Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If your DH is a white collar worker, do you ever fantasise about blue collar workers?

207 replies

BlondiesHaveMoreFun · 22/03/2024 19:16

My first DH was a white collar worker. High up in finance. Never had a fight in his life. Short and skinny. Unable to really be a guys guy or have any banter with other men. If we had ever been stuck in a dangerous situation, we would have no doubt died 😂 I never felt physically safe with him. When I was with him, I definitely found myself fancying more manly men, like builders, mechanics, police officers, boxers etc, you get the drift, and I was wondering whether I’m unusual in that?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TakeAByte · 26/03/2024 20:19

Roundandback · 26/03/2024 18:46

So on an intellectual level I know what I'm about to say is awful and reinforces gender stereotypes but....

I am only attracted to men that I can guarantee will 'look after' me....but that can look very different. I would be attracted to someone who worked in a white collar job if they were very senior and a key decision maker.

I would also be attracted to someone in a blue collar job if they made a lot of money and were able to hold their own.

What they would both need to have is an ability to read and navigate potentially risky situations / people.

I would never be with someone who couldn't protect me.

The cognitive dissonance between recognising this is what I'm attracted to and my feminist beliefs is painful 🙈🤣

Try having that attitude while also being a lesbian 🤣
I don't think it is sexist. We're still animals. We want the best situation for ourselves and the best genetics for our children. We want to be protected by our spouse, it is natural. I think the world would be a worse place if this attitude completely died out.

Loafbeginsat60 · 26/03/2024 20:16

My dh is 6'4" and an engineer - his hands are always dirty and he's so good at anything practical. He's also gorgeous looking and has the biggest arms I've ever seen - (but not weight lifter cartoon ones!)

I love how strong he is and how he could look after me if he needed to. I'm 5'3" and I love it when he holds, my head rests on his chest.

So I couldn't fancy an office worker type who was skinny and needed to hire tradesmen to do DIY!

Roundandback · 26/03/2024 18:46

So on an intellectual level I know what I'm about to say is awful and reinforces gender stereotypes but....

I am only attracted to men that I can guarantee will 'look after' me....but that can look very different. I would be attracted to someone who worked in a white collar job if they were very senior and a key decision maker.

I would also be attracted to someone in a blue collar job if they made a lot of money and were able to hold their own.

What they would both need to have is an ability to read and navigate potentially risky situations / people.

I would never be with someone who couldn't protect me.

The cognitive dissonance between recognising this is what I'm attracted to and my feminist beliefs is painful 🙈🤣

zendeveloper · 26/03/2024 18:36

gannett · 26/03/2024 17:29

Those are all good qualities to be attracted to but they're not inherently masculine!

Yes, you are probably right - I meant strictly in the context of sexual attraction, and I am attracted to men.

TowerRavenSeven · 26/03/2024 18:36

Never

ZetuianRose · 26/03/2024 18:35

gannett · 26/03/2024 17:01

Quite, but that wasn't my point at all. More that if you fetishise "manly men" (which may well include a massive-salaried rugby-playing banker, I don't know) and sneer at men who don't live up to that masculine ideal, well, don't complain if traditional masculinity is exactly what you get.

The thing is, attractiveness is a package. This thread is lighthearted (in my view) and on a very basic, stereotypical level, I go for “manly men”.

There’s no definition of manly men, they don’t have to tick certain boxes, and I’m sure there’s thousands of white collar workers who actually could reasonably tick the “manly man” box for me. However, that doesn’t necessarily mean I’ll settle for a “bad boy” dickhead that wants to go out scrapping and drinking beer every weekend.

I’m actually with an experienced tradesperson, whose knowledge and skill are extremely impressive. He’s had a wide range of jobs, mostly manly, but not all. He’s also a massive, loving softy, happy to do house chores, and when he had a baby with his ex, he was a stay at home dad for the first year!

Toxic masculinity doesn’t exist simply because some men are big and strong and others aren’t. It’s a mindset, not a physical trait, and you don’t have to accept both of those things together. You can have one without the other.

LovelyTheresa · 26/03/2024 18:14

KattyBoomBoom95 · 26/03/2024 00:21

I agree. It's the soft hands. 😂

Ok, Pol Pot.

gannett · 26/03/2024 18:06

Really don't get the obsession with whether a man can win a fight or not, that definitely seems quite toxic. DP is 6'4" and nicely muscled but one of the gentlest, most non-confrontational men I've ever known. He wouldn't know how to handle himself in a fight at all, and this is actually something I love about him, not something that detracts from his "masculinity". I really do not want or need a man to be a "protector" or to feel that's his role in the relationship.

Noicant · 26/03/2024 17:49

Fairly sure Dh could shout someone to death for me. He’s completely not a physical person but he’s got a big frame (not fat, his bones are just big) so he stands around looking, well big so maybe thats why I don’t particularly fantasise about burly blue collar men. Also Dh doesn’t have soft hands, he isn’t polished, he’s a shower, shit, shave bloke too, but he’s clever and completely lacking in vanity which I very much appreciate in a man.

OnHerSolidFoundations · 26/03/2024 17:39

BlondiesHaveMoreFun · 22/03/2024 19:32

I hadn’t thought about it for a while, but yesterday, I had to go and get my car from the garage and it was full of men covered in grease and dirt, and I thought ooft, I find these men far more attractive than my ex who probably earned 10x more.

Are you implying you would ordinarily expect to be attracted to someone because of their pay check op?

This is a weird thread. Are you a journalist?

Arraminta · 26/03/2024 17:33

DH grew up in a rough town and was known for being handy in a fight, probably helped that he did mixed martial arts and played rugby. He doesn't get male grooming and is very much your basic shit, shower, shave type of bloke who likes a pint and a curry. I'm very happy to report that he is also darkly swarthy with a few tats and permanent stubble. Having said that, he went to university, speaks Italian and works in the IT industry, so not blue collar.

I love that he's so straightforward and uncomplicated, and he has no patience for playing mind games or fripperies. On our wedding day he told me that our marriage was going to be like the Mafia, the only way out would be for one of us to die. And the few times I've worn sexy lingerie he's just smiled and said it was pointless because he was just going to take it all off anyway. An accident left me with scars on my throat and breast, and he kisses my scars the same way he kisses my mouth.

deluxe · 26/03/2024 17:30

My DH is now a white collar worker in a well paid job. He wasn't like this when we met though. He was rough and ready and very streetwise. Since we've been married he went to uni and got to where he is now as he's also very smart.
I love it because he's respectable and we have a nice life, but I also know he wouldn't think twice about throwing hands to protect me or the kids. Best of both worlds lol 😂

gannett · 26/03/2024 17:29

zendeveloper · 26/03/2024 17:23

I am attracted to traditional masculine men, It is not so much the looks, rather the behaviour. Willingness and ability to be in charge, problem solving, being the shoulder to lean on, being a non-reluctant provider - and also some shallow stuff, like ability to do basic DIY. I don't even fantasise about them being 6ft or having any muscles, that's a bit above my league lol.

Those are all good qualities to be attracted to but they're not inherently masculine!

zendeveloper · 26/03/2024 17:23

I am attracted to traditional masculine men, It is not so much the looks, rather the behaviour. Willingness and ability to be in charge, problem solving, being the shoulder to lean on, being a non-reluctant provider - and also some shallow stuff, like ability to do basic DIY. I don't even fantasise about them being 6ft or having any muscles, that's a bit above my league lol.

gannett · 26/03/2024 17:14

YourFogLightsAreOnTheresNoFog · 26/03/2024 17:04

I think we are all allowed to like what we like.

There's a thread going at the moment about male actors. Some pretty masculine men on there.

Again, quite, and again, not my point. It's the framing of that as "ooh real men" that contributes to toxic masculinity. I like a buff body as much as the posters on that thread but I don't think Chris Hemsworth, say, is more of a man than a short bloke who works in IT and doesn't go to the gym.

SabreIsMyFave · 26/03/2024 17:10

Fair enough @gannett Smile

YourFogLightsAreOnTheresNoFog · 26/03/2024 17:04

gannett · 26/03/2024 17:01

Quite, but that wasn't my point at all. More that if you fetishise "manly men" (which may well include a massive-salaried rugby-playing banker, I don't know) and sneer at men who don't live up to that masculine ideal, well, don't complain if traditional masculinity is exactly what you get.

I think we are all allowed to like what we like.

There's a thread going at the moment about male actors. Some pretty masculine men on there.

gannett · 26/03/2024 17:01

SabreIsMyFave · 26/03/2024 16:52

'Urban, 'wimpy' white-collar workers,' are no more likely to do the chores/help with childcare etc, than the 'rugged, blue-collar workers;

Quite, but that wasn't my point at all. More that if you fetishise "manly men" (which may well include a massive-salaried rugby-playing banker, I don't know) and sneer at men who don't live up to that masculine ideal, well, don't complain if traditional masculinity is exactly what you get.

SabreIsMyFave · 26/03/2024 16:52

gannett · 26/03/2024 16:44

Such strange stereotypes on this thread. You can tell many MNers don't get out much and don't meet many people, because these cliched views of rugged muscled blue collar workers vs urbane wimpy white collar workers don't sync up with reality.

Also, have whatever fantasies you want, but anyone who goes around talking about "manly men" and "pure masculinity" linking that to physical strength and how a man might handle himself in a fight... does not get to moan about toxic masculinity or complain when their "manly man" husband doesn't do the chores.

'Urban, 'wimpy' white-collar workers,' are no more likely to do the chores/help with childcare etc, than the 'rugged, blue-collar workers;

gannett · 26/03/2024 16:44

Such strange stereotypes on this thread. You can tell many MNers don't get out much and don't meet many people, because these cliched views of rugged muscled blue collar workers vs urbane wimpy white collar workers don't sync up with reality.

Also, have whatever fantasies you want, but anyone who goes around talking about "manly men" and "pure masculinity" linking that to physical strength and how a man might handle himself in a fight... does not get to moan about toxic masculinity or complain when their "manly man" husband doesn't do the chores.

Boomer55 · 26/03/2024 16:08

I was married to a blue collar worker for 30 years, and then a white collar worker for 23 years.

I can’t say it made much difference lol 😉

Ivee · 26/03/2024 16:05

Bit uncomfy with such a stark division between two cliches of man, but I know what you’re getting at.

Reminds me of that Dory Previn song “Angels and Devils”

Also reminds me that on a Bear Grylls survival show, all the egotistical biggest strongest men were gathered round the firewood trying and failing to light the wood while the skinny computer guy who’d been ignored was using his glasses and sunlight to start a fire by himself 😂

Anyway. To answer your question. I find intelligence sexy. I also find strong muscles sexy. I couldn’t sleep with a guy who didn’t have both.

I don’t find any occupations particularly sexy, no. Banking? Ugh. Law? Ugh. Plumbing? Ugh. Farming? Ugh. Work is not sexy to me.

peachgreen · 26/03/2024 15:51

My DP is, imo, the best of both worlds – he has a job that requires a shirt and tie (hot) and is very intelligent (loves art and music and literature etc and put himself through night school to get his A Levels and then through university while working full time) but thanks to his height (6'3"), general build (ex-gym fanatic with a layer of dad bod) and a somewhat... challenging upbringing, shall we say, he is clearly a man who could handle himself. Unbelievably sexy.

RedPony1 · 26/03/2024 15:24

i pay a payroll of 1200 blue collar workers.... i can see why some people are attracted 😂

I've only ever dated blue collar, i like the look, clearly... DP is a mechanic and ex was a mechanic too.

ZetuianRose · 26/03/2024 13:15

MrsToothyBitch · 26/03/2024 08:21

DH had a blue collar job before he got a white collar job. Get yourself one that does both. He's also quite good at DIY. I fancy him across the board.

I don't really have a type but I was also really into my most serious ex who was a physicist but was similarly handy so I suppose Smart but Practical Jack of All Trades is my thing! Other men I've dated who weren't like this just don't compare for me.

I guess my ex was a little like that, but now I’m with a real tradie I start to realise that the Jacks of All Trades actually don’t usually know what they’re doing 🤣 (turn off for sure lol)

Swipe left for the next trending thread