Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be trapped with DP because of nursery?

42 replies

Allalonemum · 22/03/2024 19:58

we have a 1 year old, she started nursery last month. It’s costing 1,450 a month for her to go five days a week. We both work. I desperately want to leave DP for various reasons but when I raised it last night after feeling at breaking point, he said ‘well you’ll be on your own with nursery fees so good luck.’

For context he doesn’t want to separate and has said he will refuse to have dd at all if we do and will just see her at weekends as he pleases. (He is not a nice man). I would have care of dd and would want that so I am not worried about that aspect. But I genuinely don’t know how I could pay nursery on my own? I would have to give up work as my take home pay is around 3,000, rent round here is 800 minimum for a two bed. We just wouldn’t be able to live. Is it true he doesn’t have to pay? I couldn’t see any reference to nursery costs on the child maintenance website. TIA

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SoupChicken · 23/03/2024 08:01

I do compressed hours over four days and I’m better off than if I worked five days, could you do that?

Aussieland · 23/03/2024 04:40

Also ignore his bullshit “I will see them when I feel like it”. Get a formal agreement and enforce it and do not let him just do what he feels like

Meadowfinch · 23/03/2024 03:23

I left ex when ds was 2 and he tried to starve us back too. My salary was the same as yours.

I found a (grotty) inexpensive 1 bed flat and shared a bed with ds until he started school at four and I was able to get a mortgage and buy a house. I wasn't eligible for UC but you probably are.

The time in our little flat was a bit tight for money but much happier. I sort of 'shrank my world' to what I could manage by myself. DS loved it. You will cope and find a way to make it work.

Hellogoodbyehello4321 · 23/03/2024 02:20

@GanninHyem but if your child care costs were £1400 a month like OPs you would presumably be entitled to something. Also, if there's 2 of you, you have more options re childcare as you aren't trying to do all it all on your own like the OP would be.

Not sure why you don't get that.

As has already been pointed out, OP as a higher rate tax payer will be of far more use to the government if they help her through a difficult couple of years than If she quits her job. Obviously when she's not got ridiculous nursery fees she wouldn't be claiming benefits.

It's not a race to the bottom. It's a great shame on this country that OP even though she has a decent income feels she can't afford to leave her DP because childcare is so extortionate.

samqueens · 23/03/2024 00:34

PrincessTeaSet · 22/03/2024 20:46

Fair enough but if every single parent is being topped up to the equivalent of a salary of 65k it's no wonder the country has no money!

We're on a combined income of about half that and manage to live within our means. I don't understand why people need so much money.

Every single parent is not being topped up to that income - where your income ends up will depend on your starting point and how much childcare element you receive will depend on your childcare costs.

Single parent households claiming benefits make up about 5% of ALL UK households according to ONS statistics. Not all of these will be getting childcare element. I am therefore pretty certain that the childcare element of UC is NOT what is “bankrupting the country”.

Barring children in those households, which are already statistically some of the country’s most vulnerable, from regular childcare, and preventing their parents (84% of whom are mothers) from working, certainly doesn’t seem a smart way to improve the country’s finances or resilience in the long term.

For context: estimated figures on cost of Brexit suggest it has been £100 billion a year, cost of pandemic £310-£410 billion total…

GanninHyem · 22/03/2024 22:01

PrincessTeaSet · 22/03/2024 20:46

Fair enough but if every single parent is being topped up to the equivalent of a salary of 65k it's no wonder the country has no money!

We're on a combined income of about half that and manage to live within our means. I don't understand why people need so much money.

Agreed. Mines and DHs salary combined doesn't come to £3k take home yet we are entitled to jack shit.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 22/03/2024 21:44

PrincessTeaSet · 22/03/2024 20:34

Wow and people say it's hard to live on benefits.. I really don't understand why people on a salary way above average are getting subsidised.

Because if the salary won't cover rent and childcare people can't stay in their job. It's not in the government's interests economically for people to be forced out of their jobs.

PrincessTeaSet · 22/03/2024 20:48

I mean the op said she had 750 a month after rent and childcare. That should be plenty for bills and food . Why should she get another 1000 a month? Maybe I have misunderstood the calculations

PrincessTeaSet · 22/03/2024 20:46

RagzRebooted · 22/03/2024 20:41

Because in this situation it would enable OP to stay in work, otherwise she'd have to give up entirely and claim even more benefits. It's also short term, childcare years don't last forever. OP is likely to pay a lot more tax/NI over her lifetime than she will ever be claiming in benefits.

Fair enough but if every single parent is being topped up to the equivalent of a salary of 65k it's no wonder the country has no money!

We're on a combined income of about half that and manage to live within our means. I don't understand why people need so much money.

RagzRebooted · 22/03/2024 20:41

PrincessTeaSet · 22/03/2024 20:34

Wow and people say it's hard to live on benefits.. I really don't understand why people on a salary way above average are getting subsidised.

Because in this situation it would enable OP to stay in work, otherwise she'd have to give up entirely and claim even more benefits. It's also short term, childcare years don't last forever. OP is likely to pay a lot more tax/NI over her lifetime than she will ever be claiming in benefits.

TheABC · 22/03/2024 20:41

It makes my blood boil to see men swan off into the distance without paying a penny towards their offspring.

You don't have to pack your bags and leave tomorrow, OP. Unless your life is in immediate danger, take your time, make your plans (assume you will get nothing from him and he will fight you every step of the way) and keep your job going. You will get through this.

PrincessTeaSet · 22/03/2024 20:34

craigth162 · 22/03/2024 20:12

Generally no but because of childcare costs and rent yes.

Wow and people say it's hard to live on benefits.. I really don't understand why people on a salary way above average are getting subsidised.

BookArt · 22/03/2024 20:30

Get out. Look in to universal credit. I didn't think I would be entitled to anything but thankfully I am.

Struggling for money is far better than living your life with a man like that. And even more so, don't teach your child that it's okay to be treated like that.

You can do it, you would manage, it wouldn't be easy but it'll be easier than putting up with him. I promise.

fearfulexchange · 22/03/2024 20:29

I don't think this sounds like a man you can rely on for child maintenance or any support at all. And don't be fooled that CMS will make him, there's plenty of ways he'll get out of it.
Do your sums based on what you've got coming in and treat anything you can get from him as a bonus.

Maray1967 · 22/03/2024 20:25

Mumsnet at its best here - loads of practical advice and even some actual figures worked out for OP.

OP, hopefully this will help you work out what you can afford. It sounds like you know this relationship cannot go on. I wish you all the best.

Strictlymad · 22/03/2024 20:24

As far as I understand it child maintenance isn’t based on what you need financially or what childcare expenses you have but on a percentage of his wage, offset by the amount of custody he has (which you say is 0) so it will be the max amount for his wage bracket, regardless of whether you have nursery fees, though of course you could use his maintenance directly towards them. I think I’ve got that correct!

ghostyslovesheets · 22/03/2024 20:21

Look at what @craigth162 has posted - I was amazed at how much financial support I was entitled to when my ex left us - me and 3 under 9 including a baby. It's doable and he will have to pay maintenance as well which is not counted in UC calculations.

NeedtostopusingMNsomuch · 22/03/2024 20:20

Have you written out all your expenses? Do you definitely not have enough each month? Make sure you include absolutely everything, dentist, haircuts, mot, subscriptions etc You’ll have 3.5k with his maintenance, so 2k after nursery fees which sounds like it would cover rent, bills and other extras? (You’ll also get child benefit too, you can use tax free childcare and you’ll get 11 free hours a week (15 hours a week termtime) when she’s 2. Plus any other benefits others are mentioning

beAsensible1 · 22/03/2024 20:18

don’t let him threaten you into staying.

Get a one bed with a big bedroom rather than a two bed she’s only little.

See what you can claim via working credits or UC.
and remember she will be eligible for free hours eventually.

you can make it work. Don’t lose anymore years to a man who threatens you with poverty or being a shit parent so you’ll stay.

deenaraten · 22/03/2024 20:12

I am a single parent and I get child maintenance from my ex. He is not obliged to pay anything towards nursery and I don't get any other financial help due to my salary. It is tough but it is what it is and I have managed regardless. You will manage because you have to.

Superscientist · 22/03/2024 20:12

Child maintenance doesn't explicitly include nursery and most cases fall short of a decent contribution once other costs associated with raising a child sadly. Especially if the ex is only willing to pay the legal minimum and given his current view I would budget as though he only gives you the bare minimum and not a penny more.

Could you do compressed hours doing 5 or 4.5 days over 4 days to save you a day of nursery fees a week? I know the funded hours are now kicking in sooner, once your LO qualifies for the funded hours would that make a difference? It might also be worth putting your details in to a benefits calculator to see if you would be eligible for any support.

Also, please please be very cynical and keep an eye on your other half squirrelling a significant and unfair amount of money away or moving assets etc and if you can have take a fair amount yourself not a lot but enough so that if you split and your partner emptied your joint account or stopped contributing to bills you would be still able to do a food shop and put fuel in the car to get to work.

craigth162 · 22/03/2024 20:12

PrincessTeaSet · 22/03/2024 20:06

Really? On a salary of over 50k?

Generally no but because of childcare costs and rent yes.

craigth162 · 22/03/2024 20:11

Did a rough calc based on earning £3k a month net, nursery 1450 and rent 800.

To be trapped with DP because of nursery?
Marblessolveeverything · 22/03/2024 20:09

So start to get your ducks in a row and plan financially. Have you access to any services through an employment assistance programme?

You will be a lot happier in a tiny home without living unhappily together.

dreadisabaddog · 22/03/2024 20:08

OP, I was in this exact position on a much lower income. Benefits are very generous because the government want to keep you in work- they'll pay a lot of your childcare costs to keep you working. Try a benefits calculator. You're right that it makes no sense that he only has to pay a small amount of maintenance (my ex didn't even pay that 🙄) and I was completely broke and run ragged for the nursery years but it was worth it to keep progressing in my career and give DD a good start in life and moreover, to get away from a toxic man who made my life not worth living. It wont be easy but it will be so worth it. Feel free to DM anytime you need someone to talk to ❤️