Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?

637 replies

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 12:36

I try my best to live heathily (although definitely not fanatical). I try and stay away from ultra processed foods, try and avoid saturated fat, too much meat etc., try and exercise every week. I’ll have the odd takeaway and definitely overindulge on wine, but always try and be mindful of living heathily because so much information is constantly battering me through the radio, media etc. about getting ill from various foods and not exercising.

I’ve recently lost my mother far too young too, so I suppose it’s particularly on my mind at the moment. But then you hear Kate’s diagnosis, who obviously exercises regularly, has the best instructors, best food, best ingredients, best preparation, and she still falls ill, and it all seems a bit pointless.

AIBU to feel this way? I just wonder whether I really should make an effort to watch what I eat and run when I don’t feel like it if really, what will be will be regardless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
doublec · 23/03/2024 17:29

@Delatron Stress is the trigger for many things. It pushed me into a premature menopause and have no doubt it played a part in my cancer. All the doctors I have seen since my diagnosis have stressed (ha ha) the importance of not getting stressed.

TrixieFatell · 23/03/2024 17:28

How do we know she's healthy. Because she's very slim? For all we know she could be smoking 50 a day to suppress her appetite, or restricting calories in a harmful way etc. you can't tell someone's health by how they look.

doublec · 23/03/2024 17:27

MrsSunshine2b · 23/03/2024 17:21

Maybe she would have got cancer 10 years ago had she not lived healthily. Not that all cancer is caused by your lifestyle, sometimes it's genetic and there's not much you can do about it. However, if you do happen to get any kind of horrible disease, whether that's cancer, Covid or Ebola, the healthier you are the better your chance of coming through the other side.

As for Kate, I feel sympathy for her, but the chances of her NOT being absolutely fine are extremely slim- I'm guessing the initial surgery was a result of symptoms which would have been picked up on and acted on at an extremely early stage, she wouldn't have spent any time on a waiting list; and there will be no treatment, therapy or comfort, regardless of cost, which she will not get access to. PoW having chemo at whatever private facility she goes to is not like your friend's Mum starting chemo at your local hospital.

FFS.

Question.

Are you PoW's doctor? If you're not, it's not for you to say that her NOT being absolutely fine are extremely slim.

While PoW might have chemo in a private hospital, it will still be administered in the same way as NHS patients chemo. (I know this because my mother had private healthcare and was treated at The London Clinic).

Am leaving this thread now, it is making me angry and stressed. And stress is something that can feed cancer.

PaminaMozart · 23/03/2024 17:27

Living healthily is no guarantee. Cancer, can be lifestyle related but often isn't. I know people who did all the right things and still got cancer. Either way it is unpredictable. And tough.

Having said that, I'm 70 and superfit. I work out and eat a healthy diet. If I didn't I might be as morbid as my neighour who is the same age. its very sad to watch her deteriorate over years.

EsmaCannonball · 23/03/2024 17:26

Apart from a couple of instances, the people I have known with cancer have been pretty clean or very clean-living. I know the argument is 'it can happen to anyone' but, in my observation, the diagnosis can feel extra bitter and harder to come to terms with when you've tried to do everything right.

cakeorwine · 23/03/2024 17:24

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 17:21

I do think part of this is the constant public health campaigns screaming from the rafters ‘if you drink alcohol/eat saturated fat/are obese/eat too much sugar/eat too many additives etc. then YOU WILL GET ILL AND DIE’.

The public needs information about health, of course, but the constant campaigns against all vices probably do lead to thinking ‘if I do that bad thing I’ll be ill. If I don’t I wont’. Not necessarily even consciously, but it’s so constant it must seep into the subconscious for some people.

If you do all that stuff, your chances of developing certain diseases increase.

I don't think that's too hard a concept to understand.
It's not a binary situation.

Delatron · 23/03/2024 17:24

I do think stress can be a factor in some cancers - or one of the many ‘switches’. I was diagnosed after the most stressful period of my life. Could be a coincidence. Following my diagnosis I’ve changed my job and do everything I can to keep my stress levels as low as possible (which I know is hard).

