Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this waste of NHS resources is abhorrent?

119 replies

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 14:45

My little boy woke up in the middle of the night with severe croup, struggling to get a breath. This has happened before and we were told to call an ambulance if it happens again. So we did. We were told several hours wait and to take him in ourselves. Not ideal as the hospital is 30 minutes away but luckily we do drive, although it was a rather scary drive. Would've thought that a child with severe breathing difficulties would've been a priority but there you go.

Anyway, the issue is that as soon as we arrived at the hospital we got a phone call to say there was an ambulance outside our house. We told them we'd taken him in as advised, then they said "well next time you need to cancel the ambulance". As far as we knew they hadn't sent one as we'd agreed to take him in ourselves. So due to the lack of communication they've wasted an ambulance, the cost of that ambulance and the waiting time for someone else who needed it! This is insane to me. The call handler also didn't know the difference between a rash and mottled skin. Surely more training is needed here, this isn't ok? I would never waste an ambulance like this, and I'm a bit offended that she suggested so! But more offended at the absolute waste of resources.

I genuinely think the issue isn't lack of resources, but how they're managed! Not sure if I should bring this to someone's attention so it doesn't keep happening.

OP posts:
gamerchick · 22/03/2024 19:50

After the first experience of croup in my first kid I didn't bother with hospital for the rest. A mega steamy bathroom for a bit did the same job.

There's no way I'd go now the state things are in.

*Yes the usual suspects will be along to say how wrong that was in 5...4...3...

ManchesterBeatrice · 22/03/2024 19:46

Looneytune253 · 22/03/2024 15:52

To be fair, I would say it was quite a waste to call an ambulance in the first place, I get that you were told to but it would have been much quicker and more efficient to just get there yourself.

This.

ManchesterBeatrice · 22/03/2024 19:45

I mean, you could have just driven him yourself in the first place.

THAT'S the waste of resources.

Isitovernow123 · 22/03/2024 19:44

FenellaBestwick · 22/03/2024 19:43

I saw how MASSIVELY wasteful the Nhs is as my mil got treatment over the years. She had 14 zimmer frames at by the end as they wouldn't take old ones back. She also received so many medications she handed them out to her friends. I tried my best but go nowhere trying to sort that lot out.

You handed out prescription medications to people? I hope you have cover for distribution of drugs illegally…….

FenellaBestwick · 22/03/2024 19:43

I saw how MASSIVELY wasteful the Nhs is as my mil got treatment over the years. She had 14 zimmer frames at by the end as they wouldn't take old ones back. She also received so many medications she handed them out to her friends. I tried my best but go nowhere trying to sort that lot out.

TheJoyousRobin · 22/03/2024 19:33

Isitovernow123 · 22/03/2024 19:22

I would have thought is was more waste or resources phoning an ambulance in the first place. If it were my child, I would have been in the care without a second thought, regardless of it being 30 mins away.

Unless you’re lucky enough to have a rapid response paramedic in a car around the corner, you’ve wasted more money than the nhs has.

This!

FictionalCharacter · 22/03/2024 19:28

Aaron95 · 22/03/2024 15:35

I wish they'd bring back the ward sisters and matrons and get rid of these upper management roles who don't step foot in the hospital for the majority of the time.

Why do people keep on repeating this over and over? There seems to be some belief that if doctors and nurses were the only ones in a hospital that it would run itself perfectly. I can tell that you have never worked in the NHS. If one thng is certain it is that medical staff are very good at treating people but really terrible at running an organisation.

And when doctors do have to do any admin / management tasks they complain bitterly that they’re having to spend time on that instead of on treating patients.

The roles of matron and ward sister still exist anyway.

jengachampion · 22/03/2024 19:27

TheJoyousRobin · 22/03/2024 19:23

We suspected my dad had sepsis and called for an ambulance three times on Tuesday and they had no emergency vehicles available. He did indeed have sepsis. So we took him to A&E ourselves with sepsis.

I can’t understand why you called 999 if you didn’t want an ambulance ?

Edited

Try reading the post again, slowly?

TheJoyousRobin · 22/03/2024 19:23

We suspected my dad had sepsis and called for an ambulance three times on Tuesday and they had no emergency vehicles available. He did indeed have sepsis. So we took him to A&E ourselves with sepsis.

I can’t understand why you called 999 if you didn’t want an ambulance ?

Isitovernow123 · 22/03/2024 19:22

I would have thought is was more waste or resources phoning an ambulance in the first place. If it were my child, I would have been in the care without a second thought, regardless of it being 30 mins away.

Unless you’re lucky enough to have a rapid response paramedic in a car around the corner, you’ve wasted more money than the nhs has.

Tiredalwaystired · 22/03/2024 19:15

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 15:01

@Whatsnormalhere it's just awful isn't it. I understand there may well have been sicker people, and we got him there ok so it wasn't the end of the world for us, but what if someone was having a heart attack. So sorry about your dad

@catmomma67 wow that's ridiculous! I wish they'd bring back the ward sisters and matrons and get rid of these upper management roles who don't step foot in the hospital for the majority of the time. They're haemorrhaging money for no good reason. No one can get appointments (I have a 2 year wait for neurology even though this issue is ruining my life, I can't work! I can't use my skills). I hope everything resolved ok for your husband!

I will add, children's a&e were brilliant, the nurses couldn't do enough for us and he got seen very quickly. Although the doctor never did get around to us but luckily treatment is straightforward so it wasn't needed.

which senior management roles would you get rid of out of interest? And why?

and please don’t say diversity managers as firstly they’re very rarely senior management of at all and secondly in medicine different ethnicities can react differently to medicines so this needs to be centre to treatment plans plus a multi ethnic local population needs people who understands different cultures in the workforce to help improve patient experience. If there is one profession where diversity managers are really valuable it’s healthcare.

Theoldwrinkley · 22/03/2024 18:58

Totally agree in waste of resources. Similar here on Wed evening. Ambulance arrives on blue lights and r paramedics (one training?). We didn't call them, but correct address. Turned out to be our lodger who also hadn't called them, but had spoken to his GP earlier that day. Assume doctor had called ambulance (?). But 9 hours earlier? Lodger was fine and has flown back to his home on holiday this evening.
Also, other lodger calls ambulance at drop of a hat. Hypochondriac. But always gets fast response, maybe because she always phones at 2.30am and waits for me to answer door.
When NHS allocated more money, first response is always 'we need more managers'. Well manage then!

PostItInABook · 22/03/2024 18:51

Nobody should ever be made to feel guilty for calling an ambulance for their child. The automated system will triage and categorise them the same as with adults. If the system says yes an ambulance will be sent. If the system says hmmmm you’ll likely get a call back from a clinician to do further triage and then either discharged over the phone, alternative pathways offered or actually yes we’re sending an ambulance.

Snackarooney · 22/03/2024 18:44

Dinneronmybfpillow · 22/03/2024 15:59

That advice is the same we were given after sudden onset croup with DD some years ago. Paramedics carry a lot of medications with them, including steroids which can turn around a child at home, avoiding going to A&E at all. Paramedics aren't just medically trained transport, they can assess/treat and discharge quite a lot, avoiding hospital attendance.

Exactly this.

My youngest suffers with croup terribly & are always told to phone an ambulance l, the first time I had never experienced croup or fully knew what it was, I genuinely thought my son was dying.
It took until the 9th time before I knew if I'd be able to make it there myself by how he was and the fact my husband was home and my 8 yo had to be woken up and come with us to a&e so that 1 could drive 1 could check our sons breathing. Every time before then I was alone with either 2 kids 1 of who couldn't breathe or just me and the toddler with croup i could not put him in his car seat and srive like everything's ok. We're at a fortnight ago was his 17th time in 2.5 years and only 3 of those have i not beeded the paramedics and I am not ashamed to say so. The paramedics give half of his recommended dose of steroid and because he was under 5 had to go to hospital for the rest. That half a dose helped a lot until a doctor authorised more and because of this he got an urgent ent referral from an a&e doctor who wasn't meant to do referrals but couldn't believe he was there again so ill

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 18:40

@PonkyPonky thank you. We'd usually call 111 and they're pretty good at telling us which ones going to be quicker, this time he had a really bad case and honestly think he could've done with some oxygen. Our children's a&e is brilliant so luckily didn't wait more than 5 minutes.
It's very sad isn't it, and it's so much worse when it's children I feel.

OP posts:
TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 18:38

@PostItInABook thank you. Thats really helpful, like you say I don't want to make a complaint as such. The way we were spoken to on the second call was inappropriate I felt, although I wonder how much they knew about the first phone call and understand that it must be frustrating for them if they think people are wasting ambulances.

