Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up of AMA high earner threads where the poster is not actually the high earner?

107 replies

Evilcountspatula · 21/03/2024 22:48

Please can we hear from a female (single, married, with kids, whatever) who earns enormous sums rather than someone who has married a rich husband. No jealousy, I’d have loved to have married a rich husband myself, but genuinely interested to have a thread from a woman at the top of the money earning tree. Is that too much to ask?
edited for typos

OP posts:
NChighearner · 22/03/2024 07:41

I’ve NCed for this. I earn just over £1M a year - I run a technology business. I am not like the high earning DHs you hear about on here in that I’m not on the 630 train, leaving everything to my spouse (who also works FT) or others. I am a present parent for my kids, I turn up to assemblies etc because I’m senior and (mostly) in control of my schedule. I wfh 2 days a week.

The way I did it was to simply keep working and play the long game. I’ve worked in industries where presenteeism isn’t the name of the game. had kids late enough (34 and 36) that we had good household income and hired a wonderful nanny who is still with us even though both kids are at school. I went back to work after 4 months with both, which was tough. When I had 2 under 2 it was really tough. But I forged through because I could see it would benefit us all in the long run. Everything has a price though, like a PP said I don’t do much other than work and spend time with my kids. But work is stimulating, interesting and (gasp) fun. So it’s not drudgery. I do almost nothing around the house, I don’t even know where most of the cleaning products are - I don’t consider chores to be a necessary component of mothering and I am happy to pay our housekeeper (she is paid well, before anyone accuses me of getting rich of the exploited labour of other women) to take that on.

I would never do an AMA because once you get to my level to answer anything would be very outing!

CommeIlFaut · 22/03/2024 07:37

They are utterly dull. Basically, under-occupied women looking for a way to share the novelty that they can now afford to live in Fulham, have swishy hair or buy ponies with randomers on the internet. And hoping the reply will be something like, ‘ooh, you magnificent uber-lady, we are all so envious of your good fortune.’

Like I said, dull.

The women I know who are themselves that well-earning or otherwise successful, have high enough self esteem and more important things to do than overshare their financial happenings with internet strangers.

seveninthemorningblues · 22/03/2024 07:36

Name changed for this as money is very outing

I earn a lot of money. Sometimes there are threads I want to contribute to in order to give my perspective but there are so many responses always accusing the OP of lying about it I don't want to do it. I have lots of views/advice for someone who wants to know how I got here but I will never do it because I don't want to have to deal with the other responses.

I also get annoyed at posts where it is not the woman but the man earning the money. The poster usually contributes in just as valuable a way but can't really speak to what is involved in getting to the high earner point

And finally - I have a busy and demanding job but have been mumsnetting for years when I wasn't earning as much money. It is actually easier to spend time not working now as I dictate my schedule and get to have a break whenever I want. I like mumsnet because there are funny threads and good advice so I read it still now as it is a nice break from an otherwise hellish day. Being on mumsnet isn't a sign you can't possibly be in a high earning role. Also, my job is one where the world my clients live in and I work in for many hours a day is not normal. For me mumsnet is a link to people who come from my world and keep me anchored. I don't have the financial issues some people have but I have many of the same other issues. I find it helps me feel connected to my life when I can otherwise feel a bit isolated

Yulona · 22/03/2024 07:34

Those women don't tend to spend their time on MN being sneery about other women.

AIstolemylunch · 22/03/2024 07:33

ArrestHer · 22/03/2024 07:27

There are a lot of assumptions about women directors here. I’m a director in our business. Yes it’s my husbands day today work that is the function of the business, but, alongside my own existing employment, I do all of the business administration. I deal with the finance, the website, any tax, compliance with HMRC rules and those of companies house.

without those parts of the business we would not be earning and so damn right I “earn” my share of the income. But for me he’d have to pay someone else to do it as it’s not his forte at all. Just because it’s not producing product doesn’t mean I don’t earn.

same in my job. I don’t deliver the service we sell, but with out me the team that do couldn’t either.

