Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you are doing to raise good men?

137 replies

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 23/03/2024 05:30

I have 2 sons, 7 and 4.

I read so many posts on here involving men who are useless, misogynistic, abusive etc. I am thankful my husband is NOT like this, but I have been thinking a lot about what steps I can take to ensure I raise kind, respectful and safe men. I would be so ashamed of one of my sons ended up treating a woman poorly.

Obviously an advantage is having their Dad as a positive male role model.

Other things I have been doing are teaching them to clean up after themselves (clearing dishes, picking up dirty clothes, wiping up wee splatters). But is there more I could and should be doing?

OP posts:
5128gap · 23/03/2024 09:17

I raised my two sons in the days before this new pressure was placed on mums. Before the stamping out of misogyny and the responsibility for the behaviour of adult males was laid at our door, so in honesty I didn't consciously do anything, other than create a household where the values I believed in were embedded. I've always challenged them on sexism, in an age appropriate and open way that sparked discussion. We are great talkers in our house and will happily discuss and debate a wide range of issues, so that helped.

I think my adult sons are decent men, but I think part of that is down to their inate character and their responses to their environment.

Realistically, once your boys enter the world, your influence on them will decline year by year, replaced by that of their peers and the media. So obviously be vigilant about what they're watching and the attitudes of those they mix with as best you can. I'd also foster their independence of thought so they have some confidence not to follow the herd.

ViciousCurrentBun · 23/03/2024 09:15

@Alwaystired23 I hate seeing kids chase birds.

He saw the way his Father treated me, that’s the main things. You can say what you like but there is learnt behaviour. They see men treating women badly it’s really terrible. Many young men do not have good male role models, it’s a massive issue.

He had to help with chores and I taught him how to cook. He also went to air cadets and met girls his age who did just what he did. I haven’t been involved with his washing or cleaning his room since he went to secondary school. Because of cadets he can iron and polish shoes better than I ever could.

I also told him at age 13 how scared some women are of men. It was because walking home one evening from football a woman had crossed the road and looked scared as she walked towards him. It was getting dark and he is a really tall lad he was probably about 6ft 2 then. I explained about male violence at that point and the fear women live with.

LovelyTheresa · 23/03/2024 09:14

IgnoranceNotOk · 23/03/2024 07:29

When arguing with each other I always explain it they’re hurting or snatching etc that if someone says no or they don’t like it then we don’t do it.

Last night, I let DS1 6 play phonics games on his tablet as a treat before the weekend and then he had a massive argument with DS2 4 as DS4 wanted to use one end of the sofa for his game. I then took the tablet away and we had no tv and I told DS1 he could have thought ‘I’ve got my tablet so I’m lucky, I’ll move over so my brother can use this part of the sofa’.

I really think it’s just having consistent, clear boundaries and consequences.

Oh and DS1 said something about kings and I said I could be the king and he told me I couldn’t and I asked why not and I could see he couldn’t figure out more than kings are boys and I told him it’s just a word and I’d make a really good king.

Your DS wasn't wrong, though. Kings are boys, aren't they? That isn't to say that a Queen cannot be as powerful as a King, just that the word for a male monarch is a King.

JaneChampagne · 23/03/2024 09:08

The stuff I read on here about men is so far away from my own experience of them and definitely not the norm IME. We raised our sons the same way we were raised. I would have raised girls the same way. My boys are in their late tens now and are both hard working, respectful, well liked, have lovely girlfriends and are great fun!

Alwaystired23 · 23/03/2024 08:59

SnugglyJumpersMakeItBetter · 23/03/2024 07:41

I teach them to be really empathetic towards animals. I figure a boy who restores tired bees, judges other children for chasing birds and picks up litter so that wildlife doesn't choke on it is less likely to grow up to hit his wife.

Going off topic a bit here, my MIL use to encourage my ds's to chase birds, I remember walking through the Town centre with her, she grabbed their hands and ran at a load of pigeons. I was mortified. They know not to do it now. Just why.

SmokedPaprikaPuffs · 23/03/2024 08:45

My son (7) has a good dad/grandads/uncles and ultimately I think this is more important than anything else. (I don't mean to offend single mums whose children don't have that, I know it can't always be possible and the children can still grow up to be good people.)

However the men in my child's life cuddle him when he's crying and tell him they love him, teaching him emotions are ok and not shameful, and all respect thier wives/girlfriends/sisters/mums etc.. and he's absorbing all of that throughout his everyday life. He'd be an extreme anomaly in his family if he grew up to be abusive or misogynistic.

I am actively trying to teach him to clean up after himself but that's not a gender thing for me. I just believe that being clean and tidy is a lot to do with upbringing.

WandaWonder · 23/03/2024 08:37

Whatsnormalhere · 23/03/2024 06:07

Raising my son in the exact same way as my daughter. All children should be raised with values and good manners.

Edited

I think the same, why differentiate?

