Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you are doing to raise good men?

137 replies

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 23/03/2024 05:30

I have 2 sons, 7 and 4.

I read so many posts on here involving men who are useless, misogynistic, abusive etc. I am thankful my husband is NOT like this, but I have been thinking a lot about what steps I can take to ensure I raise kind, respectful and safe men. I would be so ashamed of one of my sons ended up treating a woman poorly.

Obviously an advantage is having their Dad as a positive male role model.

Other things I have been doing are teaching them to clean up after themselves (clearing dishes, picking up dirty clothes, wiping up wee splatters). But is there more I could and should be doing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MissyB1 · 25/03/2024 12:55

Oheighthundreddoubleohtensixtysix · 25/03/2024 02:49

I can't help but feel that treating our sons like potential abusers, patronising them and applying far more stringent rules to them than their sisters could be counter-productive and feed into some of the culture which has made the likes of Andrew Tate so popular.

In my view all kids should be raised to help with chores, do things for themselves, build their independence and help out their siblings. You see all the time on Mumsnet that this doesn't happen and 9 year old Alice can't make a bowl of cereal and her twin brother Timmy doesn't know where the sock drawer is.

Once they become teenagers things change and their peers have a large influence on them - both male and female. This rhetoric that girls are angelic and lovely and selfless and meek and vulnerable really isn't how I remember it. Teenage girls are often horrible and the boys are all too aware of this. This is when a lot of the bravado and toxicity begins to seep out.

Boys should be given the space to grow up, to make mistakes, to fend for themselves, and to have someone who loves them to turn to when they need it.

I also think parents should remember that young people see things from a young person's perspective and have a real instinct for any perceived unfairness. So if they see their father going out earning the money, their mother staying at home all day and then suggesting husband pulls his weight when he gets home, this maybe isn't going to have the desired effect.

Some very wise words here.

BigFatLiar · 25/03/2024 10:17

This rhetoric that girls are angelic and lovely and selfless and meek and vulnerable really isn't how I remember it

They're bloody awful, bullying and shit stirring then whenit goes pear shaped smile sweetly and say who me?

I think girls often play on the fact that their peer group of boys are often less mature and easily led which enables them to stir up the trouble and sit back and enjoy the show. This certainly seems to be the case with young women.

Oheighthundreddoubleohtensixtysix · 25/03/2024 02:49

I can't help but feel that treating our sons like potential abusers, patronising them and applying far more stringent rules to them than their sisters could be counter-productive and feed into some of the culture which has made the likes of Andrew Tate so popular.

In my view all kids should be raised to help with chores, do things for themselves, build their independence and help out their siblings. You see all the time on Mumsnet that this doesn't happen and 9 year old Alice can't make a bowl of cereal and her twin brother Timmy doesn't know where the sock drawer is.

Once they become teenagers things change and their peers have a large influence on them - both male and female. This rhetoric that girls are angelic and lovely and selfless and meek and vulnerable really isn't how I remember it. Teenage girls are often horrible and the boys are all too aware of this. This is when a lot of the bravado and toxicity begins to seep out.

Boys should be given the space to grow up, to make mistakes, to fend for themselves, and to have someone who loves them to turn to when they need it.

I also think parents should remember that young people see things from a young person's perspective and have a real instinct for any perceived unfairness. So if they see their father going out earning the money, their mother staying at home all day and then suggesting husband pulls his weight when he gets home, this maybe isn't going to have the desired effect.

BigFatLiar · 23/03/2024 17:14

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 23/03/2024 14:18

Doesn't matter what you do raising your son he'll still be 'the potential rapist' 'the violent misogynist' etc on here.

Just do your best to raise a caring human. Hopefully he'll find a good young woman to share lives with. Remind him not to settle with someone just because and to talk through each others expectations. (And check she's not a mimsnetter, they're awfull)

Well you're on here, so I guess you must be awful. Given the proportion of women who suffer rape or sexual assault, it's not exactly surprising that quite a lot of women see men as potential rapists or violent misogynists.

Well I wouldn't have married me. Fortunately DH saw something in me and we're good together.

We didn't have sons, just girls who were largely raised by DH so by a man. They're good well adjusted young women, married with their own families and still when they visit they're daddies girls. They've been raised with the idea they can do anything they set their mind to.

ohthejoys21 · 23/03/2024 16:49

Got my son away from his abusive dad and brought step dad into his life who is an incredible role model.