It is probably something so complicated like stress affects your immune system (T cells?) The ‘killer cells’ that hunt down and kill cancer cells floating around in us. We all have them but in most of us our immune system kills them off.

I know treatments have kind of come a long way but I really wish we had something better then chemo! Yes I was told it takes 10 years off your life (great). It’s so brutal. Come on cancer research and all that money. Can’t we come up with something better?

13luckyforsomeone · 23/03/2024 17:23

Thanks @SpaghettiWithaYeti 😊When I was diagnosed I asked the specialist what the cause might be and he said, “Bad luck.” Given how extraordinarily lucky I’ve been in almost every other aspect of my life, I can hardly complain.

The good news is that, while the treatment, the fear and the uncertainty are all completely shit, there’s still a very good chance that this cancer won’t be the thing that kills me. I’m still recovering from my most recent treatment just now, living very much day by day, but I’m getting ready to make plans to live my absolute best life from now on. To be true to myself, and to live more for myself than for other people (DCs partially excepted). To figure out what I want and to do that for myself!

Blinky21 · 23/03/2024 17:23

I wouldn't say she was a picture of health. But 50 per cent of people in the uk get cancer, do you think they all lead unhealthy lifestyles

doublec · 23/03/2024 17:23

Shan5474 · 23/03/2024 17:18

I agree it’s her choice to disclose information or not. Sorry if my post sounded unclear - I meant it’s worrying that perhaps a healthy lifestyle doesn’t make much of a difference (because cancer can be caused by many things), not it’s worrying that we don’t know what type of cancer she has

Anyone can get cancer. It is indiscriminate.

This is the bottom line.

doublec · 23/03/2024 17:21

13luckyforsomeone · 23/03/2024 17:14

I couldn’t agree more. I can always tell when someone I know has been Googling my cancer and the long-term survival statistics because they cannot hide the fact that they believe I must be planning my funeral.

If the PoW or the King made their diagnoses known, then (outdated, and irrelevant on an individual level) statistics would be all over the DM and wherever else, along with detailed diagrams of how that particular type of cancer tends to metastasise, what the further surgery would be, the prognosis if this that and the other… just awful stuff that none of us would like to think about really. And imagine if everyone you met “knew” that about you. Absolute nightmare.

I am fascinated by the culture around cancer (the language of fighting, journeys, battles and so on) and the way a lot of people think they know all about it. Someone I met recently was quite taken aback to learn I had been diagnosed AFTER the covid jab was invented, I think he had already decided that the vaccine had caused it 😂. Cancer treatment is bad enough without all the armchair experts - whose sole medical training is that they once read the back of a paracetamol packet - sharing their opinions of you online.

Edited

I concur absolutely!

(Have just finished chemotherapy and experienced similar since the outset of my diagnosis. I loathe the idea the lexicon of cancer - fighting, battles, journey, warrior etc etc and have made it clear to those around me (inc. my GP) not to use these terms and that they're actually offensive, not positive. I come from a family with a lot of cancers, it was revealed that I have a rare double BCRA mutation - I have crap genes and regrettably, I was always going to get cancer. No amount of exercise, healthy eating, not smoking or drinking was going to change this.

Unless someone has been through cancer themselves, they really haven't a clue. It does not matter if your partner, child, parent or anyone else you know has cancer, you will won't fully comprehend it. Also, cancer is highly individual anyway. Two people might seemingly have the same cancer, but they might well have different causes, different treatments and different outcomes.

Should anyone on here be diagnosed with cancer. Step away from the internet. Do not google. Just talk to your consultant, GP and Macmillan. You don't need anyone else's advice. And one thing's for certain, ghoulish threads like this are a waste of everyone's time.

Boomboxio · 23/03/2024 17:21

I know people who ate takeaways everyday, smoked everyday etc and they lived well into their 90s. Just enjoy life however you want too.

MrsSunshine2b · 23/03/2024 17:21

Maybe she would have got cancer 10 years ago had she not lived healthily. Not that all cancer is caused by your lifestyle, sometimes it's genetic and there's not much you can do about it. However, if you do happen to get any kind of horrible disease, whether that's cancer, Covid or Ebola, the healthier you are the better your chance of coming through the other side.

As for Kate, I feel sympathy for her, but the chances of her NOT being absolutely fine are extremely slim- I'm guessing the initial surgery was a result of symptoms which would have been picked up on and acted on at an extremely early stage, she wouldn't have spent any time on a waiting list; and there will be no treatment, therapy or comfort, regardless of cost, which she will not get access to. PoW having chemo at whatever private facility she goes to is not like your friend's Mum starting chemo at your local hospital.

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 17:21

ZoeCM · 23/03/2024 17:10

I think some people really do believe that. I lurked on the r/vegan subreddit a while ago, and there was a question about whether it's vegan to have medical treatment that was tested on animals. One poster (clearly trying to avoid the question) said, "That's not a problem for vegans, because veganism is such a healthy diet." Astonishingly, a few other posters agreed with her.

Just - WTF? Even you think if veganism is the ideal human diet (and I really don't think it is) how could you possibly believe it'll stop you from ever getting ill? Literally make you immortal?

I do think part of this is the constant public health campaigns screaming from the rafters ‘if you drink alcohol/eat saturated fat/are obese/eat too much sugar/eat too many additives etc. then YOU WILL GET ILL AND DIE’.

The public needs information about health, of course, but the constant campaigns against all vices probably do lead to thinking ‘if I do that bad thing I’ll be ill. If I don’t I wont’. Not necessarily even consciously, but it’s so constant it must seep into the subconscious for some people.

OP posts:
AStepAtaTime · 23/03/2024 17:18

This is a controversial opinion but I think one of the principal causes of cancer can be stress. I’ve known 3 otherwise healthy people use of cancer after doing high-stress roles for a number of years. I think there’s a strong link. Healthy living (eating well/exercising regularly etc) is of course good for you. But more attention should be paid to your mental health. People do too much. Take on too much. It plays havoc with your body and you’re more likely to get cancer. I believe anyway

Shan5474 · 23/03/2024 17:18

doublec · 23/03/2024 17:01

PoW's cancer is no-one's business other than her own. She has been essentially bullied into disclosing she is having adjuvant chemotherapy b ecause cancer was found after her abdomen op.

If she chooses to share at some point in the future, great, but if not, respect it. It's not worrying at all that a private individual has chosen not to disclose her private health information to the entire world.

I agree it’s her choice to disclose information or not. Sorry if my post sounded unclear - I meant it’s worrying that perhaps a healthy lifestyle doesn’t make much of a difference (because cancer can be caused by many things), not it’s worrying that we don’t know what type of cancer she has

Mirabai · 23/03/2024 17:17

Cancer has a myriad different causes - genetic, environmental, microbial (virus or bacteria), lifestyle, stress/trauma. The best thing to do in life is to be as strong and healthy as possible, and that will give you the best chance against anything that comes your way.

Cupofteaandbiscuits · 23/03/2024 17:16

I get what you are saying but wouldn’t say it’s pointless. My FIL has never smoked, exercises daily and always has done, rarely has any alcohol (maybe the odd glass at Christmas) and eats very healthy. He has stage four lung cancer 😢
I'm just going with everything in moderation x

13luckyforsomeone · 23/03/2024 17:14

doublec · 23/03/2024 17:01

PoW's cancer is no-one's business other than her own. She has been essentially bullied into disclosing she is having adjuvant chemotherapy b ecause cancer was found after her abdomen op.

If she chooses to share at some point in the future, great, but if not, respect it. It's not worrying at all that a private individual has chosen not to disclose her private health information to the entire world.

I couldn’t agree more. I can always tell when someone I know has been Googling my cancer and the long-term survival statistics because they cannot hide the fact that they believe I must be planning my funeral.

If the PoW or the King made their diagnoses known, then (outdated, and irrelevant on an individual level) statistics would be all over the DM and wherever else, along with detailed diagrams of how that particular type of cancer tends to metastasise, what the further surgery would be, the prognosis if this that and the other… just awful stuff that none of us would like to think about really. And imagine if everyone you met “knew” that about you. Absolute nightmare.

I am fascinated by the culture around cancer (the language of fighting, journeys, battles and so on) and the way a lot of people think they know all about it. Someone I met recently was quite taken aback to learn I had been diagnosed AFTER the covid jab was invented, I think he had already decided that the vaccine had caused it 😂. Cancer treatment is bad enough without all the armchair experts - whose sole medical training is that they once read the back of a paracetamol packet - sharing their opinions of you online.

Sunshineandrainbows23 · 23/03/2024 17:12

@samarrange Aaagh what we should eat according to the Daily Mail! Yes, absolutely, something different every day. No wonder people get confused. :)

And yes a lot of the research is political.

I tend to follow Drs who have had dramatic success using nutrition and lifestyle over many many years rather than small scale research. I think it also helps to understand the why - it stops people being less susceptible, but it takes a lot of time ...

doublec · 23/03/2024 17:11

@Shan5474

For me the scary thing is that despite having access to the best doctors money can buy, the best thing they can suggest is chemotherapy which is so hard on the body. I just kind of expected she’d have access to some wonder drug that the rest of us can’t afford. I’m not a conspiracy theorist but maybe she does and publicising that would highlight class divides in healthcare

When I was diagnosed, I contacted the consultant about seeing her privately. She told me not to waste my money (and that it would be better spent on a good holiday once I had recovered), and that the treatment I would receive on the NHS would be just as good as anything I would get seeing her privately.

She was right. The NHS care I have had and am continuing to have has been excellent.

There is no magic pill that cures cancer. It does not matter how much money one has, you can't buy a treatment that does not exist. I too am having preventative chemo, and believe me, if I could have paid for an alternative, I would have. They don't use chemotherapy willy nilly. They use it because it's still the beat option there is. Not everyone is offered it either. And it is more than likely that PoW's relative good health made her a good candidate for it because chemo can be so hard on the body - it ages the recipient by almost two decades.

ZoeCM · 23/03/2024 17:10

Tropicalsunshine · 23/03/2024 12:41

Did you seriously think that a healthy lifestyle would protect you from all disease?
Do you think that all the people who are ill just didn't live healthily enough?

How bizarre.

Healthy eating and exercise will protect you from alot of illness and is very important as you age but it's not going to make you live forever!

I think some people really do believe that. I lurked on the r/vegan subreddit a while ago, and there was a question about whether it's vegan to have medical treatment that was tested on animals. One poster (clearly trying to avoid the question) said, "That's not a problem for vegans, because veganism is such a healthy diet." Astonishingly, a few other posters agreed with her.

Just - WTF? Even you think if veganism is the ideal human diet (and I really don't think it is) how could you possibly believe it'll stop you from ever getting ill? Literally make you immortal?

anonymous98 · 23/03/2024 17:09

OP I agree. I think diet, smoking etc. matters but sometimes people are just really unlucky and that's a frightening prospect.

SpaghettiWithaYeti · 23/03/2024 17:06

cakeorwine · 23/03/2024 17:02

All depends - how much of something you eat etc.

Like I said upthread - relative risk and absolute risk

It’s all relative: how to understand cancer risk (theconversation.com)

e,g,

For instance, a woman from a Western country has a 2 in 100 chance (2% absolute lifetime risk) of developing cancer of the endometrium (lining of the uterus) by the age of 85.

If the woman is obese, her risk of endometrial cancer is twice that of a woman of ideal weight. That is, a relative risk of 2 or 100% greater chance of developing endometrial cancer than a woman who is not obese.

This 100% figure may sound like obese women have a very high risk of endometrial cancer. But, in fact, the risk is still quite low, since doubling the 2% population risk still only makes the absolute risk of endometrial cancer in obese women around 4%. This is still a low probability of cancer.

Ahh don't spoil everyone's fun with actual facts, most of Mumsnet seems to love hating fat people and blaming them for everything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread