Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this waste of NHS resources is abhorrent?

119 replies

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 14:45

My little boy woke up in the middle of the night with severe croup, struggling to get a breath. This has happened before and we were told to call an ambulance if it happens again. So we did. We were told several hours wait and to take him in ourselves. Not ideal as the hospital is 30 minutes away but luckily we do drive, although it was a rather scary drive. Would've thought that a child with severe breathing difficulties would've been a priority but there you go.

Anyway, the issue is that as soon as we arrived at the hospital we got a phone call to say there was an ambulance outside our house. We told them we'd taken him in as advised, then they said "well next time you need to cancel the ambulance". As far as we knew they hadn't sent one as we'd agreed to take him in ourselves. So due to the lack of communication they've wasted an ambulance, the cost of that ambulance and the waiting time for someone else who needed it! This is insane to me. The call handler also didn't know the difference between a rash and mottled skin. Surely more training is needed here, this isn't ok? I would never waste an ambulance like this, and I'm a bit offended that she suggested so! But more offended at the absolute waste of resources.

I genuinely think the issue isn't lack of resources, but how they're managed! Not sure if I should bring this to someone's attention so it doesn't keep happening.

OP posts:
Darhon · 22/03/2024 21:02

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 15:01

@Whatsnormalhere it's just awful isn't it. I understand there may well have been sicker people, and we got him there ok so it wasn't the end of the world for us, but what if someone was having a heart attack. So sorry about your dad

@catmomma67 wow that's ridiculous! I wish they'd bring back the ward sisters and matrons and get rid of these upper management roles who don't step foot in the hospital for the majority of the time. They're haemorrhaging money for no good reason. No one can get appointments (I have a 2 year wait for neurology even though this issue is ruining my life, I can't work! I can't use my skills). I hope everything resolved ok for your husband!

I will add, children's a&e were brilliant, the nurses couldn't do enough for us and he got seen very quickly. Although the doctor never did get around to us but luckily treatment is straightforward so it wasn't needed.

They do have ward sisters/ charge nurses and matrons still. There’s just too many patients for a system set up for far fewer and not for lots of elderly people with multiple conditions. There were about 6 million over 65s when the NHS was set up. There are now more than 11 million.

cassgate · 22/03/2024 20:57

Speckledpasta · 22/03/2024 20:11

The nhs is hideously inefficient, I agree. Everyone thinks we need more doctors and nurses but if we designed what we already have really well, I bet we wouldn't need that many more.

Agreed, from my experience there were plenty of nurses but none of them seemed to be doing the job of really caring for patients. Yes, they did obs every few hours but didn’t interact with patients beyond that. They appeared busy but doing what exactly I am not sure. There was a lot of paper floating about being shuffled from one place to another and a lot of huddling around screens. There was absolutely no way I was going to leave my relative alone. There were patients who were alone and they were just left for hours without any interaction with anyone. I took my relative to the toilet myself, had to go on the hunt for a wheelchair. There was someone in the next bay who was ignored when he was shouting for help. We saw someone fall off a trolley in a corridor and 4 medics walked passed before my husband went and asked if someone was planning to help them. Writing it down makes it sound unbelievable but this really did happen.

Saltyswee · 22/03/2024 20:49

Welcome to defensive medicine! a lot resources wasted for fear of litigation.

sugarplum33 · 22/03/2024 20:48

I came over lightheaded in my midwife appointment this week the room was so incredibly hot. They apologised and opened the external door and said the heating was either off or on full and so they have 6 months of each. Meanwhile as the radiators are all cranked up to the max and blasting heat straight out of the door they are cracking down on giving out urine pots and you have to wash and reuse or beg for a spare. Because every penny counts. Hmm

AffIt · 22/03/2024 20:47

Oh, it's the 'sisters and matrons' bollocks again.

Some years ago, I, as an IT consultant (yes, I know, shoot me now) worked on a requirements-gathering exercise in a maternity department, in a major hospital, involving nurses, midwives, doctors and auxiliary staff. The idea was that it would overcome excessive management intervention and build a system designed for 'boots on the ground'.

I swear to god, it made herding cats look like a walk in the park: barely two of them could agree with the other on any topic (this was variously F2F interviews, working groups, anonymous surveys etc).

In the end, the whole project was scrapped, at enormous cost to the client.

What a fucking waste of time and money, essentially because of the unbelievable amount of politics and ego at floor level.

Having had that experience, I spend a lot of time making sure I don't get sick.

Xrayrequest · 22/03/2024 20:37

I have to say ALL my awful NHS experiences in the last few years could have been improved/fixed by better admin procedures and processes - they are shockingly bad

SayMatae · 22/03/2024 20:33

LindaPen · 22/03/2024 16:22

Yes, in my experience the most senior consultants and surgeons (not all obviously) are the biggest blockers and most inefficient, least inclined to work hard. What's really needed is managers who have some real actual authority over them

This. This. This

You really really really do not want surgeons running your hospitals. I know you think it makes sense because of their clinical knowledge and clear intelligence given their station in life.

I am a senior manager in the NHS. I’ve heard surgeons refer to female patients as “mental” at every turn. I’ve seen them present business cases for £££ because they want the latest bit of kit their mate down the road has got (even when it reduces patient flow and capacity). I’ve heard them refer to the budget as “Monopoly money”, I’ve seen them rinse every last penny they can from “additional” sessions, I’ve seen and known surgeons not work any of their admin or SPA because they are in private clinics instead.

They are doctors. Not trained to manage budgets or flow or operational work at all

IloveAslan · 22/03/2024 20:25

indianwoman · 22/03/2024 20:02

Did you ring back after you first called to cancel the ambulance? If not, of course they'd come. You've caused the problem!

They told her to take DS in herself. Surely that in itself should suggest not to send an ambulance? In no way is this OP's fault!!!

IloveAslan · 22/03/2024 20:22

PurpleBugz · 22/03/2024 17:22

I needed a prescription for a health condition I have. It wasn't on repeat so I needed an appointment to get it. No appointment for a few days in a row phoning at 8. Got rather urgent. Told to phone 111. So I do that and had to go through the process of answering all the questions they say it's urgent go to hospital I said no it's not these symptoms are explained by my condition I just need a prescription. They say ok well a dr will phone you. I had 3 drs phone me!! The first one had booked me an appointment with my normal GP so the second two was just a waste of time resources. And of course I have to physically go into my gp for this appointment to say please give me the prescription it's not on repeat and should be and please put on repeat going forward. He said ok. Took 30 seconds. So many drs time wasted. And I had my snot nosed toddler with me with a nasty cough spewing his germs around the waiting room to boot

Well that's just ridiculous. Why can't you just order another prescription from the doctor rather than going through this rigmarole? I have a minor condition, and my GP only wants to see me yearly so I get medication with two repeats, and when the repeats end I simply order another prescription online and it is sent to the pharmacy I choose, with another two repeats.

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 20:16

@bettyboo40 thank you. The last time he had it it was less severe, we called 111 for a gp call and steroid prescription but they told us they were going to send an ambulance as it's not worth a risk. We rarely go to the GP or hospital, we're not hypochondriacs, so if I need to call an ambulance for my child I will do so with no apologies. When your child can't breathe it's pretty obvious that you should call an ambulance. This is Mumsnet though, so even if I hadn't called an ambulance I'd still be in the wrong Grin

OP posts:
TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 20:13

H@Speckledpasta I agree, the doctors are usually amazing, the nurses have always been absolutely brilliant. Paramedics are always excellent too. It just seems like if it were managed better there'd be less problem. It's not the care you receive that's the problem, it's accessing it due to all the time that's wasted.

OP posts:
bettyboo40 · 22/03/2024 20:12

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 20:09

I'm going to reiterate this for those saying I shouldn't have called. I've been told by medical professionals on multiple occasions to call an ambulance, I won't be taking advice from anonymous people on Mumsnet over medical professionals. If I can't phone an ambulance for a child who can barely breathe then what on earth are they there for? I know to do cold air exposure, it didn't work. Usually the ambulance provides preliminary care that alleviates it enough to travel to hospital. They had no idea if I could drive, nor did they ask if I could get him there quickly. Also, if I didn't need an ambulance they wouldn't have despatched one at all.

This post wasn't about whether I should've called or not, it was about the mess of telling us there was no ambulance and then sending one anyway and blaming us for not being there.

You did the right thing. I've done the same for my child with croup as it was extremely scary. Fortunately an ambulance was sent very quickly, which they insisted on sending, even though we live quite close to an A&E.

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 20:11

@indianwoman I've already answered this question, they said there was none available so they couldn't send one and to take him ourselves, we said we would do this. Why would I then assume they were sending one after they said they weren't and we confirmed we'd take him? I'd love to see you explain how I caused a problem here.

OP posts:
Speckledpasta · 22/03/2024 20:11

The nhs is hideously inefficient, I agree. Everyone thinks we need more doctors and nurses but if we designed what we already have really well, I bet we wouldn't need that many more.

rwalker · 22/03/2024 20:10

I wish they'd bring back the ward sisters and matrons

there No way a 1950’s style matron would work now .
They used to rule with a rod of iron . Manage people like that now they all be off with stress and shouting bulling ( which is rife in NHS) and harassment

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 20:09

I'm going to reiterate this for those saying I shouldn't have called. I've been told by medical professionals on multiple occasions to call an ambulance, I won't be taking advice from anonymous people on Mumsnet over medical professionals. If I can't phone an ambulance for a child who can barely breathe then what on earth are they there for? I know to do cold air exposure, it didn't work. Usually the ambulance provides preliminary care that alleviates it enough to travel to hospital. They had no idea if I could drive, nor did they ask if I could get him there quickly. Also, if I didn't need an ambulance they wouldn't have despatched one at all.

This post wasn't about whether I should've called or not, it was about the mess of telling us there was no ambulance and then sending one anyway and blaming us for not being there.

OP posts:
SpringSprungALeak · 22/03/2024 20:07

Looneytune253 · 22/03/2024 15:52

To be fair, I would say it was quite a waste to call an ambulance in the first place, I get that you were told to but it would have been much quicker and more efficient to just get there yourself.

@Looneytune253

A person with breathing problems can be given some treatment at home & is much safer en route to hospital in an ambulance.

its only a waste when the call centre fucks up & that's not in the OP.

@TootYourOwnHorn it's sadly, not uncommon.

indianwoman · 22/03/2024 20:02

Did you ring back after you first called to cancel the ambulance? If not, of course they'd come. You've caused the problem!

Isitovernow123 · 22/03/2024 19:59

Previousreligion · 22/03/2024 19:52

I agree.

I was really annoyed at the waste when I broke a limb in another county and went to minor injuries. They said I should go to my local fracture clinic the following week and so I did, only for them to refuse to see me and say I had to go via my GP or A&E. So I duplicated all the same tests at my local A&E that I'd already had the week before at minor injuries. I just really feel that was a pointless waste because the two hospitals didn't communicate.

So instead of going to see your gp, you wasted resources at AE instead? 🤦

Isitovernow123 · 22/03/2024 19:58

karriecreamer · 22/03/2024 19:55

Yep, my OH has cancer and gets a monthly supply of chemo and other drugs. One of the chemo tablets costs a few hundred per tablet, the other costs over a thousand. Thing is that he doesn't take all the drugs issued. He'd agreed with the oncologist to take a smaller amount. But the oncologist says it's "too hard" to change the prescription to issue fewer drugs, so he's building up quite a cupboard of excess expensive drugs that are just piling up month on month. He must have thousands of pounds worth in there now and it just keeps growing. He keeps mentioning it to the oncologist who, frankly couldn't care less - her answer is that her dept have "the funding" for the normal/full doses so it doesn't cost her department anything to keep issuing them, and it's "too hard" to change the prescription as it would involve a meeting with her, the business manager and other NHS managers to re-evaluate his treatment plan and change the dosage.

Not only is it a mammoth waste of money, it's also worrying that his NHS medical records are wrong as they indicate he's taking more drugs than he really is, so we've made such a note in his "emergency" section of his phone and in his medical information bracelet so that if he ends up in A&E, they'd be aware of what drugs he actually takes rather than what the system shows he takes!

That is poor management and exceptionally wasteful of the doctor. Another reason they need to be monitored.

Isitovernow123 · 22/03/2024 19:56

gamerchick · 22/03/2024 19:50

After the first experience of croup in my first kid I didn't bother with hospital for the rest. A mega steamy bathroom for a bit did the same job.

There's no way I'd go now the state things are in.

*Yes the usual suspects will be along to say how wrong that was in 5...4...3...

Definitely not wrong - you know what to do to alleviate the issue. Problem is, too many get frightened over the smallest of things. Call solves a lot of problems, as does cold air (for frebile convulsions), and rest.

chuffoff · 22/03/2024 19:55

TheKeatingFive · 22/03/2024 16:08

Plus the fact that studies have consistently shown that the NHS has fewer managers, as a % of the workforce, than average across the rest of the economy.

Of course the NHS needs management. It's the fifth biggest employer in the world (or thereabouts).

The issue seems to be in the quality and training of this management. A poster on here a few weeks ago made the point that so many who do these jobs are NHS lifers. And so the need to evolve and innovate isn't always met.

The whole system needs a total overhaul. But this is such an enormous job, no political party has the will to do it.

Absolutely agree with this. The big problem is that attracting good and competent people from the private sector who know how to run organisation's efficiently is nigh on impossible. Why would they go and work for the NHS when they can sit at home several days a week, likely earn more and have nowhere near the amount of stress?

karriecreamer · 22/03/2024 19:55

FenellaBestwick · 22/03/2024 19:43

I saw how MASSIVELY wasteful the Nhs is as my mil got treatment over the years. She had 14 zimmer frames at by the end as they wouldn't take old ones back. She also received so many medications she handed them out to her friends. I tried my best but go nowhere trying to sort that lot out.

Yep, my OH has cancer and gets a monthly supply of chemo and other drugs. One of the chemo tablets costs a few hundred per tablet, the other costs over a thousand. Thing is that he doesn't take all the drugs issued. He'd agreed with the oncologist to take a smaller amount. But the oncologist says it's "too hard" to change the prescription to issue fewer drugs, so he's building up quite a cupboard of excess expensive drugs that are just piling up month on month. He must have thousands of pounds worth in there now and it just keeps growing. He keeps mentioning it to the oncologist who, frankly couldn't care less - her answer is that her dept have "the funding" for the normal/full doses so it doesn't cost her department anything to keep issuing them, and it's "too hard" to change the prescription as it would involve a meeting with her, the business manager and other NHS managers to re-evaluate his treatment plan and change the dosage.

Not only is it a mammoth waste of money, it's also worrying that his NHS medical records are wrong as they indicate he's taking more drugs than he really is, so we've made such a note in his "emergency" section of his phone and in his medical information bracelet so that if he ends up in A&E, they'd be aware of what drugs he actually takes rather than what the system shows he takes!

Previousreligion · 22/03/2024 19:52

I agree.

I was really annoyed at the waste when I broke a limb in another county and went to minor injuries. They said I should go to my local fracture clinic the following week and so I did, only for them to refuse to see me and say I had to go via my GP or A&E. So I duplicated all the same tests at my local A&E that I'd already had the week before at minor injuries. I just really feel that was a pointless waste because the two hospitals didn't communicate.

littlegrebe · 22/03/2024 19:50

karriecreamer · 22/03/2024 15:54

Personally, I actually think it's too many staff, too many people involved in pretty simple routines, made worse by the artificial "internal market" that puts a price on everything which has caused a small army of staff accounting for transfers of notional monies between departments, trusts and budgets.

Only this morning, my OH went for his monthly chemotherapy drug package to find the oncology dept had lost it! This isn't paracetamol at 1p per tablet, some of the tablets are over £100 per tablet, and one is over £1,000 per tablet. No one seemed to care they'd lost them! Just glibly told him he'd have to come back next week (i.e. a week without regular treatment) as they needed to put the prescription through the entire process again, including blood test result checking, signing off by oncologist, signing off by department manager, signing off by "business management" etc and finally getting the hospital pharmacy to order them and issue them, not to mention having to make a new appointment with a specialist cancer nurse to actually hand them over to him.

Piss up and brewery springs to mind. Far too many people involved, all chasing eachother and things getting forgotten when, inevitably, one person in the chain is "off on Fridays" or "only works mornings", or is "working from home and not answering their phone" etc etc.

That's not a universal NHS experience there, that's your trust having particularly bad processes. When my DH was having treatment he had to organise his blood test the day before and then everything else would happen within the space of a couple of hours after the doctor had checked the results and made sure he wasn't having any weird reactions. To have a series of managers sign off every single time on a drug which it has presumably already been agreed is going to be supplied is an appalling waste of time and I would be inclined to write to the trust formally about it if you have the energy.

Hope your OH and you are both doing ok.