I had it in my head that he'd be given it at home before, but perhaps not, it's been a while since the last episode. He's 6 if that makes any difference.

OP posts:
PonkyPonky · 22/03/2024 18:28

My DS is a severe croup sufferer and I have found the quickest route to getting the steroids is via out of hours GP services just in case you need to do this again. If you don’t have a walk in clinic in your area, 111 can usually get you an immediate appointment with an out of hours GP. We still have to drive almost as far as the hospital for that but there is almost no wait. The last time my bum didn’t even hit the seat in the waiting room before they called us in as the GP heard the stridor from her room. When we have used A&E for this before we were basically left to fend for ourselves in the waiting room for hours which wasted so much time that the steroids could have used to get working. It was terrifying. The last GP who gave us steroids for croup said ‘if it gets worse then call an ambulance’ and I remember thinking ‘I really bloody hope I don’t need to rely on an ambulance turning up quickly’. It’s a sad state of affairs

PostItInABook · 22/03/2024 18:22

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 18:00

@PostItInABook thank you for clarifying, glad to know it doesn't happen too often. He's much better now thank you. Is it worth bringing this to someone's attention (I don't want to say complaint because that's not really what I want to achieve if you get what I mean, I understand things like this can happen) or is it likely to be a one off mistake? I just have the thought of wasted resources. Also the fact that if he were treated at home we probably wouldn't have needed to go to a&e and use their resources too.

You could contact the patient liaison team and highlight your concern and perhaps ask for clarification on the process when someone calls and then makes their own way. I suspect it was probably highlighted in the control room at the time by the shift manager and the call handler will undergo regular audits of their calls so if they are making errors or misinterpreting anything on a regular basis it’s likely to be picked up and addressed. It isn’t something that I know to happen often to be honest. The communication/response to finding you had made your own way seems a tad inappropriate so you could make them aware how it came across to you without calling it a complaint.

Re. The treatment aspect, I’m not sure how old your DC is but all under 2s should be conveyed to hospital regardless of improvement, plus children with any remaining stridor (i.e. the barking cough) amongst a few other things so it’s unlikely they would have discharged on scene. There are also legal aspects surrounding the administration of dexamethasone for us as it doesn’t fall into the legal schedules of the meds regulations that authorise us to administer it. We have to use a different part of the law to be able to do it and give it under under a Patient Group Direction (PGD) and it’s very strict. We must follow the directions exactly and are not allowed to deviate at all, so if the PGD states if we give it we must convey to hospital then is what we must do.

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 18:07

@jengachampion that's ridiculous! To not even tell you it's coming or check if you still needed it!

OP posts:
TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 18:06

@Spoonthief that's a shame. A little bit more training probably would've done the trick. Probably a waste of time to mention it then I suppose.

OP posts:
TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 18:04

@LakeTiticaca because they'd told us they weren't sending one and we told them we were taking him ourselves. Why would I call again when we'd already confirmed that? That would be another waste of resources and time.

OP posts:
TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 18:02

@cassgate so sorry to hear that, I totally agree it just needs to be managed better. In all fairness our experience in a&e was very good, I can't complain about the treatment when we actually got there. Our children's department is brilliant and we're lucky for that

OP posts:
TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 18:00

@PostItInABook thank you for clarifying, glad to know it doesn't happen too often. He's much better now thank you. Is it worth bringing this to someone's attention (I don't want to say complaint because that's not really what I want to achieve if you get what I mean, I understand things like this can happen) or is it likely to be a one off mistake? I just have the thought of wasted resources. Also the fact that if he were treated at home we probably wouldn't have needed to go to a&e and use their resources too.

OP posts:
jengachampion · 22/03/2024 17:59

We had similar, but the 111 operator told me a doctor would call. I waited for the call, none came. DD's fever came down on its own and we went to sleep.

4am I get banging on my door - the operator had called an ambulance without telling me and it had been waiting outside for 20 minutes.

Spoonthief · 22/03/2024 17:57

You can complain all you like but the NHS will respond that they’ve “learned from it” and “reflected” ( their fave word!) but it’ll happen again and again and again …
Its so big, with so many hangers on that there is no one to take responsibility ( except for frontline doctors and nurses will often get hauled over the coals for the slightest error, or get blamed for others’ shortcomings)

It’s become a disaster !

Swipe left for the next trending thread