Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can school do this? - managed move

240 replies

Bonnyswannie · 22/03/2024 13:38

My dd is struggling at her very strict academy school. Whilst it works for some it does not for my dd and she has gone from well behaved to being pulled up for things like uniform and forgotten items to now what they call disrespectful behaviour
my dd worries about school a lot at home and we applied to a new school that is less strict about u forms and bags and I felt may be a better match.
my dd has a lot of negative behaviours points and a 1 day suspension since year 8 - nothing before that.
the new school has accepted and it’s all going through yet today my dd’s current school said they would speak to new school as due to her negative behaviours she would need a managed move. I called them this morning for help as dd was up worrying last night and not wanting to come and now we are being told this.
i asked for this in writing and they have said the new school could request due to the amount of negative behaviours. Can they do this?
my dd is undergoing assessment for ADHD she’s not aggressive or nasty or anything she does forget stuff and she can back chat . Some lessons she excels in and there are 3 subjects she is rarely in as Sw gets sent out for back chat about things that are missing. Not ideal but dd says they talk to her like crap and it makes her feel shit

OP posts:
stayathomer · 23/03/2024 11:24

a suspension is pretty last resort for something serious
This sounds insane but nowadays it really doesn't seem to be, in my son's school they seem to suspend quite readily. When we were in school you rarely heard of it (I think twice and it was for serious bullying stuff and the hugest deal at the tiem, we were all shocked) but now my son tells me almost weekly of people being suspended. Not for teeny tiny things-eg they get detention if the teacher decides it for them forgetting something, but there's been suspensions for boys not doing homework a few times and not offering a note or them talking back to a teacher more than once. I know there's a line, but I think back to our school and the messing that went on (we had a lot of the 'cool' girls int he class that would talk back all the time and made a few teachers leave the room upset) and it definitely feels like suspensions are held as an alternative to detentions

cocog · 23/03/2024 11:22

One of the schools in our city has a shed outside and kids have uniforms and equipment checked before entering. This is such a power trip and ridiculous waste of teaching time. Frustrating and embarrassing for children that just don’t have resources at home. This school is in the middle of a few bad housing estates with known social issues I feel so sorry for the kids that the teachers can’t keep a pot of pens or whatever to help support there education and there being treated like this it’s so sad! I read an article yesterday about a school locking toilets during lessons. Our children are being treated appallingly at some schools. I as an adult can use a toilet whenever I like it’s controlling and wrong to do this to them and wrong on every level. Prisoners have access to toilets. I will be looking very closely at schools when it’s time for my primary aged children go! I totally understand you wanting to move your child’s school before this treatment affects her even more!

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 23/03/2024 11:14

One of the criteria for exclusion is that the child is involved in persistent disruptive behaviour - i.e. it's not so much the individual incidents in themselves, it's the quantity and impact of them. So yes, in a sense you can end up being excluded because of minor uniform infractions - if you're doing them all the time, not listening, persistently ignoring the teacher.

I've met parents who will say their kids were excluded for chewing gum, when it wasn't the chewing gum but the repeated incidents, refusing to put it in the bin when asked, defying the teacher etc - in some situations like this the whole class can be quite substantially disrupted whilst the class teacher is trying to sort the situation out, or having to send the child to the head. Or get a more senior member of staff out of the class they're teaching to resolve this situation, so that two classes have their learning interrupted. And then having other children saying things like "well, X does this and nothing happens to them" or "what does X have to do to get into trouble" (yes, children do ask their teachers these things). Etc.

I don't know if this is the case for you, OP, and I have a huge amount of sympathy. It's sometimes the case that persistent disruptive behaviour is happening because the school isn't making small adjustments that would really help the child to cope in class. So no presumptions here. I'm just explaining to others how you might have a situation where to a parent it really does look like the child is being excluded because of a minor incident, but it's actually the last straw in a series of incidents that over time has a real effect on discipline and learning within the classroom.

(couple of small edits for clarity/better phrasing)

becauseidonwantto · 23/03/2024 11:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@veryangrymot where does the OP say the DD was shouting abuse at teachers?

Sometimes MN reads like the daily fail comments section.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 23/03/2024 11:10

imip · 23/03/2024 07:24

You are comparing yourself to a child that potentially has a disability. You wouldn’t compare your ability to see with a visually impaired person. The disability is invisible. OP, you are better posting on the SN boards as you’ll just get a lot on ignorance here. Please get in contact with your local SENDIASS for support. If your daughter hasn’t already, please ask school for a SEN support plan to help her get the support she needs from school. You may have a local adhd support group near you that you can tap into.

Suspensions and internal exclusions are really not that unusual. Maybe I see them more in my line of work, but they are used for lots of low-level behaviours that are better managed by reasonable adjustments and SEN support plans.

I agree with this.

FWIW, I don't understand why the current school is saying it has to be a managed move. Usually a managed move comes about when a child is at immediate risk of exclusion but there are mitigating circumstances which mean that no one wants the move to be a punishment for the child. Have you been told that she's at risk of exclusion if she doesn't move? If not, I'm honestly not sure what business it is of the current school's.

Bonnyswannie · 23/03/2024 10:58

Smeegall · 23/03/2024 10:30

Apologies for grammatical mistake.

i don’t believe a school would do a managed move for the reasons stated.

i feel there has to be more to this story than being stated.

managed move is the step before exclusion from a school. I can’t believe they would go to this length over a rolled up skirt, it’s just not worth the hassle.

there’s just such a feeling of us and them on this thread. The teachers at the school, even if not always on your child’s side want the best for your child - that’s it. No teacher goes into the job for any other reason, no matter how senior they are.

I will say that I’ve been sworn at so much more recently and it’s almost become acceptable to do. Parents don’t seem to care their child has sworn at a teacher. If I’ve been sworn at, and I’m good at behaviour management, and very little consequence happens (after school detention….!) I cannot believe the OPs daughter is having a managed move for some very minor infractions. It doesn’t add up.

we are so quick to label as an undiagnosed SEN and how difficult it is for the child. In the mean time there’s a class of 29 having to wait to learn, possibly with their own needs.

If child is so great and it’s the schools fault, accept the managed move they will pass with flying colours.

And if you read my posts you will see I did not believe it too, hence my posting It.

OP posts:
Bonnyswannie · 23/03/2024 10:56

itsgettingweird · 23/03/2024 10:41

This reminds me of my ds in year 3 pre asd diagnosis.

Teacher "miniweird. You've been looking out of the window for the past 5 minutes of my input. Have you been listening to- what did I say?" (Paraphrased)

DS "<starts to repeat it back word for word>"

Luckily he had a great teacher who saw the funny side and told me that she learnt a lesson that day herself and realised he didn't need to be looking to learn and he took more in if he wasn't made to feel uncomfortable by looking at her all the time.

Yes this is what has happened i have had extensive conversations with DD about how this comes across. im sure I will get accused of sticking up for my daughter on this thread (madness) but she has made huge efforts with this but can only manage it by keeping her mouth shut, because now she has learnt to not trust her immediate reaction (impulsiveness) unfortunately taking her time to answer or not answering is viewed as rudeness too. She has an amazing tutor at the school she is currently at who see’s this and has advocated for her.

OP posts:
Bonnyswannie · 23/03/2024 10:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Her crap? How disgusting.
she is not being managed move not sure how many times I need to write that
I have been completely honest

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 23/03/2024 10:41

Stoufer · 23/03/2024 10:02

Not read full thread, only up to page 3, but wanted to say re: ‘back chat’… with Sen (ASD maybe other things), there may be miscommunications that may look like back chat, eg ‘are you looking out of the window, Jack?’ answered with ‘yes miss’ (as the child with ASD thinks that an honest answer is required), at which point the teacher goes ballistic. I had to explain to my dc (very upset and unable to understand what they had done wrong as he had just answered the question), that when a teacher tells you off about something, or asks you about something which implies a telling off is on the way, you have to say ‘I’m really sorry miss, I won’t do it again’ rather than actually answering the actual question. The ‘yes miss’ answer he had given to the teacher in year 9 resulted in a detention, and an underlying assumption that he had an attitude problem, for the rest of the year (which is possibly self-fulfilling with a child with ASD, as if the teacher’s attitude to then is a bit hostile then it may trigger things due to the unfairness (things being unfair are a massive trigger). Dc has not had that teacher since year 9, which is a relief.

This reminds me of my ds in year 3 pre asd diagnosis.

Teacher "miniweird. You've been looking out of the window for the past 5 minutes of my input. Have you been listening to- what did I say?" (Paraphrased)

DS "<starts to repeat it back word for word>"

Luckily he had a great teacher who saw the funny side and told me that she learnt a lesson that day herself and realised he didn't need to be looking to learn and he took more in if he wasn't made to feel uncomfortable by looking at her all the time.

Bluevelvetsofa · 23/03/2024 10:39

It’s an opportunity for a fresh start and to find ways to manage the organisational difficulties she has. Folders and pencil cases have been mentioned and maybe trays labelled with the days of the week, so she has the right equipment and books at a glance. I’d suggest checklists in prominent places, so you only leave the house after you’ve both checked that she has what she needs.

Not easy to start with, but will become so when you’ve got into a routine.

I hope it’s a positive move.

cansu · 23/03/2024 10:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

scoping87 · 23/03/2024 10:38

Get her on Elevanse or the other ADHD med asap. Life changing for my 14y old DD

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/03/2024 10:37

I know plenty of my colleagues who teach because they like their subject and routine etc but simply cannot get their heads around the idea that some children cannot fit the mould and that they are the ones who need to adapt by helping them to manage their equipment, notes, maybe keeping their folder in the room so it's always there. Little things that can make a huge difference. My form class often speak to me about two colleagues in particular who are so inflexible and unimaginative in their approach. One gives sanctions for homework missed because the students were out of school on a school sports tour with no access to devices or time to do it.

Only the op knows the extent of her DDs behaviour and some posters on here are displaying appalling attitudes to a disabled child because they are so determined to stick to mantra that everyone CAN conform if they are sufficiently terrorised into it. Sad.

Smeegall · 23/03/2024 10:30

Flamme · 23/03/2024 09:44

OP's daughter has not been showing abusive behaviour.

No-one can "be" ADHD. It's a condition which people have.

Apologies for grammatical mistake.

i don’t believe a school would do a managed move for the reasons stated.

i feel there has to be more to this story than being stated.

managed move is the step before exclusion from a school. I can’t believe they would go to this length over a rolled up skirt, it’s just not worth the hassle.

there’s just such a feeling of us and them on this thread. The teachers at the school, even if not always on your child’s side want the best for your child - that’s it. No teacher goes into the job for any other reason, no matter how senior they are.

I will say that I’ve been sworn at so much more recently and it’s almost become acceptable to do. Parents don’t seem to care their child has sworn at a teacher. If I’ve been sworn at, and I’m good at behaviour management, and very little consequence happens (after school detention….!) I cannot believe the OPs daughter is having a managed move for some very minor infractions. It doesn’t add up.

we are so quick to label as an undiagnosed SEN and how difficult it is for the child. In the mean time there’s a class of 29 having to wait to learn, possibly with their own needs.

If child is so great and it’s the schools fault, accept the managed move they will pass with flying colours.

WhatsitWiggle · 23/03/2024 10:07

@Bonnyswannie you say your daughter is undergoing assessment? Depending how far down the path you are, you can ask your GP for right to choose and choose a private practice. There's still months long waiting lists due to demand, but quicker than years!

Also, look up "ordinarily available practice" in your local authority. This is what the school should be doing without an EHCP. EHCP are taking way longer than the statutory 26 weeks, you say she's year 8 now. So really you want the new school to do everything they can to support her as if her ADHD is diagnosed (if she's been accepted onto the ND pathway, there's a good chance she is) and if that's not enough, work together to submit a needs assessment request before the end of year 8. The only criteria are the child may have SEN and may need additional support.

Help her out as much as possible. My DD is AuDHD. She's no longer attending school after burnout 15 months ago but, prior to that, we'd prepare her school bag together. One pencil case remained in her bag, she had another in her room for homework so no need to remove the school one, and a check each weekend whether any equipment was missing. I bulk ordered protractors and rulers from ebay as they were constantly going missing! Checklist in her room for getting ready, checklist on the front door before leaving the house. Post it note on car dashboard! Whatever needs to be done to support the executive function - it's not a case of her learning to remember, she simply can't, that's her disability. It's about recognising what she struggles with and finding the right tools to support.

veryangrymot · 23/03/2024 10:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ggttl · 23/03/2024 10:03

Schools are often really rubbish at dealing with ADHD but they are usually a lot more tolerant than work places. I teach a lot of children with ADHD and the majority are not rude to teachers and are lovely to deal with. For your daughters sake I wouldn’t let her use adhd as an excuse for being rude as it won’t help her get on in life.

Stoufer · 23/03/2024 10:02

Not read full thread, only up to page 3, but wanted to say re: ‘back chat’… with Sen (ASD maybe other things), there may be miscommunications that may look like back chat, eg ‘are you looking out of the window, Jack?’ answered with ‘yes miss’ (as the child with ASD thinks that an honest answer is required), at which point the teacher goes ballistic. I had to explain to my dc (very upset and unable to understand what they had done wrong as he had just answered the question), that when a teacher tells you off about something, or asks you about something which implies a telling off is on the way, you have to say ‘I’m really sorry miss, I won’t do it again’ rather than actually answering the actual question. The ‘yes miss’ answer he had given to the teacher in year 9 resulted in a detention, and an underlying assumption that he had an attitude problem, for the rest of the year (which is possibly self-fulfilling with a child with ASD, as if the teacher’s attitude to then is a bit hostile then it may trigger things due to the unfairness (things being unfair are a massive trigger). Dc has not had that teacher since year 9, which is a relief.

Zyq · 23/03/2024 09:49

I always find it fairly amazing how often schools that claim to be very hot on discipline ignore the law themselves. It's hardly setting a good example to their pupils, is it?

Flamme · 23/03/2024 09:47

FluffyFanny · 23/03/2024 09:37

The school are clearly trying to support your child. Surely a 'managed move' is there to help her settle into the new school, help the new school understand her needs so they can put support in place for her etc. Would you prefer her to just rock up at the new school Monday morning and let them deal with her issues blind?

How are they trying to support her when they have not applied for a needs assessment? Let alone when they are trying to impose a managed move illegally. OP's posts make it perfectly clear that the new school won't be dealing with her daughter's issues without full information from her.

itsgettingweird · 23/03/2024 09:45

You clearly have no idea about how some academies operate. They make a massive Thing of discipline because it is so much easier than providing motivating teaching and they move to suspension, exclusion and, yes, managed moves with ludicrous speed if they perceive that a child with learning difficulties might dent their statistics. I think you may be the one with blinkers.

That's my experience. As soon as it was clear my ds needed and would get an ehcp they just saw the £sssss they'd have to invest and upped their anti.

They didn't even respond to the LAs request for information after the application - we both received the email with the deadline for this - and even claimed they didn't a) have to provide any and b) had a deadline to send it. They sent this to me in an email.

The crap they get away with is mind blowing if you've actually been involved in it.

My saving grace for ds is I work in education so know the law and could point out in one email sentence which duties weren't provided.

That's why they hated me and launched a personal attack against me.

Because they wanted to get away with lying - and I wouldn't let them.

Flamme · 23/03/2024 09:44

Smeegall · 23/03/2024 09:14

impulsivity is not an excuse for abusive behaviour.

you can be ADHD and not abuse everybody.

managed moves are not light things, your daughter has been awful and you need to support her to make better decisions, rather than blaming the school or teachers.

OP's daughter has not been showing abusive behaviour.

No-one can "be" ADHD. It's a condition which people have.

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/03/2024 09:44

Zyq · 23/03/2024 09:31

Tell me you know nothing about ADHD without saying you know nothing about ADHD.

It's unbelievable isn't it.

NamelessNancy · 23/03/2024 09:42

andHelenknowsimmiserablenow · 23/03/2024 09:33

I agree with PP who said that the school are probably trying the managed move angle so that their figures don't show another pupil choosing to leave the school, especially if this is happening a lot.
I feel lucky that the school DS attends, while strict about uniform, equipment and respect also has great support with ADHD and SEN requirements. It is a fine line between making DC feel overwhelmed with too many things to remember and not wanting their forgetfulness to impact lessons.
And to be honest, when they start work, there will be consequences for forgetting and losing equipment or uniform, so this can't just be ignored.

Agree about consequences later in life however punishing these kids is not the answer. It doesn't work for one thing! ND kids need to be taught strategies for things they struggle with and given understanding whilst they learn which strategies work for them.

itsgettingweird · 23/03/2024 09:42

Oh and OP ignore the ignorance on this thread.

My ds did managed move at end of year 7 into 8. Because he went to an idiotic establishment that refused to understand ND. He wasn't even in trouble - ever. But he did have issues with severe anxiety, was referred to camhs who diagnosed school related anxiety and then couldn't attend after being a victim of knife crime in a classroom which school minimised.

I've had so many people say "he must have been moved due to his behaviour". He never so much as a detention in either school. He also got an ehcp soon after the moved which I had applied for during year 7 and that school didn't even respond to Las request for information.