Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this waste of NHS resources is abhorrent?

119 replies

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 14:45

My little boy woke up in the middle of the night with severe croup, struggling to get a breath. This has happened before and we were told to call an ambulance if it happens again. So we did. We were told several hours wait and to take him in ourselves. Not ideal as the hospital is 30 minutes away but luckily we do drive, although it was a rather scary drive. Would've thought that a child with severe breathing difficulties would've been a priority but there you go.

Anyway, the issue is that as soon as we arrived at the hospital we got a phone call to say there was an ambulance outside our house. We told them we'd taken him in as advised, then they said "well next time you need to cancel the ambulance". As far as we knew they hadn't sent one as we'd agreed to take him in ourselves. So due to the lack of communication they've wasted an ambulance, the cost of that ambulance and the waiting time for someone else who needed it! This is insane to me. The call handler also didn't know the difference between a rash and mottled skin. Surely more training is needed here, this isn't ok? I would never waste an ambulance like this, and I'm a bit offended that she suggested so! But more offended at the absolute waste of resources.

I genuinely think the issue isn't lack of resources, but how they're managed! Not sure if I should bring this to someone's attention so it doesn't keep happening.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TonTonMacoute · 24/03/2024 10:07

@karriecreamer

Im so sorry, but not surprised, that your DH has to deal with all that crap, but I'm glad he's standing up for himself. You hate to be that patient, but frankly if you're not you will just be shoved in the corner to die. A friend who had cancer said it took weeks for any change of prescription to happen, when contacts on her internet support group who had private treatment would have these changes implemented straight away. Another friend who had lost his lower leg in an accident said they asked if they could amputate a bit more of his leg, to mid thigh, because they had messed up the measurements for his artificial limb and they didn't have the budget for a new one. I'm not making that up!

We had to deal with MIL, who went into hospital for a heart valve replacement, but she also had Alzheimer's, so she desperately needed to be out of hospital but wasn't safe to go home straight away. We were dealing with the discharge team and physios (who seemed to work completely different hours), our GP (3 different doctors seemed to be dealing with it, plus the pharmacist), occupational therapy teams (the hospital team, the community hospital team and the home visiting team - all different), the adult social care team and the community dementia care team who were the best of the lot. Then there were the two unsafe discharges, the long ambulance waits, finishing off with the final ambulance that was called by the lifeline service (we were away for a few days) and then cancelled. MIL spent all night on the floor alone. I won't describe the complaints process, but it was set up from the outset to prove no one had done anything wrong, so the same thing will just go on happening to other people, again and again.

I'd never really understood what being triggered meant, but there are a lot of ads for dementia and Alzheimer's charities at the moment and seeing them has brought a lot of bad memories back.

karriecreamer · 24/03/2024 08:59

TonTonMacoute · 23/03/2024 20:39

This absolutely nails it. Multiply this by a million and that explains perfectly what is wrong with the whole benighted organisation.

This sort of thing is pretty much a regular occurrence for people with a chronic condition, particularly if they have co-morbidities. Different departments don't seem to talk to each other and the only thing that anyone knows for certain is that whatever you are asking them about is 'not my job'.

Complete and utter fucking shambles.

Yep, you've nailed it. You clearly have experienced the same as my OH. He has a little black book of names and direct line phone numbers after being on chemo for five years and every sodding month there's some cock up or another that he has to sort out as no staff are remotely interested. He'd be dead if he wasn't on top of it himself.

As for the departments not talking to eachother, another yes! When he was first diagnosed, he had all kinds of tests, bone marrow, skeletal x-rays, MRI and CT scans, etc. They referred him to a different hospital in the next town, and the consultant there glibly ordered the whole lot again, same NHS trust, same county, but apparently "he wanted his own" and wouldn't wait for them to come through from the first hospital. (I can only assume he wasn't confident they'd ever appear after all his referral "file" was a single typed A4 sheet with no test results, just a generic, "this patient is xyz, please could you review" or something similar - how hard would it have been to ping over some actual detail???

Over the past five years, he's had other issues, i.e. a broken foot and a need for dental treatment. No one gives any real information - the oncologist glibly says ask the dentist, the dentist says ask your oncologist, he's constantly left in limbo trying to actually get advice/direction as he's just fobbed off.

Even with things like iron deficiencies that pop up on oncology blood tests, the oncologist won't just issue a prescription or give the data to the GP to issue, OH has to get a GP appointment, then a GP blood test, then the GP will say something like "not low enough to prescribe", so he tells the oncologist who says it IS too low due to the chemo effects, and back he has to go to the GP to tell them, and they then very reluctantly agree to issue the iron supplements. It's all so time wasting and maddening that they just won't communicate directly with eachother and leave the patient as piggy in the middle, which means more appointments, delays etc all wasting NHS time as well as his own.

