Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you are doing to raise good men?

137 replies

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 23/03/2024 05:30

I have 2 sons, 7 and 4.

I read so many posts on here involving men who are useless, misogynistic, abusive etc. I am thankful my husband is NOT like this, but I have been thinking a lot about what steps I can take to ensure I raise kind, respectful and safe men. I would be so ashamed of one of my sons ended up treating a woman poorly.

Obviously an advantage is having their Dad as a positive male role model.

Other things I have been doing are teaching them to clean up after themselves (clearing dishes, picking up dirty clothes, wiping up wee splatters). But is there more I could and should be doing?

OP posts:
ScarlettOBan · 23/03/2024 11:48

I think it’s interesting that women often feel they are shouldering the responsibility for raising ‘good men’. You will often see people posting on social media after some news headline about a terrible man that they are raising their sons to be ‘good men’. Feels like another patriarchal response to male behaviour. So much influences behaviour, both nature and nurture, it doesn’t all rest on the shoulders of women to ensure we have a society of ‘good men’.

Of course I am raising my sons to have good manners, understand inequality, to respect fellow humans and try to model positive relationships to them. But how men turn out can’t be solely laid at the door of their mother.

Hibernatalie · 23/03/2024 11:46

Leading by example. DH and I earn the same, share childcare, share housework. We treat our dd and ds the same, same expectations (2 year age difference so taking that into account). The answer is equality I think. You can harp on to your children about feminism until you're blue in the face - they won't be what they can't see.

DaffodilsAlready · 23/03/2024 11:42

Missamyp · 23/03/2024 10:33

I have boys and find these threads utterly devoid of all critical thinking.
Unfortunately feminism has become embroiled with othering including our own male children.

I think you have things backwards.
in much of history and in many places in the world, women are othered.
It is less than 150 years since married women in the Uk were allowed by law to keep their own property and earnings, it is less than 100 years since all women in this country got the vote, it is less than 50 years since women were entitled to equal pay, it is less than forty years since marital rape was criminalised in the U.K., it is less than twenty years since rape included when a woman was drunk or sleeping in Scotland (I am not sure about the rest of the U.K.).
While you may argue that these wrongs have now been addressed, women still do the majority of the household chores and childcare, and they still make up the majority of people living in poverty. Victims of domestic abuse are overwhelmingly female and two women are killed by their intimate partners a week, there are woefully low prosecution rates for rape. Women are sexualised in pornography and expected to conform to quite high standards of beauty.
(I was going to add in the marriage bar but I cannot remember when that ended. This is that women were expected to give up their jobs on marriage).
This thread is not about othering male children, but how we/should we teach (male) children that women and girls should not be othered in the ways that have happened historically and still happen today. Indeed, no-one should be othered. This is important given that it many ways, gender stereotypes are being recreated and reinforced more than they were when I was growing up.

Krakken · 23/03/2024 11:20

Dh and I are hopefully teaching ours to be good human beings.
The things I've always thought to be important is showing love and affection, good manners and being respectful, being active, doing chores, working hard at school, being practical, giving back to society, having lots of time outdoors and experiencing the world.
Being capable and having good character hopefully gives them good self esteem and strong values.

WhyDoesItAlways · 23/03/2024 11:13

I believe it's never too early to teach about consent. Consent isn't just about sex. If you're child is playing with a friend and the friend says stop, they need to know to stop. And they should expect the same in return. Personal space and boundaries should always be respected regardless of gender. No means no.

I remember being tickled as a child and asking for it to stop but was laughing at the same time so the person carried on. It was awful. I've seen the same done to my son by a grandparent. I didn't think I would have to explain to a grown up that no means no but apparently I did.

BigFatLiar · 23/03/2024 10:54

You're on mumsnet, you should know there's no such thing as a good man. Do your best, it's all you can do. Remind them that no matter what some will still be offended by them. Simple example DH was a sexist and misogynist for holding the door open for a young woman, he'd actually opened it for me.

Treat others as you want to be treated but don't be a doormat. Listen. No sex until after marriage or deciding to settle down. As a young man he could find himself tied for years to someone following a bit of fun.

Womblingmerrily · 23/03/2024 10:46

Quite frankly you are over-estimating the influence of mothers on men and underestimating the effect of society.

Your charming helpful, well mannered young children are going to do what mummy wants because they love mummy above all else at that stage.

They will reach a stage where your love doesn't matter that much to them - in fact they are trying to get away from it and other people's praise and influence is much much larger.

If everything they read, watch, see and hear around them from media sources, their peers and the way that they are treated in society is negative then your waning influence as their mum may not always be enough to balance it out.

I would really like adults to treat all children better than we do in the uk, with less criticism and more investment. I would also like to hear fewer negative sexist comments about boys and men. When they hear that, especially from women it doesn't make them want to change, it makes them resentful.

Tootsey11 · 23/03/2024 10:45

My son has grown up with no male role models, just him and me.

I've taught him kindness, manners, to listen.

Also to pull his weight, how to do things around the house, and not expect to be thanked for it, it's what you do for your household.

He doesn't 'get' male banter and how men talk when in a group. He just doesn't be around friends who talk or act in a certain way around women. He is 22 now and a kind, hardworking respectful individual and everyone who knows him has told me this.

OldChinaJug · 23/03/2024 10:35

CroftonWillow · 23/03/2024 09:54

Ensuring their father is an influence in their lives as far as possible.

This only works when the dad is decent though.

I'm a teacher. I've had dad refuse to hug their young sons when they pick them up from school because 'boys don't do that'; I've had them try and withdraw their sons from the dance element of PE because 'dancing is for girls'.

At the moment i have a dad who is trying to remove his son from PSHE lessons because we're making him and other boys 'soft' and not teaching them how to be men.

Many dads still want their sons to use their fists rather than their words to resolve problems in school.

I was a single parent and my son is now in his 20s. He's never met his father.

He's a decent man because I raised him and my daughter in the same way. To treat others with respect and to know that I wasn't their maid.

Some women I know openly admit that they didn't require their sons to do anything domestic chore related at home.

Newsenmum · 23/03/2024 10:34

Missamyp · 23/03/2024 10:33

I have boys and find these threads utterly devoid of all critical thinking.
Unfortunately feminism has become embroiled with othering including our own male children.

What do you mean?

MissyB1 · 23/03/2024 10:34

Missamyp · 23/03/2024 10:33

I have boys and find these threads utterly devoid of all critical thinking.
Unfortunately feminism has become embroiled with othering including our own male children.

Absolutely, and it’s worrying.

Missamyp · 23/03/2024 10:33

MissyB1 · 23/03/2024 10:26

Agreed. It’s depressing and totally feeds into (and reinforces) gender stereotypes.

I have boys and find these threads utterly devoid of all critical thinking.
Unfortunately feminism has become embroiled with othering including our own male children.

Lelophants · 23/03/2024 10:32

CroftonWillow · 23/03/2024 09:54

Ensuring their father is an influence in their lives as far as possible.

Ensuring a good father is in their lives. Watching their mums have self respect and leave bad men is very important.

Blueberry40 · 23/03/2024 10:32

Encourage them to share how they’re feeling and learn to communicate how they feel to others in healthy ways- there are lots of books you can read to them which help with this. This prevents a lot of bad behaviour and helps them to know that they don’t have to buy into toxic male stereotypes. Never make them feel shame for crying or being vulnerable and let them know it’s absolutely okay to ask for help. This really helps to avoid a lot of issues caused later in life which are fuelled by anger, frustration and hurt.

Newsenmum · 23/03/2024 10:28

Malarandras · 23/03/2024 10:26

Oh I have to say that as a widow I just love all the comments about the need for a good Father to raise a good son.

I guess I will just tell my son to quit while he is ahead using that logic. He is actually extremely polite and thoughtful, much more so than his older sister. I suppose that’s just a glitch though.

Absolutely not op!! It’s just easier. I’m sure you’re doing a bloody fantastic job! I’m so sorry for your loss.

Newsenmum · 23/03/2024 10:28

MissyB1 · 23/03/2024 10:26

Agreed. It’s depressing and totally feeds into (and reinforces) gender stereotypes.

Because you look at the men out there and it’s scary. I read something recently about would you rather meet a lone man or bear in the woods? Most womennsaid bear.

Malarandras · 23/03/2024 10:26

Oh I have to say that as a widow I just love all the comments about the need for a good Father to raise a good son.

I guess I will just tell my son to quit while he is ahead using that logic. He is actually extremely polite and thoughtful, much more so than his older sister. I suppose that’s just a glitch though.

Lelophants · 23/03/2024 10:26

Empathy is a massive one. A lot of things could be better if more men had empathy.
Playing games with dolls, animals, talking about feelings. Receiving empathy. Reading!!!!!

MissyB1 · 23/03/2024 10:26

Alaina7 · 23/03/2024 10:13

Threads like this and people still wonder why some women are disappointed to be having a son rather than a daughter

Agreed. It’s depressing and totally feeds into (and reinforces) gender stereotypes.

DaffodilsAlready · 23/03/2024 10:24

Alaina7 · 23/03/2024 10:13

Threads like this and people still wonder why some women are disappointed to be having a son rather than a daughter

Why?

I was happy to have one of each, but they have different challenges in the world.

Unrelated, I do think it is important to acknowledge though that good people come from terrible upbringings and people from good upbringings still go on and do terrible things. Children grow up to be independent human beings and at some point need to take responsibility for their own actions. I do agree with the ‘why is this seen as the mother’s responsibility’ comments when obviously a lot of the influences on people of all ages and whether male or female come from outside the home. And homes come in all shapes and sizes so there is not one ‘right’ way. We just do our best and hope our children will be happy and successful, I guess.

Imgoingtobefree · 23/03/2024 10:21

It sounds like what you are doing now is good.

The danger is when they reach the teenage years and puberty and porn hit them. I think this is the age that boys are often proving themself to other boys and sometimes they denigrate girls to raise themselves up.

I think the best thing you can do is realise that our children (including girls) often try to only show their best side to their parents. So always keep an open mind that they may be bending the truth at times.

It’s pretty normal I think for teenagers to compartmentalise their lives at this time and when older. They know the behaviour their parents expect, but they also know how to interact with their peers to fit in. This applies to girls just as much. (Though there’s usually less porn involved!)

wutheringkites · 23/03/2024 10:14

@EarringsandLipstick

That's reassuring! He's currently at the stage of thinking that women are cool but girls his own age are a bit silly.

Something that made me sad was seeing a poster in the classroom about what the reception kids said what was special about their classmates. Everything about my son from the girls was about how he looked.

Alaina7 · 23/03/2024 10:13

Threads like this and people still wonder why some women are disappointed to be having a son rather than a daughter

benefitstaxcredithelp · 23/03/2024 10:12

Lovingitallnow · 23/03/2024 08:16

I read once it's more about what the dad does that influences conceptions about gender roles. Who picks up the domestic duties etc. So I'm making sure dh pulls his weight at home. (Im Sahp so finding that balance is tough) but I'm happy to leave him do the dishwasher, dinner and laundry if it means my boys will become good men. It's tough but someone's gotta do it.

We do this too. At least 50-50 in terms of household jobs but also I’ve been ensuring DH does an equal amount of house/life admin as me so things like booking kid’s appointments, organizing kids activities and sports clubs, thinking of Xmas and birthday gifts, buying and wrapping, planning holidays etc. I don’t want my DC growing up thinking that only women out thought into those types of things and carrying all the mental load.

mondaytosunday · 23/03/2024 10:10

My son's father died when he was six. He doesn't really have a male role model. It has been a struggle particularly in the teen years where they copy their peers.
But generally, my son has always been respectful of others, can cook, iron and clean for himself. He teases me sometimes about 'woman's work' but I think that's just to get a rise from me (he's 20). He works very hard and is trying to make his way in the world. People make assumptions about young men which doesn't help.