Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Breastfeeding - cold turkey 13 month old tips

44 replies

AmeliaHay · 22/03/2024 07:15

My 2nd son is 13 month and exclusively breastfed, but the frequent waking for boob is killing me now. I am permanently exhausted from it, because he always wants to boob back to sleep, and if I try other methods he just cries and cries. I feel we've got to the point that he is forcing me to have to just end our breastfeeding journey completely because I'm getting angry at him for waking / wanting boob all through the night, which is then making me feel guilty for getting so frustrated with him, because I'm so tired. I'm sad to have to stop, because it's such a wonderful bond and I love feeding him (just not up to 10 times a night!) and I also know we're not having another baby, so I'll never do this again, so I know it's going to me difficult to stop - for us both. I went cold turkey with my 1st who was exactly the same when he was 16 months but I can't remember how I did it. Would you just say "it's all gone" this morning, and just stick with that until he stops asking? :(

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AmeliaHay · 26/03/2024 22:09

@fuckthemail yes I agree. @whatwhatwhot couldn't disagree more.

OP posts:
whatwhatwhot · 26/03/2024 19:07

Go away for a few days. Only way

fuckthemail · 26/03/2024 19:05

Of course it's ok 🙂 there is so much access to "advice" these days, I think going your own path with your own baby and doing what works for you both is absolutely fine

AmeliaHay · 25/03/2024 08:10

Well there were a fair few wakes last night, but hardly any crying, I haf to feed him at 4am though, my breast was so full and pump wasn't charged, but he still came off before falling asleep, so definitely progress!

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 24/03/2024 20:49

Yes I think what you're doing is fine :)

CadyEastman · 24/03/2024 08:03

Another great result Wink

AmeliaHay · 24/03/2024 08:02

Yes I agree, if he's poorly I'll stop, but he was ok in the night after calpol at 11pm. He only protested once last night, at about 3am, which was tough because he was upset for about 30 minutes, but I kept telling myself if I give in now he's cried for nothing and he'll learn that protesting will make me give in, he eventually went back to sleep with a cuddle and I fed him when he woke for the day at 6:30 x

OP posts:
PomegranateOfPersephone · 24/03/2024 03:06

If he’s ill you might want to feed him through the night until he’s better and then begin again. Poorly toddlers often want to feed more both for comfort because they feel so wretched and because mother’s milk is medicine as well as the most easily digested and nutritionally complete food. He is more likely to tolerate it with less upset when he feels well.

Pineapplewaves · 23/03/2024 21:43

When I weaned both of my DS off breast milk, I gradually phased out the day feeds first, then it was easy to end the night feeding because they were used to not getting bf by then. If you want to keep the day feeds I think you might struggle giving up the nights as that's when baby needs the most comfort and you share the same bed so the milk is always there. Imagine getting into bed with your favourite food in the whole world but you can't touch it!

CadyEastman · 23/03/2024 21:09

BFing aside, I don't think it's advised to sleep train any baby if they're unwell? Flowers

AmeliaHay · 23/03/2024 20:33

Nitwit 😂
Well he's still awake atm tonight as he's had more naps today (could be tired from the upset during the night or a bit of a temp as his older brother is poorly). He's had a bath, pjs, story, and feed in bed but wasn't ready for sleep so husband has him downstairs whilst i see to his poorly brother. Really hope he's not coming down with this bug too as it'll feel so much harder saying no if he's poorly 😢 but my plan is not to feed now until 6am at least

OP posts:
Pleasegodgotosleep · 23/03/2024 20:11

Take something like lempsip to help dry up your milk at the same time so you dont get mastitis

CadyEastman · 23/03/2024 19:57

I think the advisor who said they don't understand only feeding sometimes is a nitwit

Nitwit is so underused but yet so fitting in this context Grin

NoCloudsAllowed · 23/03/2024 19:53

AmeliaHay · 22/03/2024 19:10

We are co sleeping, which I love and embrace it, our eldest is 4 and it's mad how quick the time goes, so I have no intention of rushing him out of our bed. He doesn't snore, or sleep with mouth open, or sweat, no sign of allergies or anything. I'm gonna sleep on it tonight, they say don't quit breastfeeding on a bad day don't they... I would like to ideally feed at bedtime, and morning, and just night wean. Least then it's a slowet weaning process, I'm jusy not confident I can do that without thinking I'm confusing him or being cruel.

I think the advisor who said they don't understand only feeding sometimes is a nitwit. Of course they do, just as they understand the difference between breakfast and dinner!

If I were you and you only want to feed at waking and bedtime - just do that, and be determined enough to see it out for a week even in the face of protest, then it'll be your routine.

LightSwerve · 23/03/2024 12:11

AmeliaHay · 23/03/2024 08:50

Morning! So I decided to feed him ti sleep at bedtime last night, 7pm. He woke at 11pm so i gave a beaker with milk, he cried but not hysterically. I said milkied were asleep. Woke again 1am ish and was breaking his heart, pointing at my boobs, he cried for a good 30 mins :( again i said milikies was asleep, he fell asleep with a cuddle. 4am,third wake, but this wake was more of a whingey cry not too upset, and he was blabbing in between crying. He then woke at 6am and i said milikies are awake and gave him a feed. Is this ok? I want to carry on day feeds, and then eventually just do bedtime and morning, but want to stop nights, will this work and is it fair to him? How long will it take do you think?