Marblessolveeverything · 23/03/2024 16:30

I've a sixteen and ten year old boys.
Their role models (father, uncles, extended friends and family) are good men.

Be open with challenges that exist and your experiences, my elder son was so shocked when I brought up the change of law to rape in marriage was a recent change in Irish Law. That women couldn't own property, and where legally discriminated against in his grandparents time.

Keep communicating, listen to their concerns, their worries. If they don't know who they are then they will look for guidance elsewhere.

Be the guidance, reassure them not knowing the right thing to do isn't a failure. Not asking for help is. Teach them to be proud of themselves and to be allies and to those with quieter voices. It is a difficult place for all young people at the moment.

mrsplum2015 · 23/03/2024 16:30

My son has two sisters which has naturally clarified his understanding !!

He also goes to a school with fabulous values so is not just working from one "home" viewpoint.

emhus82 · 23/03/2024 16:14

I read in an article by a psychologist about raising boys that it's really important they understated that you are not just their mum. Someone who is just there to cater to their needs. That you are an employee, a boss, a wife, a sister, a daughter, a women in her own right.

Basically making sure they are aware that women and not just there to serve and cater to them and them alone. As this is what many many men are programmed to believe.

Powderblue1 · 23/03/2024 15:31

My sons are similar age to yours. I do the same in getting them to pick up after themselves. If they ask for something that they can do themselves, eg ask for a glass of water I tell them to do it rather than do it for them.

I also ask them to help me with things regularly like, 'can you help me carry this bag please it's so heavy and I can't do it by myself', opening the front door and turning the alarm off etc. that kind of thing. I read it's good to get them to feel good about themselves for helping.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 23/03/2024 15:27

Ensuring their father is an influence in their lives as far as possible.

Imo the father's influence is often the problem. You only have to read the Relationships board to see that. Fathers who treat their children's mothers badly, who don't do their fair share at home (either with domestic work or parenting), and some who perpetuate ridiculously old-fashioned stereotypes about boys and girls, even when the mother does not (e.g. objecting if their pre-schooler ds gets his nails painted or plays with a 'girls'' toy).

EarringsandLipstick · 23/03/2024 14:50

Newsenmum · 23/03/2024 13:53

Almost everyone seems to think their little boy is perfect, sweet and lovely. No ons thinks their son is a potential rapist. EVERY boy is a potential rapist. I think women need to realise this when raising their sons. It’s an uncomfortable truth. There is a lot you can do with teaching empathy and respect.

Ag the same time, I don’t agree that the mother should always be blamed for this. Unless a woman is actively abusive or allows rape and poor treatment of women to be viewed by her son, we shouldn’t blame mothers. It’s a man’s responsibility to not be a rapist.

Oh come on

EVERY person (male or female) is a potential ... something: thief, bully, abuser whatever.

Every human being potentially could be evil, thankfully most aren't.

Specifying that all men are potential racists is just silly.

rickyrickygrimes · 23/03/2024 14:47

I've read widely on it. I have two boys, never really expected to and I don't have any brothers, just one male cousin. I went to a tiny primary school where there were basically 4 girls in my class and that was it. So I didn't really know much about boys. My mum was a primary teacher though, and she worked in some tough schools - she had a lot of wise words about teaching boys which included don't try and be their friend, treat them with respect and demand respect in return and let them run and run and run some more every playtime! And don't treat boys and girls as if they are the same, because they aren't. You can have the same expectations, sure, but you won't necessarily get there by the same route with each sex.

If you want to learn more about the biology, psychology and sociology of how boys become men, I would recommend:

Raising Boys, by Steve Biddulph - he gets a lot of stick for what he says about boys especially needing mums to stay home, dads to be present for them and not to be put in childcare, but I think he's spot on about boys development, peer pressure, where the risk taking and aggression comes from.
He'll Be OK, by Celia Lashlie - excellent study of boy to man development and identifying what the real drivers of boy behaviour are. The author was a single mum of a boy, and worked in the criminal justice system. She did a massive research project, going round NZ / OZ talking directly to teenage boys in schools, clubs etc, finding out what really makes them tick , what influences them - and what they don't tell their mums, and why!
Of Boys and Men by Richard Reeves - the recent bestseller on this and it's fascinating, on how certain groups of boys (young, poor, black boys in the US and young, poor, white boys in the UK) are falling behind on all the important indicators while girls surge ahead. He's on a lot of podcasts as well, well worth a listen. Lots of the biology / psychology behind how boys develop into men, and why the whole 'toxic masculinity' trope is so damaging to them.