I do all that for my limited company that I am sole diretcor of as well as doing the actual work that I invoice for. Lots of women do. I pay an accountant to do my tax returns. Many men that get the women to do this and make them directors do so so they can take advantage of the woman's tax allowance to pay less dividend tax, not because they need them do the monthly admin that they could easily pay an accountant to do.

Not saying that this is the case for you as you also work, but for most men that have limited companies this is about the wife being a non or 20% tax payer and it's a way to pay less tax.

Evilcountspatula · 22/03/2024 07:30

Beezknees · 22/03/2024 07:27

YANBU. As a single parent I want to hear from women who have done it on their own.

Now that really would be interesting, agreed.

OP posts:
ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 22/03/2024 07:29

It's the posts where "my DH wouldn't be earning this much without me" that annoy me.

Yes, he actually would. He either wouldn't chose to have as many children or he would find another woman who would do your role. The fact you take care of the house, child's etc is admirable but he would still find a way to earn the same, with or without you.

The proof - will his income shrink if you divorce? Nope, he'll just find a replacement or pay someone else.

Beezknees · 22/03/2024 07:27

YANBU. As a single parent I want to hear from women who have done it on their own.

ArrestHer · 22/03/2024 07:27

There are a lot of assumptions about women directors here. I’m a director in our business. Yes it’s my husbands day today work that is the function of the business, but, alongside my own existing employment, I do all of the business administration. I deal with the finance, the website, any tax, compliance with HMRC rules and those of companies house.

without those parts of the business we would not be earning and so damn right I “earn” my share of the income. But for me he’d have to pay someone else to do it as it’s not his forte at all. Just because it’s not producing product doesn’t mean I don’t earn.

same in my job. I don’t deliver the service we sell, but with out me the team that do couldn’t either.

Alcyoneus · 22/03/2024 07:27

Lalupalina · 22/03/2024 07:19

No, he got the 6.30 train every morning and worked 10 hour days and got the bonus

I doubt he could have caught the 6:30 train every morning without his wife looking after the children and taking them to and from nursery and school. It helps hugely to have a partner who takes care of the house and children, as you can solely focus on your career.

He absolutely could. He could hire a nanny if he really is a high earner. This delusion that women create in their heads that without them no man could ever be a high earner does disservice to women themselves by reducing them to facilitators or men’s careers. Have a bit more self respect.

Alcyoneus · 22/03/2024 07:24

It’s not just the high earning threads. Anything professional related, some women come on to give advice in a really learned way and then say that this is what their ‘DH’ tells them. A but like kids saying ‘my mum said’.

Just let the women who know, share their experience, rather than shoe horning what your husband says or does.

AIstolemylunch · 22/03/2024 07:24

I don't disagree. But it doesn't change the fact that he is the high earner, not her.

That's what we should be challenging, not pretending that these women are high earners. And that setup often puts the woman at a massive disadvantage when they divorce. Why should women settle for this setup (if they don't want to)? And many don't, many women are out there quietly working and earning the same as their partners, give or take, to contribute to the family income equally.

I'd like to see an AMA about a high income family and how they juggle everything when both people are working and earning good money.

Lalupalina · 22/03/2024 07:19

No, he got the 6.30 train every morning and worked 10 hour days and got the bonus

I doubt he could have caught the 6:30 train every morning without his wife looking after the children and taking them to and from nursery and school. It helps hugely to have a partner who takes care of the house and children, as you can solely focus on your career.

decionsdecisions62 · 22/03/2024 07:16

Yes I just think 'why would I ask this air head anything'? Go back to your daytime TV love!

AIstolemylunch · 22/03/2024 07:11

I bet he takes all the dividends so they don't both pay 45% tax so its probably not actually factually correct that she is a v high earner either.

I actually find it pathetic when women piggy back off men like this or just have themselves added to companies that their husbands have started and do all the work for. Start your own company, earn your own money. And if you can't then don't paint yourself as a high earner, because you're not.

