ill from various foods and not exercising.

I’ve recently lost my mother far too young too, so I suppose it’s particularly on my mind at the moment. But then you hear Kate’s diagnosis, who obviously exercises regularly, has the best instructors, best food, best ingredients, best preparation, and she still falls ill, and it all seems a bit pointless.

AIBU to feel this way? I just wonder whether I really should make an effort to watch what I eat and run when I don’t feel like it if really, what will be will be regardless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
CormorantStrikesBack · 23/03/2024 16:37

Both my parents were slim, ate healthy, didn’t smoke, barely drank, walked a lot (daily long dog walks). Both got cancer and died in middle age. I do think a lot of it is down to genetics or chance. But being as healthy as you can be will reduce your chances of a lifestyle type cancer.

ThreeTreeHill · 23/03/2024 16:35

I can't believe how many threads there are on here that just understand the concept of risk or proximity

Living a healthy lifestyle reduces your risk of developing cancer/heart disease/lungs disease etc but it does not eliminate it. By nature even a very low risk of 1 in a million still happens to 1 in a million people.

Secondly you have no idea how healthy Kate is or not, she might go home down a bottle of vodka and chainsmoke 40 a day all whilst sitting in a radiation chamber.

Ans thirdly, you don't know what cancer Kate has. Many cancers are not lifestyle related.

TheFrendo · 23/03/2024 16:34

Rates of obesity, cancer (except lung cancer), diabetes, NAFLD, IBS, dementia, auto-immune disease etc have all increased over the last 50 years.

During this time we (as a population) have been following government healthy eating guidelines.

In particular saturated fat consumption is down. Yet, disease is up.

There is a case for thinking the guidelines and the current food environment are the culprits here.

Sunshineandrainbows23 · 23/03/2024 16:32

Cattenberg · 23/03/2024 16:28

I’m the same age as Catherine, but far less ‘in shape’.

I fear that if/when I develop a serious illness, I will be kicking myself that it might have been my own fault. That won’t be pleasant, especially if fate doesn’t give me a second chance at life.

You can start now @Cattenberg and don't forget people can look really shapely but be really ill inside if they are eating a poor diet that keeps that slim. Can you believe Dr's used to recommend smoking to keep slim?!

We can only start where we are at. :) xx

Sunshineandrainbows23 · 23/03/2024 16:29

Kittynoodle · 23/03/2024 15:57

I couldn’t agree with you more!

dementia is very prevalent in my family, all living into their 90’s , needing 24 hour care, no dignity, no capacity…

I’d rather die younger with a physical condition

and @Octomingo ... Same situation in my family.

I don't know if you've come across the Sherzai's? Apparently diet can help stave off dementia too ... Just a thought ... It runs in my family too and my very cynical mum, who is terrified of dementia, reluctantly read their book, yet described it as "magic". Also other tips and tricks to keep us functioning cognitively well for as long as possible. It might not stop her getting demential but she feels more in control now, which is worth it's weight in gold... Probably good for us all to be aware of anyway xx

The Brain Docs | Brain Health Resources & Courses

Home

Drs. Ayesha & Dean Sherzai — wife-and-husband neuroscientists, bestselling authors, and hosts of the Brain Health Revolution Podcast.

https://thebraindocs.com/

Cattenberg · 23/03/2024 16:28

I’m the same age as Catherine, but far less ‘in shape’.

I fear that if/when I develop a serious illness, I will be kicking myself that it might have been my own fault. That won’t be pleasant, especially if fate doesn’t give me a second chance at life.

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 23/03/2024 16:27

OP - you’ve had some good advice on here, but like others, I’d point out you are making a lot of assumptions on POW’s lifestyle based off her being a) thin and b) well groomed.

We have no idea if she has been a healthy eater, just that she clearly doesn’t regularly eat more calories than her body needs to function, you know nothings about the quality of food choices she’s made in relation to you. you have no idea if she’s abused her body with drugs (prescribed or otherwise), or alcohol.

this isn’t to say any of this is her fault - but your premise is you know she’s taken care of herself and for cancer anyway could be completely wrong.

and you could develop cancer next year, or maybe you won’t and will live a long life, it’s often down to luck if we make it old bones. Take care of your body anyway. (Although I’ve just scoffed a double decker so you know, all things in moderation.)

TheFormidableMrsC · 23/03/2024 16:24

Marmunia106675 · 23/03/2024 16:04

I feel throwing hormones at your body - pill, coil, etc...can create health problems. Have seen several young friends diagnosed with cancer and have been on hormone rubbish since they were teens.

My breast cancer was hormone led. I am certain it was caused by medication I was given for peri bleeding that has now been directly linked to my type of breast cancer via peer reviewed research. Excess hormones can be very damaging.

Delatron · 23/03/2024 16:21

BlueBadgeHolder · 23/03/2024 16:18

Kate smokes. That is not good for your health.

And more victim blaming. What is wrong with you people? This is so distasteful.

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 23/03/2024 16:21

I dont go mad with things but I eat healthy home cooked meals and exercise every other day, do mindfulness and yoga, but also enjoy my wine and the odd takeaway.
My grandmother died young from breast cancer and lived a healthy life while my DH's grandmother smoked since she was 14 and made it to 82.
The way I see it is if I live a good enough life, if I was to get ill then I'll be strong enough to fight it, but life is also for living so I don't get so caught up with fear about things that I can't enjoy it.

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 16:20

IslandintheSunshine · 23/03/2024 16:12

Where have you been for the last year or more @Notsuretoputit
Danger of ultra processed foods?

Are you genuinely confused or just passing away your day here?

Most people who are trying to live healthily, will say you should eat healthily for 85-90% of the time, and splurge on a treat now and then.

I'd suggest you do some in-depth reading on this.
There is no evidence cheese causes heart disease.
There's even no agreement on cholesterol figures.
Some science points to sugar and refined carbs as clogging the arteries through inflammation rather than animal fat being the issue.

If you want to monitor yourself, check your BP, get a cholesterol test (in case it's massively high), stay a healthy weight, eat healthily most of the time and have the odd treat.

Nice and rude. Cheese is listed as one of the foods to avoid to prevent heart disease on the NHS’s website, along with other foods with high levels of saturated fat. I’d suggest it isn’t me who’s confused.

OP posts:
Patrickiscrazy · 23/03/2024 16:18

User35352662 · 23/03/2024 14:10

I don't think any mother of three young children can truly be healthy on all fronts. People love to underplay the colossal impact having children has on woman's mental and physical health. Just think of the stress and sleep deprivation that nearly 10 years of being pregnant and juggling babies/toddlers brings. It's absolutely not comparable to a person without any children who has every single day to themselves and can sleep for as long as they want or schedule downtime whenever they feel like they need a break.

She also has immense pressure to appear immaculate and perfect during all work engagements so any time away from the kids is spent on grooming, makeup, hair etc. In the real world, most mums are willing to look a bit slobby in public if it means skipping hair and makeup so you can enjoy a few more minutes to yourself.

You can eat healthy all you want but it doesn't compensate for much if you're chronically sleep-deprived or under stress. Certain phases of life (eg being a mum) are fundamentally not compatible with being in a perfect state of mental and physical rest.

Interesting point of view.
Child free here.

BlueBadgeHolder · 23/03/2024 16:18

Kate smokes. That is not good for your health.

Patrickiscrazy · 23/03/2024 16:17

AstralSpace · 23/03/2024 15:25

Being healthy gives you a better quality of life and a better chance of recovery if you do get ill.
It's still worth it.

Hmmm..... hopefully...

Dentistlakes · 23/03/2024 16:17

All you can do is mitigate the risk, but you’ll never eliminate it. Eating healthily and exercising reduces your risk
of many diseases and also improves your quality of life. When I was overweight I felt terrible; sick and lethargic. Everything ached. Now I’ve lost weight and exercise I feel so
much better and my general mood has improved hugely.

Patrickiscrazy · 23/03/2024 16:16

I get the way you feel.
I call her "the fittest lady in the UK".
Now, what chance do I have, being me?
And absolutely not "unfit".
Get you, OP! 😁

Velvetcupcakes · 23/03/2024 16:13

I was diagnosed with leukaemia last year at 56. My parents lived into their 90s and I hoped to benefit from their genetics (my dad was even a smoker for 50 years!). I’ve never had previous health issues and live a healthy lifestyle. My oncologist basically said they can’t see what caused it, but menopause can trigger these ‘events’ and suggested I eliminate stress (I have raised two disabled children while working full time for years, so I just retired).
I really feel for the Princess because it’s been such a stressful few years for the Royal Family. Most of us couldn’t handle the stress and scrutiny.

IslandintheSunshine · 23/03/2024 16:12

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 16:07

Smoking causes cancer, so no, I’m not going to take it up.

But should I stop buying sourdough bread with only a few natural ingredients, or should I just buy the Warburtons white sliced that I actually like more? Should I have just made the stir fry I ate, or should I have the fish finger sandwich with cheese that I would prefer? Should I have chosen the turkey when I went out for Sunday dinner or got the pork belly I’d have preferred? Keep choosing chicken breast when I want the leg with skin? Should I keep running every week when I don’t enjoy it and it’s a chore, or just do the Pilates I enjoy?

I’m not going to start smoking because it causes cancer. But is trying to avoid cheese, red meat etc. really going to prevent the heart disease I’ve worried about since my mother died, or is it going to happen anyway and I may as well enjoy what I want?

Where have you been for the last year or more @Notsuretoputit
Danger of ultra processed foods?

Are you genuinely confused or just passing away your day here?

Most people who are trying to live healthily, will say you should eat healthily for 85-90% of the time, and splurge on a treat now and then.

I'd suggest you do some in-depth reading on this.
There is no evidence cheese causes heart disease.
There's even no agreement on cholesterol figures.
Some science points to sugar and refined carbs as clogging the arteries through inflammation rather than animal fat being the issue.

If you want to monitor yourself, check your BP, get a cholesterol test (in case it's massively high), stay a healthy weight, eat healthily most of the time and have the odd treat.

Faz469 · 23/03/2024 16:12

My sister is the same age as Kate. She's on her second cancer diagnosis since the age of 28. This time, she's terminal with a max of 18 months to live. I say live your life and have fun within reason. You never know when your time will come, but there's no point wasting it either.

TempestTost · 23/03/2024 16:12

I think yes and no, OP.

Yes, in that you will likely feel better, and have a happier life, and weather illnesses more comfortably, if you are living a fairly healthy life.

But realistically, we all die, and no amount of healthy living will stop that. In the end, we live maybe 50 years, maybe 80, and it's all the blink of an eye in the grand scheme of things. There is no way to get out of facing death and usually also a decline before that.

In light of that, I think being obsessive over "healthy living" isn't all that worthwhile, even if we knew it worked to extend life every time. We also have to enjoy the moment and take it for what it is. Going to the gym might be better than sitting around on mumsnet, but going for a walk with your kids is probably better than both.

Harrysmummy246 · 23/03/2024 16:11

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 12:58

Of course I don’t ‘blame’ people for being ill, as some of the posters on this thread have suggested.

But I suppose in some ways it is something I’d like to think. My mother died of heart problems and it’s really worried me that now I have a strong family history of heart issues, which is something I never expected, and I suppose I’ve been trying to convince myself that the increased genetic risk can be balanced out by running, not eating fried foods, sausages, bacon, red meat, and so on. But Kate’s diagnosis just makes me think that if she can get cancer in her 40s how much can lifestyle choices really protect you.

You can't guarantee that. My DM did everything right and her cholesterol levels didn't budge. They only changed with meds. DSis (younger than me, just turned 40) had hers checked last year and it's higher than average. Admittedly, we're none of us perfect with diet, but it's a risk that's there anyway. DM is now older than either of her parents were when they died thanks to statins and BP meds.

You can do everything 'right' but it doesn't mean that one mutation that leads to cancer won't occur, or that your body won't develop an autoimmune condition like MS.

OrchardDoor · 23/03/2024 16:10

Delatron · 23/03/2024 16:04

Yes thought it was just me who was getting sick of these victim blaming posts. The woman has just been diagnosed with cancer at the age of 42. And people are saying that she’s a smoker/she’s too thin/she eats crap. It’s so distasteful.

Yes. I get the impression that some people are desperate to think it is ALL to do with lifestyle and nothing to do with genetics. That way they can think "I do everything right. I'll live to a healthy old age. She must have done something wrong." Not true. Genetics plays a big part.

fizzandchips · 23/03/2024 16:08

20 years ago bowel cancer (for example) was much more likely in someone who was obese and unfit, who ate processed red meat - smoked bacon and sausages - and didn’t exercise. Anecdotally (I’m sure there are peer reviewed studies, but as it’s not my area of expertise I’ll say what I’ve heard) marathon running vegans under 40 are now being diagnosed and the medics are struggling to understand why. So, on some level I agree, it’s not pointless, but it doesn’t make you immune. But what a healthy lifestyle will offer is increased chance of coping with the recovery from surgery and the side effects of chemotherapy neither of which should be underestimated. So I suppose you’re not leading a heathy lifestyle to prevent cancer, because lets face it none of us can, but to recover from it.

PupInAPram · 23/03/2024 16:08

Well it's a numbers game isn't it. A percentage of the cause is lifestyle and a percentage is genetic. If you take out the lifestyle risks you decrease your chances of getting cancer, you don't eliminate it.

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 16:07

curiousasacat · 23/03/2024 15:58

This is a bit silly isnt it OP- you gonna take up smoking now then?

A healthy lifestyle isnt only about cancer prevention. What about chronic life limiting conditions such as type 2 diabetes and COPD?- what kind of quality of life do you think someone with chronic COPD has, gasping for breath just going upstairs. Do you think the news that some apparently healthy people get cancer is going to be much comfort to you when you're wheezing and in pain

Smoking causes cancer, so no, I’m not going to take it up.

But should I stop buying sourdough bread with only a few natural ingredients, or should I just buy the Warburtons white sliced that I actually like more? Should I have just made the stir fry I ate, or should I have the fish finger sandwich with cheese that I would prefer? Should I have chosen the turkey when I went out for Sunday dinner or got the pork belly I’d have preferred? Keep choosing chicken breast when I want the leg with skin? Should I keep running every week when I don’t enjoy it and it’s a chore, or just do the Pilates I enjoy?

I’m not going to start smoking because it causes cancer. But is trying to avoid cheese, red meat etc. really going to prevent the heart disease I’ve worried about since my mother died, or is it going to happen anyway and I may as well enjoy what I want?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread