Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If your DH is a white collar worker, do you ever fantasise about blue collar workers?

207 replies

BlondiesHaveMoreFun · 22/03/2024 19:16

My first DH was a white collar worker. High up in finance. Never had a fight in his life. Short and skinny. Unable to really be a guys guy or have any banter with other men. If we had ever been stuck in a dangerous situation, we would have no doubt died 😂 I never felt physically safe with him. When I was with him, I definitely found myself fancying more manly men, like builders, mechanics, police officers, boxers etc, you get the drift, and I was wondering whether I’m unusual in that?

OP posts:
ZetuianRose · 23/03/2024 08:46

My tradie was wearing formal attire yesterday, shirt and tie etc. There’s something about my rugged, tattooed ball of masculinity in a shirt (rare!) that is way sexier than the actual white collar guys (even the “big” ones) as they’re usually all polished and “pretty” rather than sexy. I don’t find that attractive.

AnonyLonnymouse · 23/03/2024 08:46

peakygold · 22/03/2024 19:47

I always sneak a sideways look at men in really filthy, oily overalls; like steam train drivers on heritage railways, or traction engine drivers at country fairs. The smell of hot oil and a bit of smoke. Phwoaar.

That’s one of the most cheering posts I’ve read on here in a while!

I’m picturing the scene now…. The sun is shining on a summer’s day. Tea and scones are being served in Ye Olde Heritage Station Cafe. The steam train puffs up, with noise, steam and creaks galore. Small boys are admiring the life-size Thomas and train buffs are talking gauges and pressures. Meanwhile @peakygold is peering into the cab thinking, ‘Oh yes, I would!’ 😁

DumpsterBaby · 23/03/2024 08:37

asquideatingdough · 23/03/2024 05:34

My DP is in the trades, 6'4", built like a rugby player and can fix anything. Before him I was always drawn to skinny, arty, intellectuals (although DP is funny and clever too). I find his ability to just take care of things I have no understanding of like motors and problem solve and lift heavy things unbelievably sexy. I also feel safe with him in a way I never had before, although really there is little reason to fear anything where we live. I felt quite guilty as a feminist for being attracted by these things but now I've come to accept it and just enjoy! I also find he has an easy confidence especially when dealing with other men that comes of working in an almost all male traditional environment. I am in a white collar profession but I'm very happy with someone who is not. I wouldn't go back to the Brian Cox/Jarvis Cocker types no matter what, although they also have their charms!

Very well articulated. Before my OH I didn’t want children. There is something about his masculinity that really brings out the female in me. 😂

StopStartStop · 23/03/2024 08:34

White collar, blue collar? No. I only like musicians. I do love a good suit, though.

KreedKafer · 23/03/2024 08:29

The stereotypes on this thread are doing my head in.

Bigearringsbigsmile · 23/03/2024 05:54

Chatonette · 22/03/2024 23:37

I love a man in a tie and cuff links! 😍 No thank you on the blue collar fantasy.

Yep me too

I really dislike the ' blokey banter' thing and as for fighting..

A shirt and tie with rolled up sleeves...and a nice watch.

My dh is like this and six foot and very capable which is lovely.

asquideatingdough · 23/03/2024 05:34

My DP is in the trades, 6'4", built like a rugby player and can fix anything. Before him I was always drawn to skinny, arty, intellectuals (although DP is funny and clever too). I find his ability to just take care of things I have no understanding of like motors and problem solve and lift heavy things unbelievably sexy. I also feel safe with him in a way I never had before, although really there is little reason to fear anything where we live. I felt quite guilty as a feminist for being attracted by these things but now I've come to accept it and just enjoy! I also find he has an easy confidence especially when dealing with other men that comes of working in an almost all male traditional environment. I am in a white collar profession but I'm very happy with someone who is not. I wouldn't go back to the Brian Cox/Jarvis Cocker types no matter what, although they also have their charms!

StarlightLady · 23/03/2024 04:52

Prefer collars off 😀!

OzziePopPop · 23/03/2024 04:46

Yup, boy band members do nothing for me!

Happyinarcon · 23/03/2024 03:38

Don’t underestimate how savage the white collar world can be. Some of these guys are little bundles of rage inside a business suit

WhatWhereWho · 23/03/2024 01:05

" If we had ever been stuck in a dangerous situation, we would have no doubt died"

So you would be useless in dangerous situations too then?

DramaAlpaca · 23/03/2024 00:57

My DH is an intelligent, nerdy type with a professional job. I love him to bits. But I find him sexiest when he's using his brain to figure out how to do some practical DIY task at home. I love watching him thinking it out then getting on with it. He's also amazing in a crisis, thinks things out and makes a practical plan

If only he had massive shoulders and big hunky arms he'd be perfect Wink

jubileethree · 23/03/2024 00:37

BlondiesHaveMoreFun · 22/03/2024 20:18

Just go away then LovelyTheresa. Bloody hell, why are some people such joy suckers? Urgh.

A well known one at that

Bertiebluetac · 23/03/2024 00:23

Coming from a very rough area in a working class Northern town, most lads I knew growing up could handle themselves as fighting was almost a weekly event!

i prefer the ones who ended up in “clean” jobs. I can’t stand dirty or rough hands.

bonzaitree · 23/03/2024 00:06

Mr Tree is very typically masculine and yes I love it!

Chatonette · 22/03/2024 23:37

I love a man in a tie and cuff links! 😍 No thank you on the blue collar fantasy.

ZetuianRose · 22/03/2024 23:18

My current DP is a manly man and I LOVE it. I always tell him I love that he’s “man shaped” (broad shoulders with defines muscle, lovely pecks, chunky muscled legs etc) I’ve always loved raw masculinity but my ex was an office worker. He still did some man stuff and worked out so had defined muscle but was slim build and nerdy.

Current one is just rugged and blokey. He’s done all the manly jobs and hobbies. Builder, bodyguard, doorwork/security, bus driver, army, built cars, rides/tunes motorbikes. As soon as he puts work clothes on, picks up tools and demonstrates all his years of skills it honestly has an affect on me 😂🙈

He’s not an aggressive person by nature, but equally he can handle himself, and has had to on many occasions in his various lines of work when negotiation hasn’t worked to de-escalate a situation. He wanted to go to work, get paid and go home again, but sometimes he had to fight.

DumpsterBaby · 22/03/2024 22:53

Wooloohooloo · 22/03/2024 20:53

You're massively generalising what men are like based on their jobs and it's actually quite insulting. Could you imagine if the same logic was applied to women?

I’m not generalising. I’m specifying: my other half!

Didimum · 22/03/2024 22:17

HungryBeagle · 22/03/2024 21:22

Yeah this is my experience too. I work in finance, as does my DH. A lot of our friends work in finance. Most are health conscious, gym
goers, rugby players, weight lifters etc.

Yeah but working in finance can also be an accountant, and we all know that stereotype!

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 22/03/2024 21:53

No. I dared a physically big tough guy. He always got in loads of fights, he wasn't aggressive but other men seemed to want to 'prove themselves' against him. And it was always slightly disconcerting to know that he could break bones if he wanted to. I feel much safer with my level headed sensible husband

MsCactus · 22/03/2024 21:47

My DH is white collar, a solicitor in the City. He is tall, muscular, from a northern city and used to regularly get in fights when we were younger (most recent one was punching a guy who was overtly racist to a stranger). He really sticks up for people, is kind and principled and I've always felt safe out with him.

My dad is blue collar and never fought anyone. So not sure it's to do with their profession...

HungryBeagle · 22/03/2024 21:36

I neither approve nor disapprove of your taste in men, you do you. I was solely posting in response to the OP.

NotCute · 22/03/2024 21:34

HungryBeagle · 22/03/2024 21:29

I mean, that’s fine, you fancy who you fancy. I was referring to the OPs post about finance guys being nerdy, small and weedy though. Not my experience.

Well I'm certainly glad that my proclivities meet with your approval 😊

And in defence of corporate types, my experience isn't that they are small and weedy, just a bit 'try hard' and self conscious. Not cute.

HungryBeagle · 22/03/2024 21:29

NotCute · 22/03/2024 21:28

Yeah that's not really the type I go for...

Health conscious rugger guys aren't really dripping in sex appeal, I'd rather have a fit builder who smokes and lifts brick rather than dumbells.

Health conscious is a bit try hard and overly self conscious rather than effortlessly appealing

I mean, that’s fine, you fancy who you fancy. I was referring to the OPs post about finance guys being nerdy, small and weedy though. Not my experience.

NotCute · 22/03/2024 21:28

HungryBeagle · 22/03/2024 21:22

Yeah this is my experience too. I work in finance, as does my DH. A lot of our friends work in finance. Most are health conscious, gym
goers, rugby players, weight lifters etc.

Yeah that's not really the type I go for...

Health conscious rugger guys aren't really dripping in sex appeal, I'd rather have a fit builder who smokes and lifts brick rather than dumbells.

Health conscious is a bit try hard and overly self conscious rather than effortlessly appealing

Swipe left for the next trending thread