I knew someone whose husband is a finance guy and every year she used to say, oh we got a great bonus this year, we're off to wherever on holiday and buying such and such car. No, he got the 6.30 train every morning and worked 10 hour days and got the bonus, not het, who did the school run for one kid twice a day and played a bit of tennis. Traded in for the younger model now of course, they still manage that with the 10 hour days!

I honestly don't want to hear about or celebrate any high earning woman unless she does the work herself.

Soundofshuna · 22/03/2024 07:11

My sister is a very high earner, I suspect she has never heard of mumsnet and definitely doesn’t read it. I think that’s why we have these type of threads. I haven’t asked what she does with her spare money but would quite like to!

lul1 · 22/03/2024 07:04

Well I get £2,200 a year they would be bloody shocked

Lalupalina · 22/03/2024 07:01

It’s frequently the default that “it makes no sense” for a woman to go back to work/ work full time post kids because their partner is the higher earner. I’m particularly interested in hearing from women who have pushed past that mindset, got to the top of their game, and reaped the financial rewards

In that case the father often takes on the main childcare and household chores.

dontbelievewhatyousee · 22/03/2024 06:56

The title of this thread still stands regardless as:

”To be fed up of AMA high earner threads where the poster is not actually the high earner?”

It is factually incorrect in reference to jointly owning a company. Both are equally the high earners because I’m sorry if you disagree but that’s what it says on paper, that’s what it says on the bank statements and that’s what HMRC see. Whether you agree that someone isn’t worthy of declaring ownership because they don’t do the trade.

Consider the many directors out there that are women or men. Who are directors of multiple companies, with investments, dividends, on the pay roll. They often don’t do the trade but they have the income still.

The OP of that thread was wrong to say her job was 60k it was factually incorrect if she was also a company director with equal shares.

Loopytiles · 22/03/2024 06:56

Sure, high earning fathers are facilitated at home, so get to be parents and build their career / company and personal earnings, which are shared for as long as the marriage lasts or as per the divorce settlement.

In the event of divorce they retain their personal earning power and most of the money.

ohdamnitjanet · 22/03/2024 06:51

Labraradabrador · 21/03/2024 23:34

I don’t think the poster you are referencing claimed to be a high earner, just part of a high earning household.

and if you don’t think a post is worthwhile, move on. My pet peeve is posters trashing an op for their post - it ironically elevates the post on mumsnet while also making it more difficult for people actually interested in the op to have a dialogue.

She said “ Our take home pay “ not my dh is a high earner. She also said “Happy to take the good and the bad” which she clearly wasn’t. Getting a straight answer from her was like getting blood from a stone.

TheDarkHouse · 22/03/2024 06:50

dontbelievewhatyousee · 22/03/2024 06:42

There is more to running a company than just putting the scaffolding up.

Yes I’m not totally thick - but OP makes no elusion that she actually runs the business. She added in that she is a director when someone asked if they’re worried her husband might leave her high and dry.

VestibuleVirgin · 22/03/2024 06:48

Why are you wanting such gloaty people bragging about not having financial worries, under the guise of an AMA thread?
Generally, MN flames high-earners or contains numerous 'my friend earns more than me, aibiu that i can't do x,y,z with her..' threads.
It is so common to talk about money in polite society. You run the risk of sounding like the Harry Enfield plasterer character (many of you may need a history lesson at this point, I'm talking 80s!). Asking or wanting to know about other people's income is also very crass, talking about ones income, particularly in company pooere than onesself is moreso
Be more ladylike, and don't give the show-offs fuel

toylandslide · 22/03/2024 06:48

TeenLifeMum · 22/03/2024 00:45

Women living off a rich husband probably have more time to post on mn than women earning mega bucks.

I resent that phrasing. 'Living off'.

My husband wouldn't be able to have the family we have if I wasn't a stay at home mum, he just wouldn't. He is in some way 'living off' me?

Loopytiles · 22/03/2024 06:45

TAAT!

agree it’s annoying on ‘higher earning’ threads when people post about their DHs, but suppose it just reflects reality: ‘motherhood penalty’ and economic inequalty.