One thing he advocates for is keeping boys back a year in school, routinely, to allow them to catch up with girls in terms of their organisational / executive functioning skills (apparently in elite US private schools this is the norm). I really regret that we didn't do this with our oldest who is currently the youngest in his class - he has always struggled to keep up with his peers (and he has a lot of girl friends) in terms of organisation, meeting deadlines, taking responsibility. He's 16/17 and starting to catch up, but it has been a struggle to keep his confidence up over the years - and he's an intelligent kid with supportive parents. I can totally see why any less able, less supported boys would just give up and check out.

DS1 has always had lots of girl friends. He enjoys female company, and his gang are a pretty feisty bunch - they don't take any shit from him.

As a woman, I don't take any shit from men in general. We have open discussions about consent, behaviour and Andrew Tate.

And yes, they have a brilliant dad, and lots of good male role models in our family and friends circle.

Minata · 23/03/2024 14:20

We should ask why are so many girls doing badly at school, leaving with poor qualifications, not studying for a trade or skill, taking jobs with little progression and by default being the SAHP.

Exactly, in this day and age when you have the most options, choice and equality than ever before why are women not taking accountability for their own decisions and choices ?

RainingCatsandfrogs · 23/03/2024 14:19

The main problem is children don't do as you say, they do as you do. So if you have one partner disrespecting the other one it won't end well, because the children will mirror this behaviour thinking it's normal.
I live on my own for many years because l have really high standards and won't tolerate shit behaviour. My two sons who are now young adults are kind decent young men. They are very respectful towards me as l am them. Eldest has been with his girlfriend past 5 years, very calm loving relationship, her parents have welcomed into their family, they all go out together and get on very well.
Its just a case of having high standards in pretty much everything you do. I would have raised daughters the same.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 23/03/2024 14:18

Doesn't matter what you do raising your son he'll still be 'the potential rapist' 'the violent misogynist' etc on here.

Just do your best to raise a caring human. Hopefully he'll find a good young woman to share lives with. Remind him not to settle with someone just because and to talk through each others expectations. (And check she's not a mimsnetter, they're awfull)

Well you're on here, so I guess you must be awful. Given the proportion of women who suffer rape or sexual assault, it's not exactly surprising that quite a lot of women see men as potential rapists or violent misogynists.

Parker231 · 23/03/2024 14:18

DaffodilsAlready · 23/03/2024 13:18

missamyp that’s great for you that you have a good partner and are the mother to two sons.
Nothing I have said detracts from that or indeed their qualities. We can all point to the great men we know, these are the role models the thread is talking about, I think.

I honestly do not think that good men are in any way diminished by recognising the history of inequalities which women have faced. I will do some more womansplaining, and say that many of the pioneering women in sciences, education and the professions in previous centuries thrived precisely because they had fathers who saw the value in educating women and did not feel threatened by this concept. How many more were not able to reach their potential? How many women today get stuck because of childcare not being shared equally? There’s a book by Evan Stark which in part argues that for women to thrive in public life, domestic inequalities need to be addressed (women’s time should be seen as important as men’s). I don’t think it is womansplaining or indeed a derailment of the thread to discuss these things.

(I am also not sure how you can disagree with historical facts about when laws changed, which most of my point was, is there a counter history where women were legally and socially equal which I am not aware of? Be great to know).

We should ask why are so many girls doing badly at school, leaving with poor qualifications, not studying for a trade or skill, taking jobs with little progression and by default being the SAHP.

erikbloodaxe · 23/03/2024 14:16

As you would with a daughter. You show them a strong woman who accepts no shit from anyone. You treat them as an individual and the skill of effective communication. You raise well rounded individuals regardless of their sex. Been there got the T shirt! Single mothers can and do do an excellent job. Chuckling at the parents on here that haven't a clue.

Minata · 23/03/2024 14:10

Absolutely nothing different than to how I'm raising my dd. Why do I need to? I'm not holding my dh responsible for the acts of other men, and I do not feel the need to lump him in with other men. We have ensure that they are surrounded by good role models, both male and female. Other than that, I do not feel the need to view the males in my life as predators.

BigFatLiar · 23/03/2024 13:59

Doesn't matter what you do raising your son he'll still be 'the potential rapist' 'the violent misogynist' etc on here.

Just do your best to raise a caring human. Hopefully he'll find a good young woman to share lives with. Remind him not to settle with someone just because and to talk through each others expectations. (And check she's not a mimsnetter, they're awfull)

Newsenmum · 23/03/2024 13:53

Almost everyone seems to think their little boy is perfect, sweet and lovely. No ons thinks their son is a potential rapist. EVERY boy is a potential rapist. I think women need to realise this when raising their sons. It’s an uncomfortable truth. There is a lot you can do with teaching empathy and respect.

Ag the same time, I don’t agree that the mother should always be blamed for this. Unless a woman is actively abusive or allows rape and poor treatment of women to be viewed by her son, we shouldn’t blame mothers. It’s a man’s responsibility to not be a rapist.

Krakken · 23/03/2024 13:25

Personally, I think it's important to raise strong men and women who are capable and resilient.
This is hard work and not easy to do if you don't have those qualities yourself.

DaffodilsAlready · 23/03/2024 13:18

missamyp that’s great for you that you have a good partner and are the mother to two sons.
Nothing I have said detracts from that or indeed their qualities. We can all point to the great men we know, these are the role models the thread is talking about, I think.

I honestly do not think that good men are in any way diminished by recognising the history of inequalities which women have faced. I will do some more womansplaining, and say that many of the pioneering women in sciences, education and the professions in previous centuries thrived precisely because they had fathers who saw the value in educating women and did not feel threatened by this concept. How many more were not able to reach their potential? How many women today get stuck because of childcare not being shared equally? There’s a book by Evan Stark which in part argues that for women to thrive in public life, domestic inequalities need to be addressed (women’s time should be seen as important as men’s). I don’t think it is womansplaining or indeed a derailment of the thread to discuss these things.

(I am also not sure how you can disagree with historical facts about when laws changed, which most of my point was, is there a counter history where women were legally and socially equal which I am not aware of? Be great to know).

Orangebadger · 23/03/2024 13:16

@DaffodilsAlready I agree totally with all you say. Society is more genderised than it was when I grew up. It becomes so much harder to parent with that mindset when everything around us is pink and blue with a very clear line down the middle.

Missamyp · 23/03/2024 12:49

DaffodilsAlready · 23/03/2024 11:42

I think you have things backwards.
in much of history and in many places in the world, women are othered.
It is less than 150 years since married women in the Uk were allowed by law to keep their own property and earnings, it is less than 100 years since all women in this country got the vote, it is less than 50 years since women were entitled to equal pay, it is less than forty years since marital rape was criminalised in the U.K., it is less than twenty years since rape included when a woman was drunk or sleeping in Scotland (I am not sure about the rest of the U.K.).
While you may argue that these wrongs have now been addressed, women still do the majority of the household chores and childcare, and they still make up the majority of people living in poverty. Victims of domestic abuse are overwhelmingly female and two women are killed by their intimate partners a week, there are woefully low prosecution rates for rape. Women are sexualised in pornography and expected to conform to quite high standards of beauty.
(I was going to add in the marriage bar but I cannot remember when that ended. This is that women were expected to give up their jobs on marriage).
This thread is not about othering male children, but how we/should we teach (male) children that women and girls should not be othered in the ways that have happened historically and still happen today. Indeed, no-one should be othered. This is important given that it many ways, gender stereotypes are being recreated and reinforced more than they were when I was growing up.

Thank you for womansplaining. In fact your post is by definition othering.
Mumsnet has a penchant for degenerating men-now its boys.
That's my opinion that I'm entitled to as a mother of two boys and a great male partner.

I'm not going to divert the thread by challenging your points, some of which i vehemently do not agree with.
Carry on.

Krakken · 23/03/2024 11:59

@ScarlettOBan this probably because so many men are rubbish fathers so what choice do women have?
All children should be shown love and good care and be raised with good values and that can help to form a society of good men and women.

Swipe left for the next trending thread