That sounds much less traumatic than cold turkey!

AmeliaHay · 23/03/2024 08:50

Morning! So I decided to feed him ti sleep at bedtime last night, 7pm. He woke at 11pm so i gave a beaker with milk, he cried but not hysterically. I said milkied were asleep. Woke again 1am ish and was breaking his heart, pointing at my boobs, he cried for a good 30 mins :( again i said milikies was asleep, he fell asleep with a cuddle. 4am,third wake, but this wake was more of a whingey cry not too upset, and he was blabbing in between crying. He then woke at 6am and i said milikies are awake and gave him a feed. Is this ok? I want to carry on day feeds, and then eventually just do bedtime and morning, but want to stop nights, will this work and is it fair to him? How long will it take do you think?

OP posts:
PomegranateOfPersephone · 23/03/2024 07:45

AmeliaHay · 22/03/2024 19:10

We are co sleeping, which I love and embrace it, our eldest is 4 and it's mad how quick the time goes, so I have no intention of rushing him out of our bed. He doesn't snore, or sleep with mouth open, or sweat, no sign of allergies or anything. I'm gonna sleep on it tonight, they say don't quit breastfeeding on a bad day don't they... I would like to ideally feed at bedtime, and morning, and just night wean. Least then it's a slowet weaning process, I'm jusy not confident I can do that without thinking I'm confusing him or being cruel.

This is kinder than cold turkey in my opinion. As others have said it is actually likely that it is a helpful or healthy approach because it teaches that you have boundaries but that doesn’t mean the breastfeeding relationship is ending completely. By having the boundaries you need/want you are teaching your child that it is okay for him to have boundaries as well and to respect the boundaries of others.

It is actually a very common, “normal” way of gently weaning. The bedtime and morning feeds are the last to be dropped for the vast majority of children. Lots of mums night wean first, when they feel their need for sleep is outweighing the child’s needs for night feeds.

Breastfeeding in the morning can be a lovely reconnection after the night of (hopefully) sleeping, bedtime breastfeeding can be relaxing and soothing and perhaps lead to better quality sleep for both mum and baby.

If night weaning and doing bedtime and morning is what you want to do then go for it, I imagine that if you could discuss it rationally with your child he would find it a preferable solution to going cold turkey.

I have heard of lots of techniques for this a popular one is saying we will breastfeed again when the sun comes up. Calling a breastfeeding helpline or going to a breastfeeding group you would probably hear lots of ideas.

CadyEastman · 23/03/2024 06:33

I'm jusy not confident I can do that without thinking I'm confusing him or being cruel.

That's what I did with my DS and it was fine. No confusion.

Lots of other posters are saying the same.

Has the sleep consultation got and BFing Qualifications?

I suspect not if she's giving out dodgy advice like this.

I would ring one of the BFing Helplines and talk through your plans with a BFC Flowers

AmeliaHay · 22/03/2024 19:10

We are co sleeping, which I love and embrace it, our eldest is 4 and it's mad how quick the time goes, so I have no intention of rushing him out of our bed. He doesn't snore, or sleep with mouth open, or sweat, no sign of allergies or anything. I'm gonna sleep on it tonight, they say don't quit breastfeeding on a bad day don't they... I would like to ideally feed at bedtime, and morning, and just night wean. Least then it's a slowet weaning process, I'm jusy not confident I can do that without thinking I'm confusing him or being cruel.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 22/03/2024 18:28

Oh I'd suggest infant ibuprofen to help biting caused by teething pain.

BertieBotts · 22/03/2024 18:27

You can stop at one time and not at others. They understand this just fine IME.

If you want to stop totally, that's also fine. I'd make the decision based on what you want though and have some confidence in it, rather than thinking he's "forcing" you. He's only one, he can't force you to do anything. It's perfectly fine to stop breastfeeding or put some limits on breastfeeding if you want to do that. Not cruel. It's good to have boundaries and limits - children don't always have to like this and that's ok.

Is he in his own room or are you cosleeping? A mixture?

Wingslikeabird · 22/03/2024 18:22

OP, waking more frequently than every two hours would be considered outside of the norm, and thus there will be some underlying factor at play that will be causing this (allergies, or oral ties, or obstructed breathing etc.). The infant sleep screening tool on the Evolutionary Parenting website can help you work out what's going on.

Does you baby snore, sweat at night, breathe with their mouth open? All of these are symptoms of sleep apnea which would need immediate medical attention as it causes periods of stopping breathing which can obviously have extremely serious consequences. My brother had adenoids and tonsils removed as a toddler and then magically slept. Prior to that, in the words of the doctor, it was "a wonder he can breathe" - and, of course, he woke a lot.

CadyEastman · 22/03/2024 17:51

When one of mine started to bite I honestly thought it was the end but I called one of the BFing Helplines, the BFC suggested some things to try and help stopped biting pretty much straightaway.

Might be worth giving them a call?

AmeliaHay · 22/03/2024 17:27

I have done the cold turkey with my 1st, and it actually wasn't that bad, 3-4 nights of asking but each night less than the one before. So that's how I'd do it. I just dont know if I'm ready and I feel sad all day today :( but I dont know if I'll feel any different if I stop now or in X amount of months. He has however been biting/grinding on my nipples again today with teething!

OP posts:
oldgreysquirrel · 22/03/2024 17:16

What worked for us was DH doing the night weaning. If I wasn't there, it wasn't an option.