Gettingbysomehow · 23/03/2024 08:34

My son is 40 and a wonderful man. He has a lovely partner too.
I'd say the most important thing is unconditional love, secondly not letting them game all day and all night.
Once they start that its the beginning of the end. They can have other hobbies and outdoor exercise instead.
They have to partake in chores from a young age and understand that the household can only run smoothly if everyone pitches in.
A good work ethic is also essential. The parents or in my case parent must demonstrate that.
He's a professional artist now and doing well.

neverbeenskiing · 23/03/2024 08:31

I work with children and families and have noticed a massive increase in parents excusing, minimising and deflecting when it comes to their child's behaviour over the last few years. This creates a sense of entitlement and a belief that the rules do not apply to them. IME young men who have been raised this way often feel justified in ignoring the boundaries and feelings of others, and refuse to to take responsibility for their behaviour. This has massive implications for their relationships.

My DS is still young, he has Autism and ADHD but we are very clear with him that this does not mean freedom from consequences. We will always fight to get him the support he needs, but his SEN will not be accepted as an excuse for unkindness or behaviour that impacts on others. Accountability is hugely important and one of the most important things parents can instill in boys and young men IMO.

Workawayxx · 23/03/2024 08:29

Wastedagreatusername · 23/03/2024 06:39

If they have a good dad that’s the most important thing. They are lucky

Porn is the biggest damager of men. Look at culture reframed ( Gail Dines) for how to have conversations on that.

Thank you so much for this, joining the tween course now for my 12 year old DS. I agree porn is such a horrifically damaging part of culture for men.

I would say good ways to help boys grow up are to make sure he sees equality in the home as much as possible. I’ve also found scouts (or beavers/cubs when younger) has helped my DS a lot, there are girls there and female leaders as well as male and they do all sorts including cooking, he has learned to change bed sheets, iron and all sorts. I guess it depends what your local branch is like but it has been positive for ds.

DaffodilsAlready · 23/03/2024 08:27

The point about peer group is important, I think. What I have noticed with both DC as they have moved from primary to secondary is that their friendship groups have changed with their interests. DS has a much wider friendship group than at primary and I think that has allowed him to move away from boys with views and interests he doesn’t really share anymore.

43ontherocksporfavor · 23/03/2024 08:23

Manners are very important op. Keep it up. I work with primary children you notice the chn with good manners, those who don’t snatch, push and grab or force their way past you in a doorway.

Spacecowboys · 23/03/2024 08:20

We have raised ds’s to treat other people well and be respectful. They aren’t at the long term relationship stage yet but we model the importance of shared values and expectations. Children often take their experiences of their parents relationship into adulthood. It would be the same if we had daughters ( the question of how to raise ‘good’ women is rarely asked, which is frustrating as women can be *holes too).

Calamitousness · 23/03/2024 08:19

yes, raise your children. Not just boys. To be good humans. But listen to @EarringsandLipstick that’s the real life story of young people. Manners are nice but not what is going to make your child a ‘good’ person/partner. Once they are 14/5 it’s all about peer group/school/outside influences that you need to be aware and involved in. Keep talking to them. But having a good relationship. Whether that’s with your partner or if you are on your own with friends etc. is key. Not letting anyone treat you badly while the children are growing up is probably the biggest thing as a parent you can do. After that it’s about knowing their peers and hoping they’ve picked good kids to be mates with. Fuck manners and washing dishes. That’s not where it is at.

Lovingitallnow · 23/03/2024 08:16

I read once it's more about what the dad does that influences conceptions about gender roles. Who picks up the domestic duties etc. So I'm making sure dh pulls his weight at home. (Im Sahp so finding that balance is tough) but I'm happy to leave him do the dishwasher, dinner and laundry if it means my boys will become good men. It's tough but someone's gotta do it.

tracktrail · 23/03/2024 08:15

TinyGingerCat · 23/03/2024 07:28

It's not just a woman's job to do this. My 16 y.o DS is a kind and thoughtful young man. He goes to school, he works but most importantly he has a kind and thoughtful dad who has shown him what good looks like. It's a bit corny but if you can't see it you can't be it.

It's not just a woman's job, but the reality is that vast numbers of boys are reared by single mothers. By definition, these boys should be being brought up to treat women well in large numbers. This isn't the case, though.
Many boys don't have dads on the scene at all, some because dad is a useless shit, some because mothers don't want him around. Boys then often look elsewhere for role models.
There is no 'script'. People do change as they mature both for good and bad. Mental ill health is a big problem and influences people in the way they behave.
Adults need to think about how they behave and own their life choices.
We are all responsible for our own behaviour.

Meadowfinch · 23/03/2024 08:07

My ds is 15.

I left my ex when ds was two because ex morphed after I became pregnant, and I didn't want ds growing up thinking drunkenness and sexism are normal.

So DS has grown up in a household where he sees a woman being equal to any man every day. It would never occur to him that a woman couldn't drive or do anything else as well as a man.

We treat each other with kindness, consideration & respect. We consult each other on most things, and share tasks. He carries shopping without being asked.

At 15 he is familiar with the washing machine, dishwasher, and loo brush. Less so, the hoover or the squeegy for cleaning the shower. He can cook basic meals, and understands nutrition and cleanliness. He knows basic first aid.

He's going through a teen phase of throwing all his clothes on the floor at the moment, but tidies up if I remind him.

He thinks Andrew Tate is a knob. The internet's influence is insidious though. Last summer he was upset about something and finally admitted he was worried that girls will only go out with men who have £80k a year & a BMW. Thankfully he's a mathematician, and I pointed out that if that were so, 90% of men would be single. That seemed to satisfy him. 😁He has common sense and is calm and logical.

Best of all, I like him.

43ontherocksporfavor · 23/03/2024 08:02

You all sound like fabulous mothers and as a mother of two young adult DDs it’s good to hear. They have come across some awfully behaved men and thankfully some lovely ones. They often say that DH is hard to for boyfriends to live up to. The interesting thing is he had an awful example- his dad being chauvinistic and his mum being very passive. He and his brothers are all fantastic modern men and fathers.

RickyGervaislovesdogs · 23/03/2024 07:56

26% Think YABU - and therein lies the problem, because it creates this…...

“some friends of my 18yo dd are making uni plans to suit their boyfriends, and spending every other weekend crying, because society is so adamant that they should be in a relationship.” - This so sad.

SpongeBob2022 · 23/03/2024 07:55

Encouraging good manners and behaviour (regardless of sex)
Having a positive male role model.
Having a positive female role model (possibly a bit controversial depending on circumstances but basically not being a mum martyr or giving the impression that Mum is the default parent).

There are also a few articles online about the importance of educating our sons, regardless of how nice they may be, about the fact that there are circumstances in which women feel vulnerable and what men can do to help this. For example, behaviour they can exhibit when coming across a woman they don't know who is walking alone at night, to minimise any perceived threat (for older children, obviously).

Tempnamechng · 23/03/2024 07:52

Whatsnormalhere · 23/03/2024 06:07

Raising my son in the exact same way as my daughter. All children should be raised with values and good manners.

Edited

I agree with this, not holding sons to lower standards than daughters, and setting a good example to both in what is acceptable in a healthy relationship. Also teaching both of them that being in a relationship isn't important, they don't need to settle until they feel ready. Not so much my son as he is younger, but some friends of my 18yo dd are making uni plans to suit their boyfriends, and spending every other weekend crying, because society is so adamant that they should be in a relationship.

DaffodilsAlready · 23/03/2024 07:51

I am a single parent, so somewhat challenged in the good male role model department.
To be honest, I just get on with parenting. If DS wants to talk about people he knows liking Andrew Tate (not so much now), we have a conversation and dissect that, the same if he comes home and tells me that his friends have made sexist comments he was not comfortable with. Actually, that brings to mind he also told me one time when his dad was being sexist and DS challenged him on it. But he also talks about when he has encountered casual homophobia and things like that so I think it is about recognising this and not being a bystander.

I am pretty open in my views about how he needs to grow up to be a good man who treats people well and what that looks like, but mainly when it comes up naturally in conversation.

FrenchFairytale · 23/03/2024 07:47

Left his lazy father and met a real man.

ooooohnoooooo · 23/03/2024 07:47

Lots of what people above have said. Plus when old enough talked to him about porn, trafficking and exploitation of girls and young women and how vile and abusive it is. I really do think that porn is at the heart of so much dreadful behaviour towards women. It instills a sense of entitlement to our bodies and to think they own us.

I've (we) raised both of my kids (boy and girl) to be feminists.

Challenged language and stereotypes. Small things like the word 'bossy' is not allowed in my house (if used is always challenged!) as it's always said when referring negatively to women who have their shit together. Never men. Small things like that make them think about ingrained poor male behaviour and language.

He had a baby doll and pushchair when he was tiny. He asked for it so he could,be like his lovely dad.

Shared stories of the misogyny I've experienced first hand so he can see the impact.

He's now in his 20s and a lovely respectful young man with lots of female friends.

Knew I'd cracked it when we had a conversation when he was about 17 - about consent. He told me that some people were filming each other giving consent before having sex so they had evidence if any accusations were made afterwards. I asked him what he thought about it. "If you have to film someone giving consent youre having sex with the wrong people" was his very sage reply. I love him so much.

EarringsandLipstick · 23/03/2024 07:47

Doingmybest12 · 23/03/2024 07:42

I agree that it's not about manners, anyone can learn to show manners. Actually some very dangerous and sexist men are very charming and have great manners. That's why they suck you in.

Exactly.

My ex adored his mother. Was very good to her, and in general a decent & kind person (you would have thought) to most people. My parents loved him.

His manners & outward respect gave no indication of the abusive marriage he made me endure.