Isitovernow123 · 23/03/2024 20:41

silverneedle · 23/03/2024 20:22

I genuinely think the issue isn't lack of resources, but how they're managed!

Perhaps there are some areas of waste - but economies of scale means NHS get good prices - and most importantly figures clearly show the NHS had the lowest annual increases in funding above inflation between 2010 and 2018 since its inception 75 years ago, around 1% annually during these years when the average has been 3%. There has been higher increases than 1% annually since 2018 but not enough to make up for those 8 years of v low funding. This underfunding happened at a time when more of the population is older which means higher costs for the NHS as older people need more healthcare and modern equipment is more expensive. So I would argue insufficient funding since 2010 is the NHS’s biggest problem.

Edited

Underfunding is definitely the issue and, unfortunately, it’s the older generations who aren’t paying into it so it’s difficult to increase funding, unless the current working generations pay more tax. Catch 22 really.

TonTonMacoute · 23/03/2024 20:39

karriecreamer · 22/03/2024 15:54

Personally, I actually think it's too many staff, too many people involved in pretty simple routines, made worse by the artificial "internal market" that puts a price on everything which has caused a small army of staff accounting for transfers of notional monies between departments, trusts and budgets.

Only this morning, my OH went for his monthly chemotherapy drug package to find the oncology dept had lost it! This isn't paracetamol at 1p per tablet, some of the tablets are over £100 per tablet, and one is over £1,000 per tablet. No one seemed to care they'd lost them! Just glibly told him he'd have to come back next week (i.e. a week without regular treatment) as they needed to put the prescription through the entire process again, including blood test result checking, signing off by oncologist, signing off by department manager, signing off by "business management" etc and finally getting the hospital pharmacy to order them and issue them, not to mention having to make a new appointment with a specialist cancer nurse to actually hand them over to him.

Piss up and brewery springs to mind. Far too many people involved, all chasing eachother and things getting forgotten when, inevitably, one person in the chain is "off on Fridays" or "only works mornings", or is "working from home and not answering their phone" etc etc.

This absolutely nails it. Multiply this by a million and that explains perfectly what is wrong with the whole benighted organisation.

This sort of thing is pretty much a regular occurrence for people with a chronic condition, particularly if they have co-morbidities. Different departments don't seem to talk to each other and the only thing that anyone knows for certain is that whatever you are asking them about is 'not my job'.

Complete and utter fucking shambles.

silverneedle · 23/03/2024 20:32

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 22/03/2024 15:41

Plus the fact that studies have consistently shown that the NHS has fewer managers, as a % of the workforce, than average across the rest of the economy.

Yes, I was reading a post by Sam Freedman, a fellow at the Institute of Government - who said that a current problem the NHS is having is insufficient managers. Just as you may be able to have too many, you can have not enough. With such an huge organisation as the NHS, good management is important as well as good clinical care.

silverneedle · 23/03/2024 20:22

I genuinely think the issue isn't lack of resources, but how they're managed!

Perhaps there are some areas of waste - but economies of scale means NHS get good prices - and most importantly figures clearly show the NHS had the lowest annual increases in funding above inflation between 2010 and 2018 since its inception 75 years ago, around 1% annually during these years when the average has been 3%. There has been higher increases than 1% annually since 2018 but not enough to make up for those 8 years of v low funding. This underfunding happened at a time when more of the population is older which means higher costs for the NHS as older people need more healthcare and modern equipment is more expensive. So I would argue insufficient funding since 2010 is the NHS’s biggest problem.

To think this waste of NHS resources is abhorrent?
FenellaBestwick · 23/03/2024 20:10

Isitovernow123 · 22/03/2024 19:44

You handed out prescription medications to people? I hope you have cover for distribution of drugs illegally…….

I didn't hand them out, she did.

TootYourOwnHorn · 23/03/2024 09:25

@indianwoman they told me they weren't sending one, that was pretty explicit. DH said he was taking him in, also pretty explicit. I'm really not sure what more could've been said in that phone call to make it obvious what was happening. If I had any clue they were sending one immediately I'd have waited. If she'd have said we're sending one but it'll be hours we'd have said cancel it while we were still on the phone in the first place. I can't cancel something that I've been told isn't happening. I don't know how much clearer I can make it for you.

OP posts:
Iwasafool · 23/03/2024 08:48

caringcarer · 22/03/2024 23:13

Because those matrons ruled their wards and everything seemed to go like clockwork. No diversity zahs costing over £100k each needed.

Well it didn't always work quite like that.

Example 1. I had my first baby 50 years ago, sister was a tartar and preferred mothers to bottle feed so she knew what baby was getting. The food in the hospital was awful and the only decent meal was breakfast which was good, cereal, fruit, bacon, sausage, eggs, beans, toast all help yourself except if you were breast feeding you weren't allowed to go to the dining room until she gave permission and breastfeeding mums weren't allowed to go until most food was gone and what was left was cold. I also had fluid on one leg, blew up like a balloon and young doctor prescribed an injection to get rid of it but she shook her head and said not on her ward. Doctor slunk away and came back after she went off shift and I got the jab.

Example 2. One of my children, 3 years old, was having surgery 40 years ago. I was allowed to stay with him till he went to theatre and then sister told me, and other mothers, that we could come back tomorrow, no point staying as children would be sleeping. I argued but she told me if I didn't leave the ward she'd call the police, I was a civilian police worker and knew officers at the local station so it didn't frighten me and I told her to go ahead but the staff nurse behind her was indicating to stop arguing. When sister left she told me the sister was going off shift at x o'clock and to give it half an hour and come back and she was happy to have me on the ward.

Yes those power mad sisters were great but not always as powerful as they thought.

Isitovernow123 · 23/03/2024 06:47

Previousreligion · 22/03/2024 22:01

I was at the hospital already, where I'd been told to go, and the A&E was in the next room. It takes weeks to get a GP appointment here even on the phone. Hardly useful for a fracture.

And I shouldn't have needed to see either, which is my point. I'd already had the X-rays, they shouldn't have made me do them all again.

Edited

And had you phoned your GP, they’d likely have received the information about your fracture and then been able to refer you to the fracture clinic.

MillyMollyMandy01 · 22/03/2024 23:20

It makes me so cross that I keep getting texts calling me for a NHS health check, yet NHS can’t cope with those it currently has on the wait lists. Why try to find even more ailments to add to it?
And today on This Morning there was a doctor advising people to go to A&E if they had certain symptoms and that they need treatment within 4 hours… well good luck with that! In my local hospital you’d still be in the waiting room 12 hours later. Even ambulances are queued up outside for whole days.
The NHS should have a campaign to discourage people to go for treatment unless there’s a real severe emergency, not looking for more people to add to the lists.

SleepyRich · 22/03/2024 23:14

PostItInABook · 22/03/2024 22:31

@SleepyRich You still don’t have Dex? We’ve had it for a good few years now.

I know!! It's just a cost thing since it's £50ish a dose.

Do you have a process for administering and discharging at scene if appropriate or must all patients administered to be transferred to A&E for monitoring??

caringcarer · 22/03/2024 23:13

Aaron95 · 22/03/2024 15:35

I wish they'd bring back the ward sisters and matrons and get rid of these upper management roles who don't step foot in the hospital for the majority of the time.

Why do people keep on repeating this over and over? There seems to be some belief that if doctors and nurses were the only ones in a hospital that it would run itself perfectly. I can tell that you have never worked in the NHS. If one thng is certain it is that medical staff are very good at treating people but really terrible at running an organisation.

Because those matrons ruled their wards and everything seemed to go like clockwork. No diversity zahs costing over £100k each needed.

Rollonsummer1 · 22/03/2024 22:31

I've been left in so many ridiculously time and money wasting situation it's unbelievable.

indianwoman · 22/03/2024 22:31

TootYourOwnHorn · 22/03/2024 20:11

@indianwoman I've already answered this question, they said there was none available so they couldn't send one and to take him ourselves, we said we would do this. Why would I then assume they were sending one after they said they weren't and we confirmed we'd take him? I'd love to see you explain how I caused a problem here.

Because they'll keep the ambulance coming despite the wait time. They would only cancel if you actually told them to cancel it. Otherwise they'd assume you'd wait. Surely they would have cancelled if you had been explicit. I appreciate though it must have been a scary and stressful time , so I'm sorry for stressing you with my response.

PostItInABook · 22/03/2024 22:31

@SleepyRich You still don’t have Dex? We’ve had it for a good few years now.

AffIt · 22/03/2024 22:27

@Ponderingwindow see my experience, as an IT expert engaged to try to build a functioning system, above.

Systems are only as good as the people behind them and if the people can't sort their shit out, then the systems won't work.

Pippa246 · 22/03/2024 22:25

No idea! I think the idea of “flow managers” sounds on paper like someone is doing something to free up beds for people in A&E so that waiting times can be met.

But just to reinforce again….there are already bed managers doing this! These flow manager posts are over and above that.

At the end of the day, there are simply not enough beds to cope with demand. You have people getting brought in from care homes because old folk are no longer allowed to just get old and die; people with mental health problems who should be treated at home but there’s no community mental health support available; migrants who need a translator so a 10 minute consultation takes 2 hours …..everything is bursting at the seams and no amount of “flow management” is going to change that.

FrenchFairytale · 22/03/2024 22:25

The sickness is horrendous. The money spent on people off sick is awful. I worked in teams where 40 percent are off sick!

Springsombrero · 22/03/2024 22:20

LightSwerve · 22/03/2024 17:14

Sick of these threads slagging off the NHS when they are in really dire straits after being run down deliberately for the last 14 years.

In 2009 you could get a GP appointment, or an ambulance, or seen in A&E.

The situation today is a government choice.

This 👏🏻

Ponderingwindow · 22/03/2024 22:18

Pippa246 · 22/03/2024 15:59

In our local hospital, 3 band 8 nurses (48.5k starting salary plus 30% or 60% night shift/weekend extra) were employed to “manage patient flow and staffing”. This was previously done by a band 7 bed manager. So these flow managers sit in the office all night phoning wards to ask if they have a bed to take someone from A&E - answer is almost always no as people do not get sent home during the night! (okay someone might die but the bed manager would know about this and update the bed availability accordingly).

It’s a complete waste of money. I do some bank shifts there and one of the people doing this job told me it was money for nothing but they were so bored they were going to go back to a band 6 ward post.

I am a supporter of the NHS but the waste and mis management is appalling. Don’t even get me started on the waste in care homes - literally millions of pounds in unnecessary prescriptions for meds, medicated toothpaste and dressings to name a few.

How is that not managed by a computer system? A centralized investment in software and maintenance would be cheaper and faster than wasting people’s time with phone calls. Not just the staff making the calls, but the people having to answer them and say there are no beds available when they are busy with other tasks.

Auburngal · 22/03/2024 22:15

Another piece of advice. Do not have appointments for different depts in the same week! As your notes won't be available for the second appt - based on my experience, F&F and colleagues' experiences too. As it your records need to go back to the records office then taken out again.

Auburngal · 22/03/2024 22:13

NHS is wasting money left right and centre.

I have smear tests done at hospital as had bad experience the last time I had one done at my GP practice. Each time I am discharged from the gynae dept and i I need to be referred again by my GP which means wasting an appointment with them.

I have an eye condition of the cornea (keratoconus) and had a procedure done on both eyes at different times. They booked me into the minor ops room in the eye department's area. My cornea in my worst eye is too thin to have the procedure there. The letter sent was to go to the main operating suites area. I was then told it had been moved to the MOR. Yet on my notes it specified NOT to have the procedure in the MOR. So wasted a day off work (fortunately paid), affected my anxiety and was rescheduled for a date where a good number of colleagues were on holiday.

Previousreligion · 22/03/2024 22:01

Isitovernow123 · 22/03/2024 19:59

So instead of going to see your gp, you wasted resources at AE instead? 🤦

I was at the hospital already, where I'd been told to go, and the A&E was in the next room. It takes weeks to get a GP appointment here even on the phone. Hardly useful for a fracture.

And I shouldn't have needed to see either, which is my point. I'd already had the X-rays, they shouldn't have made me do them all again.

SleepyRich · 22/03/2024 21:27

I've worked in a clinical capacity in the ambulance operations centre before and suspect I know what happened on this call.

When call volume is low and there are plenty of ambulances then most emergency 999 calls will be sent an ambulance, some minor injs etc/broken wrist for example could still be told to make own way.

When call volume increases to a certain point/ambulances are depleted then stages are triggered where the threshold to make your own way is reduced and calls that would previously have resulted in ambulance response will now be asked if they can make own way. This makes sense in a safety point of view - if a child is having a severe croup episode and struggling with their breathing and an ambulance can be there in under 18 minutes then great it's worth waiting for. However due to the level of demand it's expected that ambulance could take 1-2 hours (which is actually very common), it makes sense to enquire if the parents can take the child themselves to A&E, most people live within 30mins of an A&E so even if there is a life threatening emergency occurring, if you can make your own way the risk is less than waiting for an ambulance that might not come in time.

Also the sooner you arrive in hospital the quicker you can access their expertise. For example, the treatment for a severe croup in a child is a single dose liquid steroid - most trusts do not carry this and is administered in hospital. The treatment for life threatening croup is nebulised adrenaline - paramedics are not authorised to administer this drug by this method. All we can salbutamol which only acts in the lungs (not the throat where croup acts when it's life threatening).

It's absolutely certainly not wrong to call 999 if you think your child is having a life threatening breathing problem and this is the advice any clinician would give to do. However already this year I've had to resuscitate a child who arrested waiting for an ambulance, if the parents had not called 999 and just put him in the car and gone to hospital we estimated they'd have arrived about 20minutes before he stopped breathing, it was very possible with prompt treatment in hospital he would have survived. We obviously didn't discuss this with parents as it's not their fault, but I know if my child was very unwell and needed to be seen in A&E as a Paramedic I absolutely wouldn't consider for 1 second calling 999. I'd just put them in the car and take them to the hospital. This way I would know they could be with Doctors within 20minutes from when I leave the house (if a child is very unwell they'll be seen straight away), as opposed to calling 999 and delaying care by a likely 1-2 hours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread