Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?

637 replies

Notsuretoputit · 23/03/2024 12:36

I try my best to live heathily (although definitely not fanatical). I try and stay away from ultra processed foods, try and avoid saturated fat, too much meat etc., try and exercise every week. I’ll have the odd takeaway and definitely overindulge on wine, but always try and be mindful of living heathily because so much information is constantly battering me through the radio, media etc. about getting ill from various foods and not exercising.

I’ve recently lost my mother far too young too, so I suppose it’s particularly on my mind at the moment. But then you hear Kate’s diagnosis, who obviously exercises regularly, has the best instructors, best food, best ingredients, best preparation, and she still falls ill, and it all seems a bit pointless.

AIBU to feel this way? I just wonder whether I really should make an effort to watch what I eat and run when I don’t feel like it if really, what will be will be regardless.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
28
ClairDeLaLune · 23/03/2024 23:57

Cancer can be completely random. Yes you can influence your probability of getting it, but either you’ll get it or you won’t, and then probabilities are out of the window. I am speaking as someone who had a 1 in 10,000 medical issue happen to me. I was just unlucky.

0sm0nthus · 23/03/2024 23:57

moderation is important in times of diet, excercise, alcohol and no smoking. But the older I get, the more I think, taking this to extremes in the hope it will protect you from cancer, is pointless. There must be a siginificant genetic imperative as well as environmental. And the older you get, the more the chance of having some sort of cancer. Many just seem completely unfair and random
@Cleaningupthemess
I agree with you about moderation! I dont think there is much to be gained from taking things to excess, you can likely improve your chances quite a lot just by being sensible.
Unless you happen to get a real buzz out of exercise and austere food theres no need to make yourself unhappy.

Lion400 · 23/03/2024 23:50

Anyone can get ill or have an accident at any time. No one is immune. The one definite thing is that 3 factors we can control, could make it worse.

‘Smoking, excess alcohol consumption and obesity are among the leading (but modifiable) risk factors for CVDs and cancer.

Compared with peer countries, in the UK smoking prevalence is lower and alcohol consumption is about middling, but excess alcohol consumption is higher, and levels of overweight/obesity in adults are among the highest (64 per cent in 2021)’.

https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/insight-and-analysis/reports/nhs-compare-health-care-systems-other-countries

0sm0nthus · 23/03/2024 23:45

Chemo might be 'bad' for you, hopefully it's less bad for you than it is for the cancer cells!
Even if it has negative side effects it's still the least worst option! Many medicines and treatments have unwanted effects, as with many things in life there are trade offs. All we can do it push forwards to develop more sophisticated forms of treatment.

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 23/03/2024 23:37

Sounds like you're looking for an excuse.

AngryPrincess · 23/03/2024 23:36

Ohh! I thought you meant Prisoner of War.

Nudgethatjudge · 23/03/2024 23:33

Healthy living helps when undergoing treatment and helps if it is not curable or able to put in into remission.

crossingbridges · 23/03/2024 23:26

POW does seem to have led an exemplary lifestyle, and to be a role model for healthy living. Kate’s diagnosis is a reminder that exercising, eating healthily, keeping lean and strong will reduce the risks but won’t eliminate them. It does make me feel less reassured that I’m protecting my health by exercising etc.
Cancer cases in under 50’s are up 80% in the last 30 years. That’s a terrible percentage that I don’t think many people are aware of. We have no idea how vulnerable we are.

cakeorwine · 23/03/2024 22:51

samarrange · 23/03/2024 22:27

Chemo might well take years off your life, in the sense that the average age of death among people who have ever had chemo is probably quite a bit younger than that of people who have never had chemo.

But the reason someone has chemo is because they have cancer, not because they took it up instead of coffee or something. People who have had cancer, even if it went into remission after treatment with chemo, simply live less long on average than those who never had cancer.

If you take the people who are diagnosed with cancer (the kinds of cancer that get treated with chemo), and compared the average ages of death of those people who accepted chemo versus those who declined it, the people who had the chemo will be shown to have lived a lot longer. For those people, chemo added years on to their lives.

This is an example of something that in epidemiology is called "Confounding by indication", which is a very easy mistake to make, usually accidentally but sometimes because someone wants to spread scare stories.

(Another example: it's true that the majority of people who were put on ventilators for Covid didn't survive, but that's because there's only so much a ventilator can do. If those people hadn't been put on ventilators they certainly wouldn't have survived. But Covid deniers use "OMG over half the people on ventilators died!!!!!!1!" to try and claim that "ventilators were part of the death project", and other dangerous bollocks.)

Edited

Sounds like Bayes theorem.

Given someone had a disease that needed chemo / a ventilator, what was the average of death in that group who had chemo versus those who needed it but who didn't have it.

Delatron · 23/03/2024 22:40

samarrange · 23/03/2024 22:27

Chemo might well take years off your life, in the sense that the average age of death among people who have ever had chemo is probably quite a bit younger than that of people who have never had chemo.

But the reason someone has chemo is because they have cancer, not because they took it up instead of coffee or something. People who have had cancer, even if it went into remission after treatment with chemo, simply live less long on average than those who never had cancer.

If you take the people who are diagnosed with cancer (the kinds of cancer that get treated with chemo), and compared the average ages of death of those people who accepted chemo versus those who declined it, the people who had the chemo will be shown to have lived a lot longer. For those people, chemo added years on to their lives.

This is an example of something that in epidemiology is called "Confounding by indication", which is a very easy mistake to make, usually accidentally but sometimes because someone wants to spread scare stories.

(Another example: it's true that the majority of people who were put on ventilators for Covid didn't survive, but that's because there's only so much a ventilator can do. If those people hadn't been put on ventilators they certainly wouldn't have survived. But Covid deniers use "OMG over half the people on ventilators died!!!!!!1!" to try and claim that "ventilators were part of the death project", and other dangerous bollocks.)

Edited

Yes this is a good explanation. Many people would be dead without chemo so by the same measure it could also add years on to your life.

I was just told that it ages you by 10 years - whatever that means. It’s a brutal treatment. But I personally am just happy to be here. If I live to 80 instead of 90 then I’ll take that. Because at one point I thought I was gonna die at 35.

samarrange · 23/03/2024 22:27

tothelefttotheleft · 23/03/2024 19:34

@Delatron

Chemo takes 10 years off your life?

I'm having chemo. I've never been told that. Can you tell me more about this or point me in the right direction?

Chemo might well take years off your life, in the sense that the average age of death among people who have ever had chemo is probably quite a bit younger than that of people who have never had chemo.

But the reason someone has chemo is because they have cancer, not because they took it up instead of coffee or something. People who have had cancer, even if it went into remission after treatment with chemo, simply live less long on average than those who never had cancer.

If you take the people who are diagnosed with cancer (the kinds of cancer that get treated with chemo), and compared the average ages of death of those people who accepted chemo versus those who declined it, the people who had the chemo will be shown to have lived a lot longer. For those people, chemo added years on to their lives.

This is an example of something that in epidemiology is called "Confounding by indication", which is a very easy mistake to make, usually accidentally but sometimes because someone wants to spread scare stories.

(Another example: it's true that the majority of people who were put on ventilators for Covid didn't survive, but that's because there's only so much a ventilator can do. If those people hadn't been put on ventilators they certainly wouldn't have survived. But Covid deniers use "OMG over half the people on ventilators died!!!!!!1!" to try and claim that "ventilators were part of the death project", and other dangerous bollocks.)

thegirlwithemousyhair · 23/03/2024 22:22

TheFormidableMrsC · 23/03/2024 22:02

This is an interesting take. It was of interest to my SBCN that I had been under extreme and relentless, PTSD inducing stress for 8 years prior to my diagnosis. So much so that she arranged for me to see a Macmillan psychologist in an attempt to reduce the affects of that. Stress impacts because of the affects of cortisol on your body.

Really sorry to hear this.

Stress is debilitating. People think stress is just in your head. Its not. It leads to a cascade of physiological affects. There's a reason why people who suffer adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) wind up at elevated risk of a whole host of health conditions including cancer. Their stress response has been primed by trauma which imprints itself on the body.. the body keeps score. They know that depression actually changes the brain at a structural level. Everything is connected.

Wishing you well and a full recovery. 🙏

Wishlist99 · 23/03/2024 22:20

OP I get your point. A close family member was a health care professional and the epitome of clean healthy living. Healthy weight, non smoker, light drinker. They really were a beacon of health. Amongst other things they had shunned processed and smoked meat for 25 years because of the specific link to stomach cancer. Zero family history of any kind of cancer; their parents both lived to a ripe old age. They died of stomach cancer. Really did make me think fuck it.

TheFormidableMrsC · 23/03/2024 22:17

@cakeorwine I do not have the BRCA gene. My cancer was pure bad luck. It was not related to diet and indeed was a type that is not impacted by exercise. Which is a shame as I have been an addicted exerciser for my entire life. I had had some hormone therapy for peri bleeding with medication that has also been linked to my type of cancer. I went through all the scenarios because everybody wants to know "why". There is no why. The amount of slim, fit vegan people on the chemo ward was interesting. My own mum is the perfect example of a lifestyle cancer. A high functioning alcoholic who ate well and was otherwise very healthy and slim (a model for 30 odd years) but got oesophageal cancer. She drank. A lot. Every day. Her diagnosis wasn't a surprise.

CatherinedeBourgh · 23/03/2024 22:16

People who are otherwise healthier do better with their cancer treatment too. So even if they still get it the outcome is likely to be better, and the side effects of the treatments more tolerable.

Except that being a bit overweight when starting out the cancer treatment is good.

Findmebythesea1 · 23/03/2024 22:14

Obviously a healthy life style is going to give you the best chance, but I do feel we are all born with an ‘expiry date’ to a degree, based souly on our genetics. So I know heart disease is genetic in my maternal family… many family members having heart disease/bypasses in their 40s. All reasonably healthy. But if I live an unhealthy lifestyle I’m probably inviting those genetic issues to the table early… but will living a healthy style absolve those genetics entirely? Of course not…

Sadza · 23/03/2024 22:13

Sometimes its lifestyle, and sometimes just bad luck. Being healthy will stack the odds in your favour but definitely not a guarantee. I hope the princess of wales recovers well and I think being fit will help with the treatment and recovery. I do get where you’re coming from but you need to think about the bigger picture and not just one person.

cakeorwine · 23/03/2024 22:13

TheFormidableMrsC · 23/03/2024 22:09

@thegirlwithemousyhair Yes indeed you are warned that there may be a cancer risk from radiotherapy and again from the Tamoxifen that stops your cancer coming back in your breasts but might give you cancer elsewhere. I still take the Tamoxifen because it's the better choice. People love to victim blame with cancer but largely it's genetic and out of your control.

And yet scientists estimate that cancer cases can be reduced with lifestyle changes

Can cancer be prevented? | How to reduce your risk of cancer (cancerresearchuk.org)

To think the PoW’s diagnosis makes healthy living seem pointless?
cakeorwine · 23/03/2024 22:10

thegirlwithemousyhair · 23/03/2024 22:05

Its like victim blaming - i.e. its your fault you got cancer becuase you didnt take enough exercise, eat well etc etc. The wife of someone I used to work with died from breast cancer and she ate very well, didnt smoke, drink etc and died at 55. She actually developed a secondary cancer as a result of the radiotherapy treatment.

That's not what it is.

I got skin cancer. I had a lot of sun exposure when young. I don't think I helped myself and that most likely increased the chance I would get it.

If I smoked a lot and got lung cancer, then I would absolutely blame myself for increasing my chances of getting it.

TheFormidableMrsC · 23/03/2024 22:09

@thegirlwithemousyhair Yes indeed you are warned that there may be a cancer risk from radiotherapy and again from the Tamoxifen that stops your cancer coming back in your breasts but might give you cancer elsewhere. I still take the Tamoxifen because it's the better choice. People love to victim blame with cancer but largely it's genetic and out of your control.

cakeorwine · 23/03/2024 22:08

TheFormidableMrsC · 23/03/2024 22:05

@cakeorwine My oncologist said (in relation to my type of cancer) that there is was absolutely nothing I could have done to prevent it and very little I could do to prevent it coming back. I'm fit, I exercise and lift daily, I eat well, I like wine (again, no impact). It was just bad luck. I don't dispute that everybody can take steps to reduce risk. However, that's all it is.

That's different to what you said.
Some cancers are genetic - the BRCA1 gene being a classic example.
But others have other causes - and the probability of getting it can be altered by lifestyle.

I had skin cancer. I have a feeling that sun exposure when young did not help at all.

ChanelNo19EDT · 23/03/2024 22:07

I know what you mean op. It is a harsh reality. I feel/felt like I was going to dodge cancer myself. Hardly drink, don't smoke, I eat real food, I exercise... I felt like health was my future. This is a very natural dissonance I think. Nobody wanders around thinking there's a 50:50 chance I'll get cancer. We all have to live in a bit of denial because the facts are too harsh.

TheFormidableMrsC · 23/03/2024 22:05

@cakeorwine My oncologist said (in relation to my type of cancer) that there is was absolutely nothing I could have done to prevent it and very little I could do to prevent it coming back. I'm fit, I exercise and lift daily, I eat well, I like wine (again, no impact). It was just bad luck. I don't dispute that everybody can take steps to reduce risk. However, that's all it is.

thegirlwithemousyhair · 23/03/2024 22:05

TheFormidableMrsC · 23/03/2024 21:57

@cakeorwine My oncologist disagrees with you

Its like victim blaming - i.e. its your fault you got cancer becuase you didnt take enough exercise, eat well etc etc. The wife of someone I used to work with died from breast cancer and she ate very well, didnt smoke, drink etc and died at 55. She actually developed a secondary cancer as a result of the radiotherapy treatment.

XenoBitch · 23/03/2024 22:05

YABU

We don't know what cancer she has (and don't need to know TBH). There are hundreds of cancers, and you can reduce your risk of many (reduce, not eliminate), with healthy lifestyle choices. Some are just plain bad luck.

If you think it is futile to live healthily because of the PoW (which seems like a weird reach anyway... were you looking for a reason to say fuck it anyway?), then it may not be cancer that gets you.. it could be diabetes or cardiac issues.

At the end of the day, we all die anyway.