Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Moving area 7 miles away. Change or stay at current school?

35 replies

User291997 · 22/03/2024 12:59

Just looking for opinions really. My DD is 4 and has attended primary school since September. She loves it there, has made friends and has settled in well. I’ve been offered a council property and it’s 7 miles away from her current school. I do drive and work part time. The primary school near the new house has an inadequate rating with Ofsted and I do worry about moving her and how she would cope with the change. What would you do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
snoopyfanaccountant · 23/03/2024 09:31

DB lives in the countryside, 6 miles from the catchment primary school. Driving 7 miles to school is nothing in a rural area.

martinisforeveryone · 23/03/2024 09:15

Yes @NewName24 that’s my understanding too.

Just to be clear, in our case, existing school more or less six miles away in a village with multiple facilities. New house over a mile from different school, but say five from the nearest shop. The nearest school in mileage was actually more or a problem journey wise as it wasn’t enroute to anything else, or with anything else close, except a church. That was without comparing the schools’ suitability or provisions, or breaking up established friendships, routines and so on.

I don’t think that’s necessarily such an unusual situation in more rural areas where the houses can be very spread out and village shops, post offices, pubs etc have disappeared, so you’re travelling anyway and planning carefully if you see what I mean.

NewName24 · 23/03/2024 00:32

Fair points @martinisforeveryone , but, as the OP said she might be moving 7 miles and that 'the Primary school near the new house .....' so I am assuming that she isn't in a rural situation where one school covers every child in a 10, 15, 0r 30 mile radius in her particular case.

TesticularHeft · 22/03/2024 21:48

Will she be able to go to the same high school as the friends she has made if she is 7 miles away? If not, move her now. It so, keep her there.

DD just moved to high school this year and her friends made the transition easier. Others didn't have friends and it made a big change much worse.

martinisforeveryone · 22/03/2024 19:00

@NewName24 all very valid points. What I would say in mitigation, having done all the school years from the get go, is that when you live rurally, you plan, none of those things are an issue.

So often on MN I read all about café culture and 'the corner shop' as though that's the norm. For a lot of people who live rurally, like me, the nearest shop is a five mile drive away and there's no public transport, so we deal with all these kind of things all the time.

Katemax82 · 22/03/2024 18:13

Leave her where she is. I live 9 miles from my kids primary as we moved last year but moving schools would be unnecessary

NewName24 · 22/03/2024 17:40

I'd go and look round the nearest school, and, if there is one, 2nd nearest.

I don't put much value on OFSTED one word judgements.

You've got 6 years of doing this (not counting those times when you might have to go back for concerts / parents evenings / trips and so forth.
She will be growing up miles away from her school friends. That is important not only for her friendships, but also for you for lift shares etc. or for helping each other out should you ever need support.
What will you do when the car is in the garage ? Even just for it's MOT. Or (lets hope it doesn't happen) but if it is stolen, or written off ? Or when it is icy or snowy ?

Then what about at secondary transfer ?

I think living close to your Primary school is a massive plus, and would give it weighting above lots of other factors.
At 4 she will integrate into the new class easily - it would be different if she were in Yr 6.

Dacadactyl · 22/03/2024 15:51

Normally id say move her, but i wouldnt deliberately move my child to an inadequate school.

Tiddlywinks63 · 22/03/2024 15:48

martinisforeveryone · 22/03/2024 15:12

Keep her where she's happy and thriving. As she gets older her socialising will involve after school clubs maybe and school friend parties at weekends. If there are neighbours with children who could become friends, you can also factor them in.

I never lived near to any of my schools and for various reason our children also attended schools around the same distance away as you mention. It wasn't ever a problem as I drive and could manage the various journeys.

I'd only move her if that became a problem to you.

This ^^

RamblingAroundTheInternet · 22/03/2024 15:46

I’d keep where she is if you and she are happy for now anyway. You’d want to keep her there until July anyway.

How long ago was the local school rated Inadequate? There is generally a lot of funding and work put into schools like this as the improvements must be made. When you’ve moved you can visit the school, ask when they expect their next inspection will be and have they made the improvements, also talk to other parents about their view of the school.

You can judge then whether to move DC for Yr1.

Is there a decent secondary school feeding from local school? Another thing to think about in future is will all her schoolmates at current school be going to a secondary school that she may not get into due to catchment? 7 miles is quite a distance in our area with the amount of secondaries we have (4 in a 5 mile radius) but as you said it’s rural so there may be only one secondary serving both primary schools?

I would definitely move closer to home if school is OK as distance could be an issue with out of school socialisation when they get into Yr4-6 and I’d prefer DC to have friends in local area for school holidays.

TheNoodlesIncident · 22/03/2024 15:27

It's definitely worth going to visit the school in your new area, as there could well have been improvements made on the back of the OFSTED report. And often OFSTED marks schools down for reasons that don't actually affect the way the pupils are taught anyway. I wouldn't rule out a school in these circumstances without investigating for myself whether it would be a decent school or not.

There are loads of advantages of going to a school close by, and she hasn't been at her current school for that long. Why not check it out first before making a decision? Then at least if the local school doesn't suit, you'll know you've made your choice with the best information you had.

Floralnomad · 22/03/2024 15:13

Leave her where she is 7 miles is nothing

martinisforeveryone · 22/03/2024 15:12

Keep her where she's happy and thriving. As she gets older her socialising will involve after school clubs maybe and school friend parties at weekends. If there are neighbours with children who could become friends, you can also factor them in.

I never lived near to any of my schools and for various reason our children also attended schools around the same distance away as you mention. It wasn't ever a problem as I drive and could manage the various journeys.

I'd only move her if that became a problem to you.

Tohaveandtohold · 22/03/2024 15:10

Keep her there for now. We did the same with DD1 when we moved when she was in year 1 because the local school was inadequate and was going to get closed down and the other good options mean we have to drive her anyway so kept her in the school 3.5 miles away. The local school is now good and the nursery attached is outstanding so DD2 is going there now, she’s in reception so we’re having to do 2 school runs for a year before DD1 goes to secondary school in sept but it was the best thing we did. She has thrived in the school, made lots of friends and have 3 people that’ll be going to the same secondary school as her in sept and one is her good friend so even though she never made friends locally, she has established friendship in the school.

PuttingDownRoots · 22/03/2024 15:05

Keep an eye on improvements in the local school, and move if and when it improves.

Hoplolly · 22/03/2024 15:01

Stay. My teens are 12 miles away from their secondary school, it's fine really. It's through countryside, hardly any traffic. Keep her there and if you don't think it's working out you can make the change, but you can never go back if you pull her out now.

catmomma67 · 22/03/2024 15:00

if you are going to be living in this new area for a great length of time... i'd sway schools... your child is 4, they wont notice the change that much.. and they will make friends and grow up with people living around them.

if you continue to take them to a school 7 miles away, who do they then play with out of school

User291997 · 22/03/2024 14:57

Bramshott · 22/03/2024 14:55

Is it 7 miles across town or 7 miles in the countryside? How long will it take you to drive? The good news is that you don't have to rush into anything as it will be possible to keep her at her existing school for now whilst you check out the other option(s).

Thanks for your replies everyone

its 7 miles through country side and wouldn’t effect my working hours or anything like that. It’s fairly rural so not lots of choice really

OP posts:
Bramshott · 22/03/2024 14:55

Is it 7 miles across town or 7 miles in the countryside? How long will it take you to drive? The good news is that you don't have to rush into anything as it will be possible to keep her at her existing school for now whilst you check out the other option(s).

PatriciaHolm · 22/03/2024 14:51

Bushmillsbabe · 22/03/2024 14:03

Definitely stay in current school - if you can! A few very oversubscribed schools can ask you to prove you are still in catchment each year- to stop people renting close to a desirable school just long enough to get child in, and then move.

But I would definitely stay if you can

No, they can't. Once a place has been given, it can only be withdrawn on very limited grounds. Moving home once at the school is not one of them.

A place can withdrawn if a parent gives an address of convenience, (so a property that is not in the LAs opinion the child's permanent address) but that is not the case here.

waterrat · 22/03/2024 14:27

7 miles is an insane journey to primary school. The best thing about primary is being near it so you are friends with your neighbours/ can organise playdates etc

Schools with poor ofsted often have a huge input of support after the report - have you been and lookd round? It could be massively on the up.

I can see why you might initially keep her there ie. til end of summer but you will want to have her at school in her own community for so many reasons.

EC22 · 22/03/2024 14:16

are there no other more local schools?

WarningOfGails · 22/03/2024 14:15

Bushmillsbabe · 22/03/2024 14:03

Definitely stay in current school - if you can! A few very oversubscribed schools can ask you to prove you are still in catchment each year- to stop people renting close to a desirable school just long enough to get child in, and then move.

But I would definitely stay if you can

This isn’t correct.

Mumof2teens79 · 22/03/2024 14:14

Stay
You can move her at any point in the future but you won't be able to move her back if you don't like it.

RandomMess · 22/03/2024 14:11

How long will that 7 miles take including parking etc. Will it impact on your commute?

What are the alternatives closer to the new joys but on the way to work.

Will that primary feed into a secondary school your DD will likely attend from the new house?

You don't have to move her now but in the future it may be the better option.