Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this waste of NHS resources is abhorrent?

119 replies

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 14:45

My little boy woke up in the middle of the night with severe croup, struggling to get a breath. This has happened before and we were told to call an ambulance if it happens again. So we did. We were told several hours wait and to take him in ourselves. Not ideal as the hospital is 30 minutes away but luckily we do drive, although it was a rather scary drive. Would've thought that a child with severe breathing difficulties would've been a priority but there you go.

Anyway, the issue is that as soon as we arrived at the hospital we got a phone call to say there was an ambulance outside our house. We told them we'd taken him in as advised, then they said "well next time you need to cancel the ambulance". As far as we knew they hadn't sent one as we'd agreed to take him in ourselves. So due to the lack of communication they've wasted an ambulance, the cost of that ambulance and the waiting time for someone else who needed it! This is insane to me. The call handler also didn't know the difference between a rash and mottled skin. Surely more training is needed here, this isn't ok? I would never waste an ambulance like this, and I'm a bit offended that she suggested so! But more offended at the absolute waste of resources.

I genuinely think the issue isn't lack of resources, but how they're managed! Not sure if I should bring this to someone's attention so it doesn't keep happening.

OP posts:
TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 17:57

@NewName24 sorry I didn't clarify in op, the phone call ended with DH saying "ok we'll take him in ourselves then because we can't wait that long" and the operator confirmed which hospital we were going to (not entirely sure why) so I'm really not sure why an ambulance was then despatched.

OP posts:
Pippa246 · 22/03/2024 17:57

Aussieland · 22/03/2024 17:45

My experience in hospital would be that if they got off their bums and walked round the wards they might find several magically “just emptied” beds. Having said that 3 overnight is pointless. In the day absolutely.

Sorry to be clear - it’s 3 posts to cover all the nights/holidays so one band 8 a night.

the bed manager goes round the wards checking there really are no empty beds!! This is truly a post that is not needed.

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 17:55

@Dinneronmybfpillow yes, thank you. It's all well and good to say "don't call an ambulance, drive them there" but when your child can't breathe it's not ideal to then drive to the hospital in that state, especially after being told to call an ambulance by medical professionals who I trust over some anonymous person on Mumsnet telling me not to! Also, like you said, if he'd been given steroids at home we'd have been able to stay at home putting less pressure on a&e.

OP posts:
Bluevelvetsofa · 22/03/2024 17:51

@RickyGervaislovesdogs that’s exactly the sort of waste, which is inexcusable and criminal. Does no one care?

NewName24 · 22/03/2024 17:49

Call handlers are not clinically trained so are not really expected to know the difference between mottling and a rash.

Plus, of course, they have no idea if the person they are speaking to does.

DerekFaker · 22/03/2024 17:49

LightSwerve · 22/03/2024 17:23

'More nuanced' - what bollocks.

You run a service down, it gets run down.

Just ignoring all the posts about inefficiency and poor management huh?

RickyGervaislovesdogs · 22/03/2024 17:46

Deliaskis · 22/03/2024 15:51

A friend's business makes a large item of equipment for the NHS, say imagine it's a hospital bed (it isn't!). They were processing a big order. When it was delivered the trust said they now didn't want one element of the order (say it was 20 of an item and they all came with a specific add-on item, let's say a meal tray that attaches over the bed, that had been requested as part of the original order) and could my friend's business please collect them. Friend collected 20 of these meal trays boxed and new, and said he would return them to the manufacturer and provide a credit. The trust said they wouldn't be able to process a credit note and it was written off now. Cost of returned meal trays that cannot be credited was £60k. This must be happening all over the place.

Flaming hell!

Aussieland · 22/03/2024 17:45

Pippa246 · 22/03/2024 15:59

In our local hospital, 3 band 8 nurses (48.5k starting salary plus 30% or 60% night shift/weekend extra) were employed to “manage patient flow and staffing”. This was previously done by a band 7 bed manager. So these flow managers sit in the office all night phoning wards to ask if they have a bed to take someone from A&E - answer is almost always no as people do not get sent home during the night! (okay someone might die but the bed manager would know about this and update the bed availability accordingly).

It’s a complete waste of money. I do some bank shifts there and one of the people doing this job told me it was money for nothing but they were so bored they were going to go back to a band 6 ward post.

I am a supporter of the NHS but the waste and mis management is appalling. Don’t even get me started on the waste in care homes - literally millions of pounds in unnecessary prescriptions for meds, medicated toothpaste and dressings to name a few.

My experience in hospital would be that if they got off their bums and walked round the wards they might find several magically “just emptied” beds. Having said that 3 overnight is pointless. In the day absolutely.

LakeTiticaca · 22/03/2024 17:44

Did you ring back and say you no longer required an ambulance? If not why not? You were in the system as requesting an ambulance. They sent one.

LakieLady · 22/03/2024 17:39

PurpleBugz · 22/03/2024 17:22

I needed a prescription for a health condition I have. It wasn't on repeat so I needed an appointment to get it. No appointment for a few days in a row phoning at 8. Got rather urgent. Told to phone 111. So I do that and had to go through the process of answering all the questions they say it's urgent go to hospital I said no it's not these symptoms are explained by my condition I just need a prescription. They say ok well a dr will phone you. I had 3 drs phone me!! The first one had booked me an appointment with my normal GP so the second two was just a waste of time resources. And of course I have to physically go into my gp for this appointment to say please give me the prescription it's not on repeat and should be and please put on repeat going forward. He said ok. Took 30 seconds. So many drs time wasted. And I had my snot nosed toddler with me with a nasty cough spewing his germs around the waiting room to boot

That's appalling, and in this day and age, really unnecessary.

I needed a prescription when I had a bad attack of Meniere's a few weeks ago. I submitted an e-consult request at 7.30am, and asked if it would be possible for them to issue a prescription for the medication for it.

At 8.20, I got a text from one of the GPs saying they'd issued an electronic prescription for the meds and sent it to the pharmacy they have on record as my regular pharmacy. I picked it up from the pharmacy around 10, and was fine by lunchtime.

My surgery uses an off the peg online system called Anima, maybe you should suggest your surgery gives it a try!

Bluevelvetsofa · 22/03/2024 17:36

It’s interesting to hear from people at the ‘chalk face’ so to speak. It seems to confirm what I’ve thought, which is that there is considerable waste and mismanagement and a lack of efficiency and joined up thinking.

Obviously medical practitioners aren’t necessarily the best people to manage budgets and finance, but the senior ones anecdotally at least, do seem to have a high opinion of themselves. Do they perhaps ignore those who are less exalted.

If those who are paid to run the organisations are useless at it, what can be done to improve the situation. I’ve heard so many times, that patients are ready for discharge, but poor communication prevents a speedy discharge, so beds are blocked, medication doesn’t get to the right person and everyone is hanging around.

You'd hope that managers would have the right training to manage budgets efficiently and to be able to overrule clinicians if they’re being arrogant and unreasonable. The fact that it isn’t happening is an expensive, wasteful and potentially dangerous disgrace.

LightSwerve · 22/03/2024 17:23

DerekFaker · 22/03/2024 17:18

Oh here we go 🙄

Nobody here is running down the NHS. And the situation is a bit more nuanced than "evil Tories".

Edited

'More nuanced' - what bollocks.

You run a service down, it gets run down.

PurpleBugz · 22/03/2024 17:22

I needed a prescription for a health condition I have. It wasn't on repeat so I needed an appointment to get it. No appointment for a few days in a row phoning at 8. Got rather urgent. Told to phone 111. So I do that and had to go through the process of answering all the questions they say it's urgent go to hospital I said no it's not these symptoms are explained by my condition I just need a prescription. They say ok well a dr will phone you. I had 3 drs phone me!! The first one had booked me an appointment with my normal GP so the second two was just a waste of time resources. And of course I have to physically go into my gp for this appointment to say please give me the prescription it's not on repeat and should be and please put on repeat going forward. He said ok. Took 30 seconds. So many drs time wasted. And I had my snot nosed toddler with me with a nasty cough spewing his germs around the waiting room to boot

DerekFaker · 22/03/2024 17:18

Oh here we go 🙄

Nobody here is running down the NHS. And the situation is a bit more nuanced than "evil Tories".

LightSwerve · 22/03/2024 17:14

Sick of these threads slagging off the NHS when they are in really dire straits after being run down deliberately for the last 14 years.

In 2009 you could get a GP appointment, or an ambulance, or seen in A&E.

The situation today is a government choice.

DerekFaker · 22/03/2024 17:11

NewName24 · 22/03/2024 16:21

I am a supporter of the NHS but the waste and mis management is appalling.

This, absolutely.

I've said for decades, that the individual practitioners you meet at all points of the NHS are almost to a (wo)man, lovely, who are doing their absolute best in such a dire system it is unbelievable.

Re the OP though, I do have to ask how clear she was in saying "Okay, we can take him in - we won't need an ambulance" though ? I mean, clearly the despatchers can make human errors, just like anyone else, but I suspect what probably happened was that she didn't leave the phone call with that being clear.

If that was the case (and I don't know how you can be so sure it was), I think it's the call handler's responsibility to absolutely confirm the situation. That's literally their job.

JanefromLondon1 · 22/03/2024 17:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

cassgate · 22/03/2024 17:08

I have had the misfortune of sitting with a relative in A&E recently. The inefficiency and mismanagement are astounding. I would say there was more staff than patients yet the lack of communication and accountability shocked me. Staff were recording patient medical readings on scrapes of paper. Staff were sat at screens and ignoring relatives who were standing in front of them waiting to ask questions. My relative was approached twice with the wrong patients record. There was no information forthcoming from anyone about my relatives planned treatment. Each nurse we saw just took readings and had no idea why we were there or what the plan was. Even the drs were vague and just kept saying we were waiting for a bed without being able to say what the plan was after that. It took a complaint to PALs to get the ball rolling. The NHS does not need more money it needs to manage the money it has more effectively. The easiest thing to fix is to have someone not necessarily a medic to be accountable for communicating with patients about planned treatment and why things are taking so long. We sat in the same bay for 2 days with no information on planned treatment, when we put the complaint in my relative was assessed properly, her tests results analysed and she was deemed fit enough to go home and discharged. This should not have taken 2 days. Why did someone not think hey lady in bay 15 has been here a long time let’s have a look at what needs to be done.

PostItInABook · 22/03/2024 16:47

Call handlers are not clinically trained so are not really expected to know the difference between mottling and a rash. They just say the words on the script. Their job is to take calls and follow a script that depends on your answers to questions. They are not allowed to deviate from that script and that is what they get audited on. The call handlers type notes as the call progresses and the call gets categorised according to where the script has landed. Dispatchers can see the notes and the call disposition/category and dispatch according to what the computer says is priority. Nowadays calls are usually stacked in a queue so they have to juggle that. Unfortunately, with all that to juggle some miscommunications or misinterpretations can occur. It doesn’t happen often (because dispatchers are amazing at multitasking) but as with all elements of a job that involves humans errors sometimes occur.

In 20 years I’ve only been sent to a job where the patient has taken themselves to hospital less than a handful of times. It’s not a regular occurrence.

There is an element of day-to-day mismanagement that contributes to the problems in the ambulance service but understaffing also is genuinely a big problem. It isn’t one thing or another. It’s a multitude of problems/issues that all contribute.

I hope your DC is ok.

Gettingonmygoat · 22/03/2024 16:43

Aaron95 · 22/03/2024 15:35

I wish they'd bring back the ward sisters and matrons and get rid of these upper management roles who don't step foot in the hospital for the majority of the time.

Why do people keep on repeating this over and over? There seems to be some belief that if doctors and nurses were the only ones in a hospital that it would run itself perfectly. I can tell that you have never worked in the NHS. If one thng is certain it is that medical staff are very good at treating people but really terrible at running an organisation.

Doctors and Nurses may be terrible at running an organisation but the most infuriating thing is those that are paid to run the organisation are bloody useless at it as well.

40somethingme · 22/03/2024 16:32

LindaPen · 22/03/2024 16:24

I phoned 111 for advice (as advised on here actually) because I had chest pain. Adult DS was with me and would have taken me to A&E but they insisted on sending an ambulance.

The same happened to my sister who had difficulty breathing, 111 sent a blue light ambulance to take her to ED despite her saying DH can take her as they have a car.

LindaPen · 22/03/2024 16:24

I phoned 111 for advice (as advised on here actually) because I had chest pain. Adult DS was with me and would have taken me to A&E but they insisted on sending an ambulance.

LindaPen · 22/03/2024 16:22

Aaron95 · 22/03/2024 15:35

I wish they'd bring back the ward sisters and matrons and get rid of these upper management roles who don't step foot in the hospital for the majority of the time.

Why do people keep on repeating this over and over? There seems to be some belief that if doctors and nurses were the only ones in a hospital that it would run itself perfectly. I can tell that you have never worked in the NHS. If one thng is certain it is that medical staff are very good at treating people but really terrible at running an organisation.

Yes, in my experience the most senior consultants and surgeons (not all obviously) are the biggest blockers and most inefficient, least inclined to work hard. What's really needed is managers who have some real actual authority over them

NewName24 · 22/03/2024 16:21

I am a supporter of the NHS but the waste and mis management is appalling.

This, absolutely.

I've said for decades, that the individual practitioners you meet at all points of the NHS are almost to a (wo)man, lovely, who are doing their absolute best in such a dire system it is unbelievable.

Re the OP though, I do have to ask how clear she was in saying "Okay, we can take him in - we won't need an ambulance" though ? I mean, clearly the despatchers can make human errors, just like anyone else, but I suspect what probably happened was that she didn't leave the phone call with that being clear.

TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2024 16:08

Plus the fact that studies have consistently shown that the NHS has fewer managers, as a % of the workforce, than average across the rest of the economy.

Of course the NHS needs management. It's the fifth biggest employer in the world (or thereabouts).

The issue seems to be in the quality and training of this management. A poster on here a few weeks ago made the point that so many who do these jobs are NHS lifers. And so the need to evolve and innovate isn't always met.

The whole system needs a total overhaul. But this is such an enormous job, no political party has the will to do it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread